Out! Out! Out!
Morning, all.
We had a comfortable win at Firhill on Sunday to add to last weekend’s victory at Rugby Park, but we face a short run of four games before the next international break, and none of them will be quite so straightforward.
We start off tomorrow in Belgrade against Red Star, like ourselves a force once to reckon with in Europe. Next midweek is a home match against Braga, Portugal’s unfortunate fourth force in a three-team league. Our next two weekends are also home matches, against Hibs and Motherwell. As ever, we should be looking to take the points in all of them, and to do so will take some improvement on the performances we have generally seen so far. But if we can do that, we can head into the international break with renewed confidence and vigour, and with a fortnight to work with our late arrivals in the transfer window.
That damned transfer window is still a major talking point around the club, three weeks after it closed. This is hardly surprising, since it was the latest in a series of failures at board level to do what is required to support the players and the manager on the pitch. As we know, The Celtic Collective (TCC) was formed as a result, a loose alliance of blogs, supporters clubs and affiliations etc, with the aim of preventing this happening again. Or, as I said recently, for us to get our club back. We want it run as a football club, focused on footballing excellence. The board pay lip service to this at best, throwing the footballing operation a few crumbs from the Bumper Bag of Bunce labelled Profits.
Over £45m of profit recorded last year. That’s some going. More than £33m after paying nearly £12m to the taxman. Yet somehow or other, only £100,000 was added to our already obscene cash pile. It’s not the first time there’s been some disparity there, but none previously as glaring as this. I’m not a forensic accountant, so I was far from surprised that despite spending a couple of hours leafing through the accounts as released on Friday, I can find no explanation for why such a derisory sum was added, nor where the rest has gone. I’ve never claimed to be the sharpest tool in the box, but I’m reasonably sharp with figures. These have me flummoxed. I’d be grateful if someone would explain it all to me.
The 12th Man protest was successful at Rugby Park last weekend, so a different type was planned for the trip to Firhill. TCC handed out posters of the three main board culprits in their eyes, each in a red circle with a red diagonal through it. The meaning is clear, these are the men we hold responsible and we want them removed. This has upset some of our supporters apparently, as they think it is reprehensible that individuals are being targeted in this way. I disagree. These are the men who have been responsible for signing the players that our manager required, and asked for. They are the Chief Executive, Chief Financial Officer, and the chairman, himself formerly a failed CEO. They have one job during the summer months, and that is to support the manager (within applicable financial constraints) as he tries to build a squad for the season ahead.
They failed. Miserably. And not for the first time. Their position is untenable.
They still have their own support amongst the fans though, and they’ve been fighting back with grumbles about BR demanding oven-ready players, rather than projects. Theory being that there is no profit to be made from those players the manager has said he requires, but plenty from the type the board prefer. This is where the split between the fans who support the aims of TCC and those who still support the board become almost a matter of ideology. One side wants to support a football team, the other wants to support a money-making machine. One side wants progress in Europe, while the other thinks Europe is a nice bonus but only if we get drawn against someone from a nice wee touristy place.
IMO, Europe should be our primary goal. This club built its worldwide fame on European success!
But that’s not the only reason why Europe, so casually tossed aside by the board and their lackeys, should be so important to us. In ballpark terms, entry to the CL is worth around £50m to us. There’s UEFA prize money, TV money (EL TV money is split with the huns, btw), improved sponsorship and merchandise income, and also an increase in the exposure (and therefore, value) of our players. £50m might be conservative, in fact. The EL, by contrast, is worth £20m if we are lucky.
We have a stadium built for big European nights. Fans who provide an atmosphere which is unrivalled. Memories of sending clubs who thought they only had to turn up home with their tails between their legs; even when we’ve lost, many teams have wondered how they managed to come out of it unscathed. But there are people in our club who would bin all those memories and all that potential, because beating the huns is all that matters? Worse, because they think that beating the huns is all that matters to US?
These people in the red circles on Sunday were being highlighted for a reason. It wasn’t being done from spite. Nor is it some form of threat, as has been suggested. The reason is that they have been derelict in their duties. Have been miserable failures, in fact. They have treated the club as their own personal plaything, their own personal piggy bank, and their own personal fiefdom. They won’t appear publicly for interview, their thought processes unknown to us-other than the clear contempt and disdain that they have for the fans. (Bad news for the lackeys-that contempt and disdain includes you, ya numpties!)
They have been around too long and are stinking the place out. Desmond needs to get his favourite headhunting agency onto this, with the remit of replacing those three and most of the others before Easter at the latest. And when I say Easter, I mean in the door and feet under the desk by then, not some vague promises. Might be difficult though if any of our targets for CEO were to call Dominic McKay for his thoughts on the job. Just saying.
<><><><><>
Above article by BMCUWP
Our donations page for McMillan Cancer Care has now closed,having raised almost £1700 plus Gift Aid. Thank you to everyone who was a part of this, you are all wonderful and generous people.
That’s over £6000 in eighteen months, and you should rightfully feel significant pride in that.
Our new charity campaign will begin immediately, and as ever, it will be for a charity of your choice. Nominated via these pages, and chosen as the most worthy by our contributors.
It is Chidren’s Hospices Across Scotland (CHAS). Nominated by BAWHEID, and overwhelmingly the landslide winner of the vote. We have just reached our first target of £1000, and you can help us reach our next one.
£1888
You can donate by following this link, as set up by CHALMERSBHOY (and grateful thanks once again for doing so!)
https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinel-celts-2?utm_medium=FA&utm_source=EM
There is a default payment method by ApplePay, which I don’t use. Just click ”change” above the payment bar to view other options.
There is also still time to volunteer for The Saturday Naps Competition, which started on Saturda 13th September.
It is FREE to enter, and all are welcome.
Co-sponsorship for this will once more be from the site and 16 ROADS, though others are welcome to offer assistance too.
https://sentinelcelts.com/2025/08/29/st-leger/
Link to POTY Competition.
sencelpoty@gmail.com
POTY Update.
SENTINEL CELTS PLAYER OF THE YEAR 2025-26
RESULTS FROM GAME #9 PARTICK THISTLE 0 CELTIC 4 (YANG, SCALES, TOUNEKTI, McCOWAN)
Good evening, friends.
Another well organised pre-match protest saw a slight delay to the kick off as the rolled up disused posters were cleared from the sun drenched pitch. And pretty soon we saw that it was the most completely one-sided game of the season so far. Attackers v Defenders for the first 20 minutes but without the breakthrough we were all hoping for. The Horseshoed sold out stadium was a good substitute from our usual horseshoed back line but it was clear to all that the ‘get the ball to Seb’ option was the one most likely to get us off our seats.
The breakthrough came in the 25th minute. Some good link up play between Tounekti and Nygren saw a 60 degree lob wedge to the back post met by the head of Yang and Celtic were one up. We doubled our lead just 2 minutes later. Tounekti and Nygren again combined at the corner and the cross into the box saw Scales get ahead of his marker to send a near post header into the corner of the net. Easy Street by half time.
My own viewing was affected by grandparent duties and not only did I miss the start of the second half, but I missed our third goal! Tounekti’s driving run into the box followed by a one-two with Iheanacho saw Sebastian score his first goal for Celtic.
In the 52rd minute we saw a rare moment of shooting from outside the box! Iheanach made some space on the D and his low effort was well saved by the Thistle keeper. Kelechi has only been with us for a fortnight so it’ll take time for him to adjust to our ‘don’t just shoot’ policy!
Our 4th goal came in the 78th minute. Good pressing from Balikwisha saw McCowan pick up the resultant loose ball and proceed to drive towards the Partick goal. From 15 yards a low controlled shot across the keeper into the far corner completed our scoring for the day.
The post match celebrations saw the fans, team and manager all seemingly on the same page. Togetherness could be vital in the weeks ahead.
The draw for the semi finals was very favourable as Celtic avoided the 2 other teams that are currently in Scotland’s top 10. The semi final against Triggers Broom FC is 6 weeks away.
We have now played 9 games, winning 6 and drawing 3. We have scored 16 goals and conceded 2.
The voting numbers for this latest game are well ahead of last season’s average but disappointingly still a bit short of the 100-target. But my thanks to the 85 who voted this time around.
The total votes cast for each player are as follows, with my own nominations asterisked.
Sinisalo: 1
Donovan*: 54
Carter-Vickers: 2
Scales: 18
Tierney: 20
McGregor: 3
Hatate: 17
Nygren*: 13
Yang: 10
Iheanacho: 30
Tounekti*: 84
Bernardo: 0
Maeda: 1
Balikwisha: 0
Engels: 0
McCowan: 2
Unused substitutes: Forrest, Murray, Saracchi, Schmeichel
And so, the POINTS earned by each player for this match are as follows (with the top 2 places remaining the same as for the previous game against Kilmarnock!) –
25 points: Tounekti
22 points: Donovan
19 points: Iheanacho
16 points: Tierney
14 points: Scales
12 points: Hatate
11 points: Nygren
10 points: Yang
9 points: McGregor
8 points: Carter-Vickers and McCowan
6 points: Maeda and Sinisalo
3 points: Balikwisha, Bernardo and Engels
1 point: Forrest, Murray, Saracchi and Schmeichel
And the cumulative points achieved after 9 games played are –
149: Scales
113: Tierney
110: Nygren
105: McGregor
98: Forrest
92: Carter-Vickers
84: Engels
83: Hatate
69: Maeda
68: Donovan
66: Yang
63: McCowan
57: Ralston
55: Murray
54: Johnston
50: Tounekti
48: Schmeichel
41: Yamada
35: Iheanacho
28: Saracchi
25: Bernardo
23: Sinisalo
22: Inamura and Trusty
21: Kenny
19: Idah
14: Balikwisha
2: Osmond and Simpson-Pusey
1: Doohan
0: All the other players who’ve not yet made a matchday squad!
We now have just 2 more sleeps until our opening game in this season’s Europa League. An away tie against Crvena Zvezda aka Red Start Belgrade. The kick off in Serbia is at 8.00pm on Wednesday evening.
Hail Hail!
Bobby it’s corruption
Thats the explanation in full.
All else follows
Celtic supporters are being taken to the cleaners on the back of hunnery.
I don’t believe Dominic McKay was fired.
I suspect about 2-3 months into the job he saw what was really going on and then looked at the job description on what he was hired to do and said no way I’m fucking out of here
Unique Angle Up ( apologies if already posted )
https://youtu.be/I3cWo-n11oI?si=1PCoYqPS6qRA8DXZ
Good Morning Sentinels – Grand Day To Be A Tim
Thanks for the responses yesterday.
Apologies, for not getting back for the day, didn’t expect to be out all day….
Billy Bhoy @ 10:27 am,
“I suppose we should at least credit the Board for moulding the team into a representation of the fans views – 5 Left wingers and only 1 right winger!”
Quite:)), mirror imago of the Board…
BAD @ 10:35 am,
Yes, had some unfortunate deals with them folk in the City Of London – if you look at the bizarre goings on in the Celtic Hierarchy over the last twenty years and use occam’s razor that’s always where I end up.
Yes, often preaching to the converted on Sentinel Celts but there is a real awakening niw across Celtica
The Gombeen Man @ 11:08 am,
Cheers – Yes, all behind the team for Wednesday, it could be a seminal moment.
On Engels transfer fee, point taking in that it is a lot of spend on a development player, even for the big bhoys – yet the thinking is, if he can be developed then getting our transfer fee back with an uplift or even a multiple will be great.
Meanwhile we gave a quality player who can contribute to the first team – Celtic Say the are an elite club, a UCL club that develops UCL players, striving to be a world class Club, that’s not going to be achieved by the 2023 intake.
BSR @ 11:44 am,
Thanks
“They blew it, they know they blew it, and now they know, we know they blew it.”
Quite:))
INIQUITOUS IV @ 2:38 pm,
Thanks, really appreciate that – will never xatch on though;
Hail Hail
.Auldheid…
Firstly apologies for not getting back, I didn’t expect to be out all day yesterday.
Secondly you made a few comments with several salient points over a couple of blogs, so apologies for what might look like a generic reply; so if I miss, or misunderstand something I’m sure you’ll point it out:))
Now my point about FSR – Celtic have a huge amount of headroom in FSR compliance, they are the poster bhoys.
That is why I’m saying all this talk of FSR non-compliance is scaremongering.
Especially when folk are banging on about our Operational Expenses figure which is not the amount that is used in FSR.
Let me once again post…
Cost control and the squad cost rule
“The new regulations will see clubs subject to squad cost controls for the first time. The cost control rule restricts spending on player and coach wages, transfers, and agent fees to 70% of club revenues. (The gradual implementation will see the percentage at 90% in 2023/2024, 80% in 2024/2025, and 70% in 2025/2026). This requirement provides a direct measure between squad costs and income to encourage more performance-related costs and to limit the market inflation of wages and transfer costs of players.
https://www.uefa.com/news-media/news/0274-14da0ce4535d-fa5b130ae9b6-1000–explainer-uefa-s-new-financial-sustainability-regulations/
“This requirement provides a direct measure between squad costs and income”
So it’s NOT Operational Expenses (OE)*
Celtic’s figure for squad costs are well below that of OE and relatively speaking is a very healthy percentage of football related revenue.
If the folk who are misleading supporters in this regard are not being disingenuous and scaremongering why are they doing it?
“I have somewhere a note of Anges buys. I think it was £45m over two seasons . What were Anges purchases sold for? Just one, MoR contributed most to football earnings, and about what Ange spent in a year.
How much did Engles Idah and Twisty cost?
What will be their resale value?. I think that has a lot to do with current crisis along with the lack of urgency to get players in due to high purchases needing Board approval and that taking too long.”
Interesting you guys harping on about “How much did Engles Idah and Twisty cost?”
How about…
Kuhn, Schmeichel, Sinisalo, Bernardo, McCowan who were bought at the same time 8 mn – worth over 25 mn.
We got 7 mn for Idah – 20 goals
Trusty and Engels worth 18 mn
I make that 50 mn – What’s the issue with our 2024 intake.
Did us not to bad in the League, Cups and UCL an awe.
How are the 2023 buy cheap sell high recruits doing?
Ange’s recruitment was funded by the sale of several BR Mk 1 sales, specifically Ajer and Eduardo.
Matt O’Riley was developed into three times the value by BR&CO and with other sales paid for the 2024 intake.
My reading is that profit from selling players helps meet the wage bill for players already in situe with 4 year contracts which the support prefer to losing them.
Buying low and selling high from that perspective, and everyone has their own, is why I’ve used the hamster in the wheel strategy and I would suggest that we are where we are right now because the hamster was not pedalling fast enough.”
What we have being doing is putting players on a five year contract, hopefully after a couple of years, they have developed into much better players and have added value to the first team and their transfer fees.
At that point the Board want to sell and make profit – e.g. Nic Kuhn
Where as the football department has been trying to persuade footballers to stay by offering an enhanced deal then selling later for more – e.g. Matt O’Riley
So what do you do?
Develop a player for 18 months and see another club benefit.
Or have the player contribute to the first team over a number of seasons and make more money?
Of course, the new extended contract the player signs will be on a much better salary, when you couple that with the current wage inflation that Peter Lawwell warned us about two years ago, the bonuses we pay players for winning and drawing matches specifically in the UCL and all that impacts the FSR cost control rule which you think (wrongly) we are on course for breaching.
Also, we keep players until they run down their contract, Greg Taylor, or their value plummets when they decline an extended contract and like Daizen Maeda.
No wonder you have a knackered Hamster:)
*Our Operational Expenses Including Labour, as the Chairman puts it – “First team labour costs were the highest levels in the history of the Club” he later tells – of course Revenues were at a record high, but that must have slipped his mind, can you believe he has shares.
Hail Hail
Spot on Bobby, spot on.
💯 agree with every word. Change is not only demanded but is needed… Do I trust the current lot to deliver? That’s another story… All we can do is keep the pressure and the spotlight on those responsible. Hail Hail
I read this article and remembered why I retired early. Sick to death of the corporate bullshit and the hours spent on stuff with no tangible output in order to justify someone else’s job,
https://open.substack.com/pub/thestillwandering/p/the-death-of-the-corporate-job?r=4j2o6i&utm_medium=ios
REDMOND did you work in warrington many moons ago, and if so think we have met on a few occasions👍
Good morning, friends.
One the eve of our first Europa League game has anyone heard whether or not we added a final player to our Squad A-list or are we just going with 24, but using a player from the B-list as and when each game comes around?
And that reminds me that today is when the further sale of Europa tickets begins. Remember, the original package was £35 a game. Between 10 and 2, season ticket holders can buy single game tickets for £39. From 2.30pm the public sale begins, priced at £45 a game. Its at that point that we might get a decent idea on how many seats have been taken up so far- the old ‘count the dots’ game.
Chairbuoy.
If the folk who are misleading supporters in this regard are not being disingenuous and scaremongering why are they doing it?
great question, no need to answer really. another accurate and succinct post describing Celtics figures and FSR impact. So much nonsense ,spurious figures ,revised figures doing the rounds,crazy really. Who knows what motives are in play , I ‘m just as inclined to believe people have a need to be remain relevant , and end up coming accross like the Foggy Dewhursts of Celtic cyberspace.
I accept that folk are uncomfortable with folk losing their jobs, it’s not in our nature. In a union man, it’s not a normal default position at all.
But when the folk targeted are multi millionaires on the back of the Celtic fans investment, whilst treating them with the utmost contempt and hostility. Then, I make an exception.
Jobo
i don’t think we can add another. Can’t remember the ins and outs but because we let Welsh go we lost our full quota by not having enough home grown. And the b team squad is a separate entity or something for the purpose of uefa. I will see if I can find the article
An excellent summary. After discussions relating to the aftermath of Celtic’s phenomenal success in Lisbon, it seemed that Celtic FC the team lost its way. You would have expected the team to move on and to bring new success’s in Europe, domestic success was a given, but European teams kicked on and we kind of basked in the glow of our #67 success, so, what happened and why did Celtic lose its way in Europe after Lisbon, missing out sometimes because of lady luck or bad refereeing decisions, I don’t buy that, its my opinion (guessing) that some of the Lisbon Lions became discontented with their salaries and that unsettled them quite a bit. Salaries today are off the ‘Richter scale compared to then, but it was stated in several of the players autobiographies that they got a ‘Lisbon bonus of around £1250. This would allow them if they chose to put a large deposit down on a house, or even carpet it 😉 players salaries at that time were very much higher than the working wage. Only a few of the team found playing golf as their primary relaxation and majority of the players would relax with a friendly drink with their friends, the demon drink would affect some of the players and not in a good way. Looking at this in the round I looked at the ages of the players and when they left for pastures new…………
*As an aside it was rumoured that Racing Clubs players were on a £2000 bonus to win the Intercontinental Cup.
Ronnie Simpson – 1970 (36).
Jim Craig – 1972 (29).
Tommy Gemmell – 1971 (28).
Billy McNeill – 1975 – (35).
John Clark – 1971 – (30).
Jimmy Johnstone – 1975 (30).
Willie Wallace – 1972 – (31).
Bobby Lennox – 1980 – (35).
Bobby Murdoch – 1973 – (28).
Stevie Chalmers – 1971 – (36).
Bertie Auld – 1971 – (33).
How do you construct a new team while still striving for success?
Jock Stein – Miner – Player – Coach – Manager.
There is no rule book that can instruct a football manager to construct a new team, this is accomplished (then) by experience and led by costs and player judgement, it would be nearly impossible to get it all right.
One thing that we must also bare in mind at that time was the revolution going on in Holland and its ‘Total Football’ which swept every other team aside for over five years. You could argue that Jock and his ‘Lions were the instigators of ‘Total Football’ Irrespective of opinions Jock Stein and the team that he constructed destroyed the damaging ‘ Catenaccio’ and brought football back as an enjoyable attacking game. Jock Stein and the # 67Lisbon Lions.
Bobby, just to point out that the group are called the Celtic Fans Collective
Brechin0 @ 8:58 am,
Yes, exactly…
Have a debate by all means, make errors by all means…
BUT
When that person who should know better,
When you point something out and they ignore it,
Then wh¡t.!?
To Be frank, some smart folk have said this about the FSR for instance
Celtic have stated it on an official statement.
So, when I put my view forward, my expectation is to be corrected with facts and figures and links to sites
No
And I double check my facts, then…
Just the same misinformation repeated time after time.
Very odd.
Hail Hail
Celtic Vs Red Star Belgrade – Celtic Park 13th. Nov. 1968/69 First Leg Second Round.
Red Star were no pushovers with six Yugoslav Internationals in their team. Celtic at home were favourites to go through but in football nothing is a given.
This game went into Celtic folklore as the game cemented Jimmy Johnstone’s position as a Celtic Icon especially with his scorching performance in the second half where he dazzled the night time sky at ‘Parkheid’ 😉 and left the Red Star players in awe at his performance.
Jock Stein said that “No-one will beat us on that form” Celtic were that good, it left the return match at the Rajko Mitic Stadium a formality.
24th September 2025. “Giving Blood” – for a free ticket in tomorrow nights match is out of the box thinking only excused if ‘Count Dracula’ is a director. I give blood regularly but its mostly when I sweat it watching Celtic play. I’m looking forward to watching the game wearing Ratomir Dujkovics jersey. In 1968 he picked the ball out of his net five times, it was reckoned that he had a good game, that in itself tells the story of Jinkys performance that night.
Here is Ratomir’s jersey in discussing the game with Mr. Bigshot Tommy Gemmell (Legend). This game like some of the other teams that we play a reminder of some of the great European ties that Celtic played.
COYBIG.
Bawheid
Great post on post Lisbon decline.
We’re a weird club when it comes to money matters. Executives exempt, obviously.
Chairbhoy.
It’s all such a gigantic red herring. Endless media ,internet coverage, you would think FSR only applied to Celic. Problems in the future , no chance 5 years time, 10 years time FSR won’t be around , another incarnation in its place. Globalization holds the power here , UEFA will be picking up scraps.
Our problem is simple….. poor governance. Hire BR , give him the remnants of Ange’s completely shot squad and an expensive bunch of duffers. They knew and more importantly understood BR’s [theirchoice]requirements. THe money spent on the duds would have covered a handful of first teamers.
Rodgers has been fire fighting ever since, Ange’s players are now completely cooked despite warnings of a 2/3 cycle from both managers. The well is dry.
No discernible football structure , lip service accademy . No clue. Every player hostage , the Engles / Idah/Trusty chat tedious inflated prices due to end of the window mania….. they have all contributed .
Brendan Rogers, complete ego maniac…. so what ? His little black book has finally provided him with a striker who can take the ball on a turn,play with his head up to feet and put the ball in the net.
We are then told to accept UEFA cup as Champs league is harder, poor old Celtic. We might not make it , why waste money [ 5mill to make 40plus mill],lets be happy were we are.
After all we’re a buisness not a football club , right ?
ST TAMS
Thanks for the correction, mate. Dunno what I was thinking of when I wrote TCC, as I immediately clocked the correct acronym CFC as being quite clever. Though CSC might have been more appropriate.
Brechin0
👏 👏 👏
Brechin0
that just about sums it all up 👏
Hail Hail
Chairbhoy
September 23, 2025 6:24 am
The headroom is because the CL income more or less guaranteed is higher.
If it drops the headroom will narrow. If the top line drops because non football earnings are included the gap will narrow.
To keep the gap from narrowing too much Celtic will sell players and recruit replacements at low a cost they can get.
That explains why Celtic never strengthen when expected.
The income they do receive from player sales goes towards paying the current and future wages of the squad.
The only point of debate is what is the headroom and why is it not tighter to the 70%.
If too tight dont spend as much.
That makes sense to me in terms of recruitment and how FSR affects it.
Celtic will never breach FSR because they take steps to avoid it.
So the idea that FSR does not apply now because income is high is the red herring because it fails to look ahead.
The accounts next year if the sale of Khun who wanted to go was not included would see the gap narrow. But it will not narrow by as much because of sale and if Tounetki brought in at a quite low transfer fee and lower wage than Khun can be sold for 3 times his cost that keeps the football earnings up which means the squad costs spend can be higher.
As Ive said to make it simple Celtic are a mouse in a spinning wheel to stay sustainable.
You appear unable to let go of the idea FSR is scaremongering as in Celtic might be in danger of breach.
Well since that is never going to happen because Celtic will take steps it doesn’t it can hardly be scaremongering unless how FSR works is misunderstood and dismissed.
You see it your way but looking ahead using a spreadsheet if income falls and wages rise what steps would you take to make sure there was no possibility of entering an unsustainable level?
You would increase earnings by selling which at same time reduces squad costs.
So give it a rest on the scaremongering front.
Let’s just stick to asking why is the headroom so large?
Why was more not spent on players now?
San Luis – Yes weird in many respects. In many ways the new Celtic board are much the same as the old one (now that is weird) the old one scrimped and manipulated the cash towards themselves.
The current Celtic board have a massive amount of cash in the bank, incomparable in terms of football but indecent in terms of not spending on new players etc.
The 2019 AGM did for me, when Joe McHugh held up the 5Way Agreement that was enough, no more supporting. This recent fiasco tells us that this board should be gone, nepotism was disgraceful paying out huge wages and bonus’s while fleecing the support says it all.
Just sad that its a distraction for the team. Year after after year, it must be challenged.
The Celtic European record as the club gets richer and richer for reasons unexplained, gets worse and worse. Seven CL failed attempts from nine should be enough to end any regime, let alone one that is failing the support miserably, whilst kerchinging in the rain.
Brendan Rodgers gets no credit from an all powerful hierarchy that eats football coaches for breakfast, two domestic leagues and undeniably improved in Europe, are PLC bread and butter with the diddy league a given. Managers can even come from the elite, fulfilling their Celtic background culture, and heritage badge. Doesn’t matter what board, any Celtic board will hire and fire under the flawed no investment or ambition narrative, that’s haunted the club for quarter of a century, and even made Rainjurz and Sevco look competent.“ I know how it works up here “ BR with dozens of other soundbites knows what he signed up to, delivered it but still gets emptied.
The EL could be about to underline the paucacity of BR squad, that couldn’t score against Kairat because of boardroom dogma, in a gap filling exercise everyone else including them saw. Brendan Rodgers, won’t save the board who’ve been fleecing supporters , since they appointed gormless Tony Mowbray, with no ambition or investment in between.
2014 £3.83m
2015 £4.72m
2016 £3.6m
2017 £17.9m
2018 £36.1m
2019 £28.6m
2020 £18.2m
2021 £16.6m
2022 £30.2m
2023 £72.3m
2024 £77.2m
2025 £77.3m
£30M wiped out overnight in Kazakhstan 👏
Back the team – sack the board CSC
I too would be interested in why only £100,000 was banked from the profits .
Some might think it’s in the boards interests to avoid adding too much to the bank pile at the moment.
Can anyone with a knowledge of how these things work she’d some light on it .
Auldheid…all your assertions and assumptions about FSR are based on ifs, buts and maybes! If yer granny had baws etc etc but Kuhn was sold and NOT replaced, as was Kyogo and Idah and the injured Jota. That’s the issue, NOT FSR! Maeda, Hatate and Kyogo were all recruited at a low purchase and (relatively) low wages. And, crucially, were brought in BEFORE the business end of the Transfer Window. What’s stopping us doing that again? Well, for a start we have a malfunctioning Recruitment Dept. The FSR and all the detail you continually regurgitate is a red herring, not for you as you’ve immersed yourself in it and are trying to convince us all its as important to us as it is to you. While you type and type and type all the rest of us are asking for is properly staffed and funded recruitment team that are permitted to do their job properly without interference. And once we have operating as it should then we will then know for sure how much of a problem for the Club FSR really is! At the moment it isn’t a problem but you continually suggest it might be and our recruitment is woefully inept…and despite what our PLC would have us believe – they’re not really connected.
The Cake and Eat it PLC
Dermot Desmond invested in Celtic and from the very beginning he made it very clear that it would be ran as a business. That does not just entail making a profit every year. It means he has long and short term visions for his financial punt. Therefore plc strategies will be fluid depending on these visions. Not only that but his investment in Celtic has been used to benefit other aspects of his portfolio at a business and political level, and he will continue to do so. He is a venture capitalist. That´s what they do.
e.g The MON spend was due to a forlorn hope of getting into the EPL climaxing in Seville. This was followed by appointing Peter Lawwell and cost cutting. “Get used to the slow lane”
Dermot wasn’t and never intended to bank roll anything. If he was in any way emotionally attached to Celtic FC then this would have been the time to do it but it is anathema to him as a person. I am telling you nothing new here of course. We knew this in 2004. Since then we have been adhering to our 4 year cycle. Reduce costs. Maximize profit. Inhibit messiah complexes.
By 2006 there was a guy on CQN called Awe_Naw_No_Annoni_Oan_Anaw_Noo who regularly highlighted the “Old Firm Preservation Society”. He would also stipulate “Buy shares instead of season books” as this would be the only thing that would concern this plc. He was laughed at ridiculed even well until the Willo Flood window. Then the Old Firm preservation society accusation began to gain some traction.
By the time Sevco (team 12) was in the league cup draw it was no longer up for debate. Celtic plc
sees the Old Firm as an integral part of it´s business. Not one concession for the overall benefit
and development of Scottish football that the ASCOM video recently highlighted which is missing from our national infrastructure was sought after or gained, in fact it cost us TV money. The Common Wealth Games coming to the east side of town and the spin offs and financial benefits from that was deemed more than sufficient. Anything else would be brushed under the SFA carpet and that we, the only money making entity in Scotland at the time, had absolutely no influence whatsoever over due to us seemingly being unrepentant Fenian bastards. We could get Lizzie rock up at Celtic Park (her home from home). Seemingly it had nothing to do with having no football expertise or focus on the board and only interested in preserving Dermot´s initial punt and an obsessive fixation with money.
As long as we beat the entity at Ibrox we can carry on as a player cash and carry and keep the punters happy. We will do nothing in Europe far too risky and more importantly too expensive and also ensure no naughty messiahs to contend with.
So The Four Bears lose a fortune the poor wee things. Tee Hee Tee Hee @Celtic PLC. The SF49ers as Andrew Caveneagh is known rocks up with what must be the last throw of the dice for them’s. Our PLC do not want to have to deal with Auldheid again and come up with the sequel 5WA II “Return of the Resolution Four”. That´s expensive and risky and bad PR. Unfortunately just before they decide to cement the purchase of Sevco. Pesky Brendan Rodgers gets us to finish as the 21st best team in Europe the uppity cad that he is. He didn´t even need Kyogo for Christ sakes . Shite what are we gaunae dae noo ? We can´t even spend the extra 40m on players with regards to doing better in Europe and also whoop the bears yet again. Think of the optics. Think of the player cash and carry business ? Their customer base is at breaking point they need to establish themselves as a going concern. Think of the Old Firm
So good luck lads and lassies with chanting sack the bored, and staying absent or silent for 12 minutes while still buying tickets while there is 100m quid in the bank and remember persistence beats resistance.
Can I just say Welcome to the Club
Good Luck !
so
CFC
wants change for CFC
the PLC not the FC .
by sacking the EXECS
but not the N E D
because DD
acts like he owns CFC
whilst being an absentee
Auldheid @ 11:56 am,
It seems to me and many others that for the best part of twenty years Celtic PLC have been making excuses about why they can’t properly invest in the team.
True, some excuses were better than others but they have no excuses at all now – unless they make one up about the FSR.
They want to buy low and sell high because it’s a commercial strategy that makes the business money.
If they wish to make a revenue stream out of player trading there are many issues with that, two main ones…
They are not very good at it
It is totally unfit for purpose when it comes to creating an elite first team squad.
Of course if our revenues go down and our squad costs go up then the huge FSR margin we have will be smaller.
Yet it doesn’t get away from the fact that many of our rival clubs will need to tighten their belts, when we are in a position to invest more in our first team.
Thus narrowing the gap with our peers.
Revenues could drop by 25 mn to circa 120 mn this year.
But there is no reason why our squad costs should rise.
As fholk love to remind us, Trusty, Engels and Idah cost a fortune.
Well they were in the just published accounts and we have huge headroom.
All the scaremongering about Rodgers making the Club go bust
Has been replaced by FSR has made it “non-optional”.
Nonsense, do the math…
Even if it were true – which of course it’s not, is that an excuse for an incompetent window.
Why couldn’t we have had our own deadline of the 01 August for bringing players in.
We sell Kuhn, Lagerbielke, Tilio, Kwon, Cummings for 20 mn, Greg Taylor is off the wage bill
We get in Tierney, Nygren, Saccachi, Tounekti, Balikwisha and Iheanacho in by the first of August.
We have the cash to make it happen, without the transfers out.
We then sell Idah, Yang, Meada for over 20 m.
Then maybe a right winger last minute dot com.
There was no viable excuse for that mess of a transfer window
Apart for that ridiculous Board strategy and the incompetent Executive.
All the haggling, all the posturing does not make us one thin dime.
In fact we lose money and our reputation goes down the pan.
We get two Japanese prospects in probably for commercial reasons.
Then we treated Daizen the way we did.
Do you know how we treated that man will look like in Japan – a total loss of face.
Japanese are an honourable people.
Also all this nonsense about having to sell players to make the wages.
The PLC get 70 mn free money every year from the supporters.
Thats where the money to pay the wages and keep the lights on comes from.
Hail Hail
Brechin0 @ 10:58 am,
That is an excellent post, talk about nail on the head 👏 👏👏👏
Hail Hail
quick summarize.
for the fiscal year 24/25 ending 30th june we had 77m in the bank. there was no increase in this because no profit was retained.
people wont like it . will somehow conclude it is creative accountancy. will claim dividends and bonuses for all
but the reality
they spent what they earned
it is in the accounts
St Stivs
Ok, it wasn’t retained. Where did it go? What did we do with it? That’s the bit that we are none the wiser about.
I know I am being stupid here cos I only did accounting to O grade standard. My assumption was profit in the accounts was after all income and expenditure was accounted for. So if nothing was added to the bank balance because all the profit was reinvested then that reinvestment is part of the expenditure. So wouldnt show as profit at all?
We must be clearly talking about something other than bottom line here
we will find out when the annual report comes out.
if i was in the cfo role i would be putting together a very detailed presentation of
here is where we spent the monies ,….
that call for transparency for once actually come out and tell it all
For the second year running, Real Madrid boycotted the Balloon D’Or ceremony after learning that a Real player was not the winner. Last night, after treble winner Moussa Dembele of PSG beat out Barca sensation Lamine Yamal, Yamal’s father said, ‘“I think this is the biggest, I won’t say theft, but moral damage done to a human being because I believe Lamine Yamal is the best player in the world by far, by a huge margin.”
the Corinthian Spirit at its finest
I have been having a wee ponder wrt profits being taxed.
While we are making money should our original purpose be re-established ?
before tax a company can make charitable donations.
should this be a proposal for CFC ?
A set figure or percentage ?
if they cannot do it for the foundation due to connected parties then why not others ?
we would support that wouldnt we ?
mike jealous dads at annual awards every year
ma bhoy should have won it
mit.
on that subject it us amazing how many coaches sons win player of the year.
One for IIV,
How do you best utilise a corner though?
“The beauty is who puts the ball in the box. Arsenal’s players put the ball in the right areas nearly all of the time,”
“If you haven’t got that player, your set-pieces fail.”
Who … ?…heavily criticised for years, now his style seemingly in vogue.
Bobby,
The Consolidated Cash Flow Statement, that the PLC made available last Friday, gives a detailed breakdown in the cash movement, in and out, between 30/6/24 and 30/6/25.
Saint Stivs 1.11
Tax is a complicated subject so I sought help of AI to understand the ins and outs of how Corporation Tax works.
You can see response here.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tN_KdXHm7q1IScPK9i8YWuroR_lqUvwW/edit?usp=drivesdk&ouid=107947982974245186134&rtpof=true&sd=true
Aye, but what did wee Ratskin’s da say?
Chairbhoy
Especially when folk are banging on about our Operational Expenses figure which is not the amount that is used in FSR.
Ive never used operational costs in my calculations because I know what constitutes football earnings.
Ive probably posted the definition more than once.
Im not folk.
I took the line as Swiss Rambler did that since football earnings constitute the majority of income that is a reasonable start point but if it’s lower that reduces the size of the gap. That does not mean failure to comply but if forecast is income fall then what the wage bill will be has to be looked in case of non compliance. If there is a possibility the wages of players signed in the window on a 3 or 4yr contract has to be taken into account when recruiting.
The idea current compliance means future compliance is assured is based on not knowing how the process.
As Ive said, hopefully for the last time, compliance can always be assured by selling best players and replacing with players at lower wages but with development potential.
We need to be better on the latter to keep the wheel spinning at a consistent speed.
I like cricket.I remember once listening to an interview with England players Alec Stewart and Darren Gough , it gave great insight into two polarized mind sets. They were discussing a one day match against S. Africa they had both played in. Neither knew at the time that the match, although very exciting had been rigged by S.Africa…. fixed.
Stewart was livid ,appalled at the action.It was a totally unacceptable act , unsporting ,terrible for the fans as they had paid good money for a sideshow. Gough on the other hand, had no problem with the game , he didn’t know at the time ,it seemed competitive, some guys got a bit of extra cash, crowd went home happy not knowing they had been duped, a win win infact.
I feel this is where Celtic and the support is, it’s not just a split it is a chasm .Celtic hobble themselves for one reason and one reason only, and we All know what it is.It is not FSR ,and it wasn’t FSR for the past 15/20 however many years.
Now, it is possible to suggest it is all for the good of Scottish Football, closer,competative games, more than a one horse race… meaning only two of course, and then hopefully more the other one.
Problem is I can’t help thinking of poor old Alec Stewart, The Barmy Army ,and of course WWF Wresting.
Auldheid @ 3:37 pm,
Yes, I think we’ll have to agree to disagree.
Let’s call it a day…
We knew last year we had a UCL-Q in August.
If I was leading a sales campaign to get a 45 mn deal over the line and I was as complacent and incompetent as this Executive, I’d expect to get my head chopped off – not a Million Pound Salary.
We sold Kyogo and never replaced him
Jota, who wasn’t match fit when we brought him in got long term injured
We sold Nic Kuhn at the start of the window
Which apart from leaving us without our three out of four best forward our other forwards
Idah
Yang
Meada
Were negotiating transfer deals and were not expecting to be with Celtic in the UCL anyway.
After the plane landed Idah was in Wales before you could say Yaki Da.
How on earth is that a strategy?
Especially as the excuse now is to keep us compliant with a rule that we were easy compliant with.
Especially as we bought higher priced players last season and are still compliant
Can you see why this argument has no logic to it.
It does sound like a really crap excuse and is one of the reasons Celtic Supporters patience has well and truly ended.
People need to be dealt with respectfully and as having a bit of common sense.
Treating people as idiots is just not going to wash.
Hail Hail
McCaff.
McCaff
September 23, 2025 12:45 pm
Auldheid…all your assertions and assumptions about FSR are based on ifs, buts and maybes! If yer granny had baws etc etc but Kuhn was sold and NOT replaced, as was Kyogo and Idah and the injured Jota.
=====
Exactly. As Ive been saying ad nauseum selling players is what Celtic do to stay compliant. Is that so hard to understand.
Based on what is in the public domain there has to be an element of estimating but Celtic will know to the last penny what current costs and income are and have a better idea what that will look like two seasons hence take compliance steps now if they want to stay still as in being dominant at home with a consistent wage bill partly paid by the sale of best players.
Since that is pretty obvious what they do what other credible explanation is there for not going to the limit of the FSR ceiling every window? What they will not do imo is buy a player in at the same price of the guys they sell. That would not reduce the potential gap in 2 years.
What I would like to see in the accounts and it is something a resolution would seek is Can Celtic show in their accs the total football earnings, the total playing squad costs and the difference between the ceiling and what was spent and account for how any underspend on playing squad has been utilised.
That sort of approach seeking greater transparency will be more effective than sacking any Board member will acheive even when the current members are replaced.