The pennies and the pounds

Searching my brain for a slow news day article following yesterday’s excellent piece of nostalgia, a thought struck me with regard to our two young Under 23 International midfielders,,Kelly and Holm.

 

18 and 20 respectively, the two Hoops joined up with their countrymen over the break, and will now resume their duel for gametime in a Celtic midfield which will be much harder to come by now Reo is ready to rock. It’s fair to say Kelly is recently winning that duel, he currently sees more minutes on the park than Odin, who initially saw much more minutes than Kelly. But things change, and the local lad has forced himself above the foreigner in the pecking order,,which is kinda my point.

 

We don’t need, nor should we have, two separate young midfielders on the fringes at the same time vying for precious minutes. We should have one only, not two. There’s simply not enough minutes available to develop both, and I suspect a new midfielder will arrive in the summer to become an automatic starter further hurting their cause.
And now that the local has clearly been deemed the best bet of the two by the manager (if we assume he stays those three years he mentioned), then one really must ask why did we buy Odin Tiago Holm at all when there’s a better local youth in the same position waiting in the wings, and being prepared to sign up long term with gametime?

 

In contemplating the circumstances of both, I don’t see a lot of joined up thinking by the recruitment personnel, perhaps a disconnect between them and the youth team coaches who presumably nominate players they think are ready for first team action.
“We’ve a young midfielder good enough”
“Great, we will buy another one elsewhere!”
Not only that but they also recruited Bernardo, Kwon, and Iwata in the same window as Holm, which makes two breakthroughs nigh impossible,,,one talented young midfielder was all that was needed, and it turns out he was sitting under ‘their’ noses all that time.

 

Transfermrket lists Odin as a 2.5 million Euro signing on a five year deal, which overall will cost the club the guts of 5 million of the course. Despite being on the young side of 50 still, I’m very old school in my thinking and fully subscribe to the old adage of ‘look after the pennies and the pounds will look after themselves’. A clever club wouldn’t have recruited him, and would use that 5 million-ish much wiser.

 

As we embark on the New Barrowfield adventure, as we should be seeing the rewards of linking up with an Austrian club as a feeder club/partner club, we cannot afford such disconnect between crucial departments,,,the equivalent of looking after the pennies if you like.
A smart boardroom with a sound strategy would not have sanctioned footballing bloat, which now file many players under, Odin the latest. 5 million wasted on a player won’t make or break Celtic, but eliminating lots of recruits to that extremely long list of names would help make the club, make it modern that is.

 

The importance of the next recruitment team cannot be understated, for once we truly do need the right men for the job.
To truly progress we cannot squander the pennies and the pounds as has happened, take care of the first and when it does come time to splash the cash have an actual clear pathway for the player. But first and perhaps most important, properly access the player against all those currently on the books, so we never buy another Holm when theres a Kelly in-house.

 

By Mahe
sentinelcelts@gmail.com

78 Comments
Mahe
March 26, 2024 1:27 am

You can read our weekend article on a resolution for improving refereeing standards here.

https://sentinelcelts.com/2024/03/22/resolution-on-refereeing-standards/

Mahe
March 26, 2024 1:28 am

The Sentinel Celts Charity Drive has nominated Blood Cancer UK as the recipient for funds for the next six months to 31/07/2024,and we are getting close to achieving our SECOND TARGET.

We have set up a GoFundMe page for those who have some spare cash to donate,even from a lucky windfall or finding a tenner in the street.

Click on the link for more details,including how to donate.

https://www.gofundme.com/f/sentinel-celts?utm_campaign=p_lico+share-sheet&utm_medium=copy_link&utm_source=customer

Please give generously to a very deserving cause. Although our first target has now been achieved-and many thanks for your generosity!-we can always hope to do more.

Mahe
March 26, 2024 1:29 am

I received a very welcome e-mail a couple of weeks ago from one of our regular posters. He was letting me know that he had been given the news that his recently diagnosed prostate cancer hadn’t spread elsewhere. Obviously,I let him know how delighted I was on hearing this,but it got me thinking-I haven’t had mine checked,not ever!

Nobody wants to think about cancer of any kind. Even the word itself strikes fear into most of us. Few either really want to think about the initial testing for this particular form of it,with its lurid examples on tv and film over the years. Sadly,and particularly if you are over 50yo,you should be!

March is Prostate Cancer Aware Month,and you might be interested in reading the following:-

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/prostate-cancer/symptoms/

and

https://www.macmillan.org.uk/cancer-awareness/prostate-cancer-awareness-month#:~:text=March%20is%20prostate%20cancer%20awareness,rate%20is%201%20in%204.

Fortunately,the initial tests need not be as barbaric and mediaeval as are widely thought. There is a PSA test,which is essentially a blood test. So just a little prick!

Either way,if you have any concerns,please seek medical advice at the earliest opportunity.

Just Sayin’
March 26, 2024 6:14 am

Odin Holm signed for us as a 20 year old , he is 21 now.
A serious prospect his potential was highlighted in a “ next generation “ top 60 poll in 2020.

With our own success of a young Ajer joining us aged 18 and various other young talent making it abroad from Norway- Odegaard at 16, Haaland at 19, I’d argue he was a calculated acquisition. The sort we should be making.

Let’s give these young guys a bit of time instead of rushing to premature assessment.

Fan
March 26, 2024 9:39 am

Just Sayin
I think Odin Holm has very good potential.
Unfortunately for him BR is not interested in potential as his player picks this season and his vocall utterings have shown.
Holm’s over enthusiasm in Europe to prove himself saw him earn a red card.
Under a safety first coach that was a no no and unfortunately sent his Celtic career backwards .
He will now have the difficult task of earning the coaches approval.
I thought it strange in recent game where Iwata moved to centre back for CCV it would have made more sense if Holm played in defensive role when he came on.
This suggested to me he is not yet trusted in vital defensive mid role yet when played there he has shown talent.

Bada Bing
March 26, 2024 9:58 am

Bernard Ponsonby has retired from STV, we could do much worse than employ him to head up our media affairs

Lost in translation ...
March 26, 2024 10:30 am

Mahe

Apologies in advance but you are well off the pace with this MF angle.
The elephant in the room in all of this is BR’s ego — he is struggling to emerge from AP’s shadow.
Plus we should buy this year for next years gaps in the squad.

OTH is a quality player — young / bit immature / raw — but still quality.
Some of his individual play has been excellent — he can tackle but sometimes too energetically.
After 8 months here I do not know what his best position is — B2B / CDM / AM — take your pick.
Takes a while but even egg chasers can pick up on the lingo.

DK at this moment in time is a “Hail Mary” play to fill a jersey in MF.
PMcS @ 17.5 he most certainly isn’t — slightly off SPL pace at the moment.
Plus expectation levels need to be managed on both sides.
However he has shown that he has a lot of promise.

I would say that he still has two years of learning to work his way through.
Plus we have the shambles of BL to deal with — and this time their might be a positive.

To us — big unit so he must be a CB.
Rest of the world he is a CDM with a good shot.
Our youth set up needs cleaned out with a Christmas tree.

Next season in the MF we could have:

CMcG — Currently off form and on the slide / 4 good games this season at a stretch.
MO’R — Huge talent / top top talent but not settled with us recently and likely for the off.
RH — Lots of work required / season is close to being written of but we have 18 months of excellence to look back on.
TI — Lots of good stuff but still not quite up to speed in the SPL / day dreams at times.

PB — Worth the money? / some class but drifts in and out of games / again what is his actual position?
KH-k — the Busan Buddie who seems to have found some form 15 miles away from G40 / Again not a good look.
BL — might be something in his game we can use / the JI of the 2020’s if you like

B Team — not sure who is turning 20 this season?
Development players / loans — BS has had quite a lot of game time at Dunfermline / enough progress?
SPL breakout MF’ers — quite a few about that we should be having a good look at.

7 or 8 squad places to fill for next season.

In this context we need OTH to move up to be a starter next season.
I think he has the talent / basics to make it — issue is our set up / coaching / MF mix next season.

In this context we need to manage DK very carefully — not throw him into a mis-firing team and hope he can swim.
As noted above the set up / shape / tactics in MF are probably more important than the individuals at this moment in time.

JI — Jackson Irvine.
BS — Ben Summers.

Just Sayin’
March 26, 2024 10:42 am

Fan

Tend to agree. Hung out after a rash 10 minutes cameo v Feyenoord.
Lagerbielke seems to have suffered the same fate for the same red card reason.

b b 1

Bernard Ponsonby was at the Tommy Burns supper in Edinburgh on Friday.
When introduced to him by a mutual friend his answer to the question what are you planning for your retirement was “ to see a lot more of Celtic”

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
March 26, 2024 11:02 am

MM

28. Prolific. More mindbenders there than clues for many crosswords.

March 26, 2024 11:06 am

“Hello there! I recently noticed that you’ve taken the time to visit my website, and I wanted to express my heartfelt gratitude for your interest. Your support means a lot to me. In return, I would like to extend my support by visiting your website as well.

Lost in translation ...
March 26, 2024 11:10 am

BB @ 8.37

17th to be exact — Total retail sales / Kit + Merchandising revenues coming in at EUR 34mill for 2023.
Bit annoyed that Ajax and LU are just above us along with Galatasaray.

Glory Hunter FC seems to be making all the running at the moment.
Apart from Citeh who really must be small potatoes in real life.
Win the CL and Spurs beat you in shirt sales — not good.
AP and his growth agenda strikes again.

Quick web search — we seemingly get £6mill pa from Adidas for our current deal.
Signed in 2020 / 5 year deal / £6mill pa mentioned but a weak source — currently £30mill / EUR 34mill annual revenue.

Ajax — as a data point / also with Adidas.
Latest deal starts in 2025 / 6 year deal / EUR 8-9mill pa mentioned on the web — currently EUR 41mill in annual revenue.

Rip off Britain might come into play — the cost of a replica shirt is eye watering in the extreme.

Current web pricing
Ajax = £35 on Kitbag.
Us = £50 on the club website was £70.

Board milking the fans again?
Surely not.

San Luis
March 26, 2024 12:00 pm

LIT

That Celtic, who’ve done nothing in Europe in decades and who play in a small provincial League on the western fringes of Europe can somehow get into the Top 20 Global shirt sales, is nothing short of amazing. I’m certain every other entrant comes from the cash rich leagues or from countries with ten times our population.

Credit where it’s due.

Lost in translation ...
March 26, 2024 12:08 pm

SL @ 12.00

I fear a zombie stat coming on …
It is not global sales it is Euro sales / EUFA teams.

The support are doing well — the club are just cashing in.
LU show what can be done in trying circumstances.

Bada Bing
March 26, 2024 12:53 pm

Robertson on Sunday, they’re taking the piss,so soon after the Tynecastle cheating

JimDom
March 26, 2024 1:15 pm

Good article, Mahe.

Celtic currently have over 60 players on the payroll, plus all the associated support staff to manage those 60+ players. Why such a high number ? Well, that appears to be the current business model. Buy 4@ £2m rather than 1@ £8m. The one at £8m will be deemed to be too risky a strategy. The Celtic suits don’t accommodate any sort of risk, hence £70m in the bank but 20 years, and counting ,since we played European football in April.

Would like to know BR’s preferred number on the training field at Lennoxtown, at any one time. Less quantity and more quality would likely be the answer.

BB1 re Bernard Ponsonby

Very good shout. But not to head the club’s media. I would have him as Chairman. The current one is a toxic charlatan and the one before him a complete nonentity, not even a Celtic man.

A Thing Of Beauty
March 26, 2024 1:16 pm

Mahe,
Far too soon to write off Odin Thiago Holm. As others have said, he has shown flashes but may not be quite ready yet. Fan blames BR for not playing him but he was given a run around the time of the red card if I recall correctly and did very little except again for flashes and BR turned back to Turnbull. Safety first? Probably, but I also think there was some talk of illness as well when he lost his place in the squad. It may be taking him a little longer to get back up to his fighting weight.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
March 26, 2024 1:29 pm

MAKE

Little doubt that we overloaded ourselves in the summer with midfield mibbes. And at the expense of areas which needed either strengthening or replaced. Goalie and LB in particular as well as a midfield enforcer-which we still don’t have.

I had high hopes for Oh so maybe not a priority,but a more physical presence up front would have been my choice,even as a back-up. We got two centre backs,neither of whom has been in the side enough to impress.

But more wingers? Bloody hell. Can you imagine BR phoning the missus? “Guess what I got this morning in a lucky bag from Uncle Peter? Aye,another bloody winger. Place is infested with them. Naw,I’ve not heard of this one either!”

Not the best way to build a squad,methinks.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 1:34 pm

Some of the most dramatic footage you will ever see. Talk about missing an open goal! What on earth were the 2 pilots of this enormous container ship thinking? The driver of the semi who passed over this bridge before the ship struck is a very lucky man!

https://nbcwashington.app.link/BWbvJDtvhIb

Prestonpans bhoys
March 26, 2024 2:24 pm

Bada

To be fair he said Robertson got the on field decisions right, it was the intervention of our friend Beaton who changed the game hence Thursday.

Pity Robertson didn’t have the balls to dismiss Beatons nonsense.

Mahe
March 26, 2024 2:31 pm

IQ4,
Possible cyber attack on that ship? It lost its lights just before impact. Looks terrible.
Hail Hail

Craig 76
March 26, 2024 2:32 pm

IniquitousIV
There is footage showing the ship further away and you can see clearly it loses all power more than once before it strikes the bridge

https://x.com/CapXSid/status/1772609808136376586?s=20

Bada Bing
March 26, 2024 2:57 pm

PB- as you say mate,Robertson was in charge of the game and let Beaton get his way,no balls to do the right thing, another Uncle Tom….

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 3:10 pm

Craig76
Thanks for that clip.
IQ4😊

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 3:13 pm

I don’t know if they travelled, but neither Yang or Oh featured in South Korea’s world cup qualifier 3-0 win in Thailand.
Oddly, all the Korean back 4 players were called Kim.
A much changed Aussie team won 5-0 away to Lebanon.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
March 26, 2024 3:15 pm

Shocking incident in Baltimore,a miracle that the bridge was mercifully quiet. The bridge went down like a house of cards.

The footage above,via CRAIG76,is very strange indeed. Loss of power then a sharp turn off-course? The inquiry will be interesting indeed.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
March 26, 2024 3:17 pm

INIQUITOUS IV

Kim,formerly of Napoli and now at Bayern,could have been bought for £2m three years ago. Just thought I’d mention it.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 3:21 pm

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
INIQUITOUS IV

Kim,formerly of Napoli and now at Bayern,could have been bought for £2m three years ago. Just thought I’d mention it.
——————————————
Bobby, Was that Kim, Kim, Kim, or Kim?🤣
HH
IQ4😊

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 3:29 pm

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
Shocking incident in Baltimore,a miracle that the bridge was mercifully quiet. The bridge went down like a house of cards.
————————————
Bobby, Too right. It was a bridge carrying a freeway, Interstate I-695, which is part of the Baltimore ring road or motorway ‘beltway.’ Just imagine if it had happened during rush hour!

The disruption to traffic circulation for an extended period will be very significant.
HH
IQ4

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 3:57 pm

Scotland’s U-19s lose 2-0 in the Czech Republic in Euro U-19 Qualifying. They have 0 points, 9 points behind Italy, having lost to all teams in the Group, including Georgia.

This does not bode well for future senior Scotland teams. We are grossly underperforming at the younger levels.

Bada Bing
March 26, 2024 4:31 pm

G Mak a sub Greece v Georgia, 5pm play off final Viaplay

big packy
March 26, 2024 7:12 pm

AFTERNOON ALL AND JIMTHETIM53, been watching my local team runcorn linnets, they play in the northern premier league here in cheshire, im so close to the ground I can here every word the guy on the tannoy announces,,,another true story.LOL 😂 been to a few games only a fiver for me being an OAP but here is the rub they would give anyone a game on the lower half of the SPL and these are only semi professional players, the moral of the story is celtic need to get out of the SPL HELL and maybe find a way into the English first division, failing that an an atlantic league I was lucky I grew up watching the lions, feel sorry for the young ghuys now they will never see celtic compete in europe until we get into a stronger league.another true story,H.H.

Bada Bing
March 26, 2024 7:28 pm

Wales v Poland also on BBC iplayer and Channel 4 Wales

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 8:08 pm

Giamoukakis misses final penalty as Greece exits Euro Nations play off 4-2 on penalties to Georgia.
Toney scores penalty for England.
He has never missed one.
He is worth tens of millions.
But Lawwell preferred Ajeti.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 8:13 pm

Mikey Johnston starts for Ireland, Idah on bench.
Now down 1-0 to Switzerland ( Shaqiri – ex- Liverpool with superb free kick )
Why don’t we have anyone that can do this?

San Luis
March 26, 2024 8:13 pm

Iniquitous
This does not bode well for future senior Scotland teams. We are grossly underperforming at the younger levels.
——————————-++++

I went to watch Scott Gemills charges play Norway’s u20 last summer. It’s was a dreadful game of football, really poor quality from both teams.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 8:20 pm

Iceland take1-0 lead vs Ukraine in playoff ( Gudmunsson )

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 8:21 pm

Norn Ireland with 12% possession go 1-0 up.
We really are a poor team.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 9:06 pm

Just watched the Giamoukakis penalty miss. He weakly trundled it, and missed the goal altogether.

Unfathomable how a professional striker can do that.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 9:10 pm

Rodri puts Spain 1-0 vs Brazil from the spot.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 9:13 pm

Spain 2 Brazil 0 ( Olmo )

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 9:14 pm

These playoff games are really tight.
Ukraine 1 Iceland 1
Poland comfortably handling Wales, but still 0-0.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 9:15 pm

Welsh fans super anxious in stands.

March 26, 2024 9:19 pm

1st thing Scotland players do is turn back the way even against NI. Coaching eh?

Some wanted this idiot as Celtic Manager?

March 26, 2024 9:22 pm

Scotland missing wee Jamesie. 😁

ASWGL
March 26, 2024 9:27 pm

Nathan Patterson is Scotland’s answer to Raphael Scheidt, no way the huns sold him, you couldnae swap him for ginger boattles.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 9:28 pm

Idah in for the Republic on 57 minutes.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 9:33 pm

Matt O’Riley played the last 30 minutes for Denmark in their 2-0 win vs Faroe Islands.

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 9:34 pm

Germany 2 Netherlands 1
Spain 2 Brazil 1

INIQUITOUS IV
March 26, 2024 9:38 pm

Ukraine 2-1 over Iceland. Chekski’s Mudryk gets probable winner to send them to Euros.

Scotland hopeless – haven’t won in 7 games.