Yes We Can!
Morning,all.
One of the most famous sights in world football is also one of its most famous sites. The Yellow Wall at Signal Iduna Park,or Stadion Dortmund as it is also known. Or Westfalenstadion. And Big Packy thought we had problems with Parkhead and Celtic Park! The stadium boasts a phenomenal 81,000 capacity,over 25,000 of them in one end of the ground,and the fans wearing the team’s distinctive colours gives rise to the nickname.
It is not only a famous sight,it is also a fearsome sound,as you might imagine. Tonight it is down to our club,our players,to silence them. Knock the exuberance right out of them. Dismantle that wall one brick at a time as the members there depart the scene early. It can be done,they are not invincible at home. And Celtic were known the world over at one time for being no respecter of reputations,taking on one and all on their own patch and giving them a bloody nose. Sadly,as we know,that was a long time ago.
Even Martin O’Neill struggled to make any impact in away matches at this level. He did famously beat Ajax over in Amsterdam at the beginning of his reign,but that was in a qualifier. And our other big scalps on our travels in his time,such as Liverpool and Souness’ Blackburn,were in the UEFA Cup. We haven’t won away from home against one of the big boys for so long now that we are overdue a famous night. Will it be tonight? Well,time will tell.
If domestic form heading into a big European match counts for anything,we are as well prepared as we possibly could be. Twenty goals scored in six league matches,with a record-equalling six clean sheets in those matches as we hold onto our 100% record start. The winning start to the season isn’t just in the league. We have progressed to the semi-finals of the league cup,winning our two ties by an aggregate 8-3,as well as dispatching Slovan Bratislava in our first Champions League fixture by a thrilling 5-1. While I place absolutely no store whatsoever in pre-season friendlies,we even won our three matches on our tour of the US by a whopping 12-4,and that included matches against City and Chelsea!
In short,we have barely put a foot wrong this season (first half against Falkirk apart.) We are as well prepared as we possibly could be going into this match-which is just as well,for we shouldn’t forget that Dortmund were the unlucky losers in last season’s final. There isn’t much doubt that our fixture list for this revamped version of the tournament could be tougher,but it includes ties against last season’s runner-up as well as Atalanta,the winners of the Europa League and the only side to beat Bayer Leverkusen in the entire campaign! Both are away from home this month. Another away day beckons in Birmingham,against Aston Villa. And we also have a home tie against RB Leipzig,perennial qualifiers from the Bundesliga. Easy group,my backside.
Saturday gave us a nice lead into the tie as we annihilated a very poor St Johnstone side 6-0. It could have been a few more too,as has been the case so often this season. In a game where we had no poor performers on the day,Auston Trusty made his first start in the league,and in an unfamiliar place as the right-sided centre back. I suspect that we will see a lot more of him in that position this season. Our regular starter there for over three years now has been CCV. Solid and reliable,a force in the air and on the surface,but struggling with a toe injury which could be a major problem for him. It sounds such an innocuous and minor issue,but it is often far from that. Most of us will remember Gary Lineker as an outstanding striker for club and country,but his career was curtailed by just such an injury. And closer to home,we have lost three players who were at the absolute top of their game when they succumbed. Stevie Murray,Pat Stanton and Marc Rieper should all have had a lot more time with us,but no. I hope the medical staff are totally focused on this,and I expect the manager to give the player as much time as is necessary to fully recover.
So,Auston Trusty it is. Along with Liam Scales,of course. Liam must have to pinch himself at times,just to make sure that he isn’t dreaming. He has certainly come a long way in the last year,but it has to be remembered that he has used that year to make the left-sided CB role his own. In fact,tonight is match number 67 for Liam,so I hope it is a very special one for him! He is there on merit,and his new four year contract reflects that. I expect these two to line up alongside Johnston and Taylor in the defence.
Up front,it is difficult to see past a three of Kühn,Kyogo and Maeda. I’m fairly certain that Dortmund manager Nuri Sahin,a former Liverpool player under BR,will have shown his players a number of clips of our front three in action. Betcha they thought that the clips had all been speeded up! If they get the service they have become used to this season,they will happily knock any complacency out of their opponents. Kyogo looked as sharp as ever on Saturday,his best performance of the season arriving at a very opportune moment. Kühn provided another two assists. And I wouldn’t even know where to start if I was to describe Maeda on the day. Or any day,really. Except that he is fast becoming unplayable,a real handful for defenders-and not just the poor sod allocated directly against him.
And then we come to the midfield. For all of our excellence up front,it is in midfield that our stars truly align. Who would have thought that little over a month since we bade farewell to probably our best (imported) midfielder since Joe Ledley that we would give so little thought to Matt O’Riley? (Get well soon,Matt.) Not me,that’s for sure. But Arne Engels has already shown that he has everything in his locker,and Paolo Bernardo is matching him stride for stride. Luke McCowan would get a game virtually anywhere else,Reo is still an outstanding talent-and CalMac just gets better and better. And with four goals to his name already this season,he seems to have dispensed with the safety first and always approach which has so often frustrated over the last few years.
Our manager has the enviable task of selecting any three from five in the middle,and he has the luxury of knowing that he can call on the other two-plus Odin Holm-if and when required. Which all means that he can set the mids out in an offensive or defensive formation,and even change that about as the game progresses.
In short,we have the players to do us proud tonight. Too often we have made a complete pigs ear of it on our travels,particularly (but not only) against the bigger sides. But rarely have we had it in our locker to do the opposition any damage,and that has meant a frantic rearguard action as we try in vain to keep a clean sheet. It isn’t easy playing the big boys at this level,and it has been made more difficult over the years knowing that we have so little bite up front. But there are goals in this side,and they can come from all over the pitch too.
Dortmund can be forgiven for being over-confident heading into tonight’s match. They only need to look at our record in this tournament,particularly away from home,to gain encouragement. If that isn’t enough,the 5/1 widely available on our chances shouts it from the rooftops. Celtic are not expected to take anything from tonight,at least not by the cognoscenti. Quite possibly,even most of our fans feel the same way. After all,we are a knowledgeable bunch. Indeed,I too would normally be anticipating tonight with trepidation,ready to bolt behind the settee at any given moment. But right now,I genuinely think that there is enough in this side to get a goal or two tonight. And that gives me more than just a forlorn hope.
For once,away to a top European side,I think we can do this. And I might even put a quid or two on it.
<><><><><>
Above article by BMCUWP
JOBO POTY Competition.
sencelpoty@gmail.com
Emdy fancy a great night out? Just got this from a good friend,Frank,who many of you will already know either in person or as VFR.
Not sure if you know, but my wife Jacky came out of retirement a couple of years ago to run St Margaret’s adoption agency, the only Catholic adoption agency left in the UK. She now has it back on its feet after some significant issues.
I have been roped in as an Ambassador for the charity and one area I am looking at is fundraising. My big ticket item at the moment is a dinner dance we are running in the Kerrydale Suite on Friday 22nd November at 7:30. This is the first of what we intend to be an annual event to coincide with the Feast Day of St Margaret of Scotland, our Patron Saint (November 16th).
So as you can imagine, I have the begging bowl out! I am contacting like-minded people to see if they are willing to take a table for the event (or just some tickets). Individual tickets are £50 with the tables at £500. We are also looking for sponsorship for the event, ranging from £5k for the event sponsor down to advertising in the programme and on-screen on the night – ranging from £250 to £1000 depending on size and placement/regularity of the ads.
There will be a raffle and charity auction on the night, so we are looking for prizes and auction items for both of those. We may also look at naming tables and allowing some advertising on tables if there is an appetite for that.
So far we are on to our 3rd table for the troops.
As you will all know,the site finally nominated a charity to be the recipient of the generosity and largesse of yourselves,and I think you all deserve huge applause for raising just short of £2k.
⭐️👏☘️👍🍾
That period has passed,and a new charity has been chosen to take us through to the end of the year. A landslide vote in favour of
Lanarkshire Cancer Care Trust.
Once again,CHALMERSBHOY has done the spadework via JustGiving.
Here is the link for the Lanarkshire Cancer Care Trust,our new charity which we will support.
https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinel-celts-1722588284471?utm_medium=fundraising&utm_content=page%2Fsentinel-celts-1722588284471&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=pfp-share
This drive has already raised well over £1000,so join in. The more,the merrier.
Default payment method seems to be ApplePay,which won’t suit everyone. There is an option on the page to change that to your preferred means.
A positive take on this evening which I generally endorse.
Dortmund have played 5 league games, won three, drawn one, lost one( badly).
However, they sit fifth on 10 points with 11 goals scored and 9 against. Ahead of the team who inflicted the 5-1 hammering.
A very strong league, with competition we can only dream about.
For all their mixed start they are only three points behind Bayern Munich.
This is a huge test.
A formidable opponent. A point would be a significant achievement, a win a magnificent one. A defeat, whilst unwelcome, isn’t unlikely.
As long as we collectively put in a performance every one of the 16 who potentially play can be proud of, we can come away feeling we are on track to contribute positively to this league.
We will still have 6 games remaining to make our mark.
One criticism- you should be aware that Odin Holm was not included in the Euro squad. The home based/ overseas quota was discussed a lot at the time.
A strange oversight on your part
This evening will be a huge learning curve.
Too many disappointing Euro nights to have high expectations.
our positional play without ball is key.
Good morning, friends and a Big Happy European Matchday to all who post or lurk on this fine site.
I’ll try to keep my European League Table updates coming this week and hopefully, like Celtic, there wont be any unforced errors!
Tonight in many ways is a free hit. A game when the draw was made most of us would have discounted as one we woukd be looking to for points.
But the way we are playing….
I think the most likely is we will play well, lose but still take positives from the game. We don’t want another doing or the bubble might just burst. On the other hand if we got anything from the game away from home against last seasons finalists then it’s a real game changer for this team….
MOTM Kaspar Schmeichel
Apologies if already posted
This from a German football guy. How others see us and pretty much spot on.
https://medium.com/@business.adamkhan/celtic-fc-tactical-profile-03f3dc626c38
First of all we need to take our chances as they arise , so can’t afford to miss 3/4 before scoring 1 , as we tend to do in league games.
Also need to be better when we lose possession.
I would be delighted with a draw.
Morning all! I had a busy day yesterday but was popping in and out for a wee read when I could. Mike’s comments, with other posters, about the 442 had me thinking and almost posting a reply but I didn’t find time and the moment was lost. 3H’s post from the German guy studying our tactics reminded me of Mike’s post. My reply was gonna be along the lines that Celtic DO use 442 when they are out of possession. Maeda especially is excellent at dropping in to the defensive set up but to his credit Kuhn is also becoming much more aware and now seems more prepared to work these areas when he needs to. As is common with most top Leagues these days, as well as at international level, 433 is the preferred attacking option if the right guys are in the right places when required. Domestically we are excellent at this system, it allows us space and flexibility to move the ball about. Our problems arise when we don’t fill the spaces and are too static, this is what Fan refers to all the time when he bemoans our positioning. Tonight will hopefully show us how far we’ve come in a year..
JUSTSAYIN
Damn,forgot about that. Thanks for the reminder.
3H…superb article, extremely interesting read, cheers for that! 👍
Drew 67
Can I have your selections for beat the bookie before 5pm please.
I cannot see Brendan changing his system in any (shape or form). The Celtic players/squad play one system, they know it and use it in training and on the pitch weekly. The system that Brendan uses gives the players flexibility, a freedom of movement that they can adapt to changing circumstances on the pitch. I’m ignorant about the Dortmund players, my concern is that they are big players physically but with pace and technique, we need to be strong to match that.
Another thing that I will be interested to see is Trusty in defence, does he give us more pace to cover the rear? a shortcoming of CCV when faced with fast paced attackers? Interesting.
Was looking at the last in the series about big Jock, rekindling the anger in me as to how he was treated and what he was offered, what a bunch of sleekit, cravenous, jealous, cretins.
Footballs filled with them, thinking of Petrie of the Hibees he reminded me of a bucket of pigs swill,
Regan and the many others who brought shame to the beautiful game.
Saatchi @ Saatchi had less advertisement’s than Celtic News, its a race to the bottom with blogs filled with every kind of mince, mince yum,yum – spaghetti Bolognese! Splendido.
COYBIG.
BAWHEID
MAHE and I vowed from the start that the site will always be ad-free. And despite offers,we’ve stuck to that principle.
It offers us,as authors of the articles,a huge advantage. We can say what we damn well please! (Even when it’s wrong,like my suggestion of Holm on the bench tonight…)
I’ve got a good feeling. No more than that, no reason other than I think BR has improved us massively and, more importantly, our mindset is improving.
Chalmersbhoy
Blackpool
Sunderland
West Brom
Cheers👍
Bawheid
with so many free ad blockers out there I am surprised it is still an issue for folk. I use Adblock pro on my iPhone from the app store and never see an ad on any blog I read
Bawheid
To avoid ads there is a browser (like Google Chrome or Microsoft Edge) called Brave.
It can be downloaded as an app (try Google search) and installed on you phone or laptop.
It let’s you search for a site eg Celtic Quick News or Celtic Blog and provides a link to open the found site.
No ads. Works a treat.
Clumpany put me on to it.
https://youtu.be/u5yOvkHLTNs?feature=shared
again apologies if already posted.
But wow! Phil Mac is gonna have a field day with this one. And it was gilligan that allegedly upset Dermot in the directors box thon time.
Bobby – Principle is a great testament to peoples character and you both have that in abundance, so well done to the pair of you for sticking to your principles.
Hoop Hoop Hooray. Its no suprise to this Internet bampot, I thought that Adblocker was a suntan cream, not that there’s any sun in my neck of the woods, thanks will give it a go, number by number.
Auldheid – You lost me at browser. 😉
Confidence is a powerful friend and our confidence is HIGH, we need to give our all and with a bit of luck and three Hail Hail Mary’s, the Bhoys will be celebrating big time.
Lads ( and ATOB )
This is hilarious! Had to watch it to the end. Laughed my head off. 🤣😂😅
Aff oot. Headed for airport soon.
HH
Iniquitous IV😊
https://youtu.be/ieFGf5V8564
McCaff
in the NHL hockey, they give out end of year trophies. Player of the year, goalie of the year… that sort of thing. One of the trophies is called the Frank Selke Trophy …which is for the forward with the best defensive skills. If there was such a trophy in Scottish football, DM would win it every season. Not only for his pressing, but also for his work tracking runners. Kyogo has recently shown similar traits in tracking back … although, unlike the wingers who do need to be bombing up and down the wings, I don’t want the centre forward to be dropping quite as deep or as often
so agree the wingers (sorry for the old fashioned jargon, but you know what/who I mean) do a great job defending (particularly, but not exclusively, from the front by pressing), but I still don’t think that gives the same solidity as a 4 man mid. And really most games Celtic are on the attack- at least this season – but that won’t always be the case (possibly starting today), so would like to see a true 442 tried sometimes. Something to be able to call upon when and if needed
but I get it is hard to try a more defensive system in the SPL when you have 80% possession. And you don’t wanting to be trying a new system for the first time inBerhamo. Not sure I have the answer to to that … but then again I’m not the footballing genius that BR is, nor do I get his wages! So I’m sure he can come up with a solution
Same team as Saturday
Hey Mike, cheers for the reply. 442 as an attacking formation is not favoured by many teams these days. The 433 offers more flexibility quicker, I reckon. The article from 3H posted earlier gives a clear insight into how Brendan utilises and can quickly adapt the 433. It might be worth reading, then you and the rest of the 442 dinosaurs might be up to speed!! 😉🤣🤣🤣
This ref has given 68 cards in his last 10 games
Looks like same starting XI as Saturday for tonight.
Great appetizer for the main event Bobby 👍
Your analysis of our midfield options got me thinking back to the mid 80s – my favourite period as a Celtic fan. We played 4-4-2 and had a midfield of:
Tommy Burns – Murdo – Paul McStay – Davie Provan
What a time to be alive!
I don’t think we’ve ever bettered that for quality but we might just be shaping up to perhaps equalling it.
I suspect that this game might be coming just too soon for us – especially with the news that CCV is unavailable. I’d have preferred away games to Zagreb and Atalanta before this one.
So, we may have to settle for a 2-2 here! 😉
BILLYBHOY
Aye,thinking about it,maybe we will just have to settle for a draw.
Second thoughts,naw. Quit with the negative waves!
INIQUITOUS IV
Have an enjoyable journey,and a marvellous trip.
HH
McCaff
All joking aside, Celtic have played 4 33, or some variant of it, for the last few years (as have half the teams in Europe). But, the problem is that it puts a lot of pressure on the mid 3, and particulary the middle/deepest of the 3, and that has been Celtic’s key weaknesses when playing a better level of opposition.
It requires a lotof the midfield players, including both setting up attacks and providing cover for the defence. It requires most of the player who is tasked as being the deeper lying of the midfield three, which more often than not has been Calmac.
Celtic’s midfield has been overrun in way too many European games. As I said, these last few years, Calmac has often been the deepest lying mid, and he was and is simply not suited for that role. YOu can get away with that in the SPubL, not not in Europe. The end result in too many european games is that the midfield got by passed going forward, and run through like they were invisible when defending. Again, you cant criticize Calmac for doing a job he was asked to do, but he was never up to that role. He is an attacking mid, and a good (not great) one. Nothing less but nothing more. Asking him to do more is and has been unfair to him.
However, in Bernardo and Engels, Celtic seem to finally have two qualify mids who, from what I have seen, are both more well rounded, and capable defensively. I can see Bernardo adding a bit of steel, as well as playing a deeper playmaker role when Cetic have the ball. Engels I see as a bit more all round (but, again, need to see more of him), and Calmac as most effective going forward. If played correctly, Calmac could go a long way to making up some of the goals from midfiled that were lost when MO’R left.
Personally, I though Holm added some needed bite to the team. But I have heard different stories as to why he hasn’t broken through, but am not sure what the real story is there.
Liverpool under Klopp, who preferred the 433, were one of the best and most fun teams ever to watch. But when you have a front 3 of Mane, Firmino and Salah… what else do I need to say? Skill and phenomenal work rate. Goals from Mane and Salah got most of the attention, but the workrare and teamwork of Firmino in the middle was sometimes overlooked, but spectacular… and when added to his Brazilian skill… wow!
and of course, behind Firmino, you had Fabinho… who faded due to injuries, but at the time, was arguable the best mid anchor in the world (a Rodri before Rodri)… and of course, behind Fabinho, you had Van Diik at the top of his game, and behind him Allison…. not too many teams in history have had a spine as solid as that. So, teams like that, particularly with a spine like that, make 433 look easy… but they have the talent that can play that way.
Other good teams, PSG for example, usually preferred the 4231 as it provided the double axis – two solid guys in the middle providing cover for the defence while the 3-1 bombed forward. But, that is not an easy system, as it requires not only two really strong mids, but also four top forwards who create a lot of their own chances. Fine for PSG against Celtic, but for the lesser teams like Celtic, I think it is safety first, and I think the older 442 provides that when playing against more talented opposition. and I think that, at long last, Celtic have the guys to play that system effectively.
so maybe 433 for SPL, but 442 for Europe… the problem, as i said, is how do you prepare for Europe when playing a different game in Scotland?
U19s getting beat 3-0
Mike, I hate to say it but you’re right…to a degree! But, and you knew there was a but coming, the 433 is more flexible and Brendan has used it to our advantage – so far. The way we’ve played this season, including the preseason games, has shown me two things. The first is that Brendan has tried to ditch the pointless horizontal possession game in favour of a more penetrative, faster, direct style here’s the thing…it actually suits our players. And the second thing is that Brendan has been stubborn in choosing the players that he wants and knows will give him what he’s looking for.
Add all that into the mix of a fluent, flexible system and we’re so far reaping the benefits.
So, with all due respect, and I know you won’t take this the wrong way, results thus far have shown that a 433 for these players has worked a treat. As I said earlier today tonight is the toughest test we will have faced so we’ll see how far we’ve come but more importantly, how far we have to go!
McCaff
of course there’s always a but …. if there wasn’t, I wouldnt be in my office, watching the game on my laptop …I’d be on the bench coaching ! But, I”m not…
And I hope you dont take offence either, but I agree with much of what you said … no one can complain about results or performances so far.. including the Bratislava game…. but we have seen in the past years with Celtic, what works in Scotland doesn’t necessarily work in Europe, or with the zombies (who were the opposite), so, once Celtic have a sustained period of competitiveness, I will happily concede that BR’s system is working, and will even buy you a BP Cyber pint!
but, if Im honest, I’m still concerned that 2 key weaknesses haven’t been addressed … GT at lb (I’ve lost count of the number of Euro games where GT drops inside and teams attack that empty space), and Calmac as deep lying … if/once those two issues are addressed, I would feel much more confident going forward.
having said that, Celtic in Europe under AP was the best I have seen since MO’N… maybe not as successful as some of GS’ teams, but they played scared/not to lose… AP’s teams took more risks, but to me, it looked AP had the team believeing that they belonged there, even if they didnt necessarily win every game …
I am getting a similar feeling this season with BR’s team … Europe is admittedly a small sample, but the players seem to be enjoying themselves, and at least for Bratislava, seemed not only not intimidated, but genuinely enjoying being there …. that self belief can be huge!
I hate to say this, because I said the same for Hibs on the weekend, and jinxed them… so I hope I dont jinx Celtic, but have a sneaky suspicion that it could be a draw today.
World War 3 incoming,Iran bombing Israel
BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
INIQUITOUS IV
Have an enjoyable journey,and a marvellous trip.
HH
————————-
Thanks Bobby! Just took a quick peek at scores on my phone. Here’s an oddity – Ex-Sevco Sima scores 2nd goal in 2 weeks against 2nd Austrian team in Champions League.
HH
Iniquitous IV😊
Bada
That is terrifying. I know these guys have been fighting as long as I have been alive, but the capacity to kill is so much greater these days, and the respect for life seems so much less.
And, of course, even if somehow manage to avoid blowing each other to shit, the price of gas will double this weekend, and, like Covid pricing, once it goes up, wont come back down. The average person will pay for the sins of the madmen running the countries.
Mike…we’ve no reference point for how we’ll fare tonight other than previous efforts. It goes without saying that we’ve been miserable in Europe at times, even under Ange results were poor although the swashbuckling performances are exciting. What seems to have set this team apart so far is their play is much more controlled (yes, we still have weaknesses) and as has been mentioned already even the preseason performances against Chelsea and City left us wondering if it was due to their deficiences/selections, I’d suggest that our displays since then have shown that we are looking a bit different these days – stronger physically and mentally, much more focussed and confident in what’s been asked of them and how to get it.
Repeating myself here but let’s see how tonight goes, we’ll have a better idea at 10 o’clock how good or otherwise we are!!
McCaff
agree. lets see how today goes. and, after reading Bada’s post, a game of football doens’t seem so important.
Netan-Yahoo is now looking like a bigger cunt than Putin! We are on the brink! What happens next is anyone’s guess but let’s hope it doesn’t realise our biggest fears. 🙏🙏🙏
McCaff
October 1, 2024 6:41 pm
As I was just about to say.
BR seems now to have moved the players beyond the limitations of Angeball. The current style is much more grown up. And effective at this level. Lets hope this is just the start.
Mike in Toronto
October 1, 2024 6:30 pm
The Israelis are doing what the US government want them to do, but cannot publicly say they want them to do. Not in an election year.
Biden is a hard line Zionist zealot, and it shows.
Jimmy Carter is 100 today. A decent and humane man. This wouldn’t have happened on his watch.
Teams up . Bernardo starts. Hatate benched. Same team as weekend.
Teams up
COYBIG! 🍀
What we totally lack away in Europe, is composure on the ball,has to be better next 2 away games
Ernie
Carter seemed like a decent person. Probably too decent for that job. Much like the Canadian prime minister during some of Carter’s presidency. Joe Clarke. Got to know him a bit later, and while I would never have voted for his party, he struck me as a decent human being. Probably the last Tory politician I can think of that I would say that about. And along with his spectacular miscalculation in calling the 1980 election, his decency was probably why he only lasted less than a year in the job!
In the Irvine CSC with Paddy’s Maw and ATOB.
Some young upstarts have sat in oor seats, the rapscallions!
So, just like a home CL game…. punted oot to accommodate somebody you’ve never even seen😀
Anyway, COYBIG.Let’s see a draw at least away from home👍