Many A Mickle Maks A Muddle
Morning,all.
MAHE has posted a couple of very interesting articles over the last few days about the recently closed transfer window. It would be unfair to describe it as a curate’s egg,as I think it is fair to say that it pleased nobody. Not the fans,who saw some quality players plus a much-loved manager leave. Not the new(ish) manager either,who didn’t get the power and pace that he had made clear was a prime requirement. Probably not the board,who were forced to fork out around £18m on a raft of new players.
I mean,heavens,that’s nearly half the take from the Jota,Ange and Starfelt moves. Palpitations all round,I expect.
Yesterday,he dealt mainly with the number of players available to us in midfield. I think it’s fair to say we now have more mids than wingers. And that’s saying something. Too many of them are yet to convince consistently,while others are facing the problem of whether to stick or twist. Whether to sign an extended contract and pledge a fraction of their future to the club,or decline the offer and make it clear that they are for the off the first chance they get.
Of the latter,it is clear that I am referring to Matt and Reo. Frankly,I’m past caring whether players want to wear that famous jersey or not,if they want to leave they can go. I doubt anyone had heard of them outside of their own family or previous club beforehand,and I truly appreciate what they have achieved in their time with us. But if they want to leave,tattie-bye. Don’t let the door hit yer arse on the way oot.
Of course,should they sign the new contract,I’ll be renewing my fanclub membership for both,such is the fickle nature of the football fan in this money-driven era.
Losing them both would certainly make our manager’s job more difficult-and at the same time simpler. There would be fewer players to worry about,but a lot less quality. On the other hand,he might get about 2/6 from the sales to use next summer. Which is where yesterday’s article came in,really.
Midfield a conundrum? It’s a lot worse than that.
It’s a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma,as was once said about something far more important.
We have too many players for only a handful of places,the result of throwing mud at the wall. No matter the formation,each of those roles is specialised,and few players can truly adapt to another one.
Sutton could play central in defence,midfield or up front. Ask him to play on the right of midfield and he’d have been useless. As for instance CalMac was at left back. Or Lewis Morgan as a centre forward.
So why continue to buy prospects-or worse,projects-in the hope that we might shoehorn someone into a role that doesn’t suit them?
It does the club no favours,nor the manager. It can destroy the player. It certainly damages relations between the club and the fans.
We need to return to having a focused squad,where everyone is there for a reason,with a defined position in mind. And signed at the request of the manager.
It isn’t really a conundrum,more a never-ending story of board interference in the selection of transfer targets to fit fiscal rather than footballing targets. Next midweek,we kick off our Champions League campaign. Against the Dutch champions,Feyenoord. The Netherlands is on the brink of removing France from their position in the so-called Top Five leagues in Europe. And we have to play their champions,away from home,with a weaker team than we had last season.
Fortunately,Feyenoord were the Pot 1 team in our group. The others will be easier,right? Well,naw. Not really. Lazio will be itching for revenge for their doing a couple of years ago,and this is the team who finished second in Serie A last season. And Atletico Madrid? No love lost,for obvious reasons,and while they only finished third in La Liga last season,they were only a point behind local rivals Real.
And we all remember what happened a year ago when we played Real.
It is easy to say that goals win matches,or that if you don’t lose any,you don’t lose games. That games are won in defence or attack. (See Lisbon 67 for diametrically opposed views on this.) I’ve always thought that they are won in the trenches,in midfield. In the area which both protects the defence and feeds the forward line. And I don’t think we are strong enough for Europe,and that is a failure which I will lay at the door of the board.
I hope I’m wrong. I love being wrong when I don’t really want to be right. There’s a song about that,nearly. I know too that our main midfield contenders,DT,CalMac,Matt and Reo,are all well capable of a world class performance on the night. But to do it all at the same time,six nights in a row?
On Tuesday,I pointed out that the Rangers* fans shouldn’t blame Beale for a bad result or performance in Perth on Saturday. Today it is my sad task to say the same about our manager in Europe. And these next six games could determine events for us in Europe for far longer than the three months that they are played over. Back to qualifying for us in 25/26,barring a miracle.
And all so avoidable.
<><><><><>
Above article by BMCUWP
Napsters,follow the link.
https://sentinelcelts.com/2023/08/15/the-naps-competition-part-one/
JOBO POTY competition
sencelpoty@gmail.com
You are an absolute shower.
Good article, Bobby.
Re Feyenoord, consider this. Last season, against Shakhtar Donetsk, we were the worst missed sitter I have ever seen away from losing all our Group Stage home games. Shakhtar took third spot, and a place in the Europa League, a place many on here felt we deserved. But we have to be careful what we wish for.
Shakhtar met Feyenoord in the Europa League with the first leg at home. They spent most of the game desperately defending against a rampant Feyenoord, and eked out a 1-1 draw.
What happened in Rotterdam a week later? The Ukrainian team, who we failed to beat, lost 7-1 to Feyenoord, and were lucky to escape with an 8-2 aggregate mauling. I will be delighted to be wrong, but I can’t see anything except a drubbing.
But I was wrong about the Bigotdome. So we live in hope. It’s a big incentive to do better than Sevco did in Eindhoven.
P.S. If the statute of limitations hasn’t run out on your Good Samaritan deed from the last blog, how much is it worth for me not to clipe?🤣
HH
Bobby, I agree that this window has been badly managed. We don’t know how good the recruits are, but most of us fear the worst, and reckon that we’re gonna get a doing in the CL Group.
Did our board make a deal with BR and then simply ignore its terms and fuck about with transfers? Sorry Brendan, but that’s yer lot.
I think there was a bit of panic at CP when Ange was leaving. Nobody was sure who was staying or going, staff and players. Then the Saudis came in with mega bucks for Jota. Was the board thinking of windfall money for Hatate, Kyoto and Abada??
It must have been very unsettling for the whole club, especially with the media putting the best possible slant on all things Celtic as usual.
What decent player was gonna sign for us until BR was formally announced? How many were seriously thinking about leaving? What were agents saying behind the scenes? Was Ange gonna poach any one? Had anyone been tapped? That would all impact on who we target.
So I’m prepared to give the board and BR a breather here, on condition that experienced reinforcements are recruited in January should we not improve in our CL group games. I’ll be delighted if we get 3rd in group and fall into Europa League next spring.
If PL is back in charge of transfers, then this is all moot.
Games win or lost in the midfield… unless you miss it out and go long to and behind the defense.
Let’s defend mightily… we are allowed to, it’s part of the game…no shame ( just now )
INIQUITOUS IV
Tell you when I see you in two weeks.
GER57
If we don’t get at least third place,we will almost definitely have qualifiers from 25/26. The window just gone was the one to prevent that. We messed it up,IMO.
Bobby
Re last nights suggestion from me about a best Celtic eleven can I suggest that we go 3-5-2 as we have rarely been blessed with a raft of great defenders. Also, the Lisbon Lions are already immortal and stand above everybody else so I would start it from say 1980 to give a new generation of players iconic status.
BILLYBHOY
Difficult one,innit? Most of our sides have played with four at the back.
As for who is eligible,it should IMO only be those you have seen either in the flesh or in full live matches on tv,the latter being due to the ST situation.
Open to suggestions,as always. And grateful thanks for yours.
Without the sales we’d have expected to spend £15m? over the summer. On the £2-4m range of player we have bought.
With the sales we appear to be at least plus £10m on summer transactions.
And yet we couldn’t find those key first team personnel most definitely needed for the Euro games. Domestically we are fine.
No doubt someone will point out, ah but spending £20m on two or three wouldn’t guarantee anything. But at the very least it would improve three positions on the pitch.
Sadly, it is not a question of wait and see –
we will simply never know now.
So we go with what we’ve got.
Morning all,
Bobby, my only stipulation would be that you have to pick players you’ve actually seen live/telly ( in your own lifetime) and can be any 11 you like.
Any formations would be up to you and 11 forwards if you want ( However, might no get many votes !!! )
I think most people have 8 or 9 certainties but it’s the missing 2 or 3 that could be the surprises and game changers !!!!!
Looking forward to it when it arrives 👍
LEGGY
We’ve got plenty of time to figure out the finer details,as I don’t plan to run that until the next international break. One position at a time,preferably.
Tomorrow is our five favourite players seen,as you suggest,either in the flesh or in live tv matches.
That should throw the cat amongst the pigeons,somewhat.
Cheers Bobby 👍
I see reports that Abada could be out until next year !!!!!
If true, I feel really sorry for him and wish him a speedy recovery 🙏🙏🙏
HH 🍀🍀
The summer window did not deliver what either Brendan or the support wanted. But, as ever, an unexpected win at Ibrox lifted the gloom. For how long though ?
First up is the Dundee game. A confident and powerful performance should be our minimum expectation. Give the captain a day off and let’s see what Bernardo can bring to the party. Some minutes required for all those likely to be involved in Rotterdam.
CL Matchday 1. Park a small coach or a fleet of Routemasters, aim to leave the pitch undefeated, the end justifying the means. The play-our-usual-game mantra won’t cut it, not against proper footballers.
As BMCUWP rightly says, another season of abject European failure will see us back to qualifying for the top table, maybe even the Europa league. Win ugly, draw ugly, I’ll take ugly all day if it results in group and coefficient points.
Good stuff again this morning Bobby as usual.
On the midfield situation. There doesn’t seem to have been any plan or thought process put in , when buying all these midfield players.
It looks like we’re buying players , in the anticipation of players moving on. When we should be trying to replace what we have with better.
Looking forward to Saturday after missing the real stuff for the last few weeks.
McCaff, I’m with you on Di Canio, what a talent
On European qualification. If triggers broom fc do ok in their competition what effect would that have on the national coefficient and by default our standing for 2024/25.
Not that I want thems to do well😁
FRODSHAMBHOY
I that one of the miracles I mentioned at the end of the article?
BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
FRODSHAMBHOY
I that one of the miracles I mentioned at the end of the article?
Understood. Do Huns believe in miracles
You sexy thing – Hot Chocolate + lyrics (I believe in Miracles)
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OTXjgkFRpCk
I believe in miracles. Leggy bought me a drink once.
LEGGY
You’ve just been libelled most disgracefully.
FRODSHAMBHOY
They might have to. So might we.
Good afternoon, friends.
Frodshambhoy – we get an automatic Champions League spot because Scotland are currently high enough in the UEFA coefficients table. Currently 10th and I think 11th or higher is what’s required to maintain our automatic spot. Scotlands points come from both the national team and also those clubs playing in the group stages of Europe. So the only single benefit for me of Sevco not losing every game is that Scotland is a whole are ranked better. But for the record I always DO want them grubbed every time!
There’s a bit of a lag in the system in that we already know that Scotland have an automatic spot for next season, 24-25 as it’s based on our position at (I think) the end of last season, 22-23..
At the end of this season, 23-24, any points gained are added to each nations total; however points gained 5 years ago during season 19-20 drop off. Current predictions suggest that from 25-26 our automatic place is in jeopardy with our league winners having to play a qualifying round.
In terms of how teams contribute I think its maybe 1 point for a win, half a point for a draw during the group stages. The total is then divided by the number of teams from each nation. So we will total the points from Celtic, Sevco and Aberdeen and divide that by 3.
But in terms of individual teams and which pot they end up in etc, that is based on their own individual past performances and rankings. Sevco are currently in a healthier position than us and had they qualified for the Champions League would probably have been a pot 3 team even though we are Scotlands Champions and are in pot 4. Sevco are ranked 30th with 49 points, Celtic have 29 points and are ranked 52nd.
The go-to site for all of this is the wonderful Bert Kassies:
https://kassiesa.net/uefa/
Hope that helps. And I hope my own understanding is mostly correct!
Some travel info for anyone heading from the City Centre to the game on Saturday:
Currently, the Gallowgate is being re-surfaced from the Sarry Heid up to the Heilan Jessie. This work has been ongoing all week and is supposed to finish today – we’ll see.
To make matters worse there is now a 4-way Traffic Light System on London Road at Bain Street. They are digging up the corners and it looks as though this could take a while.
All of the above could have been started after our last home game but ????
HH
This takes you to the actual calculation of all coefficients. I see it’s 2 points for a win and 1 for a draw but in international games it’s half of those. You may need to put on several anoraks for this one….
https://kassiesa.net/uefa/calc.html
JOBO
Blimey,you weren’t kidding.
Thanks (I think) Jobo.
My head hurts now.
I’m at the Australia v France Davis Cup tie at the AO Arena in Manchester.
Purcell of Australia kept rushing the net and losing the point. He has just lost the match. He must’ve lost about 90% of the points he came in on. Incredible that he kept doing it.
Reminded me of us playing CalMac at left back and expecting different outcomes.
PS
can someone organise a collection for me. I’m gasping for another pint. Cheapest is £8.75.
FRODSHAMBHOY
£8.75? That’s bloody criminal.
With the news that Abada is now out for four months possibly are we allowed to bring someone else into the UCL squad or is it just hard luck guys.
I don’t know the ins and outs of that really.
Bmcwp
8.75 a pint is expensive but here’s a wee story. Me and the boss are going to Celtic the musical . Up to Glasgow early for some nosh and a couple of drinks first. The said lady and my daughter frequent a bar called The Anchor line at George sq anytime they are in town. Okay says I we will try it. Pint of the black nectar and a red wine 15quid. Guiness was 6.50. On leaving as usual the lady goes to powder her nose. I read the drinks list. McAllan 18yr old 50 quid a nip. Mcallan 30yr old wait for it …… 250quid a nip. Asks the waitress if it’s a misprint. I don’t know says she I’ve never been asked for any of them.
Now that’s extortionate..
Most use the expression ‘many a mickle makes a muckle’ to mean ‘lots of small things make a big thing’ (for example, problems).
however, the problem is that both mickle and muckle were words that mean the same thing … something large. so, the quote doens’t really make sense.
some say the proper quote is ‘many a pickle, make a muckle’ with pickle being an old word for small (like piccolo ), while others say the proper expression actually is ‘many a little makes a muckle’
either way, Celtic still need a left back, and a central midfieder …. if Celtic want to do anything in Europe, Iwata needs to be given a run in the Calmac role … I watched some of the Japanese highligts on the weekend… they all know how to play the game (as opposed to the Scottish ‘run about until something happens’ approach)…. if he was the best player in a league that plays football like that, he is more than good enough for Celtic, and just needs to be given an extended run in the team…
Bobby,
Schockeroooni !!!!!
Hey Ho !!!!!
I’ll sort that trumpet out next week when I see him 😂😀
HH 🍀🍀🍀
BBC4 8pm
‘How The Celts Saved Britain”
From barbarian hordes ?
Same as it ever was !
MIKEINTORONTO
Stupid expression,I agree. The muddle in the heading is a play on words. Describes how I view the transfer window,and our midfield in particular.
AULDBHOY67
I think I’d be going to the Counting House round the corner. £250 a nip,WTF?
AULDHOY67
Turns out that £250 a nip is a bargain!
https://www.thewhiskyexchange.com/p/8579/macallan-30-year-old-sherry-oak
Al-Ittihad, despite spending gazillions on Benzema, Kante, Fabinho and Felipe, and leaving Jota in limbo by not naming him in their 8 registered foreign players, have only named 7 subs on their bench today. Their opposition have 9.
Postecoglu shortlisted for FIFA Coach of the Year. The other nominees are: guardiola, inzaghi, spalletti, and Xavi, so pretty good company.
Auldbhoy67
Anchor Line, probably the most expensive bar in Glasgow.
The owner is a good Tim though
Talking of expensive pints, Paddy’s Maw and I went to the Armidillo to see Celtic Story and and it was £7 for a pint of lager(Birra Moretti) and £1 deposit for the PLASTIC pint pot it came in
You might take back the first but how many take back their last? Not me anyway too bloody much bother and a long queue😩
Eridivise does a deal with ESPN for €115 million a season, that useless blouse Doncaster got us signed up till 2029 for £30 million a season, even the huns were right about him
MIT
As a kid I was told Many a Mickey makes a Mouse, but as I’ve grown older I’ve realised it Disney.
COSYCORNERBHOY et al
I thought it was bad in London at £6.60 a pint. Although only £4.50 in The Cock Tavern. But charging a deposit on the glass,that’s bang out of order.
Btw,Slug and Lettuce is to experiment with what they call surge pricing. When it’s busy,they put the prices up. Basterts.
I wouldn’t give iwata a run round the park.never mind in the team.he looks lost and hopeless if I’m brutally honest.im more worried if kyogo or aj gets injured.them you are in deep trouble.all of this should have been addressed 🍀🇮🇪🍀
Eustace was asked about the zombie job, and said categorically ‘not interested’. The second manager (after Potter) to knock them back this week.
A quid deposit for a reusable pint tumbler seems reasonable when you understand that previously the soft plastic tumblers were left all over the place, crushed to bits and with no further use end up in landfill. This is an educational exercise in teaching us new tricks whilst surreptitiously charging us for the pleasure! It’s also entertaining watching the entrepreneurs collecting the discarded quid tumblers and returning 30 or 40 at a time, yip really, to collect the moolah that the rich, careless or daft cannae be bothered returning!!
Craig76
I appreciate you posting the Brendan presser, but Geez! It’s the same old pap every week. The intellectually challenged copy and paste so called journalists trying to trap the manager into a verbal slip up and controversial headline, evaded easily every week.
It’s 2:10 PM here. I was sitting holding an IPad on a sofa while watching. I literally fell asleep, then was wakened by the IPad banging on the floor. Just shows you how gripping these farces are.😊
HH
Benzema nets winner for Al-Ittihad. Top of league with 15 points from 6 games. Two following teams on 13 points but with a game in hand. Slippy G’s Gettaefaq in 5th with 10 points, and also with a game in hand.