Junction ahead

It’s funny, there’s nothing like a crisis to bring everyone together, then again, there’s nothing like a quality side to get everyone dreaming and off their ass. Whether that’s to the Superstore, the ticket office, or the humble Supporters club, and of course every fixture doable.

 

A quality side we aren’t and during my daily Tim podcasts today (excellent work recently from all the fan media) nearly all agreed we are not looking at 2 wins. I wrote the other day how much this block of games would define us,,but that was prior to our latest defeat. An opener that went awful. Most of todays views, even having slept on it, were of the opinion ‘this has to end’.
Be that players selected, tactics, mentality,,,for everyone’s sake something’s gotta give.
Usually, in that situation, the manager goes, and a month ago I would have thought that unthinkable, and I’m not on the ground, but a broad spectrum had clearly had enough of what they are being forced to watch.

 

Instead of launching into a defense of Brendan, rather than slamming the board, I’m gonna ponder on the players for a moment.
Two things can be true at once, as much as a good boardroom makes a good club, a good dressing room makes a good team.
I’m not gonna throw individuals under the bus but rather throw a question out there.
Are they collectively desperate, absolutely dedicated, to winning trophies for/at Celtic?
Hand on heart it’s hard to say yes as a group and the wisdom of time tells me that it’s common for players who have been there, seen it and done it, to ease off.

 

There’s a reason why Paul Mc Stay and Roy Keane are legends, they never lost the spark, the fight, the sheer will to win. Our mainstay are winding down, surely pretty wealthy, and with medals galore from those doubles and trebles. Our prodigal son must manage his body over the team.performance. Whenever viewed through the prism of real hunger to do well at the club is it any wonder the two leading the scoring charts and the POTY chart (Nygren and Scales) are not over the hill mainstays? No offense to those who delivered BTW. Is that (cannot be bought) drive not the reason AJ was spoken of as a future Captain? And KT? I believe one piece of advice Jock gave Fergie was never let a team grow old together. Those words are echoing. They’re maybe not all late 30’s, but in modern day football you’ve generally given your best by 28. In road terms there’s lots of miles on that dressing room clock.
A lot of them have been around the block quite a few times.

 

It’s funny but “is the hunger there” is a question that could be asked of every single shareholder/director/employee.
But then again, where should that drive come from? Yup, the head down, just a fish rots.

 

It increasingly feels like the end of a cycle, and we want our hunger back.
100 million and Im worried not excited, forced through devotion and duty to fret over the pitch and boardroom?
That’s the sport we fell in love with eh?

 

By Mahe

145 Comments
Mahe
October 22, 2025 5:32 am

Our donations page for McMillan Cancer Care has now closed,having raised almost £1700 plus Gift Aid. Thank you to everyone who was a part of this, you are all wonderful and generous people.

That’s over £6000 in eighteen months, and you should rightfully feel significant pride in that.
Our new charity campaign will begin immediately, and as ever, it will be for a charity of your choice. Nominated via these pages, and chosen as the most worthy by our contributors.

It is Chidren’s Hospices Across Scotland (CHAS). Nominated by BAWHEID, and overwhelmingly the landslide winner of the vote. We have just reached our first target of £1000, and you can help us reach our next one.

£1888

You can donate by following this link, as set up by CHALMERSBHOY (and grateful thanks once again for doing so!)

https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinel-celts-2?utm_medium=FA&utm_source=EM

There is a default payment method by ApplePay, which I don’t use. Just click ”change” above the payment bar to view other options.

October 22, 2025 7:52 am

The team has no bottle under BR. 8 times this year we’ve went 2 goals down against all levels of team and lost every single one of them . No great fightbacks to even draw games, nope, we’ve lost the lot.

That tells me everything I need to know about this weak minded team. This is not the stuff of Celtic legend. Far from it and BR is not the type of Manager to inject steel and fortitude into them.

BAuldyin
October 22, 2025 8:46 am

The malaise in the dressing room can also be pointed at our boards recruitment, if fans can see the downsizing so can the players, not to excuse their lack of fire as they’re supposed to be professionals, Rodgers takes his share of the blame for fielding a powder puff midfield with not a tackle between the three of CalMac, Hatate and Nygrens, add players who should have been allowed to leave and it’s a toxic mix that we’re seeing on the park.

Fan
October 22, 2025 8:49 am

Watching Champions league games brought a stark realisation of our coaching failings at every level.
From youth to seniors there’s little evidence of coaching to play in modern game.
Against Dundee both McGregor and Nygren received a pass with chance to shoot on edge of box! Neither did and both passed ball on as their body was not set in position to shoot.Likemost of our players their body was in a negative position.
Last night PSG youngster Duie scored a goal that was about skill and technique.
He received ball in crowded box and with one touch moved ball to his left foot shot across goalie before anyone could defend.
Amazing in its skillful simplicity.
Watched teams hold shape, deny and create space because of good coaching.
We at no point seem to have much structure or ability to put our bodies in correct position to defend or attack,
It begs the question of what coaching our players receive at every level???

The Gombeen Man
October 22, 2025 8:51 am

“If you listen to fools, the Mob Rules.”

Ronnie James Dio’s words have been rattling about my consciousness for a couple of weeks…

This topic is highly emotional stuff I tend not to get involved in chat online. In the past I’ve got involved in spats that I’ve regretted.

If I do make a personal comment, hopefully it’s directed to an individual who is a veteran of blog ‘banter’.

Nobody at home pays much attention to my ramblings, anyone who reads this is wise to follow suit 

Anyhoo,

The ad hominem nature in the apparent strategy employed by supporters of The Collective has been counter-productive.

Over recent weeks I’ve ventured into the territory of Celtic media. Some of the content I’ve watched has been extremely poor.

Leaving the material that goes into the area of the defamatory aside…

# There’s a failure to offer the bigger picture. – To pursue the whole truth. There’s a tendency to present half the story, only certain facts are often recorded. 

Leaving out awkward facts and the lack of an open mind are fatal.

– Much appears to be agenda driven. 

Unfortunately the content of a number of the posts yesterday was disappointing. The aggressive tone adopted in the language used is undermining The Collective.

I couldn’t care less about anything written about me online. The violent tone and labelling simply highlights a perception that robust scrutiny and appropriate due diligence of The Collective will be resisted.

– All members of the Steering Group should be subject to appropriate due diligence. The Celtic Trust know why.

– If the violent tactics continue The Collective will lose support.

Anyway…

– Targeting employees of the club by possibly unfair and aggressive means based on assumptions or perceived personal characteristics is bullying.

For example, the following was posted yesterday…

“The disruption at Dundee is specifically targeted at MN, our mild mannered CEO who, it has been revealed, hates it when the TV cameras are trained on him.”

– Going after an individual because it’s believed he doesn’t like to be on camera, isn’t on. Apart from being un-Celtic like behaviour, there is a variety of possibilities in relation to the individual concerned.

– There is a whole number of possibilities that might be known to the Club, that isn’t in the public domain.

Speaking very generally targeting people in the workplace due to perceived vulnerabilities is wrong on numerous levels.

If a Celtic employee was targeted in this way by The Collective, it’s unacceptable.

Folk in their place of work are entitled to be treated with dignity.

– Secondly, when the salary of employees is discussed. It’s disappointing that the breakdown of basic salary, pension contribution, car allowance and bonus payment rarely gets mentioned.

In my experience what we read is invariably the cumulative figure. It’s variable, not fixed.

– This is an example of a failure to present the full picture. An attempt to construct an unfair narrative.

– The bonus payment for senior employees at Celtic moved to an annual payment from a 3 year scheme.

– For the CEO, it moved from a system primarily based on CL qualification to criteria related to profitability and sustainability objectives.

(This may have been as a result of testing by auditors and a concern about the possibility of moral hazard. There was also public disquiet about the perceived quantum of a 3 year bonus payment.

# A further concern about the potential unfair targeting of a Celtic employee…

– Was it agreed before the recent meeting between The Collective and Celtic that body language would be recorded in the notes?

– I’ve read numerous accounts of best practices in recording of minutes and it appears to me that body language isn’t recommended.

– If it was agreed that body language was to be recorded, why was the perceived body language of only one individual at the meeting recorded?

– What are the qualifications of the individual recording the minutes in this area?

– Instead of targeting individuals stick to the (apparently) accepted facts :

“It was interesting to note in the minutes from Celtic’s Executive meeting with the CSA on 5 September 2025 that there was comment from one of the points of discussion – a rebuild of the main stand is “not viable while we remain in the SPFL.”

Celtic Star.

# If this comment is accurate why is a rebuild “not viable”.

– Where are the numbers?
– What assessments have been done.

UEFA’s FSR is really flagship capitalism.

– Onboard as many new supporters/customers as possible.

– Figure out ways to increase your share of the supporter’s wallet.

– Reduces costs.

The SPFL has been largely uncompetitive since 2012. Competition is a key component of capitalism. 

Elite football is a jewel in the crown of capitalism.

The SPFL is of marginal interest to global broadcasting networks. We’re at a huge financial disadvantage in terms of domestic broadcasting income…and the potential to onboard new supporters.

Our recruitment in Asia isn’t only attempting to recruit talent at lower cost but also improve our exposure outside of Scotland.

It might be the case that the frustrations and inefficiencies that are perceived by many are the direct result of the lack of serious domestic competition.

Our domination has undermined us on and off the pitch. The lack of competitive league fixtures is undermining us. Is buying a couple of players every year is the solution?

There is an assumption that only 50% of transfers will be deemed as a success in senior football.

(I haven’t checked but I’d be interested to look at the value of our squad in all of those qualifiers we’ve lost under Brendan, Neil, Ronny etc…)

Might it be the case that we’ve consistently lost to sides that cost less than the Celtic team/squad?

– Is the lack of competitive football also undermining us? How do we address that? With the other factors like recruitment, youth policy, coaching etc.

It’s a trifle ironic that the perceived staleness is possibly down to a lack of competition.

The term The Collective has an unfortunate Orwellian ring to it. Who’d of thought that one club dominating could lead to inefficiencies and staleness?

Are we about to see the GB and Bhoys become converts to free market capitalism?

Till later, busy in Glasgow.

Granny Macs Bhoy
October 22, 2025 8:57 am

Too many players lack the attributes that the manager has been asking for over the last 2 years. Quality, Pace & Strength. The way things are going this will probably still be the case when the new manager comes in. For me, we don’t seem to have moved forward enough on recruitment since we signed James McCarthy. Our assessment of future targets should also be including players attitude/game sense e.g. when to commit a yellow card foul on the halfway line to stop a dangerous transition like the weekend. Shouldn’t be difficult for a world class club.

16 roads
October 22, 2025 9:48 am

The official online shop has improved drastically, I’ll give them credit for this.

It took years, and years to get there.

Everything is slow you see, half hearted.

All they care about is the balance sheet,at the end of the day.

The last thing they should be taking for granted.

Celtic supporters are most faithful, however even their patience is wearing thin.

Hoop hoop hooray
October 22, 2025 9:57 am

Great points Mahe

Something isn’t right.
it could be any of the following or a combination of the following.

1) Lack of top talent in the summer having our mainstays feel let down as they have been weakened
2) Some players having transfer promises broken
3) Players feeling undermined as not good enough by managers comments
4) Players being frozen out as not good enough by manager when in fact they might be collateral in an ego battle of manager signings and board signings. These players include someone good enough to start in CL for Man City last season. The two Japanese players have disappeared off the radar despite early promise.
5) Loyalty to certain players who fail to perform week in week out.
Or it might be the whole negative cloud around the club affecting the team.

If we win these next two games and the semi that cloud might lift but things have gotten so bad I believe it will only lift with change. Both in the boardroom and in the managers office.

October 22, 2025 9:58 am

Gombeen

As a rule your posts back the Board/ Club but generally find a way to insult, condemn and undermine the support , indeed your tone treats said support with the same contempt our Directors do.

I’m with the paying customers on this one. We have Leadership not fit for purpose.

Change is coming.

Chris
October 22, 2025 9:59 am

Gombeen Man
What you have said roughly translates to ‘..you malcontents leave us poor wee souls on the board alone. How dare you throw tennis balls on a pitch or show us on the tv..’
Also, you say the board are maybe being targeted personally..’maybe’..means your warped imagination is in overdrive.
No surprise really after the bullshit you came out with over FSR and staff in club shops.
C’mon, give everyone a laugh and tell everyone about European tax laws like your pal Michael.
Incidentally, I don’t believe for a second that you are this stranger in a foreign land who has came to Glasgow to spend loads of money in club shops to help protect jobs😝!!!
As you have a habit of lying, i think you are a placeman for the board and are on here backing your pals like a number of like minded lackeys have been doing.
Well your idols days are numbered and change is coming.

Hoop hoop hooray
October 22, 2025 10:06 am

There is so much wrong in the world just now that is quite terrifying and makes my blood boil. Celtic should be a release from all that, Looking forward to the next game, reading fan media, listening to podcasts etc is part of that release. It is a joyless place right now.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 22, 2025 10:33 am

TGM,

Un-Celtic like behaviour??

You mean like telling us that Rangers didn’t die?? Telling us all the money we input goes straight back into the team on the park? Openly lying to the fans and treating us with utter contempt? Going behind our own manager’s back to try to undermine him? And on and on and …

That kind of Un-Celtic like behaviour!?

I take it you were also happy to go along with the big lie, eh? Quite happy to help try and resurrect a dead club that brazenly cheated us for years, and also stood by sniggering as we appeared to be going out of existence? A club that wouldn’t have lied for us! A club that would quite happily have crushed us out of existence!

That kind of Un-Celtic like behaviour?

How about selling all our best players and replacing them with vastly inferior players, then leaving a husk of a team who can’t beat Hearts right now? …

Oh, my mistake, that’s very much Celtic like behaviour!!

October 22, 2025 10:34 am

Remember folks, they’ll use lies and misinformation to sow discord.

They’ll try and drag you into a tit for tat with long screeds of text to make a site difficult/tedious to navigate (flooding)

And they’ll use emotional blackmail to try and make you look bad for calling them out on it.

Their goal is to frustrate and exhaust to maintain the status quo which benefits them and their masters.

It’s quite easy to spot when you know how.

Keep your money in your pocket. That will get them out.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 22, 2025 10:59 am

The only group of people who’ve remained true to what Celtic were supposed to be are the fans.

Lads like McCaff and his son, that’s REAL Celtic!

If Lawwell, Nicholson and Desmond stopped earning a fortune from the club tomorrow, you really think they’d be back on Friday?? They’d be outa here as fast as their private jets could take them!

This current mob blew it when they tried to tell us it was just the company that died … their lackeys are still calling them NEWCO to this day

As far as I’m concerned, there ain’t a single one of you that can call yourselves Celtic fans. Imagine bending over for the Huns and then trying to claim “I’m a real Celtic man”

Be thankful I’m not in charge, you’d be turned away at the bottom of the carpark!

Big Audio Dynamite
October 22, 2025 11:02 am

Star,

They actually want our manager to fail.

Try getting your head round that kind of thinking .

Chris
October 22, 2025 11:08 am

Gombeen Man
What is in it for you to come on frequently to spout a pile of shite?
Are you on the Celtic board or are you a close friend of a director?
What motivates you to do this?
What is your end game?
There is another site where the board lackeys like yourself all contribute.
The guy that runs it actually makes up lies in order to have pathetic digs at Brendan, but he’s been rumbled several times and called out for it.
Are you Burnley78 from CQN?

bournesouprecipe
October 22, 2025 11:22 am

Looking forward to tomorrow maybe a blessing we’re not in the CL.

The loss of AJ to injury, and Greg Taylor for KT nostalgia, has been enormous for the back four, we’ll likely be looking to sell AJ for the stash, and searching for a left back punt as per usual next summer unless permanent loanee Adam Montgomery returns. We haven’t a Saracchi option to buy clause. 

The midfield was shot even last season, Nygren hasn’t really improved matters, in any big game especially, CalMac is weary Hatate was always hit or miss, at the moment it’s miss.

Bernardo has regressed, and never took his chances, expect BR to try him again verse Sturm Graz because it’s Europe. For breaking up the regular three, we only really have Engels and McCowan. 

The loss of Jota led to Tounekti who looked good because he’s the only player in the squad that takes in his man on, the same happened with Kuhn, double banking lessens the threat and SPL teams soon get it – still £18M for the stash. Quite why you buy two wide left players may well never be explained, when we had Maeda retained Yang retained and Jota to comeback?

With zero quality central strikers signed in the last two windows but two sold, the sudden necessity of a free agent and promotion of Johnny Kenny, means  it’s not looking good for the Hoops, or silk purses from sows ears. 

Shrugs Shoulders CSC 

October 22, 2025 11:41 am

BAD,

It’s disgusting, quisling behaviour.

Sadly, they walk amongst us.

McCaff
October 22, 2025 11:47 am

I’ve not watched this but did listen to the preview. It’s a free podcast on the Celtic Underground site. I listened to the preview which was released last week and it sounded good. So, if you’ve got any interest in what’s happening, or not, at the Academy this should give a bit of an insight into what’s going on.

If video isn’t working there’s a “switch to audio” button to the left of the screen.

https://thecelticunderground.substack.com/p/celtic-academy-pathway-or-pathetic?utm_source=podcast-email&publication_id=2631292&post_id=176641830&utm_campaign=email-play-on-substack&utm_content=watch_now_button&r=f40h1&triedRedirect=true&utm_medium=email&initial_medium=audio

St tams
October 22, 2025 12:31 pm

Chris , as ive said before, you’re better scrolling by that clowns posts.

Big Audio Dynamite
October 22, 2025 12:42 pm

Star,

As you can clearly see, they won’t be happy until the Huns are back cheating and winning again, that’s what this has all been about over the last decade and a half.

our manager’s record of 20+ wins and 3 defeats is obviously just getting in the way of their preferred outcome, the renewal of the old firm duopoly.

Have another read at what’s been written just today, nonsense about how our dominance is actually not good for us, and how we really need stronger competition …

Translation – We need a strong hun team.

That lodge they are all members of trumps everything else! Constantly calling them NEWCO tells you all you need to know.

Margaret McGill
October 22, 2025 1:00 pm

After reading TGM today I suggest any more official meetings between Celtic FC representatives and Celtic Supporters (e.g. the collective) are videotaped and end all this minutes nonsense.
But then Michael Nicholson’s a poowir wee soul who doesnt like being filmed even when he’s at the games. Awwwww.bring a tear to a glass eye.

Bada Bing
October 22, 2025 1:16 pm

Maeda missed training again

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 22, 2025 1:24 pm

MAGS

“But then Michael Nicholson’s a poowir wee soul who doesnt like being filmed even when he’s at the games.”

Well, it’s the right time of year for him. Hallowe’en season. Maybe he can buy a CEO mask.

October 22, 2025 2:14 pm

BAD it’s pathetic. I would welcome genuine ie non-corrupt, competition from any club in Scotland. Sadly we know one club above all others will get help from every quarter. And the other clubs will get everything going to help stop Celtic. I used to believe it was us vs the rest of them. It seems I was wrong.

October 22, 2025 2:15 pm

If the CEO of Celtic doesn’t like publicity then he could always look for a job with a much lower profile.

Margaret McGill
October 22, 2025 2:27 pm

https://thecelticstar.com/neil-lennon-pipes-up-for-dermot-desmond-and-peter-lawwell/

Neil. GTF out of the showers! You’ll catch your death.They’re no coming.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 22, 2025 3:41 pm

MAGS

Where’s Tony Perkins when you need him?

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 22, 2025 4:04 pm

Possible that AJ might be fit for tomorrow? Fit enough for a start?

bournesouprecipe
October 22, 2025 4:09 pm

Stats…..Stats…..we don’t need no steenkin Stats

Since Kairat, we’ve played 11 games and won 4.

We’ve failed to score in 6 of those 11 games.

We’ve failed to score in the first half in 9 of those 11 games.

We required an injury time winner to win 2 of the 4 games we won.

Hearts, Hibs, Dundee United, and Motherwell have scored more goals than us in the league. We are tied with Kilmarnock.

@ Bada Bing

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 22, 2025 4:27 pm

BSR

I’m minded to delete that. Cos it’s depressing the life out me.

A thing of beauty
October 22, 2025 4:34 pm

BSR,
Bada’s stats confirm what we already know. This formation is not working. As I said on Sunday, if BR is staying as he says he is, then he needs to put the petted lip away and find a formation that gets more out the players he has. I’d like to try 3-5-2 tomorrow. It’s a free shot after all because we are doing nowt in the Europa league.
Sinissalo
CCV Trusty KT
Donovan Engles McGregor Balakwishi scarrachi
Ineahacho Kenny
It can’t be any worse than this horseshoe shit football we’ve been watching since Bayern. Plus every team in Scotland now knows how to play against us. Cmon Brendan, give yourself a shake and show us you’ve still got it.

Hoop hoop hooray
October 22, 2025 4:38 pm

Watched the CL goal feast again last night. Unbelievable amount of goals scored from outside the box either taken first time or a quick touch and bang. What’s wrong with these teams. Have they not got horseshoes to play round.

Bada Bing
October 22, 2025 4:48 pm

ATOB- Sent same idea to others, I would have Nygren instead of Balakwisha,AJ instead of Donovan if fit,but the formation needs to change

Billy Bhoy
October 22, 2025 5:31 pm

Star

“If the CEO of Celtic doesn’t like publicity then he could always look for a job with a much lower profile”

MN has quite successfully MADE the Celtic CEO role a low profile one! I have no idea what his voice sounds like and he’s in, I think, his third year as CEO.

What an absolute joke!

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 22, 2025 5:31 pm

BADABING

You obviously have a higher opinion of Nygren than I do.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 22, 2025 5:43 pm

BILLYBHOY

He took over in 2021.

Bada Bing
October 22, 2025 5:59 pm

BMCUW- It’s a very low bar,but I think Nygren has more chance of scoring

Pitymevin
October 22, 2025 6:18 pm

I like a mob, but its got to be angry. The angry mob works. Last time an angry mob turned up outside celtic Park the CEO resigned. We got Dom in all because of an angry mob. It works, always has, always will.

All the money in the world won’t protect you from an angry mob.

Now am I condoning an angry mob? Your fucking right I am.

bournesouprecipe
October 22, 2025 6:25 pm

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS

 October 22, 2025 4:27 pm
BSR
I’m minded to delete that. Cos it’s depressing the life out me.

A thing of beauty

 October 22, 2025 4:34 pm
BSR,
Bada’s stats confirm what we already know. This formation is not working. As I said on Sunday, if BR is staying as he says he is, then he needs to put the petted lip away and find a formation that gets more out the players he has. I’d like to try 3-5-2 tomorrow. It’s a free shot after all because we are doing nowt in the Europa league.
Sinissalo
CCV Trusty KT
Donovan Engles McGregor Balakwishi scarrachi
Ineahacho Kenny
It can’t be any worse than this horseshoe shit football we’ve been watching since Bayern. Plus every team in Scotland now knows how to play against us. Cmon Brendan, give yourself a shake and show us you’ve still got it.

——————————-
Guys

FWIW Perfectly pitched and all playing out for Timidus Maximus and Mik Invisibilus they are coming in their pants on ‘the other channel’

‘The bored’ have even got BR committing Hari- Kiri for the press, Two in a row of telling us what we already know and there’s nothing he can do, he’s a non tactical manager that coaches players to his system alone ( just like Ange )

He was emptied the upshot is IMO,

The loss of AJ to injury, and Greg Taylor for KT nostalgia, has been enormous for the back four, we’ll likely be looking to sell AJ for the stash, and searching for a left back punt as per usual next summer unless permanent loanee Adam Montgomery returns. We haven’t a Saracchi option to buy clause. 

The midfield was shot even last season, Nygren hasn’t really improved matters, in any big game especially, CalMac is weary Hatate was always hit or miss, at the moment it’s miss.

Bernardo has regressed, and never took his chances, expect BR to try him again verse Sturm Graz because it’s Europe. For breaking up the regular three, we only really have Engels and McCowan. 

The loss of Jota led to Tounekti who looked good because he’s the only player in the squad that takes his man on, the same happened with Kuhn, double banking lessens the threat and SPL teams soon get it, still £18M for the stash. Quite why you buy two wide left players may well never be explained, when we had Maeda retained Yang retained and Jota to comeback?

With zero quality central strikers signed in the last two windows but two sold, the sudden necessity of a free agent and promotion of Johnny Kenny, means  it’s not looking good for the Hoops, or silk purses from sows ears. 

Shrugs Shoulders CSC 

Rebus67
October 22, 2025 6:26 pm

Pitymevin,

what happens if an angry mob results in violence? Do you still recommend it?

Rebus

October 22, 2025 6:26 pm

My team for tomorrow night ” free shot” as ATOB says.

Sinissalo
CCV, Trusty,KT
Engles, McCowan,Bernardo Saracchi
Nygren Balakwishi
Ineahacho

Pitymevin
October 22, 2025 6:40 pm

Rebus67, let’s be honest, thats the only real threat from an angry mob.

So lies, deception, skullduggery and contemptible behaviour should just be shrugged off.

The issue i have is that the business of celtic is built on emotion. The sale of season tickets, match day attendance and the tat they sell is all built on who we are, and the hope we pass this down to the next generation.

Anger is just another emotion, the same as happy, sad, scared, love, surprised, disgust, shame, joy.

And normally when you are scared of something you go into fight or flight.

Some people are scared for the future of celtic!

So would I condone violence, I dont know. But what I do know is, every action has a reaction and if some people’s emotions run too hight then dont act surprised and shocked.

Shocked there’s another emotion.

A thing of beauty
October 22, 2025 7:24 pm

PMN,
The support Resorting to violence would suit our board perfectly. It makes it easy for them to dismiss them as a rabble and yobs and tell the rest of the support not to get behind them – They are bringing down the reputation of the club etc etc. For me, we have to be smarter than that and the not a penny more campaign is something I am right behind. I’m not sure about the tennis balls protest but we do need to draw attention to the people who have got us into the mess we are in. That is mainly the board and if Michael Nicholson doesn’t like it he knows he can leave. Just like he knew he didn’t have to take the job of Celtic CEO in the first place, especially if he doesn’t like to be on camera. Ffs it’s like being prime minister and saying don’t take my picture. It goes with the territory.

Pitymevin
October 22, 2025 7:33 pm

ATOB, I get where your coming from, but sorry your wrong. PL resigned after 2 week of angry mob during covid. Not because of results, let’s not kid ourselves.

Even thatcher resigned after the pol tax riot.

They will love not a penny more, and this is exactly the rainy day they have been banking on. £100 million in the bank.

So not a penny more, ok, will you give up your ST next year?And I wouldn’t want you to. But its the question that the collective needs to ask.

The answer is no, because if it is yes then the collective is no more.

A bit like the SNP, if independence was voted for they become an irrelevance.

St tams
October 22, 2025 7:37 pm

Team for tomorrow
Sinasalo
Murray ,CCV , Trusty
AJ, Engels, Bernardo, Sarachi
Nygren
Balikwisha, Iheanacho

October 22, 2025 8:03 pm

In respect of the judgement being passed on MN:

I should never have mentioned that MN did not like being seen on camera in 2016 when the media tried to trap Celtic and MN into the narrative that it was Rangers that was the target of the Res12 approach to UEFA.

Yes trap MN and expose him to the vile attention of the huns.

In those days anyone associated with challenging the narrative that Rangers were a new club or were cheats became subject to physical threat. Getting the truth out was risky.

I know because at one point the spotlight turned on me and my face and location started to feature on social media.

I reported the source (The Bheast that cannot be named) to the police and the revealing article was removed.

However there was a time thereafter I looked over my shoulder or did not wear the same shirt I wore in the images put out.

Being Spain I had less to fear and I did not have a young family there to protect.

I understand Celtic continue to provide security and I hope none of you might question its cost.

Look at what you are becoming, the very thing I had to take measures to protect myself from in 2016.

That is NOT the Celtic way for me.

If I needed a reminder why I do not post much on SC now it is because somewhere, the loss of The Celtic we all grew up loving is dieing and the anger it is causing has caused a deparure from our normal understanding senses.

I only made the point originally on the basis that it would bring out the best in our understanding of human nature of ourselves and others.

Seems I erred.

Jobo Baldie
October 22, 2025 8:05 pm

Good evening, friends.
I too would love it, I’d absolutely love it (thanks Kev) if we see 2 different things tomorrow night – a change from 433 and some fresh starters on the park. A wee bit disappointed that some on here are referring to it as a ‘free hit’ though. I know we only sit on 1 point but there are 18 more still to play for. And whilst our recent form leads me fearing all 3 of our next games we do know that we can play much better than we are doing, even with the current squad.
So my own 3-5-2 pitch is…
Sinisalo
Donovan CCV Scales
Forrest Engels McGregor Bernardo Tounekti
Iheanacho Kenny

October 22, 2025 8:06 pm

Bayern 1-0

Mike in Toronto
October 22, 2025 8:07 pm

Interesting to see Spurs practicing corner and free kick routines in their pre-match warm up. Guess they saw how much benefit they have been to Arsenal, and have decided to follow suit