Our Best Ever Midfield-Part One

Morning,all.

Choosing our best ever central defenders proved to be a very tight affair. Although VVD and Mjallby just shaded it,Bobo,Aitken and Elliott weren’t far behind. Nor,come to that,was Marc Rieper. Yes,we’ve certainly seen a few good ones in our time.

So the team so far looks like this:

Boruc

McGrain-VVD-Mjallby-Gemmell

We now move on to the midfield,which I’ll do over two days,today and Thursday. Although the line-up so far has four at the back,some of you preferred two or three,so just stick to your preferred formation. In midfield,the formations call for any of two,three or four. Today,I want you to name your TWO central midfielders,the engine room. Thursday,you can tell us the rest. 

<><><><><>
Above article by BMCUWP

73 Comments
McCaff
October 17, 2023 9:10 am

Morning all…I’m sure my choices will be usurped by a couple from our 67 side – Auld and Murdoch are the obvious winners of this part of the contest but I’ve making my picks on the basis of watching and understanding the game. So, for me it’s another easy shout for my first choice midfielder. It can only be the Maestro, Paul McStay! Second choice is much harder – Collins, Burns, Petrov, Lambert, Burley, Lennon? More recently, Broonie for his leadership, maybe Joe Ledley as a scoring, box-to-box mid with a beautiful touch and an eye for goal? I’m gonna go for Big Vic Wanyama, though, a Colossus of a figure. It’s a shame we had him for such a short time but what a bull in the middle. But, he played with 67 on his back!

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 17, 2023 9:20 am

I’ll start this one off with Lennon and Murdoch. Not particularly easy,given the sheer quality we have had there in my time,but these two in particular were standouts in their roles for their sides.

NL was like Ronseal. Did what it said on the tin. Hardly the most mobile or most gifted of footballers,he was playing “the Makalele role” even before Makalele himself. Dario Gradi at Crewe was the first to spot it,and Martin O’Neill refined it. If either manager wanted a midfielder to ping the ball fifty yards onto a sixpence,or to go on a mazy dribble,Neil was yer man.

He would win the ball,then pass it five yards to the player who could do these things!

He had an uncanny ability to read the play,to be in the right place at the right time to make the vital tackle,break up play-and pass the ball to a colleague who could use it. Every team needs a player like that,and we had the best there was.

Also the best there was,Bobby Murdoch could easily stake a claim to be the best midfielder on the planet during his peak from 65-71,before that ankle injury and the associated weight problems finally caught up with him. Not that it stopped him moving to Middlesbrough and becoming a legend there too! Strong as an ox in the tackle,his real strength lay in just what he could do with a ball at his feet.

He could beat a player,or he could take out an entire team with a slide rule pass over any distance. He could control the ball in the tightest of spots or pass it first time. There was little he couldn’t do,though I never saw him play in goal! Jock was the envy of his managerial rivals simply because he could call on Bobby,and he knew it.

“When Murdoch plays,Celtic play.”

That simple one line comment. A compliment from a man not particularly known for handing them out easily. But Jock knew what he had with Bobby. We all did.

Ernie Lynch
October 17, 2023 9:31 am

The Maestro and Lubo for now.

I know who my forwards will be, so just two places left.

Decisions, decisions.

Awe Naw
October 17, 2023 9:43 am

Kouassi and Flood

Big Audio Dynamite
October 17, 2023 9:45 am

Mjallby before Aitken, what is wrong with you people!

Chris
October 17, 2023 9:52 am

For the engine room Murdoch and McStay.
Lambert, Petrov and Collins as back up,
I dont see Lubo as a central midfielder.

D R M
October 17, 2023 10:08 am

Mcstay and Lennon for me

JimDom
October 17, 2023 10:11 am

Centre Mid, not easy at all. Will restrict it to my own regular attendance period.

1. Paul McStay. One of our own and broke into a very good Celtic team as a teenager, and kept the jersey. Fabulous natural talent and deserved better team mates post 1988. The clowns that ran the club decided otherwise. Probably too loyal for his own good and would have been a revelation in England, Italy, etc.

2. Neil Lennon. Everything that BMCUWP said, and more. Described by Kenny McDowall as a ball magnet (look and learn Callum McGregor and Reo Hatate ). Was the glue that binded MON’s team. Couldn’t run very fast and posed no goal threat whatsoever. However, was always in the right place at the right time and found space in congested areas of the part. A leader and, like The Maestro, Celtic to his core.

Bada Bing
October 17, 2023 10:20 am

McStay
Moravcik
Dalglish……he played as many games in midfield for Celtic, as he did as a forward

St tams
October 17, 2023 10:28 am

I’m going for Paul Mcstay and after much thought Neil Lennon just edges Paul Lambert

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 17, 2023 11:09 am

A veritable litany of legends could easily have found themselves included today,and oh,the guilt at who to leave out! ATHINGOFBEAUTY will probably never forgive me for leaving out The Maestro,but I’ve only got room for two. Others of note include (remember,these are only my own recollections)

Bertie. Murdo. David Hay. Lambo. Big Vic. Broonie. Just as examples.

Good luck whittling them down,but don’t forget to leave room for the creative mids on Thursday!

Billy Bhoy
October 17, 2023 11:20 am

Bobby

I’m going 3-5-2 so I’ve got 2 DMs(6)

So many really good players to choose from.
For the first I finally narrowed it down to:

3 Stan Petrov. I’d have loved him to have spent his entire career with us. Class act and provided lots of goals and assists.

2 Chris Commons. Pretty much the same as the above. Unreal how many goals he scored from midfield.

But the jersey goes to Murdo McLeod. Nine seasons of hunskelping from a former Rangers supporter. He really bought into Celtic. I absolutely loved the wee man. So he gets a jersey.

My other DM is Neil Lennon. An absolute colossus of a player. The biggest compliment I could pay Neil is that when he hung up his boots I was casting my eyes around for a direct replacement and could only come up with Edgar David of Juventus!
The next biggest compliment I can give Lenny is that he’s got the jersey ahead of
Paul Lambert and Scott Brown.

Disclaimer: no Lisbon Lions were considered in compiling my team.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 17, 2023 11:37 am

Another thing that struck me,thinking back over this wee series,is not only some of the wonderful players we have seen,but also some of the top players we signed who just didn’t do it for us.

Sure,we unearthed some rough diamonds on the cheap. Robson and Hartley dragged us over the line in 2009,cost us peanuts but will always have a place in our hearts. But we spent hugely,if you include fees and wages,around the same time on Jarosik and Gravesen. And they were bloody awful!

Maybe that is why Lawwell preferred to sign players nobody had heard of. He simply didn’t have an eye for a player at any level.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 17, 2023 11:41 am

BILLYBHOY

Loved Stan-he’s actually in the running for my creative mids! Same wi Thommo,which category fits them best? As for my formation,I still haven’t decided on 4-4-2 or 4-3-3. Don’t think I’d have cut it as a manager….

Craig 76
October 17, 2023 11:46 am
October 17, 2023 12:01 pm

I’m going with a diamond formation so my 1st 2 midfielders are Paul Lambert as the sitting defensive midfielder/regista and L’ubomír Moravčík as the Number 10/Fantasista.

Leggy
October 17, 2023 12:06 pm

Morning all,

Maestro and John Collins.

Just edging Hay, Lambert and Lennon

HH 🍀🍀🍀

Big Audio Dynamite
October 17, 2023 12:18 pm

For balance ..

Wanyama, Dalglish and the Maestro

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 17, 2023 12:49 pm

BADABING

Cracker. Playing just off the shoulder.

Ernie Lynch
October 17, 2023 1:01 pm

OK

I’ll go with McStay, Moravcik, Dalgleish and Petrov.

George Connelly on the bench.

Prestonpans bhoys
October 17, 2023 1:25 pm

McStay & Aitken for me, remember Roy could play in midfield or defence

Mahe
October 17, 2023 2:51 pm

I shall go with Wanyama and Lambert,, solid as a rock.

Hail Hail

Bada Bing
October 17, 2023 2:55 pm

The Beckham series on Netflix is very good, the press and paparazzi got away with murder back then

Mahe
October 17, 2023 3:28 pm

Mackers if looking in a fella elsewhere was asking about this. Any help appreciated.

,,,,,,,

Good morning, friends. Don’t suppose there are any qualified electricians on this fine wee group chat? We’re getting our back garden ripped out next week and a new one put in. As part of this we’re wanting some outside lights installed. I’ve had a quote but it’s the guy’s labour charge that surprised me but it’s highly likely that I’ve underestimated how long I thought the job would take. I guessed at 3-4 hours so his charge of £360 for labour looks very high. But before I try any haggling, am I way off the mark on how time consuming the job is?
In short we already have 2 lights on the outside of our house. So effectively he has to take a feed off of those, run armoured cable under what will be our new garden, then up behind the fence and branched off where the 2 lights will go. The wiring run is about 15metres. Have I greatly underestimated the time this will take him? The costs of the cabling, junction boxes, lights etc all seem as expected but I’d be happy to try someone else if it looks as if he’s ripping me off with £360 to actually do the work?
Maybe we should rename this group AskTheExpertsCSC 😉

McCaff
October 17, 2023 4:21 pm

Mahe…looks no bad to me to be honest although I’d be delighted at that hourly rate!!
Rates have gone up with everything else so although it seems a bit expensive I’d expect a couple of guys on the job to run the armoured cable and do the second fix.
Was talking to a guy on Saturday night who reckons he’s getting £50 an hour as a spark – £2k a week!! I challenged him and he, eventually, admitted that was for some specialist reports etc that he’d been asked to do but ordinarily he was getting about £25-£30 an hour. Still a reasonable wage.
I’d be clarifying what’s involved and seeking another quote, I think.

October 17, 2023 4:29 pm

Mahe
Electricians don’t come cheap…..could be over $100 p/hr depending on the work get another couple of quotes.

McCaff
October 17, 2023 4:44 pm

TimH…there won’t be many sparks in the UK earning that kinda money for domestic work! There’s a couple guys do work for me now and again and their rates are more like those I quotes earlier.

Margaret McGill
October 17, 2023 5:12 pm

Mahe
Solar lights?

I’ll go with Burns Nakamura Broonie

big packy
October 17, 2023 5:23 pm

AFTERNOON ALL AND JIM is the lions exempt from this vote because some of the players getting votes could not lace any of the lions boots, and another thing while there is babies and children being bombed to bits in the middle east,I wont be commenting on celtic or any football for that matter, another true story.

October 17, 2023 5:35 pm

Paul McStay
Murdo MacLeod

Both brilliant box to box midfielders with terrific shots, good tacklers, great energy levels and commitment.

Could have been Tommy Burns, Paul Lambert, Stan or several others, esp Bobby M and Bertie but as a child I barely new what roles they had. Course I know now.

October 17, 2023 5:42 pm

McCaff
Looked it up on the net the range was $60 to $150 depending on the job but that’s quite a gap as you said get another quote.

Ernie Lynch
October 17, 2023 6:12 pm

McCaff

Who is digging and backfilling the trench? Has the guy done work on the house before? He’ll have to check and sign off the job once he’s finished and if he isn’t familiar with your electrics he might be making an allowance for things maybe taking a bit longer than anticipated.

Seems a bit on the high side, but not excessively so.

McCaff
October 17, 2023 6:16 pm

Ernie…not my house or my job, I would’ve done it myself and got a spark to do the final connection at the Consumer Unit!
Mahe asked what I thought – I’m with you, plenty of points to determine to ascertain if it reasonable or not. A second quote or a chat with the spark will clarify.

October 17, 2023 6:40 pm

Evening all.

My midfield trio.

Andy Thom

Paul McStay

Murdo McLeod

HH

Craig 76
October 17, 2023 7:05 pm

So many Huns with Celtic twitter acconuts

https://x.com/BHOYSbrigadier/status/1714265645724942358?s=20

A thing of beauty
October 17, 2023 7:07 pm

No surprises to hear I have selected Paul McStay aka the Maestro as my number one midfielder. Utterly peerless in my eyes. I’ve said before he set my bar far too high on what a footballer should be like especially one from our youth system. He played with such a straight back, never flustered and seemed like he had wing mirrors on. My all time favourite Celt.
For my other man in the middle I’ll go with Paul Lambert. We don’t have many European cup winners in our ranks outside of the lions and that why I’ll go for him over Lennon. I also like the fact that he got every ounce out of what he was given. He left Scotland as a journeyman right winger and returned as a top class centre mid. I like a player that knows the game and is willing to keep learning.
Honourable mentions to big vic and Lennon. Very good players.

ASWGL
October 17, 2023 7:51 pm

First off I’m not dissing anyone’s choices, we aren’t all like minded.

With that said and given that we are not all young un’s on the blog, It kind of amazes me that no one has chosen (The quiet assassin) Davie Hay for either of the last three leaders, Full back/Centre back/Midfield he could play, and did play them all, with exceptional natural talent (he even played as an accomplished number 10) to me he was the complete footballer, up until the tight wads on our board wouldn’t pay him the wages he deserved, and rather than doing the honorable thing, they sold him to Chelsea.

Davie in later years firstly as our manager again had to deal with a biscuit tin board, who wouldn’t give him money for defenders to supplement our decent attacking players, while Souness *ick spit hurl puke* was luring engerlund’s top talent on dodgy EBT schemes, which allowed him to steal trophies from Davie/Us.

Later still as our scout, Davie was responsible for discovering some very good signings, such as George Cadette, Big Pierre, and the hugely talented fascist nutter known as Di Canio.

It just goes to show what diverse opinions we all have.

Murdoch & Hay for me

HH

Craig 76
October 17, 2023 8:08 pm

For ATOB and CCB also any other ayrshire based posters,lurkers

https://x.com/irvineno1csc/status/1714164847313604852?s=20

16 roads
October 17, 2023 8:11 pm

Not certain of this – think when Davie Hay left Celtic spelled the end for George Connolly?

Anyway it’s too difficult for me to pick three without leaving out any of the Lions.. therefore it’s only Paul McStay,The Maestro and my Idol!

HH.🍀

ASWGL
October 17, 2023 8:16 pm

16 Roads, that’s correct both Davie and George were at odds with the board for a decent wage, and when Davie was sold George just decided to quit.

Auldheid
October 17, 2023 8:17 pm

If it cannot be Bobby Murdoch then I for Davie Hay and Nakamura.

Sol Kitts
October 17, 2023 8:19 pm

Engurland with their traditional penalty. Just like watching Sevco.

Prestonpans bhoys
October 17, 2023 8:21 pm

Sol Kitts

My thoughts exactly

Bada Bing
October 17, 2023 8:25 pm

Taylor should go through Greizmann👍

Sol Kitts
October 17, 2023 8:29 pm

France 1, Scotland 1. Poor goal to lose from a corner.

ASWGL
October 17, 2023 8:30 pm

Sol you have to wonder why no defender takes the back post