Do they do what it says on the tin?
We were all surprised to hear Brendans critique of our two central defenders that our currently unable to break into the matchday squad, namely that they need to show more in training in order to come into contention.
We’ve all watched Liam Scales grab his chance with both hands, we’ve heard Tomoki Iwata trains very hard and has earned some quality time in the Hoops, ditto Oh who has won over many detractors when called upon recently, so it’s a bitter pill to swallow when others either don’t follow the example being set or refuse to knuckle down and truly earn their place.
It’s doubly bitter when the position in question really needs strength in depth, I doubt Liam will last the full season either through injury or form, and Big Cam has reached his peak value as an asset having a couple of years left on the contract and will probably be in demand from a club in a bigger league offering a bigger salary. Realistically Nawrocki and Lagerbeilke could be our twin towers at the back together for three or four years, two International to replace two Internationals is great foresight on paper, just not in reality.
Or is that necessarily true?
There’s been plenty of examples of players who don’t actually train that well but produce on the park, Celtic are not alone with this apparent problem, but the gaffer has spoken. Train well in order to play, he said out loud. For the moment he can call upon Nat Phillips to spare his blushes, but what happens when he’s not in town?
It’s move Iwata back or call upon a bad trainer, which either leaves egg on Brendans face or a ‘midget’ at the back. Neither are ideal.
Should he persuade the transfer committee to move them on and start again we shall surely take a hit on their costs, not only that but the very same transfer committee supposedly got these two wrong, what’s to say the replacements will be adequate?
It seems their due diligence on the pair wasn’t up to scratch, asking numerous people in the know about their attitude and demeanor should have topped the list of requirements a player must pass in order to be considered,,did they do that?
Soon one or both will be overlooked for their national sides and urged to get game time (not train better) by their respective managers, further widening the wedge and bringing the situation to a head. A situation that really doesn’t benefit our actual defense as they will be further along being settled Celtic players ready to be called upon at any given moment.
Another negative is the poor publicity attached, tempting another Swede will be that little bit harder if they’ve watched their leagues best defender not get a proper chance with the club, Lager won’t be big upping Brendan anytime soon one imagines, he won’t be giving a glowing reference for joining to any fellow countrymen.
Worse still is the possibility they are training hard but not looking good quality, Lord knows an International Cap doesn’t suddenly turn an average player into a good one, I’ve witnessed many a capped player underwhelm in the green and white, Laxalt immediately springs to mind.
‘Do more in training’ isn’t specific, but usually means try harder, but I think Brendan would have framed it differently if they just weren’t up to scratch as footballers, work on their game or some similar jargon, so I’ll assume it’s not a quality problem but one of dedication.
Which sucks. Full dedication is something we all expect from ‘our’ employees, which can be fanciful. Recall Jinkys rowing boat, Broonys kebab, Lenny and Henkes KFC, even our ex midfielder Roy Keane had his escapades despite the reputation for ultimate professionalism. They made mistakes off the field, yet were excellent players on it.
So I’m really torn about the affair, very much in two minds.
Firstly I admire a manager who sets standards that must be kept, nothing wrong with that and as far as I can see the bar hasnt been set too high.
But secondly, you don’t win points on the training pitch, it’s what a man actually does in the Hoops he should be judged upon.
Do they do what it says on the tin?
I just don’t know if it’s a hill worth dying on or not for the manager, if it’s a case of cutting your nose off to spite your face.
I do know one thing though, I’d rather enter next season with two central defenders who know the club and playing style than two newbies.
It’s a big call, and that’s why Brendan gets the big bucks I suppose.
What’s your take?
By Mahe
sentinelcelts@gmail.com
POTY competition
sencelpoty@gmail.com
Napsters follow the link
https://sentinelcelts.com/2023/11/30/the-sentinel-celts-naps-competition-part-three/
“Does what it says on the tin”
Official Celtic tins with official club crest.
Available in the Superstore (portacabins)
A great Christmas present for all the family and ideal for kicking down the road
should any “unpleasantness” arise concerning the Club
Only £19.99.
Given we aren’t getting much return from the CB’s you mention (Haven’t a clue)
Being without Abada, Maeda and Hatate for long periods (First picks of the last couple of years)
Added to injuries to other key pieces like Cameron and AJ,
I’d say Brendan deserves enormous credit for having us still unbeaten at this stage of the league campaign.
I’m looking forward to seeing what he may add in the next couple of windows.
And especially what the team might look like if he is properly backed in the market.
Matthew has been Incredible this Season, Listening to him, which is always Great, I think he is Loving life @ Celtic. Aye Aye Caramba Matthew would be my choice.
BAD
Agree I think this January window will tell a story more than most….both incoming and outgoing.
Of all the summer signings including 3 centrebacks and 3 midfielders it looks like we could be settling on Iwata and scales who were already here.
Of the three wingers signed only palma has passed muster but would prob be back up to maeda and abada if both fit.
I was there at the Metro Saltcoats when KWS played. Showing ma age.
H h h
January windows don’t often provide much to cheer about.
The priority will be a no9 and anything else would be a bonus.
I reckon we have enough elsewhere to win this league- I’m hoping by then we will be 11 points ahead, the Huns having a game in hand.
Quality upgrades in the positions where we are clearly weak will probably have to wait til summer.
Maybe some of the driftwood will go.
PETEC
I was there at The Metro when it was still The Regal cinema.
Triple H,
Now that we have another squad full of saleable assets, it would make sense to concentrate on only adding key (First picks) pieces to the puzzle. We have had our fair share of January successes, so there’s really no excuse not to attempt to find a striker, a full-back and a proper no nonsense defensive midfielder. Adding in our need for a more agile keeper, I should think we might be looking at adding 4 new first team picks 👍
Given we have billions in the bank …then 😉
Petec,
Did you ever go to the Arches in Glasgow??
From memory – were Iwata, Daizen, Reo, Matt and AJ not all January acquisition??
There may be more.
BAD
Correct.
As was Oh.
I’d rather not discuss the others.
BMCUWP
Loved the Regal. Plush carpets up the stairway to the balcony, to watch the latest films on what was then the biggest screen in Scotland. Back in the day Harry Kemp even managed to get the Scottish Symphony Orchestra to play there.
Then there was the La Scala across the road, latterly split into 2 smaller cinemas before eventually morphing into its current guise as a Wetherspoon’s pub, the Salt Cot.
Many a great Friday night spent in those cinemas…….😉
Michael you are Showing yer age now to 🙂
January will be the https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8W8nZ4xFPEU Acid test
The Huns have got to 2 meaningful Finals, since we last got to 1.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3RDHb77kvA
His DJ’ing on the night eismae bad tae
OOps I did it again
ASCID TEST
eis (School Strike)mae.
Mistakes All over the hardcore Bass.
SOLKITTS
There was a balcony?
PETEC
We’ve been to more finals than them this century. Won more too.
BMCUWP
https://x.com/sol_kitts/status/1733432993417515256?s=61&t=hheZSqALUoYbwu9Cj7EjBg
SOLKITTS
We were told that was for the choir,and I wasn’t allowed as I was a lousy singer. Who knew?
Europe – Michael, we are underachieving there so much – Aidan was quite visibly annoyed at the Bodo Glimt game – What does it say when you are Heralding a Bank Sheet. I didnae go on Wednesday. Thankfully the Support, Aidan went.
It’s gonnae be a lot harder now to Win a Euro Trophy.
No Parachutes – Michael I’m scunnered
Big Audio Dynamite
Petec,
Did you ever go to the Arches in Glasgow??
………………………………………………………………………
Apologies for a late response.
I Went Vanilla Ice (2 Times)
I know Laurent Garnier done a mega set there (i’d have Loved to have been there – the 12 hours he’d just be Bonkers), I missed out there for sure.
None of you Ayrshire mob ever go to the Ingledene?
Fascinating Lead Mahe,
My take!?
Well!!
First can I give you Paul67’s take from the other day…
Brendan Rodgers comments last week about Gustaf Lagerbielke and Maik Nawrocki were more nuanced that the reported headlines. The manager made the point that neither player have had an opening with Cameron and Liam Scales having established a solid pairing. We have five fit central defenders; our top man has a tightness which could turn into an injury, but four are in pristine condition.
Whatever the perceived levels of Gustaf and
Maik, they are is not a reason to leave them in the stands. Celtic are a club which needs to take promising players from other environments and develops them into great talents. This is the path we must follow, we cannot turn into a club which wastes players.
Now, many of us regarded Paul as someone ITK, my feeling is after he got the Brendan Rodgers appointment badly wrong in the early summer is that his sources are not as “accurate” as they once were.
That said, he obviously knows a lot more than your average Tim.
My take away from his lead was that their is pressure on BR, at least from some quarters, to play the development players specifically the CHs.
Your sentence was interesting…
‘Do more in training’ isn’t specific, but usually means try harder, but I think Brendan would have framed it differently if they just weren’t up to scratch as footballers, work on their game or some similar jargon, so I’ll assume it’s not a quality problem but one of dedication.
Think you are correct, he has been specific about what other players need to do, Mikey this week after the Hibs game, he needs to be more aggressive, “He’s been really good in training and he’s earned his start, so hopefully if he gets more starts he can show more of his qualities.”
Bernabei he said needed to improve defensively.
The fact is, we know that BR gives each player a personal development plan, that is key to how he brings players on and he’s had some fantastic results there throughout his career.
Oh came in from Korea thinking he was going to set Europe on fire, Iwata came in from Japan with a big reputation.
That was close to a year ago now, how many of us were convinced by their early performances?
Yet now, after several months on the fringes with the BR treatment, here they are looking like the real deal.
Also look at bhoys with potential who have stepped up, Liam Scales, Matt O’Riley etc, very quickly became better players, obviously listening to advice, obviously doing it in training.
That’s the way forward.
If the big CHs want a starting berth they know what to do, grab the opportunity lad, ’cause it won’t be presented to you on a platter at Rodgers’s Celtic.
Hail Hail
BMCWP 9.47
What about the invisible man. Signed Jan 2018 with much hype and didn’t make 1 league appearance in 18months. Robbed us blind.
I echo Chairbhoy’s comments. If you want to play for Celtic you do what the manager asks you. The days of players not being good trainers and turning it on at the weekend are gone. 100% commitment to your profession is what what’s needed now. If you can’t do that, then cheerio. League one is dying for your attitude.
Triple H (copyright BAD)
I worked in the ingledene for a few years in my late teens. Great days. A more classy establishment than the other local pubs that bmcuwp and sol frequented. 😂😂
Who knows, maybe I served you a couple of pints or a cocktail with a maraschino cherry back in the day!!
No apology necessary, Pete 👍
Me and my bestie spent many a great night in there during the height of the ecto scene.
Funny thing is though, neither of us were really into them or there for that.
He liked a beer and I like a doobie, so we must’ve been in a very small minority.
We were basically there for the atmosphere (Incredible at times) and the DJ sets.
Oh ..and it was a fantastic place to meet some beautiful (Full of lovin’) ladies 😉
MemoriesCSC.
HH.
still to trap for Superbru:-
18 yard man, a thing of beauty, Aipple, Angel Gabriel, Bhoy from the Village,brth, Chalmersbhoy, Paddy’s Maw and TheLurkinTim
HOOPHOOPHOORAY
Many a good night spent in The Ingledene!
Sadly long gone. Demolished,and the site used for housing.
SOLKITTS and I spent a late evening in there with a British Transport cop once. Gutting ourselves at how his colleague had somehow been left at the previous stop in Saltcoats.
Big Audio Dynamite
I Love hardcore Techno but a DJ is only allotted a certain time.
They are always gonnae play the Bangers.
Sonics frae the past (even frae before I was born) would get little ol petec going Radio Rental.
I think I’d be in Dance Heaven wae 12 hours of uniquness, as I said I missed oot that Davie Hay.
AULDBHOY67
A pawn in Lawwell’s pissing competition. As was Shved a year later-and countless others over the years.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v7gK6UuSQ10
I have 3 of these mixes on CD.
Bmcwp.
What’s that charity sentinel celts are supporting this year?
Could you provide link so I can donate leggy’s winnings towards it.
Cheers.
CHALMERSBHOY
Turned out that the donate page wasn’t working,so rather than hope for the best,I’ll reinstate it when it is operating properly.
Well done,Leggy!!!
Vougepunter
Your horse is a NR
Don’t know if I agree that a less enthusiastic trainer, makes for a bad player, Big bad John Hartson will be the first to admit he hated training, and was dire at it, still you wouldn’t have sent him to League One. As WGS said he’s a crap trainer but will get me 25 goals a season.
HH
A Thing of Beauty
“A more classy establishment than the other local pubs that bmcuwp and sol frequented.”
——————————————————-
Perhaps these establishments were classy UP UNTIL bmcupwp and sol frequented them?🤣😂😅
ASWGL
Heard a few times that George Best would just phone it in at training. He wasn’t too bad a player either.😊
Bayern getting gubbed 3-0 by Eintracht after 38 minutes.
Sevco 0 Dundee 1
IniquitousIV
Penalty incoming in 5,4,3,2…
Well, well, well when will the mibs get involved. They will not be allowed to drop any points….
AFTERNOON ALL AND JIM ,so here is the leeds story, 1970 my dad myself and 2 of his mates all had tickets, my dad being partial to a pint of Guinness and a black rum chaser, asked our next door neebor brian kinsella if he would drive our car to hampden, brian didnt have a ticket but my dad said to him brian if we cant find you a ticket you can have mine,,as we got closer to hampden my claustrophobia was kickin in thousands and thousands of celtic supporters walking towards hampden we had to park about a mile away from Hampden and walk the rest, as we got to the gates it was just a mass of celtic supporters waiting to get in, I knew from that point I would not make it ,my claustrophobia, had beaten, me said to my dad give my ticket to brian,he was over the moon so the moral of the story is, I listened to the game on a transistor radio outside Hampden but I can still say I was there,another true story.LOL 😂
Took them 26 minutes to award a penalty for the famous shirt pull that no one else would get!
ASWGL/IQIV,
True in both cases but hartson would not get above league one level now such was his lack of fitness. The game has changed. It is played by athletes who clubs try to make footballers of.
Bmcuwp,
For the record, the Ingledene was not knocked down. The original part was converted to two flats but the disco was knocked down giving room for some houses. As an aside, I would not live in one of those flats if it was free. There was a ghost in that place that gives me the chills even now when I think about it.
Given the 100% guarantee it will not go unpunished, you would almost think opposition defensive players are quite deliberately tugging Sevco shirts in the box to disadvantage their own team. Why do they do it, week after week? That’s Hertz, Sheep and Dundee, all recently. Dundee didn’t even wait until the last minute, like the other two.
Dundee Goal disallowed for fk all
Craig 76
IniquitousIV
Penalty incoming in 5,4,3,2?…
———————————
Can you give me some lottery ticket numbers?
How exactly are we going to stop Sima scoring from a corner or free kick on Dec 30?
Put Taylor on him?