Regrets? I’ve Had A Few
Morning,all.
I think it’s fair to say that more Celtic fans have mourned the departure of Ange Postecoglu than have welcomed his successor with open arms. This is actually an unusual thing in football,as most managers these days are sacked-and good riddance! The newbie is welcomed as the new saviour,the man to bring back the good times.
One thing though that BR is not,for all his real or perceived faults,is an idiot. He has walked back into the club and accepted the offer with his eyes wide open. Recognised the fact that his appointment does not have the universal approval that it did in 2016.
The club recognise this too,there was no possibility of a repeat of the 15,000 who turned up outside Celtic Park simply to welcome him to the club,as they did back then. There would have been serious and vocal dissent. The SMSM,far from friends of ours,would have lapped it up. They would probably have coughed for a few agents provocateurs to turn up. They wouldn’t have had to. There are plenty of Celtic fans who feel that way.
However,it is what it is,and we have to deal with it. As do the dissidents. I’ve loathed the board ever since I was a kid. I’ve been vehemently opposed to some managerial sackings/appointments in my time. I thought sacking Jock and Dr Jo were terrible decisions. I thought the appointments of Brady Barnes and Lennon were not the least bit clever. But while these things may cause us some fear for the short term,we are usually brave enough to suck it up in the knowledge that the club always survives.
(Thanks,Fergus!)
But any new manager,even one as accomplished as BR with a fine track record down south and an unblemished one up here,comes fraught with difficulty. Yes he knows the club,but he is unfamiliar with almost the entirety of the coaching staff,the backroom staff,the youth set-up,medical or scouting facilities,etc. He hardly even knows any of the players-and he only left four years ago!
On top of that,the system instilled into the players over the last two years will almost definitely not be one that BR will prefer. And not all of the players from the Ange era will be available to him anyway. And even fewer of them in a year’s time. That’s football. We all know it. Even if we don’t like it.
I’ve mentioned before that if it wasn’t for his current injury,CCV would almost definitely have left in the summer. That I think Kyogo and Hatate will be heavily targeted by predatory sides down south and elsewhere. Jota too.
I was speaking to ATHINGOFBEAUTY on Sunday morning about this,and she has forgotten more about football than I can ever hope to know. I mentioned that a report down south said that Kompany at Burnley felt a signing target was overpriced at £18m,and they were now looking at Kyogo. Now,their target may have been overpriced at £18m-I’ve certainly never heard of him!-but if they think they can get Kyogo for less than double that,they are on Cloud Cuckooland. ATOB was predictably furious,WTF? Dae they think wur f…..g styoooopit?
Same for the other three too. And they have youth on their side,into the bargain.
Yet,I read some eejit reporter in the DR yesterday saying that £40m combined would be good business? Aye-it bloody would be-for his team of choice! Rip the heart out of our side for peanuts. Not gonna happen.
But the fact remains that our current side is not set up for how BR prefers. Yes,he does like a speedy forward,regardless of physicality. Think Muchu at Swansea,Sterling and Suarez at Liverpool. Moussa first time around with us,and Vardy at Leicester. Hell,everyone does! But these guys have that height,the physicality,that maybe Kyogo doesn’t have. Yet Kyogo is the best in the business at finding space in the box when a cross comes in,and even does it with the high balls. Finds the space and hangs in the air,and in that respect he reminds me of Henrik.
And Henrik wasn’t the tallest either,remember!
So,no. I can’t see our back five changing much in this window. Our front three? BR might not be too keen on Maeda-who I rate very highly-and might prefer Haksabanovic there. But,he knows we need a much harder midfield. And that might be the big problem,a major hurdle to overcome.
Does he drop a player,or rejig the positioning? He will have to. We know Mooy,CalMac and O’Riley can play the six. But that is particularly the one BR will be looking at. Time for a big hard bastert,and you all know my preference on this one. Mooy and Matt can play the eight,as can Cal. Cal and Reo can play the ten. Something has to give here.
It won’t be CalMac,even though his playing time should be limited in order to extend his career. It might be Aaron,if rumours about his injury are true. Even if not,his playing time will be carefully monitored. Matt,I adore. I honestly do. But his rankings are not what they were before the World Cup break,as we’ve discussed before.
I think he’ll rotate the main four,on top of bringing in that big hard bastert. He doesn’t really have too much to do to continue the good work. Just a bit of tinkering at the edges,and even that is only to have the side playing more to his preferred style.
Time will tell,and I’m usually wrong when I try to second-guess the thinking at Celtic. But never mind the Frank Sinatra reference in the title. Think of The Walker Brothers when they had no regrets. And specifically said-I don’t want you back. Well,to be honest,I didn’t want BR back either.
But he has my 100% support. And he scares the living daylights out of the other mob!
<><><><><>
Above article by BMCUWP
Bobby, I completely agree.
He will go nimble, pacey, and tricky on the wings,,
that’s not Maeda or Abada,,,
Push Callum forward, and play two behind, one a killer and one a box to box.
Odins very young, can’t count on him full time, though him and Hatate are an option.
I hope he does sign a real bastard, for the middle and to shield the defense.
Haksa could be a revelation here, once Brendan gets his hands on him.
But Jota has the next couple levels in him awaiting. Brendan could turn him into a real superstar, if he stays.
That’s a year max, by then the young Ozzie is ready.
A central defender, left sided preferably,,bastard of a midfielder, striker to Challenge, maybe a left back.
That’ll do me, fix the gaps in January.
Up the Hoops!
Looking forward to next season already.
Hail Hail
TheGombeen Man
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/politics/inside-politics/inside-politics-empire-imperialism-and-ireland-with-prof-jane-ohlmeyer-1.4502048
Very interesting article BMCUWPS,
It will be very difficult to predict who Brendan is going to play and what formation and tactics he will employ.
Of course, he is, to an extent, a horses for courses guy, so unlike AP we should expect changes during game time as well as from game to game.
The five subs is going to be manna from heaven for Brendan.
Who played No10 last time, Armstrong, Edouard, Christie, Rogic, Calmac etc etc so we can deduce from that…
…nothing
We must also remember he is unlikely to play a 4-3-3
He will play 4-1-4-1 or a 4-2‐3-1
That’s five in midfield, of course often two of these could be wingers.
He often played Calmac on the left of midfield.
Matt O’Riley I believe will be given the James Maddison treatment and we will see a great improvement, as you say, the bhoy didn’t really flourish under AP.
BR has more than hinted he will bring players in and change things, that’s good for two reasons, against European teams and even against Rangers we struggled especially in midfield.
Under AP we were a one trick pony who had been sussed by the SPL fraternity. Also another myth that was uncovered during AP’S final innings – we do not have two players for each position.
……………………….Hart
Johnstone…CCV…Starfelt…Bernabei
…………………Reo……..Iwata
Jota……………….O’Riley…………..Calmac
………………………..Kyogo
Mikey Johnstone
Meada
OH
Abada
Haksabanovic
Odin Holm
David Turnbull
Montgomery
Ralston
Taylor
Scott Bain
My starting eleven and bench tells it’s own story – it needs several improvements, either through player development or player replacement.
As you say the other unknown is who is staying and who is going from that 22.
What happens to the other 18 members of our first team squad?
Lots of work to be done – think Brendan knows what is needed…
Hail Hail
I’d suggest the Scottish glass ceiling comes into play re Kyogo and talk of silly money is completely unrealistic. That’s straying into Hun blog territory with their mythical/ hysterical player valuations.
Another consideration is his age which will also significantly impact any resale value – he will be 31/32 at the end of a three/ four year contract.
A Dembele level offer c £20m would be very difficult to turn down, and the player would have the opportunity to treble his wages. Keeping an unhappy player, should he wish to go, is not a good idea as various examples show.
If he goes we move on.
Jota, on the other hand, with a good CL campaign behind him could exceed KT money.
Right age profile and a goals/assists asset.
Hopefully he is encouraged to stay for another season.
Everyone in our squad is replaceable – even the virtual unknown ( when he signed) CCV.
The midfield, centre defence ( whether we lose CCV or not ) and left back areas are priorities for improvement. Keeper position too. Though Joe may be given the responsibility of one last season.
So a few new welcome faces to come in, battle hardened rather than moving up a level from the nursery slopes.
Looking forward to the pre season churn.
I’d love to see the robust Mr Ralston converted to midfield enforcement duties. He has a nice eye for a pass, in my opinion. And seems to have some “street smarts” in dealing with opponents.
MAHE,
‘nimble pacey and tricky on the wings …”
That absolutely is Abada !
I’d suggest the Scottish glass ceiling comes into play re Kyogo and talk of silly money is completely unrealistic. That’s straying into Hun blog territory with their mythical/ hysterical player valuations.
====
Very much agree. Remember all the talk about how much we were going to bank from JJ and GG, one of them being a proven international player from a team that had just reached the semi-finals of a world cup. How much did we get for both? Circa £12mill received and lots of rumours about contract release clauses and our short-lived CEO fecking up their contracts. Who knows the real facts but I tend to think it shows the reality of what teams are willing to part with for players plying their trade in the SPFL unless they are an unprecedented talent. Is Kyogo really worth more than a much younger Mousa? We only received £20 mill for him. It is going to take a very exceptional talent to break KT’s £25 mill Scots transfer record imho.
PS we only received £14 mill for Odsonne Édouard. At the time of his departure, he was the second-highest-ever scorer in the Scottish Premiership with 66 goals in 116 matches behind only Leigh Griffiths. His ratio of 0.57 was the highest on the all time table.🤔
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottish_Premiership#Top_scorers
Mahe@11:43 from other thread
Yes I’m aware of this:
“Rangers insist that rule I7 of the SPFL states that clubs are ‘not obliged to comply with this rule if to do so would result in that club being in breach of a contractural obligation entered into prior to the commercial contract concerned.’”
But I’m not aware if them producing the evidence that Park had a signed contract with the huns to provide car facilities or any facilities!
óglach
I really hope Jota stays this season to maximise our and his CL profile.
A player of the Season performance and a KT level move is not impossible,
He also scored two goals in the CL last season- half our haul, and two more than Kyogo.
I consider he already has a better current profile and viability than Kyogo.
Any realistic Kyogo offer has to be seriously considered. This is his valuation peak.
Just need to look at the Huns to appreciate how to mismanage maximising “talent”, as Kent n Morelos slunk off for nowt.
Ps
Good point re OE, he only had a year left I think? Confirms my point about maximising peak value.
😂😂
https://www.facebook.com/100070264328601/videos/1046321472996154/?idorvanity=351858699226&mibextid=rS40aB7S9Ucbxw6v
“Regrets? I’ve Had a Few?”
“I was born in the Monklands in Scotland.” – Chairbhoy.
“I like this one…” Auldheid.
What’s the nature of this ‘I’?
Is it just a thought?
Conditioned and programmed to pursue impossible goals. Attainments, enlightenment, ambitions..?
– All thoughts too.
The problem is that things are constantly changing.
Therefore ‘I’ is rarely at peace.
Just like the womaniser or the holy man yesterday.
Trying dropping everything that the thought ‘I’ trusted or believed just for a moment or two.
Every concept, philosophy, belief or thought.
***************
Thanks Nabbla for posting the link. I’ll check it out later.
Have a great day everyone.
BMCUW
Thoughts on the summer — there will be more change in the squad than most were predicting 2 months ago.
New manager vs old manager with money — bit of both but AP will be desperate to move the needle and he knows our players.
Not really getting the chat that every player will have his price and everybody is available.
KF at 2 years in vs HL at two years in — we didn’t sell HL so why should we be pushing KF out the door.
Some players are worth more to us playing for us rather than selling them the minute a big offer comes in.
We should be a buying club — net spend every year — investing in the squad to improve our performance levels.
An automatic two years and punt is not what we should be working to — some need to stay longer.
We should not be scared of working the squad to our playing advantage.
Rather than always working the squad to our financial advantage.
Other point — the defence needs work — starters required.
First of all we need a new starting LB / CL experience would be a bonus.
Then we move onto CB where we could be doing with an upgrade if the right person becomes available.
Finally we need to get rid of the Scottish / SPL cringe — football is moving on and so should the valuations associated with our players. KT @ £25mill is yesterday’s news — £50mill should not be out of the question for the right talent.
That needs big seasons in the CL and hopefully we can make progress this year.
If Portugal / Portuguese League can get all their ducks in a row then so can we.
BMCUW @ few days ago
Forest 93 chat — not appreciated / I still have the scars of BC’s decline.
The real man behind the curtain — not a pretty sight when the facade collapsed.
Prefer to remember the giant he was before.
Be wary of snake oil salesmen getting all transcendental / existential …
Or talking tripe about population figures.
1841 census — the population of Ireland was not the same as England.
England — 15mill
Ireland / 32 counties — 8mill.
Scotland — 1.5mill
The Gombeen Man,
Trying dropping everything that the thought ‘I’ trusted or believed just for a moment or two.
Some very good advice…
The true nature of this “I” is the conditioned self…
…The only way to true understanding is to rid ourselves of our conditioned self and live your life as it is, not bound to anything.
Your Beautiful women reminded me of a Koan…
A senior monk and a junior monk were traveling together. At one point, they came to a river with a strong current. As the monks were preparing to cross the river, they saw a very young and beautiful woman also attempting to cross. The young woman asked if they could help her cross to the other side.
The two monks glanced at one another because they had taken vows not to touch a woman.
Then, without a word, the older monk picked up the woman, carried her across the river, placed her gently on the other side, and carried on his journey.
The younger monk couldn’t believe what had just happened. After rejoining his companion, he was speechless, and an hour passed without a word between them.
Two more hours passed, then three, finally the younger monk could contain himself any longer, and blurted out “As monks, we are not permitted a woman, how could you then carry that woman on your shoulders?”
The older monk looked at him and replied, “Brother, I set her down on the other side of the river, why are you still carrying her?”
Hail Hail
Mm
Of course we’d rather keep our players.
If the player has his head turned by what’s on offer elsewhere then we don’t keep him. It’s self destructive.
Nothing at the moment suggests that’s the case with Kyogo but if he turns down a contract offer from us , assuming we’re working on improving his current deal, the sensible option is sell at maximum market value. We do not need another OE huff and eventual sale at a tangible discount.
I reckon you’d be first to castigate our “ bean counters” if they let this happen.
£50m sales? Only in the highly fevered imagination of the follow follow community.
Let’s break £25m first!
Marco Tilio, The young Aussie.
His mother tells of how at 6 days old he contracted bacterial meningitis and how he fought for his young life, reminds me of a very young Lisbon Lion, – Stevie Chalmers. A fighter for sure, how good he will be is uncertain but I am convinced that he will be a great player for Celtic.
Michael Beale: Worked under Brendan at Chelsea and at Liverpool, says it all. I for one am excited about this coming season.
The Gombeen Man: Thanks for your reply yesterday, as you know, the Industrial Revolution was a game changer in Britain, in technical terms and in innovation, the population more than doubled. (The Industrial Revolution 1760 – 1852). If you knew my name, you would understand why I know a little bit about ‘An Gorta Mor’ – (1845 – 1852). People never factor in population density, for example – Rod Liddle in the Times compared how Sweden had hardly any lockdowns compared to the UK, and much fewer deaths, a reader who was on a month long cycling tour of Sweden recalled how he calculated that he saw a Swede every 1.25 miles, they hardly ever met living more solitary lives, because of the size of the country and the number of the population. Comparing how Sweden handled Covid compared to the UK was just meaningless, but its amazing how many people never factor in population density. Still watching out for the Excise man?
Eastern mysticism used to be the safest way into Tynecastle / where is the PastaDome …
Harry / Harry / Harry Hood has become Hare / Hare / Hare Krishna.
Strange times.
TMG
What is love? Just another thought to be ignored?
Just another precondition?
Where does the idea of love come from ?
I’m not talking about Eros or Phileo but Agape.
How did that idea become a wide spread part of human consciousness?
Is even the idea of spreading it or sharing it a foolish notion?
MM 859
Agreed. Cloughie was the best manager England ever produced. Loved the guy. That’s why I didn’t reference him in my comment.
MM
The Sufis I understand were seen as part of Eastern Mysticism.
They are credited as the inspiration of The Ennragram, although this is challenged to a degree.
You can read about the origins and development in the 21st Century at
https://www.integrative9.com/enneagram/history/#:~:text=Greek%20Roots%20The%20term%20%22Enneagram,gramma%22%20meaning%20%22figure%22.&text=Some%20authors%20claim%20strong%20roots,common%20to%20all%20Sufi%20traditions.
If you want to.
It is used as a tool for self discovery and a very accurate one at that in my experience.
Delving into it is one way of embarking on the road less travelled, the journey inward and is a useful device for understanding others and can be a compass for navigating a healthy way through life.
Cortes
I’d love to see the robust Mr Ralston converted to midfield enforcement duties. He has a nice eye for a pass, in my opinion. And seems to have some “street smarts” in dealing with opponents.
====
I like that suggestion for the reasons you give.
Perhaps the £25mill barrier is about to be smashed. Mega spending Saudi team Al Ittihad is ‘allegedly’ tracking Reo. ”A news network associated with Al Ittihad claims that Hatate is ‘CLOSE’ to joining the Saudi team”. I detect an overpowering whiff of excreta with this report but at the same time, a tad worrying as Reo is definitely on the keep list and a huge mega-money deal from the Saudis would surely tempt Celtic.
AR redeployed in midfield kinda happened under the inverted full back role.
AR sitting would certainly make the right hand side of defence hardy enough with the muscular AJ and CCV behind.
Definitely worth having in the squad for a number of reasons, not least one of the required 4 home grown for Euro competitions.
Ah @ 9.39
Best of luck with your navel gazing.
You can try and hide from reality but it gets you in the end.
Cardinals included.
What one club is prepared to pay and another is prepared to accept, that is a players worth.
Everything else is just opinion.
Teams would be willing to pay much more for a player who’s performed well in the CL.
Madmitch @ 9:15 am,
Interesting take on the Transcendental, Eastern Mysticism and Hare Krishna movement…
One of the main participants of this, and the folk that made it popular in the west was of course the Beatles.
In the mid sixties, they were the biggest pop band in the world living a drug fuelled hedonistic lifestyle.
Once they got into transcendental meditation their lives changed.
They became big supporters of world peace, embracing other races and cultures and assisting refugees and those victims of war and natural disasters.
On top of that they became very successful business men and family men, whether that was music, films, vegetarian food etc etc
No one is perfect but why do you think people who decide to seek spiritual truths and enhance their lives in this way are doing such a bad thing.
Hail Hail
They make it so easy to mock them 😂😂
https://twitter.com/RetroCeltic/status/1673621942773874688?s=20
Ange who?
Jesting.
Two games involving English EPL teams I watched last season, the FA cup final and the CL final.
Both games were equally dire.
I know very little about English football however that Harry Kane is the best striker on the planet, without a doubt.
Don’t see where Kane fits in with the Ange Postecoglou brand of football, even if he were to stay at Tottenham.
Take away those goals from that team and you are looking at struggle, irrespective of how good their manager is.
How do you replace that?
I hope Ange Postecoglou does well, and probably will watch some Tottenham games next season out of interest, however you would fear for them minus Harry Kane.
HH.🍀
CRAIG76
Belter!!!
Craig 76
😂 imbeciles
They missed a trick – should have had time commencing on June 31st half an hour earlier at 16.90.
Good article Bobby.
A couple of observations.
During Brendans Q and A with the fans groups .
He said he felt the team lacked physicality and strength, which a few on here have been saying for months.
I would say some areas that need improving are , left back, midfield and wide areas. I personally don’t see a future for Maeada and O’Riley.
Would also like to see Haksabanovic tried in the no 10 role, not enough pace for a wide man.
16R…is Kane better than Haaland?
Cb 10.09
The Beatles and their engagement with eastern spiritualism.
Fair point — but not the whole story.
The songs could be a tough listen and they were fewer of them.
Plus they ended up hating each other to the point that they split up.
Not good.
Business affairs — bent accountants and mushroom farms played far too big a role.
And then you have Bad Finger — puppets on a string.
They should have stuck to their working class roots.
St tams
I was wondering if Odin has been recruited as Matt’s early replacement?
That really would be revolving door policy at work.
Word to self – do not get involved in controversial subjects on the blog,politics particularly.
Not good for the mental health. 😵💫
McCaff
16R…is Kane better than Haaland?
June 27, 2023 11:00 am
———————————–
Better striker, definitely.
Think he would have hit 50 goals for Manchester City.
Haaland looked like a cart horse in those final two games of their season.
Forgot about Mbeppe though, perhaps better than Kane, although there isn’t a better more clinical striker in the game.
HH.🍀
Ralston, has a poor first touch and too slow for midfield.
Morning all,
Got to agree with St Tams.
Please not Ralston in midfield !!!!!
First touch is, well not the best, and could you imagine him and O’Riley playing together.
Slower than a BRRB round 😁😁
Like to see Odin in midfield. Think he could be special 💚
HH 🍀🍀
Aren’t we all getting a wee bit too excited about 2 ‘prospects’ few of us have ever seen kick a ball out with the dreaded youtube montages? I remember watching a youtube vid of Ajeti and thinking he looks like the real deal🤔 WRONG. Haven’t we been burned too often by the promise of exciting young talents joining us only to later find out they can’t even trap a ball, does anyone remember Amido? Let’s wait to see what the young Norwegian and Australian can offer before assigning them places in the 1st team.
Prospects we have had millions of them CSC
16R…I’m not sure tbh! Haaland is still young, still got a bot of learning to do. Could you compare Kane of 7 or 8 years ago to Haaland today for a better comparison. Consider also the fact that Kane is a diving, cheating bassa! Haaland for me! 😉
16R @ missing post
CoViD19 vs Africa / Sub Sharan Africa — interesting stuff.
Big issue to me would be the population distribution.
How many pensioners do they have?
More specifically how many people over the gage of 75 or 80?
Plus they don’t seem to have many care homes.
The general population just struggled on.
To me — CoViD19 was very real / too real looking at the body count.
One thing it did do was show up the weaknesses of the societies it affected.
UK — highlighted all too visibly that we are not a serious country anymore.
McCaff – Forgot about the diving and cheating!! 😂
HH.🍀
16R @ Harry luv
Not for me — HK is a good player who has won nothing.
Nowhere near the best in the world — only thing about him at that level is his ability to manufacture contact in the box.
Very efficient / very effective — king of WHL.
Best dressed man in Cov type of award.
MM – Recently watched a documentary about the Nestle corporation and the antics they got up to in Africa – the very definition of evil.
Re – Harry Kane.
It’s not a personality/popularity contest.
Obviously a different type of player from Haaland, however Kane is a million times more clinical – the best finisher on the planet bar none.
HH.🍀
16 Roads
Last season stats have Kane behind in every metric- goals scored, assists, goal and assists and expected goals.
He is not “ a million times more clinical”.
Pretty absurd conclusion.
Last night Will Sutton scored against Sutton United.
I was wondering if that’s ever happened before?
Did James Chester ever score against Chester?
Did Dwight Yorke ever score against York?
Did Stefan Kuntz ever score against Rangers?
Does anybody know?
HH
CT, 😂😂
C T
Did we ever suffer a Scheidt own goal?