They Embarrassed The Hoops


Morning, all.

When the champions visit a team who are joint bottom of the league with only six points and six goals from eight games, they don’t expect to come away with nothing. And in fairness, we didn’t come away with nothing. We came away with a good doing, one which embarrassed everyone connected with the club. And one which highlighted yet again the shortcomings of our board, our manager, and the players. 

MAHE usually writes the weekend match reviews, but the kick-off for this one is 4am in California. That’s something of an ungodly hour to expect someone to be up and about, alert enough to note down his thoughts on the game as it happens. So I volunteered to do the article, and he can watch the match when it is shown again on his provider.

I did what I normally do with reviews, noting down the important bits for later. I’ve decided not to bother putting them in this article. What’s the point, you all saw it. 

I believe that is now fourteen games that we have played. It is the SIXTH time we have drawn a blank. That is where our problems start, with the simple fact that we cannot score. But it isn’t quite as simple as that. We started with Yang and Tounekti wide, Iheanacho through the middle. Iheanacho was the best of them by a mile, but he should see no credit in  that. If I’d have been playing up front, I’d have been better than Yang and Tounekti. Yes, they were that bad, and not for the first time either. 

But that’s not to blame those players. They are nowhere near the level of the players that they were brought in to replace, it’s as simple as that. Most of our board were present yesterday, and the mediocrity that runs through the squad is down to them. Not the manager, and not the players for being there. The players aren’t good enough, and the board carry the can.

I’ve also seen many comments over the last eighteen months about high spend, and most of those players being on the bench. Stuff like-we’ve got £30m on the bench, ffs! Would these people prefer it if we only had eleven players who cost money, who all play every week, while our bench consists solely of free transfers and the occasional youngster? They are missing the point; this squad is poor, and the manager is having to make the best of it.

That’s not to say that I’m entirely in his camp, that I think he is blameless. Far from it. We have been rank since New Year, when we got our arses handed to us at Ibrox. Sure, the occasional flash of brilliance like Munich-but we all know it’s the hope that gets you in the end, not the despair. The manager has huge questions to answer about what he does with the players provided. My argument is that the players provided are not his fault, but they are his problem.

Can he explain why everyone on that pitch yesterday who has been with us for a while is so much worse than they have ever been? This is a manager who repeatedly tells us that his greatest strength is improving players, yet all of our personnel are pale shadows of themselves from only a year ago. Maybe it’s the mind-numbing tedium of The Horseshoe which is doing for them. If so, I wouldn’t blame them; it’s doing for a lot of us. Yet we still, despite all that, managed a whopping 23 attempts on goal yesterday, so we can’t truly say that we aren’t getting into shooting positions. But only three of those being on target probably tells you plenty. 

If not, here’s an example. Corner comes in from the left and is (weakly) headed out. CalMac is on the edge of the D, in acres of space. It is crying out for him to run in and hit it. He scored ten from distance only last season after all. Nope, he waited for it to come to him, took a touch and then shot. He needn’t have bothered, two defenders were on him before the shot had travelled a yard. That’s a player who is lacking confidence, even the confidence to do the things that he would normally do in his sleep. And it’s the same right through our side. 

The manager and the players need to take the few days before Graz arrive to sit down and talk some home truths. Why are the players performing so badly? Why are so many lacking in confidence? Why are they still playing the same dreary stuff that allows opponents to get eleven men behind the ball while we are still buggering about in the centre circle and going nowhere? Why are we so easy to hit on the counter? Why are our set pieces so bloody pathetic, whether that be defending them or attacking them? Why can’t we even take a bloody throw in any more, etc…

There are a lot of questions that these players and the manager need to find answers to, and quickly. We know that they have been shafted by the board, but this is nothing new. It’s been happening since Adam were a lad, but we’ve risen above it to win trophies at an unprecedented rate. We’ll win sod all this season if things don’t improve dramatically very very quickly. Lose at Tynecastle on Sunday and we will be EIGHT points behind. We won’t be able to get those eight points back, we will be relying on Hearts somehow blowing it and handing the eight points back to us. 

In trying to place how bad we are this season in the great post-Fergus pantheon, I can really only think of 09/10 and 20/21 as being worse. We know the board CGAF, they have their placemen to hide behind when the blame is being handed out. It’s the manager and the players that we need to fix this. And if I’m honest with you, I think they’re all out of ideas. 

I think I might tell MAHE to set his alarm clock early for next Sunday. 

<><><><><>
Above article by BMCUWP

156 Comments
BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 20, 2025 12:27 am

Our donations page for McMillan Cancer Care has now closed,having raised almost £1700 plus Gift Aid. Thank you to everyone who was a part of this, you are all wonderful and generous people.

That’s over £6000 in eighteen months, and you should rightfully feel significant pride in that.
Our new charity campaign will begin immediately, and as ever, it will be for a charity of your choice. Nominated via these pages, and chosen as the most worthy by our contributors.

It is Chidren’s Hospices Across Scotland (CHAS). Nominated by BAWHEID, and overwhelmingly the landslide winner of the vote. We have just reached our first target of £1000, and you can help us reach our next one.

£1888

You can donate by following this link, as set up by CHALMERSBHOY (and grateful thanks once again for doing so!)

https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinel-celts-2?utm_medium=FA&utm_source=EM

There is a default payment method by ApplePay, which I don’t use. Just click ”change” above the payment bar to view other options.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 20, 2025 12:28 am

I can proudly inform you all that Sentinel Celts members are amongst the

TOP 15% OF DONORS 

to JustGiving in September.

Well done to everyone concerned.

👏 🍾 ⭐️

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 20, 2025 12:29 am

Link to POTY Competition.

sencelpoty@gmail.com

mike in Toronto
October 20, 2025 12:36 am

Great volley for 2-0

mike in Toronto
October 20, 2025 12:40 am

Saw an interview recently with Graeme Sounness. He was talking about his first week and first game with Liverpool. Said there were no tactical discussions in the build up to the game, so he went to ask JoeFagan what the tactics were. Fagan responded that ‘they didnt need to discuss tactics; GS was a professional footballer, so should know what he is to do on the pitch.’

English football has moved on since then. Not sure Scottish football has

mike in Toronto
October 20, 2025 12:45 am

Morocco break quick and in numbers. But, when they turn it over, they bomb back and get into position. All work really hard, and know where they are supposed to be. Impressive. Well coached.

mike in Toronto
October 20, 2025 1:21 am

Ronny Delia fired by Atlanta after one season. I can see Postecoglu ending up in the MLS

Mahe
October 20, 2025 1:31 am

I expect to wake up next Sunday, scroll through and discover a 3nil pumping.

Imo there’s only one way to fix this in the immediate term, draft in the cavalry and play the second string for the most part. If the usual suspects fail over the next two games it becomes a necessity to salvage something.

I also think if MacInnes wins the title he will head to Ibrox riding on the wave.

Auldheid
October 20, 2025 1:34 am

Pitymevin

 October 19, 2025 9:23 pm
ATOB its was a line Auldheid put on his post that the celtic collective need to look at themselves around communication.
So when the Collective go on about the lack of communication they should start by looking at themselves.

=====

The Collective represent the Celtic support or a large part of and my point was not about the Collective as a body, but everyone who moans and gripes about The Board and communication in particular, but did sweet fuck all to use the facility to improve communication. Did you ever use it to put your gripes to Celtic?
How many on SC have taken the trouble to use it?
Yet when a means of communication is offered and repeated at subsequent AGMs, it is not used. Is that down to The Board?
You were critical that Res12 did not deliver what would have made you happy, but I dont recall you being one of the shareholders I and the other 3 guys represented and consistently communicated with updates.

Where were the banners seeking action on Res12 or PLs denial of sight of the 5WA?

Why did some of those in the Collective who were not interested in support for better governance suddenly becoming champions of a cause that would not be necessary had the attempts at SFA reform and show PL up as a liar had their support at the time?

Reap what you sow includes the support.

Take responsibility for it.

My mistake was thinking enough supporters gaf about how Celtic and Scottish football were run when we were winning.

So grow up. Look in the mirror and think could I have done more to encourage unity to prevent the one thing I personally was foolish enough to think could be avoided, which is where we now stand- a house divided?

Now we are here I hope realisation dawns on both sides that a) they need to be honest with themselves for their part in perpetuating division and as a result start being honest with each other to end it.

It is in that basis I have not commented much but in your case Ive made an exception although nothing I can say will change your mind, but others reading might stop and think.

Am I for unity or division? Is what I am doing furthering what I seek?

I reached a long time ago the point IQVI (who was very very supportive of Res12 ) and Rebus 67 have reached, which is that Celtic were not the good guys I thought they were and are part of a wider enterprise corrupted by money to which I would provide no financial support, but would do what I could to rekindle my original belief that Celtic are the good guys.

bournesouprecipe
October 20, 2025 1:48 am

Pressley leaves Celts all shook up. 

Picked the side on Friday, but most Celtic fans could have, therefore we can’t really moan about the selection the format never varies, if you’re waiting for change, you might need to wait for Maloney, Kennedy, and Strachan the Development Brigade to giddy up as ‘caretakers’ till – heaven forbid, one of them jumps in the showers with the players.

The back line can’t change much, the middle can’t change much, and neither could the goals for column, when you don’t have a strike threat. Team Brendan is shot, ( not predictive text ) it’s all there is. We didn’t need the city of Discovery to find out Ralston, Scales, Tierney, Kenny, Yang, Nygren, Forrest, McCowan and Iheanacho aren’t featuring in a Celtic team to be feared, anytime soon. We also knew Hatate,CalMac and CCV were well jiggered, summertime Pimpernel third in the queue Michel-Ange ,wasn’t even ever good on YouTube and you know how well we rely on that channel?

These are the cards BR was dealt, for his terminado farewell year, nobody is playing well, we lost two simple goals, to a simple side, in a very familiar story. Tennis balls, hit the target of the national news and tickets for something now called “ group stage football “ that should have been plain Champions League are buffering again, with Tynecastle suddenly a new unwelcome to hell. 

Some players go too quick, some players have stayed too long, Neil Lennon part II deja vu, Brendan Rodgers part II deja vu, leave em danglin, it’s what they do. The first league loss, isn’t the boardroom sleepwalking, but the dividing the support definitely is. In fairness, no wonder they are tired, turning players for under £1.5M into £25M inside a couple of years, a right tough gig, the same as investment in Celtic, it seems. Much easier meantime to sit and watch the inevitability of bad football results land the buck on Brendan, who at least still has the grace to have his naughty press briefings, up front in public. Things won’t improve till you remove the root cause.

We’re caught in a trap. 

M.O.M 😀 CCV

Rebus67
October 20, 2025 3:04 am

Bourne,

I think it is more Heartbreak Hotel, n’est pas?

Well, since Fergus left me
Well, I found some shares to sell
Well, it’s down at the end of Kerrydale Street
At the Euro Package Hotel

Chorus

There I’ll be, I’ll be so wealthy, baby
Well, I’m so wealthy
I’ll be so wealthy, I need to lie.

Although the park is always crowded
We can always find some room
For waiting list losers
To wallow in the gloom.

Chorus

We’ll be so wealthy, baby
We’ll be so wealthy.
We’ll be so wealthy, we need to lie.

Now the CFO’s tears are flowin’
And the CEO is dressed in black
Well, the Chairman’s got so wealthy
He’ll never going to up track.

Hips gyrating. Hips gyrating!

====/==/=///

Extra curtesy of GI Blues:

And if you say goodbye
Then I think the club could die
Maybe my income would die!
Cause I don’t have a working head.

Rebus

Big Audio Dynamite
October 20, 2025 3:17 am

Let’s be honest, the team has been asset-stripped and left bereft of any real talent!

Sarachi captained Uruguay during the week, AJ is fit again, Yang before Forrest, our captain looking done, and although he also has received a bit of criticism of late, I’d hate to see where we’d be if CCV wasn’t in that backline! And please don’t start me talking about our overweight goalie! I can’t watch him make one more blunder, then search for someone to blame to cover his embarrassing lack of mobility and talent!

Fans don’t want to hear honesty from their manager either – Martin tried that and it was downhill from there! Players and fans are too sensitive to anything that doesn’t resemble constant back-slapping! If Brendan came on TV telling us everything was peachy we would be howling, so he’s not in a great position. Would the manager have sanctioned the sale of Kyogo (If he even had any input) if he knew what would follow?

We are experts at selling anyone who shows a bit of talent for more than 5 games, and amateurs when it comes to closing deals for like-for-like replacements. Since Ange went south, recruitment has gone south with him!

We appear to be sleep-walking into what would be our biggest league disaster since ..erm, our last one!

As ever, we don’t crack on from a position of strength, and the memory of holding our own in Munich is fading fast! As I’ve been saying since tipping Hearts to be in the CL mix this season, if we don’t quickly recognise there’s a threat, it may be too late by the time we do.

In today’s football there’s generally one answer to these types of problems …SPEND, SPEND, SPEND!

Imagine how radical it would be if we attempted to put the best team onto the pitch that our bank balance would allow, eh? Mind-blowing stuff!!

Wakey wakey, Celtic

Leggy
October 20, 2025 7:26 am

Morning all,

I’ve woken up ✅
I’m still a Celtic Supporter ✅
I still hate the Board ✅
I still hate the Huns ✅

Checklist complete.

I said yesterday watching Celtic, “ It’s like 11 players have been put together, not knowing each other and trying to play a formation they can’t understand “

Things must change with the Manager, players and backroom staff stepping up to the plate.

3 massive games coming up, so let’s see what you’re all made of Celtic 🍀🍀🍀🍀 ( Glass half full man )

In other subjects,

Rebus 3.04 – Absolutely brilliant 👋👋👋👋👋

Help MaBoab – Welcome to the site 💚

And finally Iniquitous,

Really saddened by your previous post. But, don’t you ever leave this site.

With BRRB donating to The Betty Ford Clinic and temporary out of action, this site is already a man down.

Wit, satire, Informative posts, laughter and humour, well what can I say,

Perhaps, if you could add these to your repertoire , well maybe you could rethink the decision of leaving 😁😁

Of course, you know I’m kidding and I’ll finish with this

”Please stay as your a top notch poster and good friend” 💚💚💚

HH 🍀🍀🍀

BAuldyin
October 20, 2025 7:45 am

morning BMCUWP, you certainly drew the the short straw having to watch the game and write about it, difficult to disagree with anything you wrote.
It’s not just the fans who’ve noticed the downsizing the players seem disillusioned by it also, add in the likes of Daizen who should be at the next team he’d agreed to join, all part explains the drop off in performances. The shooting way off target I have no answer for, they’re professional players but the heights some of them sent shots way over the bar is shocking and it wasn’t just the odd shot either. I think we’re so easy to counter attack partly due to CalMac, Nygren and Hatate ALL being unable to tackle, I can’t remember a more lightweight midfield in decades. It was noticeable that in the second half we started putting balls straight into the box while the first half we ruined every corner taking them short and messing up trying to create chances from them, the second half tactic wasn’t helped by having our best corners taker Engels on the bench until the game was nearly over. Your point about us relying on hearts to collapse like Aberdeen did last season rather than us making a better challenge is also valid. Below Brendan seems to have realised it can’t continue as is, we’ll see. I remember being told one of Steins great strengths was him finding systems to suit his players talents, whilst Rodgers is no Stein at least he sounds willing to try, even if he doesn’t sound like he knows which system would be best.
If only our fans had brought enough wee balls to last the 90 mins we’d have been spared that yesterday, I write this only half joking.

Rodgers

“I think the challenge from the summer, now leading into here, where we lost a lot of firepower, a lot of goals out on the team.“And there’s no way you’ll go into a race and be given the keys to a Honda Civic and say, ‘I want you to drive it like a Ferrari’. It’s not going to happen.“So until something changes, I have to find the solutions. Because like I said, goals, speed, everything has come out of the team and we need to find a way to be better.“It was clear in the summer, but it’s really the past now. There’s nothing we can do about it.“We had the opportunities to do what we needed to do. It didn’t happen, so now it’s finding ways, whether it’s 4-3-3, whether it’s 3-4-3, whether it’s 3-5-2. We’re trying to look at all these different permutations within the team.”

St tams
October 20, 2025 7:54 am

In the 29 competitive games that we’ve played since Munich in February, we have failed to win 13 of these games, frightening statistic.

The Gombeen Man
October 20, 2025 8:03 am

Mahe,

1) The GB, Bhoys and North Curve Celtic are front and centre of The Collective.

Members of the GB and Bhoys were clearly seen hurling missiles into the pitch yesterday. These guys will continually undermine The Collective. Given their prominence with the organisation, any act of violence by either group will be linked to the Collective.

– The GB and Bhoys are now my only a problem for Celtic but they are an issue for The Collective.

2) Is there a proposal within the Collective to establish a Register of Celtic Social Media sites?

There needs to be a complaints mechanism put in place in respect of social media sites that publish material that lacks veracity and might be described as “clickbait”.

The “the ends justifies the means” mindset that so undermined the Res12 era and the association with Charlotte Fakes cannot be allowed to undermine The Collective.

Awe Naw,

Will I file your comments about Celtic never playing in the CL again with the ones about the ‘proposed’ US takeover at Ibrox being “bullshit”?

Anyway,

– Not only the Celtic Ultras undermined decent supporters yesterday. Brendan Rodgers has been gaslighting the support for months. He’s been working his ticket since the Bayern game.

I’ve highlighted for months his failings in the transfer market at Liverpool and Leicester. His predictable tactics and lack of a Plan B.

His mé féiner outlook his turned the squad into a complete mess.

It took Jürgen Klopp 2 years to straighten out Liverpool after Brendan left
Leicester are still struggling.

Hopefully his luxury club motor has been replaced by a Honda Civic this morning.

God help the poor unfortunates in the club shops who face uncertain futures, primarily down to the Manager’s lack of ability and arrogance.

– Bada Bing,

Who told you that it was Michael Nicholson who made the decision to call Yang back?

Do you have any information on specific players that Brendan Rodgers refused during transfer Window?

– Do you think that it’s likely that contemporaneous notes were kept of conversations with Brendan during the Window?

– I’m sure that’ll become clear during the Review.

Have a great day everyone.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 20, 2025 8:10 am

Of course the club/board have their placemen everywhere ..and that includes here, every popular Celtic site online and probably leading the collective. Are the collective’s actions making any sense to anyone? Will sitting in silence or throwing tennis balls bring about the removal of our board? Anyone who believes that is a few French fries short of a happy meal!

Those you might believe are speaking/acting on your behalf, are probably the very same people working to make sure their masters stay in power until THEY decide when they want to go! And when they do eventually go, they will only be replaced by people cut from the very same cloth!

The very same as the switcheroo that took place in the 90s, even though some still believe that the old family dynasties were replaced by people who only wanted to save Celtiic.

Yeah, sure!

Again I’m staggered at the naivety being shown here. The only power we actually hold here is the power to decide to take part or not, but we certainly don’t possess the power to remove those that currently hold it at Parkhead.

This is why I am always wary of those online who continually suggest you have ways of challenging the status quo. Then there’s the fact they start out looking/sounding anti-board, only to eventually let the mask slip and prove which side they were really on all along!

They are fucking snakes, not to be trusted in anything they say! They are complete enemies of the best fans in planet earth!

BAuldyin
October 20, 2025 8:15 am

Right, now I’ll try to distract you with good news, my son’s fine after his fight which he won with the referee ending it in the second round to stop Jakes opponent taking further punishment. Since Jakes first fight his stamina and core strength have noticeably improved, his training covering both in the run up to the fight, Jake took two huge haymaker punches to the head in quick succession but remained on his feet AND still fighting, bhoys got some jaw but I’ll be having a word about his defence soon. I took him to Middlesbrough for the fight and he was noticeably calm and quietly confident as he’d put the training in and knew he couldn’t have prepared much better, he also spent less time in the sauna to make the MMA lightweight 70.5kg on Friday morning and by Saturday lunchtime was back up to 76.5kg. I left him and his friends straight after the fight as I’m not a fan of MMA and it took a few beers for my heart to return to a normal beat. Jakes fight gym will have ten professionals next year which can only help Jakes progress as, even if he’d lost he intends to keep fighting. Bhoy told me to pass on his thanks to S.Celts for your messages of encouragement which I also endorse, I’ll let you know when he fights next.
P.S. Luckily for Jake I’ve had to give his ST to a cousin as Jake just can’t get up for many games, probably just as well as I’m not sure his fighting confidence could take watching us at the minute, Hail, hail …
Oh and fuckin Middlesbrough, covered in england and butchers apron flags, I won’t be rushing back there.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 20, 2025 8:22 am

TGM

If Gerrard didn’t slip v Chelsea, do you really think any Liverpool fan would have given a fuck about BR’s signings? No they wouldn’t!

I might be wrong, but hasn’t he also won more trophies for Leicester than anyone in their history?

And ..

Outside of Jock, have we ever had a manager that’s been as successful as Brendan? Have we EVER had a manager who normalised the winning of doubles and trebles?

I heard him tell us and the world what we needed X100, and yet the board done absolutely nothing to strengthen the team in the summer, and in fact they have made us much weaker!

Hoop hoop hooray
October 20, 2025 8:22 am

Hope Brendan had a comfortable ride to work in his Honda civic this morning. It’s Steven pressley I feel sorry for. Bloody cold out there going to work on his second hand bike.

If we had been playing Bayern Munich again those post match comments would have been thoroughly relevant given the shambles of the summer. When we are playing the worse team in the league it is utter deflection and was the last straw for me.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 20, 2025 8:29 am

“God help the poor unfortunates in the club shops who face an uncertain futures, primarily due to the manager’s lack of ability and arrogance ”

Just wow! I’ve read some hysterical nonsense in my time but this takes the biscuit and the whole cake!

October 20, 2025 8:44 am

TGM,

There will be a few more fake overs at Ibrox before we play CL football again.

Glad you agreed with all my other points. That’s encouraging from the man who never gets anything wrong

You’ll be toddling off again soon for sure anyway. Catch you next week xx

October 20, 2025 8:48 am

Gerrard and Muscat said Non.

Thelwill needs to learn to lie like the Celtic board.

October 20, 2025 8:49 am

The boards mouthpieces are in fine voice this morning.

Ignore the noise.

Their goal is to frustrate and to exasperate.

Thus maintaining the status quo.

Stop giving the board your money.

That will get them out.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 20, 2025 8:55 am

Awe naw,

I believe Brendan will be the last manager we have who openly challenges the board to match his Euro ambitions for the club

We will get Russell Martin type appointments from here.

All those who are screaming for him to be replaced will have gotten what they want, but Scotland will be the height of our ambitions from then on!

We’ll certainly be the only Scottish club to lose while holding £100m in the bank!!

October 20, 2025 9:01 am

If Hearts win their next three games, they will be a minimum of 11 points clear of Celtic.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 20, 2025 9:03 am

Star,

Like I say, they are everywhere online ..nothing is ever left to chance ..every base is always covered!

Slowly but surely people are waking up to who they are. Took a while, but better late than never.

October 20, 2025 9:11 am

BAD,

The board missed a trick with regards to authorizing the project to purchase a virtual square foot of Celtic Park with accompanying pdf file. They should have made it an exclusive virtual square inch of a board members arse to kiss. Price off arse in direct proportion to position and percentage of shareholding. Would sell like hot cakes for those emotionally attached Celtic fans who have more of an eye on the share price than the league table. Maybe a daily fee for each time it’s to be kissed with a 500 quid badge for a 10 quid fee to be worn proudly for all to see

Auldbhoy67
October 20, 2025 9:18 am

Croker (who I very seldom listen to) hit the nail firmly on the head yesterday with two comments.
“Last season at this point Celtic had 39 goals this season 20 -they also scored 10 goals inside 1st 25 mins but this season ZERO. ”
Thats what you get when the greedy barstewards of a board sell all your forward line and leave you with trash.
The best manager in world football would find it hard to get wins . BR isnt faultless but Jesus Christ hes no where near being totally to blame either. Some folk maintain he has spent more money than any manager in our history. Thats because they cost more now for any quality. A 650k Henrick is playing u15 football. We are all spending more just to go to the game. Buses -trains -tickets have all doubled or more since the MON era . The cost of players imho is a non relevance IF you want success. Look at Liverpool at present. Spent 450million take a moment to really think how much that is but have lost their last 4. Dont hear anyone shouting for Slots head. Price doesnt gaurantee wins . Barca have turned out teams this season with 7 ex academy players on show and that is where the success of real clubs SHOULD be started. We as a club are stratospheres away from being anywhere near these elite teams now. A sad fact but a true one.
Our B team are faltering and even our Ladies team manager is complaining about lack of investment after they won their league recently.

Auldbhoy67
October 20, 2025 9:24 am

San Luis
If Hearts do go 11 points clear then they deserve it. They have invested in a few decent players and not sat back on their fat arses feeding off the support. Thats what boards who want progression tend to do .
No one can blame them for their current success whether you like or dislike them.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 20, 2025 9:27 am

THEGOMBEENMAN

“There needs to be a complaints mechanism put in place in respect of social media sites that publish material that lacks veracity”

Consider that comment in light of those you regularly make on here, particularly about our manager. How many times have you been corrected about the half-truths, selective interpretations, and downright lies that you have written on here about him?

One of your comments was apparently mentioned on a podcast the other day (as told to me by MAHE on Saturday) as the type of misinformation that the board are pushing! I hope you’re bloody pleased with yourself about that one. Cos I’m not.

This site was set up to give supporters a voice, one where they can express their opinions about everything good or bad about the club. While my own thoughts on most issues are an open book, I have no problem reading the opinions of others who disagree, and indeed I sometimes come round to that point of view as a result. I hope others have had that experience too. What will NOT persuade me in any way is someone with an agenda whose only weapon is a quiver full of poison arrows and lies.

I’m disappointed in you, mate. Genuinely.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 20, 2025 9:30 am

BAULDYIN

Congratulations to proud father and son combo! I’m delighted for you both. Particularly that Jake has a strong chin, it sounds like he needed it. Good luck working on the defence.

October 20, 2025 9:34 am

The decline began in earnest at the start of this calendar year. In truth it started way before that, but on terms of results and our Manager losing his magic touch it’s the telling turn of events.

In that time his league record reads.
Played 28, won 18, drawn 5 and lost 5. A 64% success rate. Not champions form.

His record v the Huns in that time is a 0% win rate v Barry and Martin included and taking it back a bit further to the start of 2024 it reads a 16%win rate. Very Poor.

Europe does not read much better. Our sole success a late o.g v Young Boys. A 12.5% win rate. Shocking really.

Most of the teams we play have inferior players and resources. But , even yesterday, at Dundee, they appear to be coached better, and alarmingly, much fitter.

I blame the Board for most things wrong at Celtic, but not the inability to coach good players.

The Gombeen Man
October 20, 2025 9:35 am

Rodgers’ comment comparing our most expensive squad of players in our history to a Honda Civic was straight out of the David Brent playbook.

– It was so like the bumbling boss in the classic comedy The Office.

If you close your eyes you can almost picture David Brent making that comment behind the back of his staff to the film crew.

1) Who decided to sell Kyogo?
2) How was he playing under BR?
3) What players did BR reject?
4) Who decided to offer KT 50k pw over 5 years?
5) Who agreed to sign Adam Idah for £9m and then sell him at a loss 12 months later after scoring 20 goals?
6) Who decided to spend £12m on Arne Engels?
7) Who thought it was a good idea to give Trusty a reported £30k pw?
8) Who makes the decisions about tactics, player selections etc?

Etc, etc, etc.

– We have the most expensive squad and highest wage bill in our history.

Brendan Rodgers’ basic salary is a reported £3-4m a year. That’s EPL wages for an Scottish club.

Contemporaneous notes will have been made of all the decisions re-Onboarding and exiting of players.

He is delivering well below expectations and deflecting in the media.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 20, 2025 9:36 am

AULDBHOY 67

“even our Ladies team manager is complaining about lack of investment after they won their league recently.”

Seems our former Company Secretary is now responsible for the ladies team. As I said last night, I’d sue for constructive dismissal.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 20, 2025 9:42 am

Awe naw 9.11

Brilliant, buddy! 😁

Bored By The Board
October 20, 2025 9:45 am

Well, the great and powerful one has spoken and it was pretty much “Get Stuffed”. As I said yesterday the choice can now only be non attendance particularly to away games. A completely empty stand would have been far more embarrassing to the board than a handful of Pro V 1’s. The board will now sit hoping that we lose on Sunday and get papped out of the Cup by Sevco. They will sit and wait for the supporters to sack Rodgers. Rather than them dirty their cash stained hands.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 20, 2025 9:47 am

Gombeen,

He’s delivering well below who’s expectations?

I’ll take doubles and trebles EVERY YEAR for the rest of time.

Your board has left us all in danger of being losers this season – something Brendan has never experienced managing in Scotland!

I hope you are being well rewarded for your efforts!

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 20, 2025 9:47 am

Simple fact is that we are in big trouble. A dreadful position both on and off the pitch-but with an even bigger issue just around the corner.

Next summer will see us faced with the same scale of rebuild as in 2021, but without a Dom McKay, an Ange, or even the player sales to fund it.

Fan
October 20, 2025 9:49 am

BAD
This fan wants the coach to be honest with fans , stop with the Calimero persona and concentrate on coaching.
This decline since Munich has to be addressed.
BR should build fences with players he has maligned and stop picking his underperforming favourites.
Every player deserves a coach who views them in an even handed manner.
This season is a right off unless BR finds a way to create a team from squad he has.
The board parasites will not release funds to help so time for him to earn his large salary and show his worth.

October 20, 2025 9:52 am

BAD,

And their MO is the same. Half-truths, distortion, false accusations and misrepresentation. Then when called out on it fall back onto emotional blackmail.

I hope whatever benefit they’re getting is worth it.

Fan
October 20, 2025 9:56 am

BMCUWP
Maybe our boardroom geniuses have hatched a cunning plan with their Old Firm partner to have Tony Blooms Hearts win league in hope others see SPL as place to invest???
As our ambition is outwith Europe only a strong SPL will give them a chance of continuing profit without competence or effort.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 20, 2025 9:59 am

Fan,

I don’t think we have played well since before the cup final, Brendan has to take a large portion of responsibility for that, no doubt.

But between our haste to sell anyone for profit while taking all the goals out the team, the board has left a husk of a team because the Huns are in disarray. The manager wanted us to push on from Munich, but the board have done the exact opposite.

We all wanted our ambitions to stretch further than Govan, but the board have made it abundantly clear we can fucking forget that.

It’s a big shit sandwich, and it looks like we are all gonna have to take a bite! Be honest, we are backpedaling to try and meet the Huns again, aren’t we? It’s been blinding obvious for years.

Utterly sickening

Big Audio Dynamite
October 20, 2025 10:03 am

Star,

Still amazing that some seem incapable of seeing these snakes for what they are.

They are the real enemy within!

Never Celtic supporters in a million centuries. No, their own wee secret club comes before everything else, and everyone else!

Bored By The Board
October 20, 2025 10:05 am

When I read the statement from our board this morning I was reminded of another quote by Sun Tzu “An evil man will burn his own nation to the ground to rule over the ashes”

Hoop hoop hooray
October 20, 2025 10:15 am

I think the only solution I can see is a new ceo a new chairman and a new manager. They have all overstayed their welcome.

Tony Bloom is a smart guy. Made his millions from poker and professional gambling and playing the margins. Formed his Jamestown analytics which gave him such an edge he took Brighton from the depths of the 4th tier to a stable premiership club. Took USG from second tier in Belgium to the championship. He boldly stated at the start of the season he would split the big 2 in Scotland. He probably thought that one or other of us could implode. Rodgers in his final year unbacked or the uncertainty of the Ibrox takeover. He has won a watch with a dual implosion, He must be praying the hun go for Mcinnes so he can get in his own man. Then we could all be in trouble, Oh for that level of intellect and foresight at parkhead.

McCaff
October 20, 2025 10:32 am

Bored…was a statement made by the Board yesterday/today?

Bored By The Board
October 20, 2025 10:51 am

McCaff
Majority shareholder Dermot Desmond will not make any changes to the Celtic hierarchy amid rising anger from the support while the meeting between the Celtic Fan Collective and CEO Michael Nicholson and CFO Chris McKay was a “token gesture”. (Daily Record)
Quote on the BBC website this morning regarding token gestures is enough “Bugger off” for me.
Sadly, anyone looking for change at the top are farting against thunder.

JimDom
October 20, 2025 10:52 am

From the suits, to the manager, to the players, Celtic appears to be a very unhappy place of work right now. An organisation at war with itself.

Who has the power to step in and end the feuding ? Perceived wisdom would point to Dermot Desmond, the guy who makes all the so-called big calls.

Optional big call A would be to sack BR and back all the current execs and NED’s. Appoint Maloney (or AN compliant Other) on an interim basis, and just see how it goes until the end of the season.

Optional big call B would be to back BR, sack Nicholson, and instruct a couple of NED’s to retire. But probably not Lawwell.

Optional big call C would be ………………………..that’s anyone’s guess ?

The status quo cannot be allowed to continue.

The Annual Report and date of the AGM would normally have been released and announced by now. What’s the reason for the hold up ?

bournesouprecipe
October 20, 2025 10:55 am

Rebus67
October 20, 2025 3:04 am

—————————

Played 👏

—————————-

Leggy

 October 20, 2025 7:26 am

—————————

Played 👏