Great on paper, but not on the Park

I can only write so much about the current team. Down to one game a week, and lacking any breaking news to cover, subjects can be few and far between after everyone has given their tuppence on the last performance.
And I love a bit of nostalgia incase you hadn’t noticed.
So with that in mind, I thought I would touch upon a phenomenon that’s not unique to football, yet very common in the beautiful game,,,someone who fits the bill on paper, but somehow doesn’t work out.
 
It’s not just players, managers also are very prone to this particular mysterious occurrence. I happened to believe a safe pair of hands was very sensible post Sir Alex, and our ex-defender David Moyes offered that very thing. It was no surprise here he was the chosen one, he had proven himself capable of the stepup from PNE to Everton, assembling a very hard to beat team with some playing talent (Tim Cahill would have been fantastic in the Hoops) and having that inner fire or passion for the game in his blood. Should have been Fergie Mark2, instead he bombed. On paper, he shouldn’t have.
 
Searching the memory for some Sellic players who have succumbed to this ‘curse’ didn’t take long, infact only three seasons ago we were given a prime example.
 
I recall reading ‘thats us winning the league’ from wise and experienced Tims the day big Shane Duffy signed. I trusted the judgement of natives who had much more exposure to his performances than myself, boosted by the fact he was from Derry, his formidable physique, and his experience.
He ticked all the boxes on paper, it didn’t happen for the fella out on the field though. What should have been an unforgettable experience for him is best forgotten.
 
I mentioned the Everton team under Moyes earlier, well one of his midfielders impressed so much in the biggest league in the world that the biggest club in the world nibbled. No one really holds it against a player who joins Real Madrid, sees chances limited, craves game time in his supposed prime footballing years, and decides to move on. That’s understandable, totally. You don’t write him off, it’s just one of those things.
That said player goes from Real Madrid to the famous Glasgow Celtic is less understandable from a financial point of view, but the baldy Dane had it in his head he wanted to join our beloved club and set about demanding the move.
I was stunned, and full of admiration. A quality International apparently out of reach had ‘got’ the club, and needed to wear the Hoops.
Tommy Graveson was a major coup, then a flop.
I would have signed him though.
 
I also would have signed the next ‘victim’ in a heartbeat. ‘Mahe fancy a youngish Dutch International defender?’
‘Contracts on its way, I’ll find out the name later!’
You know what I mean, they don’t fall into your lap everyday, but big Glenn Loovens fell into Celtics lap and into the heart of it’s defense. He should have been the original Virgil, standing out on the park, the rock that many attacks floundered upon. He was big, had age on his side, the world at his feet it seemed.
Shining in Glasgow would be his launchpad to a great career. It never happened.
 
While Joey Barton is the ultimate example across the city, he never played in a World Cup final after not cutting it for his ‘lowly’ club.
When I meet my maker I must remember to ask him how exactly did Edison Braafheid get so far in the game for one so limited?
I’m still perplexed, trusted against the globe’s finest but flounders against Inverness?
 
There’s more examples and please add your own. One common theme is that there’s no universal reason for each ‘flop’, the reasons vary with the individual, some are known and some aren’t. And while I point out ‘the sob stories’ it’s worth remembering they are heavily outweighed by success stories such as Naka. We currently have five Asia born players in the dressing room, he was alone back then.
And still shone like the sun.
I also don’t wish to personally criticize any of our past or present players, to reach the stage of pulling on the green and white must take lots of hard work and perseverance, not to mention inner belief, but it’s a fact that some players look like a good fit, sound like a good fit, have a body of evidence to suggest they will be a good fit, and then don’t fit.
And it will happen again.
 
By Mahe
sentinelcelts@gmail.com

244 Comments
CFC
April 19, 2023 6:31 am

Mahe

We don’t have to look too far into the past, we currently have two who meet the criteria on our books now- V Barkas and A Ajeti.
Both internationals, apparently in their prime- Ajeti is still only 26.

One from the past- Juninho, started well v Huns then fell out the picture.

CFC
April 19, 2023 6:49 am

Auldbhoy67 ( previous topic)

Agree with you re CL and EL observations.
Looking at the fixtures tomorrow 7 out the 8 could be considered regular CL quality teams.

We would be doing very well to be playing in that company.

Danny Mac 23
April 19, 2023 7:14 am

Mahe

Edson Braafheid

Ex Bayern Munich player donning the hoops?

Had to be a player.

Thankfully for the most part Ange knows a player.

Like his assess the person first then the player mantra.

Enjoyable read on the way to work.

Thank you.

BOBBY MURDOCH'S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
April 19, 2023 7:38 am

MAHE

That is a brilliant article,bringing back memories both good and bad. I’ll bet there are players who wish they had never left us,as well as those who wish they had never joined up in the first place. Strangely,I reckon most fans still feel the same about them too!

We were just talking about Barkas yesterday,how he ticked every box. Yet fell to bits any time he entered the box that mattered. And I’m struggling to think of a player who flopped with us yet proved his quality afterwards. Those jerseys don’t shrink.

Twisty
April 19, 2023 7:46 am

Stuart Slater
I’d high hopes for him. Didn’t seem to happen for him, yet, I always thought it was about to. Thought he showed glimpses of the talent he undoubtedly had but as I say, never quite hit the mark.

Auldbhoy67
April 19, 2023 8:24 am

Derk Boeringeur. Came through one of the best team academies (Ajax) around but if memory serves me correct was continuously injured. Tried to blame our medical people for poor advice and treatment. Only played a handful of games.
The 2 standouts we all know too well are Scheidt and Compter. Enough said about them by just naming them.

SteveNaive
April 19, 2023 8:37 am

Auldbhoy,

Derk’s ( possibly) home debut v Ross County.
He looked class and the crowd was with him.
County full back nearly broke his ankle.
Never fit after.

Bada Bing
April 19, 2023 8:37 am

Seems CCV will have knee surgery after the semi final

April 19, 2023 9:30 am

Morning Mahe et al

Smashing article- even if some of the names quoted by you and others have given the shivers.

Couple of names for your (dis) approval

Gary Gillespie. I thought he was the kind of classy centre back we would need to replace the ebullient if sometimes erratic Elliott. He’d played in a World Cup and in his one game dealt with Careca quite comfortably. He had played for Liverpool when they were not just a successful team but a joy to watch*. And he was, whatever he and others say now, a Celtic supporter. 10 minutes into his debut I thought we had signed a reincarnated Beckenbauer.

2 weeks later he was outplayed and outmuscled by Hateley and it was mostly downhill fast- although in terms of actual pace he was in the Allan McGregor class. And every time he seemed to be rediscovering his Anfield form he got injured. To borrow an old Two Ronnies joke , when Gillespie turned up for training he did not clock in- he signed the visitors’ book.

My other choice might surprise you. Haraald Brattbakk.

When he arrived in late 1997 he seemed like the last, perfect, piece of Wim Jansen’s jigsaw. Lightning fast and with a McGrory-esque scoring record for Rosenborg that included a winner against AC Milan- Weah, Maldini, Costacurta et al.

But a lot of the time he was poor at what he was meant to be good at – putting the ball between the posts , under the bar and past the guy in the funny jersey. Running in on goal, almost under the crossbar, finishing off a flowing breakaway- whatever , he missed them all. Especially in a drawn game at Tynecastle when he could have had six- and Hearts equalised deep into injury time. Excuses racked up- we did not play him in his best position, use him the right way, wrong leaves on the tracks. I never learned what his best role was- jeez he had scored 94 goals in 100 games in Norway and yet he could not hit the target if the goals had been 12 feet high and 12 yards wide. And yet…

Haraald scored the most rapturously received goal in the rebuilt Celtic Park to date. In that moment he slid the ball into the St Johnstone net to clinch our first title in a decade it all fitted – and I’d have forgiven him robbing me of Jac and my Clash vinyl in the original sleeves. Funny old game

Jimbo
* Unfashionable though it is to say it the great Liverpool sides were a bit mechanical for my taste- although their number 7s were exceptional.

Jobo Baldie
April 19, 2023 9:40 am

Good morning friends.
When we signed Eyal Berkovich (sp) wasn’t he our most expensive signing? Or in the top 3 anyway. He wasn’t very good!

Madmitch
April 19, 2023 9:45 am

AB67 @ 12.06

It is not a case of winning it — it is a case of being in the mix and being competitive.

There is some amount of dross in this seasons CL competition from the group stage onwards.
Just a case that we were a bit undercooked / overwhelmed and our performance levels dropped rather than improved over time.

If we consider ourselves to be a substantial football club with a storied history and a wide international following then we need to act accordingly and push ourselves forward to be the best footballing side we can be and that will come from Euro performances and not how we get on in the SPL

Filling three sides of various small grounds in the SPL shows how weak the competition / opposition is and is nothing to aim for / be proud off if we want to be considered a front rank footballing team.

As for the 5 big league angle — they can’t all be good so to put them on a pedestal is a step too far and feeds into an unhealthy attitude that they are all somehow better than us / mere mortals in the rest of the wee leagues. Too many look for excuses for failure not solutions delivering better performance.

AP has shown what is possible in a short period of time with limited resources.
To me there is much more to come and we need to be straining at the leash to move forward.

Being one step ahead of our friends in Govan just won’t cut it in the long term.
If that is the case then they live in our heads rent free.
The world / we are bigger than that.

April 19, 2023 9:48 am

Jobo Baldie

Eyal B was not just our record signing but, at time, a record paid by a Scottish club. We paid the same for Chris Sutton and then the Huns doubled the record signing Flo. How did those two signings pan out?

Jimbo

Madmitch
April 19, 2023 10:07 am

Mahe

Interesting article — however I think most of our analysis need more work.

DB @ ex Ajax fame — career was littered with issues / warnings.
Low energy showboater with an injury record — what use to us is a guy who can’t hack it in the ‘Dam?
He was looking for an easy life in the SPL with good money an a lack of effort required.
Poor / lazy / misguided scouting — stood out like a sore thumb at the time.

DM to ManU — hand picked by his predecessor who didn’t believe in a well earned retirement.
He was star struck from the off and wasn’t even allowed the basics of bringing in his own players.
The job was too big for him and he was undercooked / poorly prepared to deal with such an experienced squad.
The whole situation was so mis-judged it has become a footballing trope.

GL might be Dutch but he was a PL ego trip first and foremost.
CL windfall spent to get one over on our friends in Govan.
PL was running the show and he had his own agenda.
A good football team was not part of it.

SD was the wrong guy at the wrong time with the wrong tactics with a manager who was MIA for most of that summer / autumn.
At least he got time on his XBox — he played as if he was living off 4 hours of sleep a night..

As for the success of SN — he came too the club two weeks too late.
PL and his penny pinching ways yet again and the AMB shambles was the outcome.

Most of the failures you list were called out at the time.

As for GG — timing was the issue.
We should have been chasing him when he was at Falkirk.
Not 8 sorry 13 years later when he was on the slide out of the L/pool team.

He was available for £40K in 1978 aged 18 from Falkirk.

The Star Above The Crest
April 19, 2023 10:09 am

Juninho

I was delighted when we signed him, a World Cup winner who had already adapted to the climate/culture in the UK and had in infectious enthusiasm for the game, playing for a manager with legendary man management skills.

I thought he would be a sensation for us, alas it was not to be.

Bada Bing
April 19, 2023 10:20 am

Gillespie AKA The Rigger,2 weeks on 2 weeks off

The Star Above The Crest
April 19, 2023 10:26 am

We also signed a full back from Dortmund but I can’t remember his name. I thought at the time he could’ve been decent for us

Madmitch
April 19, 2023 10:44 am

GG — it just gets worse and worse.

We seemingly paid £925K in 1991 pounds for him.
He was 31 at the time — the insanity of the old board laid bare.
Penny pinching with DH in 1985 to spending like a drunk sailor on shore leave 6 years later.

What a clueless bunch.

SteveNaive
April 19, 2023 10:58 am

Teemu Pukki did well for Norwich.

April 19, 2023 11:03 am

Mad Mitch

Whilst I share your belief that Celtic- plc, team and support- should have loftier objectives than to be the best here/better than Rangers #2 I am prepared to accept that others in the support disagree with me. Even more, though I understand why people are no longer captivated by the thought of us playing in the Champions League – this is a competition which was once unmissable but which now unless Celtic is in it or there is a team as truly captivating as Milan, Ajax and Barca from 2009 to 2011 is almost unwatchable.

As long as 4 teams from Italy, Germany, Spain and England are guaranteed qualification – at least 11 of whom won’t have won the league in the previous season – whilst teams which have won their title have in sometimes had to play as many as a further 8 games to qualify for the tournament proper then I don’t understand how anybody can say it is not skewed in favour of the big 4 leagues. Clubs like Porto, Benfica and Ajax which have never settled – as I believe we did latterly under Lawwell – for being kings of small hills are often scarcely able to compete any better than we did this season and whilst it is not my personal view when people see us losing 12-1 on aggregate to PSG I get why people do not feel thrilled bybus being in it. And whilst I think we should aim higher than we have even I sometimes wonder why we bother if we have about as much chance of winning it as Queens Park has of winning next season’s SPFL

As for your response to the leader much of that response reads like one of my old report cards. From the wee school at that. A much more light-hearted article than in the recent past your tone is unnecessarily disrespectful- and littered with judgements made with the benefit of hindsight. Of course I realised that Gillespie was a turkey very quickly and that his shelf life had nearly expired but I did not want him or expect him to be as bad as he was.

Here’s an idea for you how’s about you admitting to your high expectations being confounded about a player or manager who joined us instead of just irascibly marking others’ homework

Jimbo

Madmitch
April 19, 2023 11:37 am

J67 @ 11.03

Thanks for marking my homework …

As for attitudes in the support regarding the CL — I think that PL has had a part to play in what some now feel.
He was the Excuse Monger General sending out his interweb tribe to plant seeds of doubt regarding the competition and our place in it. All about shaping opinions to cover for his inability to grow the club and the team in any consistent and managed fashion.

So the word went out that the CL was not for the likes of us and the EL was more our level.
Until it wasn’t as his lazy self serving efforts denuded the squad to the point that we were local worthies and little else.

For better or worse AP and his growth agenda is trying to move us forward.
Given the dross in this season’s CL and how this suggests that next season will be little better I think that we need to engage with Euro football completely as it is a better determinant of the health of the club than the SPL will ever be.

We should not fear the Big 5 or Big 4 — we need to lose the Scottish / SPL cringe and face up to all comers and give it our best shot.

I we can’t be bothered in Europe then why should the rest of Scottish football be bothered with the SPL?

The financial disparities that afflict the CL are also part of the SPL.
Just a case that we are holding the smelly end of the stick in Europe while holding the clean end in the SPL.

SteveNaive
April 19, 2023 11:55 am

MM,

Who are ‘the dross’ and would you, come August, expect us to beat them as is ?

CFC
April 19, 2023 12:03 pm

This revisiting of the PL years is tiresome and inevitably shapes the narrative in a negative way.
Perhaps that is the intention.

We are in a new era, let’s get with that, support Ange and the team’s efforts in the CL next season and see where that takes us. Playing what is in front of us, as well as we can, is all we can do.

Unrealistic expectations are not helpful, incremental progress in terms of a third place finish and drop into EL would be a good enough sign for me that we were at least heading in the right direction.

Madmitch
April 19, 2023 12:04 pm

Dross in the CL this season.

Start with L/pool and Chelsea.
A couple of Spanish clubs and then there is the Bundesliga.

Madmitch
April 19, 2023 12:10 pm

The PL years got us into the situation where we collapsed towards football irrelevance.
AP with limited resources has totally transformed the club.

That is how low we had sunk.
Basic stuff has taken us forward in leaps and bounds.

Aiming for third in any CL group we find ourselves in is setting us up to fail.
The squad need to be pushed to the max — give a player an excuse and they will happily fail.

CL vs SPL results not performances — we have no excuses to fail in the SPL.
So we approach the game totally differently.

McCaff
April 19, 2023 12:16 pm

Interesting article Mahe! Our history, like most clubs, is full of might have beens. There’s no science to signing players other than hoping it’s gonna work out. The recent ones are obviously the most obvious but Stuart Slater as a £1.5m record signing of the time, when Celtic were pretending to try to match Oldco was a huge disappointment but then you could add the manager into that, too! Liam Brady looked a good fit for Celtic only because of his allegiances and playing career but really had no right to take on a job the size of Celtic. Likewise John Barnes!
The mention of Gary Gillespie always brings a smile, my mate was at a Falkirk /Celtic game and as he approached the stadium Gillespie was leaving the stadium, walking across the car park “Awrite Garry?” “Aye, I’m on the bench the day, I’m no hanging around for this shite!” And off he went! Ironically another Brady signing that looked on paper to be decent but t’wasn’t to be…

CFC
April 19, 2023 12:24 pm

Setting up to fail by having football after Christmas and the possibility of a long run in the secondary competition?

My expectations next season are realistic due to the glass ceiling of the CL.
We are likely to be seeded 30-32 and a good way off the top 16.

The season after presents a different challenge.

Cortes
April 19, 2023 12:24 pm

Re Brattbakk: as a mere spectator it used to leave me tearing my hair out to see him repeatedly make fabulous runs only for midfield “maestro” Burley – usually – ignore them and pass the ball ten yards to the side or back the way. Heaven knows how frustrating it must have been for Harald.

McCaff
April 19, 2023 12:28 pm

MM…for the record, I’ve read your comments in full! Aiming for third is a mistake, I agree. But competing and finishing third would be considered an achievement. We competed for large spells in our CL games last year, not only that but we entertained in spells, too. This season coming we should be looking to compete and achieve. Ange knows this, he also understands the expectations of the support and seems to be doing his best to deliver. Talk of major changes during the summer are misplaced in my opinion, he knows what the players bring on a daily basis and will see the faults. He’ll know exactly at this point who he wants replaced and I doubt it’ll be as many as we expect.
Moving forward we know this plc ain’t bankrolling a shot at a 2nd place finish in the CL so the long term strategy at Parkheid must be to invest further down the line in terms of Youth Development. Your suggestion yesterday of loan players from the US/Aus/Lower English Leagues has to be the worst suggestion I’ve ever heard for Scottish Fitba! Why not invest properly in developing our own, it’s hard enough at the moment for our kids to get into the senior teams without filling it with boys from across the continents. Your opinions can be perplexing and interesting in equal measure but that idea is an abomination!
Edited…this team will be a year older and a year more experienced, Ange will know who’s pushed on in his estimation and who’s not gonna reach his expectations. Welsh, Ralston, Turnbull, Bain, Abada, maybe even Taylor and Hart might fall into this category. Time will tell!

McCaff
April 19, 2023 12:33 pm

Cortes…I don’t think Brattbakk was suited to our (Celtic’s) game in Scotland. We play high up the pitch in the opposition third, Harald needed space to run into. He was better suited to a counter-attacking system which we rarely played, still don’t! I though the same about Mark Burchill when he came through, Bellamy was another…incredible pace to burn, leaving defenders in their slipstream but in tighter spaces just not clever enough.
Loved Harald though, even when he scored against us I couldn’t bring myself to be annoyed!

Madmitch
April 19, 2023 12:41 pm

McC @ 12.28

You do know that the SPL currently uses the external loan route quite widely to improve their teams / squads.
Mu suggestion was just a SPFL inspired programme to help the smaller clubs.
We need to improve the talent levels in the SPFL by every way possible.

Regarding local talent — that should already be underway.
If it is not up to international standards then why is that and how can it be rectified?
Iceland would appear to be the most productive set up in Europe so maybe we start there.
Closer to home — could we do do better and how would it be measured?
If we are failing they why is that?

Our youth graduates of recent years have struggled to get games in the SCh never mind the SPL.
Youth into the SPL — Killie seemed to be going down that road.
Desperation is the mother of invention.

If other leagues go global for talent then we need to follow suit.
If the money for transfers is limited then the loan route is an alternative worthy of consideration.
Sounds simple to me — what are you afraid off?

Auldheid
April 19, 2023 1:03 pm

On another Rangers share issue. In response to a David Lowe Twwet.

One of the objectives of FSR, of which overdue tax is but one indicator, is to alert UEFA that a club might be on the verge of insolvency & go belly up in the group or later stage with serious consequences.

If share sales inject reassuring cash, that might be the reason for them?

SteveNaive
April 19, 2023 1:09 pm

Ergo you’d expect to beat Liverpool and Chelsea just now ?
And the Bundesliga minus BM ?
Good grief !

McCaff
April 19, 2023 1:12 pm

MM…the suggestion to me was fill the bottom SPL leagues with loanees from across the world. To what end? What kind of set up would that leave us when the loans end, another tranche of loans in perpetuum? That’s no way to organise fitba. What incentive would there be for grassroots players, already struggling for pathways into senior fitba!
As Jimmy Sanderson would probably have said “Pure bunkum, caller!” 🙄
I get it that fitba in Scotland has many, many faults but the desire of boys, and girls, to play is not one of them. There are thousands of kids playing organised fitba every weekend in Scotland but the structures required to improve them and give them better chances of progressing to top level do not exist. That’s where the focus needs to be not in bringing players from abroad to further decrease their chances!

McCaff
April 19, 2023 1:16 pm

MM..
“You do know that the SPL currently uses the external loan route quite widely to improve their teams / squads.”
Nope, I wasn’t aware that the Lower half of the SPL, your intended benefactors of your proposal did use the external loan route quite widely. I doubt they do but if you could give me figures and ratios per Club/League to the number of registered Scottish born players I’d be very grateful!

Prestonpans bhoys
April 19, 2023 1:21 pm

McCaff

Agree about youth development but it seems to be in the Lowland league and you are not going to develop much in there.

McCaff
April 19, 2023 1:24 pm

Prestonpans Bhoy…my argument, and I’ve put it out here for a while now is that the structures are completely wrong. We aren’t getting it right for our youngsters who want to play. The Lowland League is shit for development but it is the only show in town at the minute. It’s better than not playing and that is what was happening in that age group before the Lowland League participation started!

CFC
April 19, 2023 1:25 pm

Mm

If the CL has its share of dross, what do you think of-

Roma

Feyenoord

Sevilla

Man Utd

Sporting

Juventus

Union Saint-Gilloise

B Leverkusen

EL quarter finalists. I’d suggest that sort of company is ambitious enough for us at this stage of our development under Ange!

Danny Mac 23
April 19, 2023 1:39 pm

On my break,enjoying the read back this morning;

I remember Harald Brattback scoring all 4 goals v Kilmarnock

Henke must have set him up about 10 times in that game.

What a steal Henrik was.If I remember on the day he could have had a hat trick but kept looking for Harald to the extent it was getting embaressing but over to you guys how many players have scored 4 in a game for the hoops.

Jobo Baldie
April 19, 2023 1:40 pm

My brief tuppenceworth on Europe is that the season after next is when the whole set up is revamped. I think we should be using that as our target. Instead of being drawn into our usual group of death where we almost give up on qualification before a ball is kicked, playing 8 different teams, 4 home and 4 away should, on paper ironically, be much more interesting. In addition, our final placings will also be affected by how all of the other teams around us do. Aiming to be in the top 24 out of 36 sounds much more realistic than aiming to be in the top 2 out of 4.
At the other end of the scale, the Lowland League has not been enhanced at all by the inclusion of Celtic, Sevco and Hearts. I’d much rather proper reserve league was resurrected which would benefit both Celtic and my home town team.

CFC
April 19, 2023 1:59 pm

J B

‘24/‘25 season is the game changer.

Top 24 is the target, then one tie play off ( round of 32) between teams 9-24 to face one of the top 8.
No EL safety net, but I assume the financial rewards will be game changing for teams like ourselves.

Agree that should be our next target.

Auldheid
April 19, 2023 2:00 pm

Jobo Baldie
My brief tuppenceworth on Europe is that the season after next is when the whole set up is revamped. I think we should be using that as our target. Instead of being drawn into our usual group of death where we almost give up on qualification before a ball is kicked, playing 8 different teams, 4 home and 4 away should, on paper ironically, be much more interesting. In addition, our final placings will also be affected by how all of the other teams around us do. Aiming to be in the top 24 out of 36 sounds much more realistic than aiming to be in the top 2 out of 4.
At the other end of the scale, the Lowland League has not been enhanced at all by the inclusion of Celtic, Sevco and Hearts. I’d much rather proper reserve league was resurrected which would benefit both Celtic and my home town team.
===============
And so say all of me.

JimDom
April 19, 2023 2:02 pm

Memories of They Embarrassed the Hoops, from the Not The View fanzine, spring to mind from Mahe’s enjoyable latest offering.

Just about half the team from 1990-94 would comfortably fit the description. What a field day Sandman would have had 30 years ago. The Whites and Kellys most certainly allowed the jersey to shrink to fit the journeymen from the pre-McCann era. Quite a few since but that will always be the case in Celtic’s line of business.

The Europe debate. We will find out in September if defeats can be turned into draws and draws into wins.

I see Liverpool and Chelsea being described as Champions League dross. Undoubtedly, both clubs are having a poor season, both play in a very competitive EPL, against very good players. The general standard is multiple levels above our own SPFL. Both clubs qualified from their respective CL Groups and both fell at the Real Madrid hurdle . Runaway Serie A leaders, Napoli, also fell at the same stage as Chelsea, to an AC Milan side 22 points behind them in the league.

When good players compete against other good players, the outcome becomes uncertain, that is the nature of competitive sport. We will discover in the autumn if Celtic have improved enough to play European football after Christmas.

McCaff
April 19, 2023 2:16 pm

MM…you piqued my interest with the “widely used” loan route so to save you the bother of checking I had a wee look while I had my lunch. Now this isn’t in-depth research but it looks like there are 12 players on loan from non-Scottish clubs playing in the Championship, First and Second Divisions. Only 12 players from 30 clubs, and it looks like Dundee have 6 of the 12 on their books! So rather than being widely used it looks more like the bottom two divisions, who don’t appear to have any loans from non-Scottish clubs, don’t use it at all. And even in the Championship it looks like it is scarcely used, other than by Dundee.
As Jimmy Sanderson maybe or maybe not once said “Don’t come on here with your mendacious propaganda!” 😂😂😂

big packy
April 19, 2023 2:16 pm

AFTERNOON ALL and JIM, one of the players who i thought would be a great signing was Rafael scheidt, watched him play in a bounce game, celtic reserves against blantyre victoria, think he played barefooted, had high hopes for him, remember him having two great shots on goal ,the fact that he hit the corner flag with both shots is neither here nor there🤩🤩 another true story.hh

Madmitch
April 19, 2023 2:50 pm

McC @ 2.16

Crossed wires I think.
You are off at a tangent and into fresh air.
My focus was the bottom half of the SPL.

Some sort of SPL organised draft of external loan players to improve the quality of the SPL.

Things are so bad in the SPL that we need to turnover every stone / kiss every frog to take things forward.

SPL teams already use the loan route to bulk up their squads so it is a well trodden path with — from memory — some good talented players doing a season or two in the SPL.

As for pathways for our local players — they are already there.

Just a case that our 18 year olds are a very mixed bag which would suggest that youth age group football is not of the standard required in Scotland.

The St Ninian’s Glee club jibe was pretty cheap but very accurate — to me at least.

As for a Reserve League — might work if managed correctly.

Would that mean less players out on loan?
Would that be good or bad in the long run?

The Yorkshire Two — LSh + OU / apologies in advance to BMCUW — would reserve football be better than a loan move?

What about MJ — the prince across the water?
Would reserve football suit him?

Reserve team — run that as open aged with a B team as well for the U20’s / U19’s.

To me — we need to play more football at all ages.

Current 20/25 games a is a part time job.

The Real McCoy
April 19, 2023 2:50 pm

Big Packy,
It takes great skill to hit the corner flag. Especially from the penalty spot, and particularly barefoot (or bandaged)🦶🏽🦶🏽. 🤷🏻‍♂️😂
MohammedSalimCSC
HH💚🍀

Rebus67
April 19, 2023 2:52 pm

Since we are going down the nostalgia route today, why not cast your mind back to a day in May, 1963 at Hampden park when a good Austrian team came to “play” Scotland. The game was memorable, not just because Scotland scored four times, but because the game was abandoned by the English ref after 79 minutes. An Austrian had already been sent off for spitting at the ref. However that did not calm the Austrian tackling. Eventually, Mr Finney was obliged to send off another Austrian who refused to leave the pitch! At this point, Finney abandoned the game, fearing for life and limb of the remaining players.

The score is recorded as 4-1 to Scotland with Davie Wilson bagging two and Denis the Lawman scoring the other two.

The above events are remarkable in themselves but there is a simmering scandal beneath it all. Can you guess what it was?

Here is the Scottish team:

Keeper: Bill Brown
FBs : Alex Hamilton and Davie Holt
Midfield : Dave MacKay, Ian Ure, Jim Baxter
Forwards: Willie Henderson, Dave Gibson, Jimmy Millar, Denis Law, Davie Wilson.

Anything shining through?

Rebus

Bada Bing
April 19, 2023 2:55 pm

IMO Slater was a good player, unfortunately we had a very poor team then,and got dragged down a few levels, couldn’t fault his effort.

Madmitch
April 19, 2023 3:03 pm

R67 — very Lowland sounding team.
Only one Mac / Mc in it?

Now for the Lowland League — not sure why it gets the flak it does.

I think that it is a good idea.
Although currently it is a bit of a mixed bag.
Allowing more teams access to league football.

Just a case that our U20’s are taking time to adjust.

What more does the B team need to move forward?

Crowds — P/ head vs TFOD2.1 B …
The support spooked our team more than the opposition.
Hardy professionals to play against — Any organised / ambitious team in the league causes us problems.

Just what exactly do our U/20’s need to develop — international football festival’s against other big team U/20’s to show off flicks and tricks for YouTube?

Not quite getting the vibe if that is the case.

McCaff
April 19, 2023 3:04 pm

MM…where are the wires crossed? I’ve responded to your point that the loan route is widely used, your words not mine! I had a wee look to check if your assertion had any basis in fact – it doesn’t! So what tangent – yours or mine! I’ve already given you figures showing that SPL teams in fact DON’T use the loan system to bulk up their squads with only 12 players from 30 teams on loan from non-Scottish clubs.
“As for pathways for our local players — they are already there.” – Can you expand on this please?
“Just a case that our 18 year olds are a very mixed bag which would suggest that youth age group football is not of the standard required in Scotland.” – How do you know this?
“To me — we need to play more football at all ages.” – And finally, as usual, your own contradiction proving more or less what I’ve been saying.
I genuinely wonder if you deliberately troll the posts on this site!!

1 2 3 … 5