An OK Result,At Best

Morning,all.

We were all looking forward to the Hearts game at the weekend,our first game of the season at the “traditional” time of 3pm. This one was especially welcome for a number of reasons. The return after the international break. The first game since humping the huns. The chance to see more of our new signings. And an opportunity to pile the pressure on that Ibrox mob by stretching our lead to eight points,albeit only for 24 hours. Plus,of course,we all love humping Hearts. 

It turned out in the end to be a bit of a damp squib,probably our worst performance of the season to date. Hardly ideal preparation for our first Champions League match. Still enough to beat the minis though. And we got a new MIB worth the watching,in screaming skull Colin Steven. He might have reffed us before,but I don’t recall seeing him refereeing any game before this one,no matter who it involved. Still,2-0 to the good guys,and a blubbering Naismith after the match. What’s not to like?

Another damp squib arrived yesterday,in the form of the annual accounts to 30 June 2024. As usual,they arrived without any breakdown of costs and expenditure,which makes it hard for anyone but a forensic accountant to analyse. And I’m certainly not going to try. 

The headline figures told us that revenue was up a mere £4.7m at £124.6m. While this is,as expected a new record turnover for us,I think most of us were expecting a good bit more. Maybe our merchandising operation didn’t go as well as we had been led to believe when we read that we are in the top ten for adidas sales,that about the only thing I can think of. After all,the fans filled the stadium for every game,bar the early rounds of the cup when there were maybe around ten thousand empty seats. So that’s a puzzle for me.

Even more disappointing was that “operating expenses including labour increased by 10.4% to £105.4m.” That figure is over 10% higher than last year,and that is difficult to explain. Especially when,as mentioned,there is no explanation offered as to where the money was spent. Yes,we spent a small fortune on players-but most of them have been at best disappointing,and even at that,we still cleared £6.6m in profit from the transfer market. And I agree that all those extended contracts wouldn’t have come cheap either,though the new signings wouldn’t be on anywhere near top whack. 

We also made a start on the Barrowfield redevelopment,spent more on Lennoxtown and on maintenance at Celtic Park,and then there’s the one-off inclusion of £13.5m last year,presented as a non-recurring item which inflated those figures by that amount. Overall,the gross profit for the year was down almost 60% to £17.8m,nett £13m,which most clubs worldwide,never mind in Scotland,would give their eye teeth for. And we have cash in hand of £77m,which isn’t to be sneezed at even if our amortisation levels are the highest in the club’s history. 

As you’re probably sick of me telling you,I always try to give credit to the board where it is due,and it is difficult to quibble that the club is by and large a well-run business. But we have to remember that these figures are from 01/07/2023 to 30/06/2024. They don’t include our latest signings,nor do they include the transfer fee we received for Jota (which was rushed through in order to appear in the previous accounts.) They do,however,include the approximately £17m we wasted on absolute crap last summer. Apparently that took our spending on players to £68m since the 20/21 accounts were released. I’m glad to say that the other £51m was generally better spent,and that the halfwits behind the £17m of wasted cash have been shown the door. 

Oh,there you go. Told you I’d give credit to the board when it is due. But I have to be honest too,and I don’t think that this is one of those glorious balance sheets that the board will be bragging about. More importantly,the club needs to be more open with the fans when it comes to breaking down our operating costs. Our club will be no different from any other one operating in a professional league,particularly at the top level. In other words,football wage costs,mainly the players,will comprise the bulk of our expenditure. But without an explanation of how that £105.4m was arrived at,we can only guess at where it went. And since I honestly doubt that we spend as much as £60m on player salaries,that leaves an awful lot of money sloshing around and unaccounted for. 

That’s not me making even the slightest accusation of fraud or malpractice,nor anything along those lines. After all,total expenditure includes capital costs,replacement costs and maintenance costs,as well as the wages for around 500 staff. But we would all be a lot happier if we had some idea of where it is all spent. And the board fails to provide that every year. 

Looking forward to a year from now,I expect to see a decent uplift in operating income,but we should prepare ourselves for player trading profits to be minimal. That will probably see the overall totals not much changed from the current ones. Could be worse,and there’s always that £77m lurking in the cash drawer just begging to be spent!

<><><><><>
Above article by BMCUWP


229 Comments
BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
September 17, 2024 6:08 am

As you will all know,the site finally nominated a charity to be the recipient of the generosity and largesse of yourselves,and I think you all deserve huge applause for raising just short of £2k.

⭐️👏☘️👍🍾

That period has passed,and a new charity has been chosen to take us through to the end of the year. A landslide vote in favour of

Lanarkshire Cancer Care Trust.

Once again,CHALMERSBHOY has done the spadework via JustGiving.

Here is the link for the Lanarkshire Cancer Care Trust,our new charity which we will support.

https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinel-celts-1722588284471?utm_medium=fundraising&utm_content=page%2Fsentinel-celts-1722588284471&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=pfp-share

Default payment method seems to be ApplePay,which won’t suit everyone. There is an option on the page to change that to your preferred means.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
September 17, 2024 6:09 am

JOBO POTY Competition.

sencelpoty@gmail.com

Bawheid
September 17, 2024 7:46 am

Bobby – Some of the figures need a more detailed explanation, not that we will get it, but the figures put out yesterday, once we could only dream about, realising that our figures including cash in the biscuit tin could help keep Scottish football going. I mean that’s the whole stupidity of the game here in Scotland, where some clubs are rushing to expel our away support, short of money, so lets ban the Celtic support? The other point was after the nepotism disaster, was there a pay out? who knows, but with figures like they put out yesterday who could complain and all the new players are players of quality. Because of what happened in the past we will always be suspicious and that is why overall, I will still be holding back on any celebrations.

Hoop hoop hooray
September 17, 2024 8:14 am

Bawheid
Hell mend those clubs who turn away good money in favour of empty seats. It’s beyond comprehension. Would never happen in any other entertainment business.

Bobby
I thought the most telling bit about the statement was that our strategy and goals each year included qualification for the CL. Nothing beyond that (which has been proven with our CL performances).

Hopefully we have a bright new dawn starting tomorrow.

Bawheid
September 17, 2024 8:22 am

ACSWGL: Thank you for putting up the pictures, the picture on the right, is my overall first equal best picture of Lisbon, it is my screenshot, Billy swapping pennants with the Inter captain Armando Picchi.
Look at the faces of Armando and the three officials, the German referee, they show admiration and respect, bordering on hero worship. That sums up Billy McNeill – the character of a born, natural leader. He took his responsibilities very seriously and had a very positive mindset, as a center-half he was the very best, with John Clark covering the back, it allowed Billy to run forward and attack the ball, what a leap, such strength, such leadership, Billy had it all.
Billy MacNeill – Celtic captain – Player – Manager – Leader – Legend. Always In Our Thoughts.

But one thing is certain, he was Cesar, not the name that some are trying to push today, he I’m told never liked that, no, he had one of the first cars in the group, he was the – getaway driver. CESAR.

As a thank you for putting up the picture yesterday, here is a letter from Billy to a friend, pretty much self explanatory, but, basically telling the friend Jocks thoughts on how much playing for Celtic means and how it makes the Celtic players try that little bit harder.
Thank You.

IMG_3997
Bawheid
September 17, 2024 8:25 am

3x H. Yes, absolute dafties. I wonder how their AGM figures will turn out?

Jobo Baldie
September 17, 2024 8:42 am

Good morning, friends.
The headline financial details that were released yesterday was simply that – the full accounts have been prepared and here are the main entries. The fully detailed accounts which normally run to dozens of pages will usually be available over the coming weeks. Celtic aren’t trying to hide anything here and are no different to any other plc in terms of what they are obliged to disclose publicly. So there should be more detailed breakdown of both turnover and operating expenses, etc in the weeks ahead.

big packy
September 17, 2024 8:55 am

BILLYBHOY just saw your post from last night, yes terrible tragedy that affected many families, the weird thing was my grandfather was due to retire a few months later ,H.H.

SteveNaive
September 17, 2024 9:01 am

Bobby,

Top 10 Adidas sales, shirts or in general ?

Madmitch
September 17, 2024 10:03 am

BMCUW

Hertz game was very low energy both on the field and in the stands.
Hobbled both ways — NT guys were jaded / non NT guys were in 5’s mode with flicks and tricks.
The midfield is still not settled with CMcG in full “Peter the Pointer” mode.
New bloke looks like a real find — bit raw but huge potential.

Lots of interesting stuff bubbling up to the surface.
SPFL VAR is now making refereeing a tag team operation.
Hints that this has always been the way since the 4th official was mic’ed up.

Then it was amateur VAR using SKY replays.
Now it is constant chat and detailed re-runs.
WC out front is making it entertaining.

VAR and slanted lines — Big Auto “Diesel-gate” vibe looms large.
Different VAR instances depending on who is attacking rather than different engine maps.
Just a thought — Ludge VAR / MIB is now working all the angles.

Their desperation is almost heroic given the situation Govan FC find themselves in.

Interesting stuff 2 — our finances tell quite a few stories.
Operating expenses up 10% — BR is on a lot more than AP.
I hope we didn’t spend too much on agents fees to bring in all last season’s punts and projects.
Loans fees might be another area to look at — PB is good / AI was desperation.
Plus wage rate jostling.

Tomorrow is huge — another performance like Saturday and we will be CL toast.
Hertz were honking — the three monkeys and a tablet act is this season’s SPFL failure trope.

Frodshambhoy
September 17, 2024 10:05 am

Talking of empty seats. We’ve had them for years by not allowing season ticket seats to be recycled when the holders can’t attend. I’ve moaned about that loads of times when I was told a game was sold out then noticed the attendance was only around 59,000.
I believe the club has introduced a system this year to allow the seats to be sold. Be interesting to see the attendance figures and turnover going forward.

Just Sayin’
September 17, 2024 10:09 am

Revenue on an upwards trajectory, likely to approach £150m in this financial year depending on CL and continued domestic success.

Investment in the true sense of the word, not the Ibrox version, in infrastructure and the playing squad.

Plus a huge cash surplus.

It is only a damp squib to those who do not have a transfer window to moan about, and seek gloom where there isn’t any.

The target now is progress, consistency and consolidation in Europe. Growth will happen organically.

The key take away is this moment is the realisation that old certainties are being replaced with new drivers.

Spare a thought for those left in our wake- the likelihood there of revenues actually decreasing from a high water mark of £84m. My guess is Bennett ( and Bisgrove) knew winter is coming and decided to decant rather than be authors of distressing news.
No CL or Bassey type sales in ‘23/‘24 to underpin a fundamentally weak balance sheet. What limited funds they have diverted to costly court battles, mismanaged “investment “ projects, poor player sales etc should see revenues heading down to £70m or below.

Effectively half a Celtic. Their pain is palpable.

Domestic hegemony guaranteed, the aim now is to leave a mark on the CL.

McCaff
September 17, 2024 10:13 am

Frodshambhoy…from what I gather the adjustments have been made to the IT systems to enable the swap/sale/transfer of tickets on a game by game basis but as yet is not active. So, unless it comes online soon it is unlikely to make a significant difference to attendances or income!

Madmitch
September 17, 2024 10:14 am

Hertz penalty that never was — the MIB delay in pointing to the spot is very suspicious.
The audio will be interesting if we ever get to hear it.
Suggestions that it was a “collegiate” decision.

Crowd numbers — we can sell out our allocation.
The empty seats on show don’t hurt the club — they have been paid for.

The away support may not sell out their allocation.
One thing from last season — there were games when we didn’t sell out.
Big change from the AP years where it became the norm to sell out our allocation.

Last season we lost that vibe and its loss is reflected in our stadium revenue number.
Not a good look to see it fall in this time of high inflation.

Points to the lack of exec level nous // energy / business brains.
Low energy / low ability / low ambition — we have it in spades.

Madmitch
September 17, 2024 10:17 am

Season ticket re-sales …

40% credit to the SB owner / 40% donation to the foundation / 20% admin fee to the club.

Not rocket science — as in a lot of things we are just behind the curve.

Madmitch
September 17, 2024 10:23 am

Unforeseen contract termination / non player — £66K expense?
I wonder who that was for?

One or two individuals vs 3 or 6 months notice?
Very low rent if scouting was part of their remit.

SteveNaive
September 17, 2024 10:33 am
  1. Barcelona (Nike) – €179m
  2. Real Madrid (Adidas) – €155m
  3. Bayern Munich (Adidas) – €147m
  4. Liverpool (Nike) – €132m
  5. Manchester United (Adidas) – €130m
  6. Paris Saint-Germain (Nike) – €97m
  7. Arsenal (Adidas) – €89m
  8. Chelsea (Nike) – €87m
  9. Juventus (Adidas) – €74m
  10. Tottenham (Nike) – €74m
  11. Manchester City (Puma) – €73m
  12. Borussia Dortmund (Puma) – €54m
  13. AC Milan (Puma) – €47m
  14. Ajax (Adidas) – €41m
  15. Galatasaray (Nike) – €35m
  16. Leeds United (Adidas) – €35m
  17. Celtic (Adidas) – €34m
  18. Fenerbahce (Puma) – €31m
  19. Eintracht Frankfurt (Nike) – €26m
  20. Inter Milan (Nike) – €26m

See what you mean now.
Coatbridge generates that alone !
Behind Leeds ?

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
September 17, 2024 10:33 am

STEVENAIVE 901

Jersey sales,mate. A table detailing adidas-wearing clubs was released earlier this year.

SteveNaive
September 17, 2024 10:41 am
BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
September 17, 2024 10:44 am

Strange question-do you know the difference between green and blue?

https://ismy.blue/

Auldheid
September 17, 2024 11:28 am

Jobo

Correct on a full set of accounts being sent to shareholders as part of AGM papers as well as being published.

What I will be looking for is how much detail is provided on player costs and football earnings.

That detail will be required to establish if ratio is within the 70% ceiling under FSR which says that licence applications must align with the accounts.

I don’t see how the ratio check can be completed without the detail.

Madmitch
September 17, 2024 12:33 pm

SN @ 10.33

Interesting numbers on corporate football clothing revenues in Europe.
What year is it for the figures — will make a difference.
Plus these are corporate not retail numbers?

Nike — 8 teams.
Adidas — 8 teams and we are 8th …
Puma — 4 teams.

Bit of a way to go — CL progress will help plus some eye catching designs.
Being behind Ajax and LU plus less than half of Spurs …
Not a good look.

One angle to work on — current tops vs retro tops / knock off at the Hertz game.
I think we are quite big on retro tops — LU doesn’t have a EC winner top to worry about.

No matter PL needs to get huis erse into gear and fire up his apprentices.
DD will be having a nap before his next round of golf.

SteveNaive
September 17, 2024 1:34 pm

MM

From UEFA annual report on revenue from kit sales.
22/23.
Leeds Utd the first club to do this (sell replicas ) after a chance meeting between an Admiral salesman and Don Revie.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
September 17, 2024 1:37 pm

JOBO,AULDHEID

I’m aware that the release yesterday is not the same as the annual report to shareholders. But the point still stands that there is insufficient transparency in either of these in terms of breaking down our expenditure.

Presumably,the club see no legal requirement to provide this,and I don’t think they ever have. The only breakdown required of them,in their eyes,is to provide the figures demanded by UEFA to meet FSR requirements. I’ll look forward to seeing them sometime in the future.

ASWGL
September 17, 2024 1:42 pm

Bawheid that is indeed a cracking picture of Billy, I too noticed the Inter Cptn and officials looking at Billy as if almost in awe. One other thing I noticed is that Billy’s boots look to have 3 painted white lines as opposed to Picchi’s almost pristine Adidas boots.

It wouldn’t surprise me in the least if the Kelly and Whites never splashed out for Adidas and got the Bhoys some cheap Woolworth jobs and a pot of white paint. 😜

As a few have said, your collection is great to see bit by bit 👍

ASWGL
September 17, 2024 2:00 pm

Bobby good leader

Record turnover, big profit, our biggest rivals died leaving us years and years of the richest competition in football, fuxake it would have been harder to fail, than to turn a profit.

The cash is there because of our fantastic fans pouring cash in, a 60,000 seated stadium, that’s on the bunnet, not any of these charlatans.

A stadium in need of upgrading, a shoddy DIY Celtic TV, but they expect us to believe we are were we are because of some great financial strategy of the current board.

ChancersCSC

AweNaw
September 17, 2024 3:24 pm
Big packy😉😉
September 17, 2024 3:30 pm

What’s all this Celtic nonsense ok they won the European cup in 1967 with eleven players born within 30 miles of parkhead and got to another final in 1970 that’s nothing my team Albion rovers beat gala fairydean 5-0 in the Scottish cup once aye Clifton hill was a fortress another true story 👍 😭

Sol Kitts
September 17, 2024 3:35 pm

ASWGL
Billy wore Puma boots and the reason for painting the stripes was…..(from the Glasgow Celtic Supporters page on Facebook).

“Adidas were paying Celtic players 30 quid to wear the brand, so the Puma logo was polished out and white Adidas stripes were painted on. You gotta’ love that!

Don’t judge a book by its cover. Billy helped write the most unlikely story European football has ever told.”

IMG_2939
Craig 76
September 17, 2024 3:43 pm

Levein given the boot

Bada Bing
September 17, 2024 3:51 pm

Levein bagged

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
September 17, 2024 3:59 pm

CRAIG76,BADABING

No great loss. Dunno how he survived in the game this long,he did nothing to deserve it.

Auldheid
September 17, 2024 4:04 pm

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS

 September 17, 2024 1:37 pm
JOBO,AULDHEID

===
In days of yore I used to examine the accounts to try and get a handle on player wage bill but the figure shown was for total employees so whatever devil was in the detail remained out of sight.

It was when reading FSR I wondered how the necessary detail to carry out the calculation would be provided.

It was at that point I found the linkage to accounts mentioned in FSR.
I’ll copy what it says later when back at my laptop.
I suppose if every club has to do it then the commercial in confidence reason why the info was buried in the past no longer holds to same degree.

Like you I suspect I wondered how Celtic and our rivals would get by with minimum degree of compliance.

Auldheid
September 17, 2024 4:07 pm

Bada Bing

Levein bagged.
===
Dead man walking for a while.
I saw nothing inspirational in his interviews. I doubt the players did.

Bawheid
September 17, 2024 4:16 pm

ASWGL. – The picture of Billy was taken off the internet, printed on photographic paper, enlarged and cut to size. I have hundreds of pictures, from the early years up to the seventies, the real treasures are hanging on the walls, I will never sell them. Every morning I wake up and see my hero’s, it gives you the best feeling watching them come thru from the dusk and into the light.
But collecting need not be hugely expensive, these are my Celtic scarves but one, the one that I always wore to the games I think my brother made off with, bottle green with shamrocks, white tassels and white badge surround, I wore that scarf with pride, been searching forever to get one but no luck ….so far.
The one scarf in the middle is an Inter scarf, or more appropriately a wall hanger, bought it on the internet for £6.00 delivered. So collecting if you have the time need not be too expensive.

Sol Kits is correct, re Billy’s boots, ain’t it ridiculous how these Celtic players virtually had to beg to
get a living for their talents and success, shame on them.
I have a programme about Bob Kelly, no guesses where that hangs.

Thanks again M8. Ich Hoffe, die Fiische beifen. 😉

IMG_4004
A thing of beauty
September 17, 2024 4:46 pm

Levein sacked. Two words as synonymous as pie and beans yet he still gets a job in Scotland. Completely sums up the lack of modern thinking in our game.

Bada Bing
September 17, 2024 4:49 pm

Levein, like Billy Dodds,as soon as they’ve bagged,straight back to Radio Scotland on our coin

Leggy
September 17, 2024 4:50 pm

Iniquitous 1V,

6 Champions League games, plus EFL Cup.

You’re going to need a bigger Multi Screen TV 😁😁😁😁😁

Enjoy and keep up the good work 👋👋👋

Mike in Toronto
September 17, 2024 5:33 pm

With all the work Inq does reporting on various games on here, I would think that profits from the next pool could be used to buy him a bigger TV like this one…115″ inch!

Mike in Toronto
September 17, 2024 5:33 pm

although we then might need to have another whip around to buy him a bigger house for his new TV!

Bada Bing
September 17, 2024 5:54 pm

Aston Villa game on TNT

Leggy
September 17, 2024 5:59 pm

I assume because Celtic play both these teams, a draw is the result which would best suit us ???

NotascoobyCSC 🍀🍀🍀

SeS
September 17, 2024 6:03 pm

Leggy – I’d agree a draw suits us .. I’ve taken Young B for the win tonight on my 15 tho’ …

already a few scrapes for Emery …

INIQUITOUS IV
September 17, 2024 6:08 pm

Juve 1 PSV 0

Leggy
September 17, 2024 6:11 pm

The Villa right back, Humphrey is getting skinned quite a lot 😁😁

INIQUITOUS IV
September 17, 2024 6:14 pm

LEGGY, MIKE IN TORONTO

Appreciate the comments, lads!🤣
Dealing with a few technical problems at the moment. The Paramount App has stopped working on the TV and IPad, and I am getting no sound on the laptop. I’m toggling back and forth between Villa and Juve, but more focused on the former, as it is 2 direct opponents.

The sound issue is the one that’s most frustrating. The loudspeaker icon is crossed out on both the control bar and in settings, but wont toggle on.

Villa 1-0 up.

INIQUITOUS IV
September 17, 2024 6:15 pm

A rehearsed set piece move from a corner.

SeS
September 17, 2024 6:15 pm

Great goal Villa – kept on down

16 roads
September 17, 2024 6:16 pm

Kenny ‘Mental’ Miller is back, today.

King yesterday,Souness the day previous.

Like a merry-go-round it is.

Why I am reading them?

Because they are constantly referencing Celtic, and by consequence appear on my newsfeed.

Only read the headlines which is enough for anyone.

Baloney…nonsensical tripe.

HH.🍀

INIQUITOUS IV
September 17, 2024 6:16 pm

Juve 2-0 up on PSV.

1 2 3 … 5