The Can’t Lose Final
They are all abouting winning you know, that elusive knack.
I might be in a minority but I think the timing is excellent for several reasons.
For starters everyone is forced to be on top of their game, no excuses in a Final for not trying your best, afterall surely winning a medal for the grandkids was an inspiration, regardless of everything going on you can be a winner with Celtic and no one can ever take that away from you.
I believe winning the Cup just might be the boost EVERYONE needs, especially the dressing room.
Which in turn helps the manager start steering the ship in his direction.
Finally, the Supporters really, really, want/need something to smile about.
But as the Title says, I do believe its a must win. But not for Wilfs job, its a must win in his increasingly hard battle to persuade the Tims he has what it takes. I haven’t gone in on him, but this week saw many really questioning his appointment.
For the record, I hope he works out, I really do as I want a new playing style.
And as we all know Dermot won’t show egg on his face by quickly sacking a manager whilst ‘under pressure’. It would be a terrible look for the club and as much as we said good luck finding a decent manager after Brendan, imagine what giving the bullet 3 games does to a clubs image? And shareholder confidence then the share price?
Hes going nowhere soon, but shall face the steepest of uphill battles should we not claim the Cup, by hook or by crook.
Im delighted its not a derby final against you know who, and the Saints will get a boost in the coffers to help make the improving (my eyes and the table) SPL more interesting. They’ve done incredibly well and I rate their manager, I think hes one worth keeping tabs on. He’s got his side functioning well on a shoestring budget, and I think their last three results say it all, picked up points in two and lost one the one they probably should have won. They’ve had the week off, but no doubt practicing drills galore. And they field a lot of big strong men. And what do you drill into into big strong men all week in his shoes? Yup, the set pieces will be a major factor on the day I expect. Gulp!
In saying that I now see the wisdom of accepting the position two games before a Cup Final, one of them an automatic write-off by the supporters. Third time lucky or just that extra training time before the big occasion to really announce yourself!? The league table, difference in budgets etc, would signpost this Final as ‘a gimme’ and therefore I wouldn’t blame any manager walking in the door to think Ill win the Cup and all is good.
I heard the excellent Huddleboard podcast point out the benefits of the different dynamics at play, with the overall conclusion we needed a finisher for Hearts. The finisher has returned and was probably our best player against the Romans despite being a sub. Theres another angle, Big Kel can win Celtic a Cup and become a cult hero legend. His words suggest hes here for that very thing.
I
Im not nervous at all but really looking forward to the game.
I want to see everyone forced to perform on the big stage, on no excuses day, and you’ll read my honest review on Monday.
Up The Hoops!
By Mahe
sentinelcelts@gmail.com
Our donations page for McMillan Cancer Care has now closed,having raised almost £1700 plus Gift Aid. Thank you to everyone who was a part of this, you are all wonderful and generous people.
That’s over £6000 in eighteen months, and you should rightfully feel significant pride in that.
Our new charity campaign will begin immediately, and as ever, it will be for a charity of your choice. Nominated via these pages, and chosen as the most worthy by our contributors.
It is Chidren’s Hospices Across Scotland (CHAS). Nominated by BAWHEID, and overwhelmingly the landslide winner of the vote. We have just reached our first target of £1000, and you can help us reach our next one.
£1888
You can donate by following this link, as set up by CHALMERSBHOY (and grateful thanks once again for doing so!)
https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinel-celts-2?utm_medium=FA&utm_source=EM
There is a default payment method by ApplePay, which I don’t use. Just click ”change” above the payment bar to view other options.
I’m delighted to let you know that CHAS will remain as the beneficiary of our charity drive till 31st July 2026.
There is still time to volunteer for the following two betting opportunities, which proved so popular and successful last season.
The CHALMERSBHOY Saturday Treble.
One contestant at a time taking their turn to pick three results from the eight UK leagues. Chalmersbhoy will place a £5 bet on these each week, with the proceeds going to our nominated charity.
The Saturday Acca.
Six of us each pick a result from the eight UK leagues. The site will place a £5 bet on these each week from Sept 13, with the proceeds going to our nominated charity.
Please note- we have closed nominations for The Saturday Acca, which will now comprise a Magnificent Seven pundits. Entrants for The Saturday Treble are still welcome.
Volunteer via this link, please.
https://sentinelcelts.com/2025/11/21/saturday-football-charity-bets/
POTY competition sencelpoty@gmail.com
I have spent a lifetime being super confident in our ability to finish the job when we reach Hampden, which lasted right up until the last couple of weeks and watching the team painfully try to implement whatever it is the manager is asking of them.
Speaking of that – can anyone really say they know, or understand, what it is that Wilf is attempting here?? I’ve never been so underwhelmed with a Tic manager, or so confused with his decisions.
The very last thing I want to hear a Celtic manager say is “Winning isn’t the most important thing” Oh yes it fucking is, mate! And you better quickly learn that, or this could be the shortest reign in our history!
Mahe – You say he’s gonna be here a while yet regardless of results? How long does that remain true? If losing on Sunday doesn’t have alarm bells ringing, what if he loses the first 4? 5-6? How ridiculous do we let this get before we do something to try and save our season? This is why I didn’t want to let Martin go, because I had regained my confidence we were about to turn a shit season into a great one.
Now? Now I’m not confident of beating ANYONE! If the manager plays that same amateur level formation, sticks with this insane system, I will be expecting St Mirren to win! I really can’t believe I’m saying that, and saying it after we just went to Holland and won comfortably while playing great.
Even during the worst of times, and there’s a catalogue to choose from, I never felt this disconnect from the club, or had such little feelings for a Celtic manager. Doesn’t help that I didn’t want the guy in the first place, but I also couldn’t be more shocked and disappointed at what I’ve seen from him so far. Add to that he seems to be the double down type – and when that doesn’t work, double down some more!
Not changing to a 4-5 man defence against Roma wasn’t just daft, it was utterly inexplicable, and I’ve a feeling his ego won’t allow him to bin this crap and do the smart thing, hence what I mean about just sticking with a failing plan!
If he names that same team/formation and we lose, I want the guy gone! There won’t be a shred of doubt in my mind. I said often that this had the potential to go really bad, really quickly, and so it’s playing out. Sitting back and watching this guy turn our season into a fecking disaster will be some of the worst decision making I’ve seen from the club.
Of course I don’t want to feel this way and hope Wilfred can surprise me, but I am anything but confident. If I was a betting man, the odds on St Mirren would probably be too attractive to ignore
This’ll be the most anticipated line-up I can remember for a while, simply because I’m dreading seeing us start with 3 at the back, no fullbacks, no wingbacks, 4 midfielders and 2 wingers! I have never even seen that tried .. there’s probably a good reason for that Wilfred!!
FFS do the smart thing –
Bin what isn’t working, don’t try and be cute while playing out your own version of insanity! You have the players to easily deal with St Mirren, but if you persist with a system that has them all looking like they’re playing a sport that’s brand new to them, and sees them looking bewildered, you use your brains and find a formation they are comfortable with!
I believe we’ve been winning in our recent history in spite of the board, are the players now gonna have to win in spite of the manager?! Wow, this board really are determined to fuck us right up!!
POTY Update.
*SENTINEL CELTS PLAYER OF THE YEAR 2025-26*
*RESULTS FROM GAME #26 CELTIC 0 ROMA 3*
Good evening, friends.
Before the game there was little doubt in my mind that Wilfried would play a system that was very similar to his first game. Although I didn’t expect him to start with an unchanged team. That was surprise number one. Surprise number two was that we couldn’t even manage to win the coin toss and found ourselves shooting the ‘wrong way’ in the first half. My third surprise was a pleasant one – 2 minutes into the game and a throw in to Celtic which was taken by Yang – can’t remember the last time that a shy wasn’t taken by a defender! Come on, we are looking for wee signs of progress, surely?
The game got underway and was a bit messy to start with, each side failing to string too many passes together. But there were only 5 minutes on the clock when, from a corner, Scales peeled off the guy he was originally marking to challenge another Roma player in the air and bullet the ball into our his net. What’s happened to our early POTY leader?
We were then pretty much battered for the next half hour. One obvious new tactic was Kasper’s distributions, mainly down the centre of the park. In the main, Kasper did his part of the equation OK, firing the ball towards Maeda or Nygren but neither of those receivers did what we hoped they could do, receive the ball, control it and lay it off to our attacking midfielders or wingers. Nygren in particular was statuesque in these matters, regularly waiting on the ball reaching him rather than taking a couple of steps towards it. And so we had wave upon wave of Roma pressure, albeit with not too many clear chances being created.
But on 35 minutes Roma doubled their lead, and grudgingly deservedly so. 2 of their players progressed down the right with only Tierney there to try to cover the 2 of them. An easy cut across to our 6 yard box was knocked home for number 2.
A couple of minutes later we saw Celtic’s only good move of the first half. Close interchanges down the right involving Engels, Yang, Nygren and Hatate found Reo in on goal but from 12 yards his effort went over the bar.
Only 1 minute of stoppage time was announced and I was readying myself to boil the kettle thinking that we had probably escaped with only being 2 down. But Roma’s Ferguson had other ideas. Receiving a ball in the box with his back to goal he controlled, swivelled and shot across Schmeichel into the far corner of the net to put Roma out of sight. And yet we were thrown a potential lifeline just seconds after the restart when Engels was pulled to the ground for a clear penalty. If there is such a thing as a good missed penalty then Arne’s was it. Hard and low heading into the bottom corner, it came off the inside of the post and across to safety.
Wilfried rang the half time changes and so that was a positive sign. Donovan for Tierney gave the 3 at the back better balance, with Scales and Trusty both moving one place to their left. Bernardo for Nygren was a significant upgrade (then again, even just taking Nygren off might have improved our chances)! And Iheanacho coming on was another positive although personally I’d not have replaced Maeda, but instead hooked Tounekti and played Daizen out left, his best position.
The changes did make a difference though, particularly with our goal threats. In 52 minutes Hatate broke down the left and curled a great pass across to the inrushing Iheanacho but, under pressure from a Roma defender Kelechi clipped his effort just wide. Arguably, in the previous 7 minutes of play we could have been only 2-3 behind. But on such small margins….
On the hour mark, Ralston came on for Yang suggesting that we were maybe adding extra cover on the right rather than trying to create further chances. Tony did alright during his time on the pitch.
In the 64th minute I finally had something to cheer about, if only for about 90 seconds. A Celtic corner had come to nothing (as usual) but Hatate picked up the ball outside the box and spotted Engels (the corner taker) on the right. Reo’s through pass split the defence, Arne crossed first time and Iheanacho glanced the ball home and, briefly, there was hope. But when the VAR lines were finally drawn it showed that he was a good yard offside. 10 minutes later and a similar outcome at the other end. Scrappy tussles on the half way line broke Roma’s way and the ball was played into a busy penalty box where some of our defenders decided to stand off rather than challenge. A shot was fired into the top corner but subsequently we saw that there was an offside earlier in the build up, this time by about half a ba’ hair! But offside is offside.
Balikwisha replaced Hatate with 15 minutes left and while we still tried to get some sort of consolation from the game it eventually petered out as a 3 nil defeat.
Now, I’m still not pressing any panic buttons with regard to our new manager. He had very little time before playing the league leaders and was then up against a formidable side in Roma. Before last night’s match the majority view from folk I spoke with was that getting anything from the game would have been a bonus. Just like Midtjylland, we were 3 nil down at half time but, as in that earlier game at least it didn’t get any worse!
A lot of preparation is now required before Sunday’s cup final. I hope that our starting 11 for that game is more like the one we finished with last night.
We have now played 26 games, and have won 14, drawn 6 and lost 6. We have scored 43 goals and conceded 24.
As for the voting numbers, despite our loss I’m really delighted that 77 folk made the effort to voice their opinions and have generated another £3 donation to CHAS.
The total votes cast for each player are as follows, with my own nominations asterisked. For this game I’ve again listed the players in a 3-5-1-1 formation.
Schmeichel*: 4
Trusty: 15
Scales: 1
Tierney: 8
Yang: 16
McGregor: 15
Engels: 2
Nygren: 0
Tounekti: 0
Hatate*: 44
Maeda: 2
Iheanacho: 66
Bernardo: 37
Donovan: 20
Ralston: 0
Balikwisha: 1
Unused substitutes: Doohan, Kenny, McCowan, Murray, Sinisalo
And so, the POINTS earned by each player for the Roma game are as follows –
25 points: Iheanacho
22 points: Hatate
19 points: Bernardo
16 points: Donovan
14 points: Yang
12 points each: McGregor and Trusty
10 points: Tierney
9 points: Schmeichel
8 points each: Engels and Maeda
6 points each: Balikwisha and Scales
3 points: Nygren, Ralston, Tounekti
1 point: Doohan, Kenny, McCowan, Murray, Sinisalo
And the cumulative points achieved after 26 games played are now –
413: Scales
359: McGregor
283: Tierney
281: Hatate
273: Engels
245: Tounekti
238: Maeda
231: Nygren
219: Schmeichel
203: Trusty
183: Donovan
182: Forrest
168: Yang
166: Iheanacho
165: McCowan
158: Carter-Vickers and Saracchi
127: Kenny and Ralston
91: Bernardo
82: Murray
69: Balikwisha
60: Johnston
49: Yamada
40: Osmand, Sinisalo
22: Inamura
19: Idah
10: Simpson-Pusey
5: Doohan
1: Hale and Isiguso
0: All the other players who’ve not yet made a matchday squad!
Our next game is at 3.30pm on Sunday and a chance to claim the first domestic silverware of the season when we face St Mirren in the final of the League Cup. If we were to succeed it would be our 120th domestic trophy in our history.
Hail Hail!
Auldheid
Your premise is the same as the Celtic PLC in that Scottish football needs hunnery for the bigot buck and the 5WA was essential in maintaining it. This is confederate Dixie Bhoy thinking in my opinion. Obviously, since the 5WA, the standard of Scottish football has soared and for someone who used the Plato’s cave paradigm to be the messenger to the blissfully ignorant, it desperately falls short here. Celtic PLC have encouraged bigotry in a country honestly trying to shrug it off in my opinion. They did it with no vision and only for the bigot buck.
Mags,
After years, possibly decades, of suffering the loss of trophies and millions in income, we had the opportunity to seek justice, or at the very least make it known we weren’t prepared to just meekly accept things, so what do we do?
We release the most weasely statement in the history of Scottish football, saying how great a club the Huns were! If you ever needed any proof of how bent the Desmond’s are, it’s right there in your face!
These people are utterly sickening, and are the biggest threat to the club that exists anywhere! They will be here to oversee the Huns lording it over us once again, with all that will entail, you can bet your fucking life on it!!
Good morning, friends.
Just for the record, my latest results post is missing a 3rd asterisk. It should be alongside Bernardo, a player that I’d have in tomorrow’s starting 11.
Auldheid
December 12, 2025 10:46 pm
So what’s your argument here?
Is it that ‘Celtic’ were powerless to stop the 5 way agreement or that ‘Celtic’ went along with the 5 way agreement for the good of Scottish football as a whole?
And by ‘Celtic’ I think we both understand that to all intents and purposes that actually means Dermot Desmond.
I reject either claim.
Desmond went along with (and I suspect that downplays the degree of enthusiasm involved) the 5 way agreement and the same club narrative because it suited Desmond’s purposes, it protected his investment. No other reason.
I don’t need to remind you of his comments at the time. How great Rangers were, how much of a pity it was they’d been ‘relegated’ etc.
So if Celtic/Desmond are prepared to ignore something so existential as the death of Rangers because it suits their interests what else are they prepared to go along with in furtherance of the same objective?
And is that why we are where we are? A toxic, dysfunctional mess on and off the pitch.
I sincerely hope not !
Morning troops- hang in there.
My prediction 3-1 Celtic with KT scoring 2. You read it here first.
Pressure all on St.Mirren.
The games fucked. The game has been fucked since big TV took over, and with the introduction of water breaks in the world cup for a set 3 minutes to allow TV adds, the game is only going to move further away from what we grew up loving.
Every single social contract has been torn to shreds, and now even the hobbies we do on our down time are being savaged. But its all good , just so long as someone is making money.
Cash is king, the very though that helped the conception of RES12. Well cash is king and why would anyone have though that turning the tap down never mind off, might even been an option.
On Wilfred, I still think he will come good and when the players click and get it, the thumpings will start again.
BAD, I agree in some sense, but everyone knows systems dont guarantee wins, good players do.
BR knew this, and the board also know this. This is the reason we have been so poor this season, simply because our wingers are shite and the forwards dont get the service.
WWF at play.
£77 million in the bank.
Second in the league to the 3rd place horse.
This is exactly the board plan and there is fuck all anyone can do about it.
Second on the boards charter.
To increase profits for our shareholders.
Not sure where football gets mentioned on the charter list.
Mags was right when he told me not to get over excited about the collective. How right he was.
Time to just drop this emotional embarrassment of a hobby once and for all.
Think I will just check BP the oil company and supporter the great work they do and their share prices. They have the right colours for a start.
See you all later.
I really appreciate your attempt at optimism Mahe but the first two games where our ‘not very good quality’ wingers and three left footed defenders were running around like headless chickens still gives me the fear, I so hope I’m wrong but I’m dreading the final. After the renewed optimism under the once blessed, now sainted MON I’m back hiding behind the couch for this one.
GAUN US.
NOT A FUCKIN PENNY MORE.
BAD
Couldn’t agree more.
If the performance v Roma has any redeeming features, it’s hopefully that Wilf now realises that this squad doesn’t have the players to function in his system.
We are not yet at Defcon 1, despite the wailing and over the top hysterical bellyaching of many.
We showed enough v top of the table Hearts to have taken something from that game. We didn’t but that hardly makes it a calamity.
I’m with San Luis, a two goal victory tomorrow to sustain our domestic dominance.
Then we will see where this season takes us.
Jack Nance and Wilfried Nancy.
One centre stage in an atmosphere redolent with a pervasive sense of dread, alienation, and industrial decay, enhanced by stark black-and-white visuals and haunting soundscapes…
whilst featuring hallucinatory sequences, including a backward-talking dwarf, a checkered-floor Green Room, and a “Man in the Planet” who seems to control creation.
Further…
he explores anxieties of fatherhood, self-doubt, and alienation through disturbing visuals and soundscapes that blend reality with nightmarish subconscious fears.
The other appears in a David Lynch film.
Encouraging.
Sounds like there was dialogue.
Celtic manager Wilfried Nancy to ‘slow down’ the pace of change going forward after training ground feedback from players.
Nancy said: “I am different in terms of the previous coach. We are all different. Players have to adjust regarding that. I also have to adjust regarding the players, and also change – not a lot of change, but a few changes, because we are all different.
“So yes, it takes time. When you try to learn something, it’s difficult to catch it like that. I knew that before I signed and this is the adversity that I knew that I would face. Now what is good is with my group, we have open discussion regarding everything; the system, the way we play, the way we attack, the way we defend, because I want them to feel good also regarding what we want to do.”
Asked if he had welcomed his players speaking their minds, Nancy said: “Yes, because I am like this as a coach. My job is not to arrive and say, ‘This is how we’re going to play, so we have to do this, and you shut your mouth’. I’m not like that. This is a project, this is why I want to do this, this is the big picture, now we’re going to try to do it step by step, knowing that I have to slow down everything that I want to do.
“For the moment, the chemistry has been good. I have to accept that at certain moments, yes, I want to change, I want to talk, but I also have to figure it out, and this is not easy.
“Usually this is during the pre-season, but again, I accept the challenge, and I’m here for that. It’s new for me also but we are all on the same boat, and I can feel the good energy with my players, knowing that this is not an easy task, but everybody knows that.
“When I was a player, the coach was saying ‘you run and you shut your mouth’,” the 48-year-old continued. “Now it’s not like this. I like to explain why we do what we do, and we discuss.
“But obviously I need to be convinced of the way I want to play, because as a leader, if I’m not convinced, they will not follow. So yes, I have the conviction that this is the way I want to play. Now, I am able to twist certain things, because I don’t want to change everything drastically, so interaction.”
Piteymevin
Cash is king, the very though that helped the conception of RES12. Well cash is king and why would anyone have though that turning the tap down never mind off, might even been an option.
====
Res 12 started off on basis SFA were guilty of accepting Rangers monitoring submission for a UEFA licence.
That subsequently changed to challenging the initial granting of the licence after seeking answers from SFA and a growing understanding of tax process and FFP rules.
So SFA were the target and the belief was UEFA would want to invesigate as they had the process in place to do so.
it was not until 2017 when the information became public that Celtic had written to Infantino about Rangers use of ebts that shook the original belief in UEFA and Infantino has shown himself since to be bereft of integrity.
This supports your view the game is corrupt.
It was just that in 2013 shareholders were unaware how far up the chain it went.
Res12 was a learning process, like peeling an onion and like peeling an onion it brought tears to eyes.
Saturday acca.
Coventry
Luton
Bradford
Cheltenham
Luton
Cardiff
Walsall
Around 72/1.
🤞 🤞 🤞
They are out marching today in the city centre with the usual lepers tagging along all dipping their sandwiches in each other’s heads. This cold east Wind would cut you in two as well. Someone is looking down smiling 😁
Margaret McGill
December 13, 2025 5:34 am
Auldheid
Your premise is the same as the Celtic PLC in that Scottish football needs hunnery for the bigot buck and the 5WA was essential in maintaining it. This is confederate Dixie Bhoy thinking in my opinion. Obviously, since the 5WA, the standard of Scottish football has soared and for someone who used the Plato’s cave paradigm to be the messenger to the blissfully ignorant, it desperately falls short here. Celtic PLC have encouraged bigotry in a country honestly trying to shrug it off in my opinion. They did it with no vision and only for the bigot buck.
=====
No my premise is that all SPL teams not just Celtic accepted the 5WA as they too depended more than Celtic on the bigot buck.
In explaining what went on does not mean I like it.
In fact from about age 17 I stopped attending Rangers game because I did not want to join in the bigotry.
I did what you asked about 4 years ago in not renewing my OST because of what I had learned since 2013.
I pursue change and ending the divide still on behalf of those who continue to pay up because without them there would be no Celtic to love.
Bitterness is not in my makeup.
Frustration aye but not bitterness.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GUgtMB4SSUk
Together For Palestine – Lullaby
Pitymevin
December 13, 2025 10:45 am
This is exactly the board plan and there is fuck all anyone can do about it.
###
I disagree.
If Celtic fans refuse to buy season books they could wrest back a degree of control. They won’t do it though. Too risky, too much inconvenience.
Bobby – Check the acca. Luton twice?
Sounds to me like Wilf is saying one thing and doing something else. You changed everything that the previous manager had working, that’s all on you.
Pitymevin,
You’re right, systems don’t guarantee success but I’d be much more confident if he ditched that crazy formation tomorrow l.
Auldheid I was with the big man the night he thought about starting the process. Before he had even bought a share in the club, they were his words, while the cogs turned in his head to go about how to get started.
Because the licence was granted, when it should have been declined and passed over to the next position in the league cost the shareholders and club potential earnings.
This was the thought process originally, and from this thought it would have caused an investigation and resignations from within the FTSFA. Our glorious board decided to place the emphasis onto the revolutionaries to provide evidence and pay for lawyers to bring the case, and in doing so killed the resolution, instead of doing their job of protecting the interests of the club, shareholders and supporters.
Now they quote these very same statements 13 years on.
When I say the game is rigged, thats because Celtic choose to rig the game. Not because of any external bodies and the £77 million in the bank is proof of that especially when we watch the shit on the park and count the cash in the bank and FSR non will convince me otherwise.
Thats my truth and how much I know.
The Celtic board are the issue here.
I understand that it takes time for a new coach to bed in. I also understand that Wilf had a couple of tough games to start his career at Celtic. I do hope that he will succeed. Am I confident? Frankly, no, I am not, simply because there seems to be a lot of naivety surrounding Wilf. Perhaps, I should not have been surprised since he has only had 4-5 years as the man in charge. He seems to have known very little about the players before he arrived and yet his appointment was agreed some weeks ago. Why, was he so unprepared?
Bringing someone in mid-season was going to be difficult for any appointee, especially one that has little experience managing, and all of it in another continent. However, given MON was interim, at some point in the season, the new guy had to be brought in. MON, himself, had to cope with that, but he did have several advantages over Wilf. Firstly, he is a vastly more experienced manager who knows both Celtic and UK football. Secondly, he was smart enough to utilise two coaches that knew more than he did about the current state of the squad and of the SPL. Ultimately, his appointment was judged as a huge success.
What should have happened, is that Wilf and his team, should have come in for a two week period to observe and contribute to the recruitment drive. MON and his team would have remained in charge for the Hearts, Roma, and the LC final games. Wilf would observe these games, get to know the players and then take over after the final.
Instead, we have a situation where the players have to tell the manager that the pace of change is too rapid. Where was the head of football operations in all of this? Was it not his job to tell Wilf that he needed to adjust his approach? I find it curious but concerning that we have a story appearing in the media that, “NO”, Tisdale did not appoint Wilf! Just a coincidence, or is a rear end being covered?
How the new manager search and recruitment was handled is another example of unprofessional senior management. Not only can they screw up recruiting to improve the squad, they can do the same for a manager.
It is almost unbelievable…almost!
Having cleansed myself of that, I think we shall win tomorrow, but we shall lose a goal, similar to the Hearts’s second, and the Roma first.
Rebus
Pitymevin. 12.59
Absolutely correct.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=3HmR1NJXeqg
Homebhoys – Room 1 on 1 – Paul Quigley
Rebus67
December 13, 2025 1:04 pm
A phased handover would have been a good idea. That’s why I suggested it at the time. Didn’t see anyone agreeing with me.
I hope Wilf isn’t relying on any assurances he received about having money to spend in January. If things don’t improve before then I think he might find out what pervious manager have found out about how reliable such assurances are.
Ernie,
I did not see your suggestion on a phased intro for Wilf. Mea Culpa!
I did think about it earlier but I thought, NO, both the Board and Wilf know what they are doing!
Yes, it is not just Wilf that is naive!
Some of the stuff that is emerging about how this club is run is unbelievable!
Lately, I have asked myself if there will be a point when I cannot take what is happening any more. I watch other teams but I just do not have the same emotional involvement. Currently, no Rebus money is going into the club.
I was in the Ottawa Scottish/Irish store and saw Celtic scarves for sale…no Sevco ones. Normally, one of those would have found its way to me at this time of the year but not this year. As a sidebar, the quality was very poor.
Rebus
Rebus67
December 13, 2025 2:03 pm
I think the best word to describe it is disenchantment.
l.
Pitymevin
December 13, 2025 12:59 pm
Auldheid I was with the big man the night he thought about starting the process. Before he had even bought a share in the club, they were his words, while the cogs turned in his head to go about how to get started.
=====
If by the big man you mean Canalamar I read the original draft and said it had no locus and Celtic would say what was presemtrd would simply say all the stuff in it was for SFA to deal with.
He got the idea of a Res based on one I drafted before the Open Meeting at St Mary’s adopted by attendees. He introduced himself in typical Canalamar fashion. ” Are you a hun” he asked me with a smile. Are you Canalamar, I was hoping we might meet” I said.
That St Mary’s Res seeking SFA Transparency and Accountability and change to Video Review panel process was adopted at the meeting after Jeanette Findlay read it out went to PL who was happy to run with it.
It was on that basis I thought PL would run with Res12.
After discussion in which BRTH was involved all the valid points Canalamar set out were put after the SFA handling of the UEFA licence application precisley because it gave Celtic shareholder locus.
An investigation into that had UEFA ever done it and found licence was wrongly granted and so Celtic were deprived of the opportunity to play in CL which would have helped share price is where shareholders had locus.
BRTH with his legal background saw it that way.
I had many an exchange and meetings with John. He stuck to his belief that it was fraud and he was right, but had the Res not had locus we would never know for sure.
The original draft would have gone nowhere as there was no evidence to support it.
I had evidence to support the direction taken by Res 12 and PL himself agreed SFA reform was needed and that made a difference to the final version that Celtic could not ignore because they knew the evidence existed.
Your judgement of Res12 based on what the big man said at a point in time. (and we got on fine in meetings – he actually criticised me for losing the rag with MN although he didnt trust MN) and we would argue by e mail on how many angels could stand on the top of a pin) but in real life he was easy to get on with.
At the end of the day your thinking quite naturally is based on what the big man told you but that is not how matters progressed based on my actual involvement before Res12 took shape.
JOBO
I corrected that immediately on the betting page, apologies for being a daftie and posting the error here. This is the correct version.
Saturday acca.
Coventry
Luton
Bradford
Cheltenham
Stockport
Cardiff
Walsall
Can anyone imagine that only a few months ago, they’d be watching a League Cup Final against St, Mirren from behind the couch?
Not me Celger. 100% confident about it.
CELGER
At the moment, I can certainly watching a League Cup Final against St, Mirren from behind the couch, but I’m not expecting to.
How Sports Media Drifted into Negativity.
Well worth a read.
https://www.linkedin.com/posts/tonyasghar_i-had-to-present-at-short-notice-to-a-group-activity-7404592593868853248-esd1?utm_medium=ios_app&rcm=ACoAAGFduSgBsiXX2zOhz5XY257CEwlfPf_OpxU&utm_source=social_share_send&utm_campaign=whatsapp
Bobby, Celger,
My plan is to watch the game but maybe disappear behind the couch for St Mirren corners 🛋️🫣
I’ve given tomorrow a lot of thought since the Roma performance.
I find that I’m currently very calm and confident which is in stark contrast to what I’m reading here and elsewhere.
This is based on certain facts. Firstly, on paper it should be a relatively straight forward victory. This Celtic team have won 10 out of 15 SPFL games – scoring 25 goals. St Mirren have won THREE – scoring 14 goals. Only Dundee have scored less.
In my view if we fail to win tomorrow its 100% down to the players. Whatever XI is picked, regardless of formation, should be enough to win the cup. We’ll have guys on the bench that would be the superstar in the St Mirren side. Especially if Bernardo doesn’t make the first XI.
A failure would inevitably heap massive pressure on WN but for me it would be solely down to the players completely buckling under the pressure that their lacklustre performances recently have created.
If we start with 3 at the back again I hope its a 3-5-2. With Iheanacho now fit again we have 3 strikers in the squad at last so can afford to start with 2 and have a reserve on the bench.
Could game be postponed due to adverse weather?
San Luis,
Pouring again right now, and a hell of a lot of rain has fell in the last 24hrs
Don’t think so, see below
Yellow warning
Periods of heavy rain may lead to travel disruption and some flooding
Impact: Low
Likelihood of impact: Medium
Bluegrass. Great comment, I’ll go behind the couch for corners!
BAD
Good point, does Hampden still have a bad reputation for pitch maintenance 🙄
Lennoxtown today. Same old, same old. Without giving information to St. Mirren, they could easily show oblique angles of players practicing penalties, free kicks, corner routines etc.
I have previously watched clips of training sessions from various teams, Real Madrid, Barca, Man U, Sporting Lisbon, Juve, Milan, PSG, LA Galaxy, Inter Miami featuring set piece routines.
We never see any of that. Makes you wonder if we even bother. If the game tomorrow goes to penalties, I have zero confidence that we will prevail. Several reasons. Limp, unconvincing, no confidence debacles vs Aberdeen and Kairat ( with Schmiechel nowhere near the oppositions well struck efforts ), plus our pitiful record over the last 10 or so years.
https://youtu.be/wL8wB-JbkgY?si=zYw3TnCss-oY2zst
Celger @4:14 pm
By the same token, I’ll go into kitchen and make a brew when we get a corner or a free kick on the edge of the box.🫣