You get what you deserve, except the Tims
I’ve gotta say it, Saint Mirren deserve their name on the trophy, they got what they deserve as a club, as a manager, and as a group of players.
Celtic also got what they deserve this week, the biggest reality check since the Covid season and one of the best run clubs in Europe (not my words) with ambitions to be world class in everything they do (the boards words) are officially in crisis and a laughing stock.
The weather brought rain which I believed would benefit the better footballers, generally identified by value, International Caps and trophy haul. This alongside the seemingly wide Hampden pitch (same dimensions as Falkirk apparently) plus the fact we had a larger travelling support hinted that we might have an advantage before a ball was kicked.
That thought quickly evaporated when the teamsheet was announced. I was glad to see Benji benched, we expected Kelechi up front, but Ralston at right centreback and Tonetki ahead of him just made no sense. Neither did putting Arne left and Reo right which reverses their usual roles. I understand the KT inclusion on the left but to me that only makes sense if its balanced by another fullback on the opposite flank to provide a really strong back 5, ie Colby Donovan not Tonetki.
I didn’t like nor understand the team selection. But its a Final and surely the Bhoys would be pumped up to win, at 7.30 am on the West Coast I was smiling with anticipation.
By 7.31 I was smiling with disbelief. Callum opts to kick off, we quickly foray up the park which was encouraging but its easily mopped up (a sign of things to come) and they likewise opt for a quick thrust up the park which results in a corner with about a minute gone.
I said to myself ‘dont be paranoid’, turns out I wasnt paranoid enough.
When the corner taker started his movement two attackers split from the mass and quickly attacked the front post dragging two defenders with them. With the ball in the air and a nice bit of free space opening up right in front of goal, I realized we had been done. Sure enough, Garry’s nephew Marcus Frazer hit that space and produced a delicious bending header that was inch perfect hitting the inside of the post leaving the save nigh impossible. Reo might as well not have tracked him, he was useless, but then again I can’t remember him ever being the ‘saved a certain goal with that tackle/header’ type so I can’t say he’s to blame when Celtic simply cannot defend corners.
Okay so we are one down just after kickoff, but theres a reason its the best time to concede, theres an entire match left. However Celtic were clearly rattled and the first 15/20 minutes was an extremely painful watch that offered next to zero hope. We were pathetic, really should have been two down actually and then,,,Im not sure why, maybe we had finally gotten to grips with the surface or perhaps just settled down,,but Celtic suddenly began to play.
Seemingly out of nowhere we had better control, more movement, a bit of a spark that made the affair interesting and Im finally rubbing my hands thinking ‘game on’.
This spell first delivered a half chance, then two good chances, then ultimately the equalizer.
The second phase of a freekick saw KT sweep it into no-mans-land but Reo had smartly stayed onside, then tracked the ball, and pulled out a beautiful volley which was the only thing beating their excellent keeper on the day.
It truly was game on and 99 out of 100 fans surveyed would say yes Celtic will go on and win this now they are playing and have scored.
I was certainly in that camp.
As the old song says ‘I shoulda known better’.
Our ‘rebirth’ lasted approximately another 12 minutes and when Kelechi pulled up and grabbed the back of his leg it officially ended. He had been instrumental in that brief rebirth, and our bench just didn’t have a like for like replacement. Johnny Kenny replaced our now injured again main striker, while I wanted Daizen up front with Tonetki shoved left and Yang on the right.
The remainder of the half was scrappy and I thought we had visibly lost whatever cohesion we had between the midfield and attack, Inenacho a massive lose to our play. The opening 15 of the second half only confirmed what my eyes were telling me, we had lost our cutting edge and connection.
Seriously worried, I watched as our opponents grew in confidence realizing Celtic were toothless and sure enough when they found themselves in a position to capitalize they did. A scrumptious lob over the rearguard was met with a finish it deserved and once again we needed to respond but I just couldn’t see where it was coming from.
12 minutes later came the hammer blow. Piling numbers forward while flaffing around the ball in the final third we gave away possession and quick as a flash we were counter attacked. Robinson played a masterclass leaving two dangerous widemen upfield for the outball, they collected then combined and that was that. We all knew this team wasnt scoring the 3 we needed to win, nor the 2 to deliver a penalty shootout we would never have won.
Infact they really should have had a 4th on another late counter.
When the whistle blew I said to myself the best team won on the day. Celtic might, maybe, have some decent footballers,,but we dont have a team. The better plan worked on the day, the better system that had years in the making with players accustomed to and signed for that very system. Their manager has reportedly been watching Colombus Crew videos for three weeks, and it worked a trick.
My hat is tipped, enjoy your bonuses and your still ongoing celebration session. Gamblers, back whoever they face next.
Those at Celtic responsible for this calamitous week can enjoy what they sowed, what they deserve.
Those seven days have literally thrown fuel on the fire that was already getting out of hand and the house of cards is collapsing with nowhere to hide. World class in degrading a once respected football club, whilst minted. They’ve handed the Collective an open goal with our triple exposure over seven days.
And sitting here now typing this, it looks like another own goal hiring Wilf. His system might work elsewhere, but its not working here and now. I couldn’t believe what I was seeing, asking ‘backs to the walls’ defenders like Scales and Trusty to become ‘quarterbacks’. It was Trusty stepping out of defense that caused the second goal ultimately. Im looking at a feeble forward line including subpar Kenny, a tenth of last year’s Daizen, and the Tunisian Mikey Johnston and thinking our only hope is goals from midfield. The manager never noticed with Reo and Engles switched they shoot less if ever, and Callum was never finding space for a rocket off that hard working and well organized opposition. In fairness he brought on Yang and Luke, but with goals needed and a retreating backline which suits our top scorer Nygren he ignores him. Colby proved in his all too brief spell that he was worth the start in a one-off must win game.
I saw him grab Callum for a tactics talk and instruct him to spray his passes wide ala Paul Scholes, and Im thinking he doesn’t do that, he hits the easiest pass and has done for years. Like watching Scales and Trusty be tasked with the breakthrough ball, its not gonna happen. The manager would need an entire new team to play his style, with zero guarantees of a return.
Just imagine how easy it is to find an under 3million ball playing centreback that can also cope with the physical game and wont mind the weather nor the less than EPL Championship wages,,and hes gotta hit the ground running plus be under 24 so we hopefully make a big profit?
I see the biggest self made clusterfuck because either his system won’t work or we won’t source the players to play it,,if its even worth going all in on. And I will be fucking furious if we bother a 73 year old man again, I sincerely hope his wife and family take the phone and tell ‘him’ to ‘do one’ should that call occur. I do have some sympathy for Wilf, obviously we know from constant observation what each player is capable of, he wasnt afforded that chance and at least dropping Nygren was a sign that regular starters weren’t safe, admirable. Its not his fault on many issues, and Daizen is the classic example. Of course a new manager would rub his hands at those stats from last season and think ‘what a player Ive got’ but hes literally phoning it in by previous standards.
All these International players must look good on paper, but they haven’t shown up for the guts of a year and have reached the end of their cycle. I count 7 out of the 25 odds I would keep. He’s been sold a sows ear not a silk purse, no wonder he looks bad, regardless of whether his system fits.
As a football club we needed the self sustainable evolution into a regular Champions League club, today we need revolution as those who created the mess should not be tasked with fixing it, especially after years of world class bullshit that’s came to nothing but swelling coffers that dont win you games. Schooled by Saint Mirren and Hearts, embarrassed in Europe,,,all hail the glorious balance sheet!
I would like to tell you this is rock bottom and the only way is up, but we are sinking and sinking fast. Our pain their gain must end, is ending, and not a penny more has never been more justified. The Tims aren’t getting what they deserve, a good version of Celtic, but Collectively we can help give this board what they deserve, a boot out the door.
Celtic til I die.
By Mahe
I
Our donations page for McMillan Cancer Care has now closed,having raised almost £1700 plus Gift Aid. Thank you to everyone who was a part of this, you are all wonderful and generous people.
That’s over £6000 in eighteen months, and you should rightfully feel significant pride in that.
Our new charity campaign will begin immediately, and as ever, it will be for a charity of your choice. Nominated via these pages, and chosen as the most worthy by our contributors.
It is Chidren’s Hospices Across Scotland (CHAS). Nominated by BAWHEID, and overwhelmingly the landslide winner of the vote. We have just reached our first target of £1000, and you can help us reach our next one.
£1888
You can donate by following this link, as set up by CHALMERSBHOY (and grateful thanks once again for doing so!)
https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinel-celts-2?utm_medium=FA&utm_source=EM
There is a default payment method by ApplePay, which I don’t use. Just click ”change” above the payment bar to view other options.
POTY competition sencelpoty@gmail.com
And don’t forget our world class medical staff, responsible for Saracchi, AJ and now Iheanacho ALL re-injuring their hamstrings, a medical department literally harming our players.
NOT A FUCKIN PENNY MORE.
HOUND THAT BOARD.
Said it a million times ..if you want these fuckers to know you even exist, you have to do more than just spend your time arguing with their online helpers, and boy were they working hard last night.
Still Brendan’s fault, yeah? Thought his name would come up again!
You need to get by those rats to get to king rat!
No point saying the same thing over and over about this manager, it was clear almost immediately he didn’t have a clue what he was doing! Still some were prepared to place all the blame on the players ..are these people for real?
This board will again do what our manager chose to do in the last two games, double down, as that is what they usually do, and fuck what you think about it!
Strap yourselves in, this is about to get a whole lot worse! The board have been trying to get us here for years. We used to win in spite of the board, now we’ll need to somehow win in spite of the manager too!!
Make no mistake – this was all done on purpose.
🤔
Mind this from dermot’s childish toys out the pram rant….
“Every member of the board and executive team is deeply passionate about Celtic and acts at all times with a professionalism, integrity and a shared desire for success. What has failed recently was not due to our structure or model but to one individuals desire for self preservation at the expense of others”.
Well you know what? That individual who openly stated he wanted to improve, not maintain, and who begged in open court for two months for players is now swinging on his hammock saying see I fecking Telt ye!
World Class in everything we do.
Here’s the worst part… we kinda knew that was
going to happen.
Calmac should have just gone original 433 above Wilfried’s playbook.
Video playback will be painful but will it be instructive or destructive ?
https://philmacgiollabhain.ie/
Morning troops
Well we’ve been here before, a painful LC final defeat to a lowered ranked team, StMirren now join Patrick and Raith with that honour.
However, with the latter two came belief that Jock would sort it out quickly and the hope that Tommy would create his vision for Celtic. What has Wilfred given us?
3 games is too soon to sack a Manager, so we can forget that talk immediately. Nonetheless, 5 or 6 defeats would prove untenable imo. That’s where we are folks.
The Board wanted this man, so they’ll need to back him, but I think we can write off this season as it’s obviously going to take the guts of 6 months to implement his ideology and two windows to sign his own players.
But for now, just win Wilfred, that’s the bottom line for you on Wednesday.
That’s a great combination for a manager to have .. incapable and arrogant.
So we just have to trust the process? Fuck that! Another throw away line the incapable use to buy lots more time that they use to double down and continue to make things worse.
We are fast running out of people to point the finger at ..time to point it at those who have caused this, and those brought here to implement their managed decline.
Waiting in hope is simply not an option here!
Good morning, friends.
I dont see me overcoming my embarrassment at the thought of issuing reminders for this latest game. But, win lose or draw, there does still have to be a Man Of The Match along with a ranking of the 16 players that (ahem) contributed yesterday. Not sure I’ll post again before 9.00pm tonight…
SENCELPOTY@GMAIL.COM
BAD
Everyone knows who caused it, but I’m afraid it’s got a bit further to drop, I mean a few seasons worth of this, before the groundswell of fan anger and opinion will move to total rebellion.
Nothing changes fast at Celtic, everything, including how we got to where we are today, is a gradual decline.
Great article, MAHE. Doesn’t miss.
Hands up everyone who thought Nancy deserved more time!
BMCUWPs @ 12:27 am,
“AULDHEID 1152
No evidence? You should have been defending OJ, you missed your calling.”
Spot~on:)))))
Auldheid @ 8:33 pm,
Rebus 67
Yes, lack of quality players is an issue but what we have should be good enough to beat St M, and yet, we were way short of doing that.
========
I disagree. What we do have if everyone is fit should be good enough but what we do have on the day after injury and tiredness was not strong enough to beat stronger opposition.
Bring back Bobo.”
How do you reconcile that with what you stated about Brendan Rodgers.
You slandered Brendan Rodgers by stating he was working his ticket when his injury-decimated side got beat at Tynecastle by an in form Hearts side.
Auldheid @ 9:00 pm,
The anti-Rodgers brigada were saying the Brendan Rodgers had brought Dr Tisdale in and all the summer signings were on those two.
This is now ridiculous for two reasons; Brendan Rodgers repeatedly said recruitment wasn’t good enough, again you’d have to be pretty warped that on one hand Brendan Rodgers was overseeing all the recruitment, then going to media conferences week in, week out saying it wasn’t good enough.
Brendan Rodgers went and so did John Kennedy, Adam Sadler, Jack Lyons, Glen Driscoll – yet Paul Tisdale stayed and has become more influential.
Auldheid @ 10:05 pm, 11:02 pm,
You criticise Brendan Rodgers for the summer recruitment shambles – yet you say we lost the game because our two best fighters went.
As Kelechi and KT were our best two fighters, KT brought back by JK and BR, K Iheanacho brought in after the window closed by Brendan how do you reconcile that contradiction?
Auldheid @ 11:14 pm,
“It would have been a collective board decision of which BR accepted/approved.”
Two points here, you are again stating supposition as fact – there is no evidence that all decisions at Celtic PLC are a collective Board decision, in fact since September it has been more and more obvious that Celtic are an autocracy ran by Dermot Desmond and proxy Peter Lawwell.
When Brendan Rodgers came back he agreed to be a “team player”, not pushing back on all the Board’s football decisions – that is now getting rubbed in his face as his tacit approval, all the time those really responsible had sloping shoulders and now worse Roger Hannah of the Sun or official club statements to disseminate their falsehoods.
Auldheid @ 11:52 pm, INIQUITOUS IV
There is a huge amount of evidence that Brendan Rodgers was sabotaged.
Firstly the recruitment and player sales in 2025 means the team were very badly weakened, this is down to huge incompetence or sabotage.
If incompetence why are those who are responsible still in position? In fact they have been highly supported and commended by the Board.
The hierarchy that went to the Sun and briefed Roger Hannah, slandering our then manager – that was sabotage.
What about Dermot Desmond’s official statement eviscerating Brendan Rodgers with nonsense and hearsay, that was sabotage.
Among other evidence I posted this…
“He’s the only manager in the club’s history who has repeatedly questioned things….” 5th Sept
“statements about transfers and club operations came entirely out of the blue…” 27th Oct
I asked you to reconcile the obvious contridiction and you couldn’t. This tells us that the hierarchy are making up their own version of events that suits them at any particular time to sabotage Brendan Rodgers
We know what the Executive promised Brendan Rodgers when they pleaded with him to come back – and what we are seeing is not a world-class club but sabotage – a hierarchy to were more than willing to bite of their nose to spite their face.
Auldheid @ 1:32 am,
Brendan Rodgers made his position clear in many interviews and media conferences, that is all a matter of record, the wisdom of his candour may be questioned but the content of it is on the record, the promises the Board made to Brendan Rodgers on his return is on the record.
Why don’t you c&p what LQB stated? If it’s key to the discussion, let’s have a proper dialogue.
Just as an aside…
How does your slander of Brendan Rodgers fit in with your
No blame, peace and love and flowers charade,
Hail Hail
San Luis,
You suggested that yesterday the manager was blameless,, still believe that?
Drew67 @ 2:06 am,
“Magua
Iv always felt thay PL pulled the wool over DD’s eyes on stuff outside of business/money matters..just my personal view
Martin O’Neil couldnt believe how average the Celtic forwards were especially Kenny”
That would be my take, obviously DD is the autocratic boss yet this circus is in reality not run by the “owner” it is run by the ringmaster.
Our last disasterous period ended when he left as CEO.
It is no coincidence this disaster comes from him ascerting his “authority” again.
Hail Hail
BAD, SAN LUIS et al
You are right on the money-pun intended. We know where the blame lies, and why we are here. As always, it lies at the top.
BR should never have been reappointed when AP left. Yes, he had “unfinished business”, in that he felt he had bridges to build with the fans who felt let down at the timing of his first departure, but the reasons for that departure were still there. Chief amongst them, Lawwell.
Who really thought that Lawwell would put up with the thought of a cheesy smiling Rodgers lording it over him and milking the applause? All he had to do was bide his time, and rinse and repeat from their first time together. After all, those first two disastrous windows this time around backfired-cost his son his job and made Rodgers a hero.
Remember the millions of wingers? Or needing a new CB because Boyata wanted out? And getting Kompper! Rinse and repeat, this time up front. Sell Kühn. Tell him we’ve received an offer for Maeda. Light the touchpaper and stand back.
Doncha just love it when a plan comes together…
If it’s not blindingly obvious by now who the board plants are, I fear you will never see these cunts.
They never take a day off ..no matter how obvious they might appear!
Blame anyone – and I mean anyone – but those who have done this to the club!
BMCUWPs @ 1:40 am,
“AULDHEID
Apart from a very brief visit last Sunday-where, as I expected, some were blaming BR for it!-i stopped reading it a week or so before BR left. The nonsense being written about him-like his son being a certain player’s agent, for example-was getting beyond a joke. If I’d stuck around, I would have fallen out with people that I have a great deal of respect and time for.”
Very well said – Total respect.
👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏
Auldheid…
When I suggested you were getting information from a third party as the things you were posting coincided with the “placemen” e.g. Mark Lawwell and his great recruitment record, like Trusty, Engels and Idah a waste of money like Brendan Rodgers working his ticket…
All stuff from the placemen, all stuff you said you’d thought up yourself and had not been third party briefed.
Yet now it appears you have very much been swayed by the placemen on LQB
I stated at the time, the nonsense being peddled by you on this site was the same detail as others on different sites was too much of a coincidence, yet you weren’t having it – Phil Mac didn’t trash your reputation by giving out dodgy info. You did that by disseminating it.
Hail Hail
San Luis
December 15, 2025 9:24 am
Finding a new manager, if it comes to that, will not be easy. Certainly not a manager of the right calibre.
Dermot Desmond’s petulant and unprofessional rant has made sure of that, never mind any other consideration.
BAD
Please stop mentioning board plants. I strongly disagree with the opinions of some on here too, but I doubt very much that they are board plants. There are more important discussions, more important targets. We should focus on that.
Bobby,
So, none of us are allowed to point out the obvious about all these sites ..why? If there’s no board plants, what exactly is the problem?
What is there to fear from the truth??
BAD
I’m not getting dragged into this again. It’s a polite request, and you’ve made your point.
The manager is certainly not blameless.
But imo , these supposed international players , are more too blame.
I don’t believe we have hit rock bottom yet , unfortunately.
Bobby,
Youre not getting dragged into this? No one asked you to involve yourself.
We were told the rules here were simple, no personal abuse, which I agree with.
So, I’ll ask again, if there are no board plants here, who could possibly be offended at me and others speaking about them?
You’re not making a lot of sense here. Are you now telling us what we can and can’t talk about?
MON on Talksport saying he would have stayed on to the end of the season if asked, but no one did. Also, Nancy didn’t want to listen to him when he wanted to hand over the reins, and the entire process took 15 minutes.
The board need to get the arrogant French idiot gone immediately and go back to MON with their best grovelling faces and ask him to save this season.
Absolutely brilliant article in the Irish independent this morning. Desmond won’t be happy…the line “Maybe someone at the club thought Ted Lasso was a documentary” is fucking brilliant.
Eamonn Sweeney
Celtic deserve better than Dermot Desmond. Enough is enough. Things can’t go on like this. Ireland’s leading Bismarck lookalike and his minions are dragging the club down the drain. It’s hard to imagine things improving on their watch.
Their League Cup final loss to St Mirren was one of the most humiliating episodes in Celtic’s history. This was “Super Caley go ballistic Celtic are atrocious” territory.
The game was a 90-minute embodiment of the dysfunction which has enveloped Parkhead this season.
St Mirren have won just three of 15 Premier League games. They lie ninth out of 12 in the table and are the league’s lowest scorers. It’s 99 years since they beat Celtic in a cup final.
The idea that they would not just beat Celtic but outclass them would have seemed outlandish, but the paradox is that you could almost see it coming.
Celtic have cruised towards disaster with the blithe unconcern of the Titanic entering a field of icebergs.
Something like yesterday’s fiasco was on the cards. The surprise was that little St Mirren, to their credit, were the ones to take full advantage.
It’s not a case of hindsight being 20/20 vision. The omens were clear after a pre-season transfer window widely derided as the worst in club history.
Just nine months ago Celtic came agonisingly close to bringing Bayern Munich to extra-time in the Champions League round of 16. It was the kind of European performance which had almost vanished from the club repertoire.
The expectation was that Celtic would kick on and strengthen the squad significantly in the close season. Brendan Rodgers certainly expected it.
Instead, the board took the miser’s route and left the manager with a weaker side than last season. Champions League qualifying-round humiliation at the hands of Kazakhstan’s FC Kairat (currently 36th of 36 in the league phase) followed.
Rodgers barely tried to hide his dismay but his departure at the end of October still came as a surprise. More surprising still was the statement which followed soon afterwards in which Desmond described Rodgers as, “divisive, misleading and self-serving”, accused him of “creating a toxic atmosphere” and “fuelling hostility” towards the board.
Dermot Desmond (right), Celtic’s chief shareholder
Dermot Desmond (right), Celtic’s chief shareholder
The chief shareholder’s extraordinary outburst reeked of plutocratic entitlement. Anyone spouting such invective was hardly in a position to complain about others being divisive, self-serving and toxic.
It further inflamed the atmosphere within a club descending into chaos. Celtic’s AGM had to be adjourned after five minutes when shareholders heckled board members and called for them to be sacked.
On its resumption, Ross Desmond, son of Dermot, decided it would be a good idea to read a statement describing the board’s critics as, “irrational” and “bullies”. The reaction to this led to the meeting being abandoned altogether.
The board’s one good idea was to bring Martin O’Neill in as caretaker manager. O’Neill won seven of eight games with the victories including a thrilling win over Rangers in the League Cup semi-final and an outstanding 3-1 away defeat of Feyenoord in the Europa League.
It would have been wise to leave O’Neill in charge until the end of the season. His experience would have been invaluable at such a fraught time.
Instead, Celtic brought in Wilfried Nancy, late of Major League Soccer’s Columbus Crew. They still had the option of leaving O’Neill in charge for the tricky trifecta of a league match against title rivals Hearts, a Europa League tie against AS Roma and the League Cup final.
But they threw Nancy in at the deep end and his credibility has instantly been damaged by three terrible losses. Questions are already being asked about his suitability for the job.
Nancy is a somewhat odd choice whose managerial experience consists solely of four years in Canada and the US. Very few managers have made the crossover to European football from North America.
The most notable was Jesse Marsch, like Nancy a former MLS Manager of the Year, who flopped at Leeds United. Maybe someone at Celtic thinks Ted Lasso was a documentary.
The way Nancy’s team steamed blithely forward into attack only to be picked apart on the counter suggested a certain naivety on the new boss’s part. The English and Scottish league experience of Saints manager Stephen Robinson seemed to prepare him much better for yesterday’s challenge.
Wilfried Nancy has had a nightmare start to his time at Parkhead.
Wilfried Nancy has had a nightmare start to his time at Parkhead.
Liam Scales, Arne Engels and Daizen Maeda are players of proven quality whose dire performances suggested a certain puzzlement about Nancy’s change of system. The constant internal turmoil at the club is hardly helping player morale either.
The new manager’s disastrous start presents the board with an instant dilemma. At what stage do they cut their losses if the experiment isn’t working? Their extreme parsimoniousness will make them reluctant to pay out a contract.
Yet waiting in the wings is Ange Postecoglou, who knows the ropes, is a fan favourite and was expected by many people to succeed Rodgers after fortuitously becoming available around the time of the resignation.
Perhaps the board will be governed by what appears to have become its guiding principle. Namely that it can do what it wants because no matter how badly Celtic is run, the team will still win the league.
Hearts may currently be top of the table but the odds are that for the 14th time in 15 seasons Celtic will prevail in the end. The board may feel that everything will be forgiven when the league trophy is once more paraded around the ground.
Yet such victories ring increasingly hollow as a catalogue of humiliations betray a proud European tradition. A club which once considered itself the equivalent of the English giants has become a north-of-the-border Norwich City. The fans are told they shouldn’t expect anything better.
Christmas is coming and Tims both tiny and large are being tormented by the Scrooges of the board. It’s time for the Ghost of Celtic Past to arise, rattle its chains and make them change their ways.
Otherwise, God help us everyone.
Morning all,
Sol Kitts,
Wow !!!!!!
Some very interesting points there and to think WN would not listen to Mon is really staggering.
It really is one big Shitshow and things are going to get worse. ( I fear )
👎 👎 👎 👎 👎
Auldheid
December 15, 2025 12:04 am
‘As regards having David Low as an authority, I finally found out why Low was dead against Res12. He shared a Directorship with Donald McIntyre in his pub business who was the Rangers official who accepted the £2.8m potential liability before 31st March making at a payable overdue if not paid by then.’
###
Which company were they co directors of?
BAD 10.10
Is the manager blameless? No, but he’s certainly not responsible for the state of the club and the quality of players inherited.
This team, plus AJ and CCV could not find a way past Barry Ferguson Huns, nor Russell Martin’s. They couldn’t even beat the lowest ranked team available in the CL qualifying games , unable to score in almost 4 hrs. So, even with an elite manager we struggled big time.
We got fortunate with MON ( we are a lucky club, I’ll give you that), and his victories lifted the support and the players, but performances were pretty much in the ‘ dire’ camp. Would he have gotten them over the line yesterday? Probably, but what if he hadn’t,what then?
We now have a new guy, our main target , who looks completely out of his depth, but who was appointed on a 2.5 yr contract, I presume, to change things?
So, I think we need to back him to the hilt and suck up some bad days like yesterday and accept that this “Decade of Domination” is over and get used to the sharing of silverware and bragging rights for the coming season or so.
Alternatively, we bin him immediately and go back to someone we know. Because, no top Manager is touching us with a barge pole.
Sol Kitts
Thanks for posting that, it confirms everything I thought. Everything we are seeing is a deliberate act of self harm and this new “ Manager” is an arrogant fool. Perfect pick by the Board
San Luis,
We could pick thousands of results from our past to make a point, Jock Stein lost a cup final 4-1 to Patrick.
It was clear to some of us we might be making a monumental mistake by not asking Martin to hang around till the summer, and so it has proven.
Right up till last night, you and others wanted to blame the players ..I simply don’t understand why you’d want this guy Wilfred to remain in place for even one more day
Back him to the hilt? I would have sacked him when he chose to repeat his Hearts fuck up! The fact that he arrogantly chose to repeat the same mistakes at Hampden simply beggars belief!
The guy is way, way out of his depth, and backing him would be absolutely suicidal.
We need to act, and we need to act now!!
Nabbla,
Thanks for posting that article which reviews the history of how the club arrived at this point. I need a review like that in order to sort out my thoughts on what might happen next.
Clearly MON and Ange are immediate options. Each would be available without having to pay compensation. However, MON might be sceptical now and Ange would probably want a contract longer than just the end of the season. Of the two, I’d prefer MON.
Hopefully, the Board are smart enough to have a meeting this week to discuss options and costs. Costs are important for not just the obvious reason. Keeping WN means he needs to be backed in, at least, the next transfer window. In addition to a striker, he needs at least one WB and CB. That is before he considers the midfield where players would need to be moved out before others were brought in. The squad needs investment anyway but how risky is it to fund a playing style that shows no sign of being viable?
On the other hand, sacking WN and his team has significant costs. Paying out two and a half year contracts, although phased over the term, adds to management costs which will already have been inflated by some form of payoff to BR. In addition, whoever comes in brings additional costs. All of this is accounted as football expenses contributing to the FSR calculation. In short, it impacts on allowable transfer expenses.
The Board is struggling with the civil war with the Collective and the fanbase, generally. There are many specific issues but they are all centred around the accusation of incompetence. Looking at the current impact of the new management regime on performance, it would be an extremely insensitive board that did not see some truth in the Collective’s theme.
The current “crisis” over the manager is really only part of the Board’s dilemma. Questions need to be asked on how we arrived at this point. How was it possible for an inexperienced manager from another continent to become, first of all, a target, and then to emerge as the successful candidate? Then, of course, there is the small matter of how do you ensure that it does not happen again.
Rebus
BAD,
Interested in why you think that the Board wants the club to fail, or at least be less successful.
Or, have I got the wrong end of the stick?
Rebus
BAD
Yes, I blame the players. For a team full of established internationalist to repeatedly fail under 3 different managers in Europe and two Managers domestically, suggest to me they have neither the ability nor the balls required to play for Glasgow Celtic.
“Big game” players who cannot win big games at home or abroad this past 18 months need gutting. I think, off the top of my head, we have a 25% win rate in big games in that period , under 3 different managers against some very poor opponents too.
It’s not going to improve any time soon with this squad. So, rip it up and start again is my preference.
Rebus,
Hey mate.
I could simply ask if you DON’T see managed decline here, then how would you describe what we are witnessing?
What sense did the board actions in the summer (And most windows) make, when they knew we’d be competing across 4 different tournaments?
Why the determination to take what was a winning formula, then keep ripping it up to the point we’re getting outclassed at Hampden by St Mirren??
And on and on …
None of what I believe is giving me any pleasure.
Hope you’re good.
Eamonn Sweeney is a brave man penning that article.
Especially as it points the finger at our petulant and vicious major shareholder who refuses to contemplate he has been disastrous in the running of our club.
A man with political clout in Ireland.
But as someone posted we have still to see the worst from this Despot and his Board sycophants.
These charlatans who claim to be Celtic supporters will put self first so for the present I see no light at the end of the tunnel.
The large bank balance will see them ride out fans dissatisfaction and financial boycott’s until surplus has dwindled.
I have actively started to seek other pleasures as a replacement for a club I don’t recognise who were once an everyday part of who I am.
Loved being part of a cause but now we are reduced to being nothing more than retail stream for already rich parasites.
San Luis,
Me and you disagreeing on who to blame just gives those looking for that, exactly what they want, us all fighting amongst ourselves ..
I’m just not understanding how anyone can think the players are solely to blame for the embarrassment this week has been.
These same players had absolutely no problem adjusting to what Martin asked of them, and went out and proved it by winning games we’d have zero confidence of winning now.
I’m afraid Wilfred is not only incapable of leading a club our size, he’s now proven to be an arrogant fool on top of that! That is a combination we simply can’t allow to last any longer ..unless we want to have another trophy less season while sitting on a mountain of money.
Wonder what the Huns would do with 10s of millions, eh?
Fan
👍
BAD
No harm in disagreement at all mate, healthy for debate and you always come with good intentions and no malice.
I know the overall issues are at the top and as I’ve said previously it’s gonna take years to remove them all.
But, for For now, we need better players, better able to cope with the more robust nature of Scottish football and the cheating SFA.
I am with BAD, Nancy has to go now, he has totally lost the players, there is no way back for him. We will be lucky to finish in top three if he stays.
Put Maloney (and I’m no fan of Maloney) and Fotheringham in place to end of season—-with sizable bonus incentives and bring MON back in an advisory capacity. As the season goes on, watch, analyze, way up the options, and make decisions before end of season.
“If asked I’d have stayed on to end of season”
Martin O’Neill
Are the board waiting till Auchinleck Talbot humiliate us in the cup? I guess their manager watched our last 3 games and is currently coaching his team to exploit our obvious weaknesses – lack of structure, players out of position, no striker worthy of the name, and an arrogant manager who won’t accept that he’s getting it wrong in every way. This game was always a potential banana skin, but with Nancy in charge it threatens to be the worst humiliation ever in the history of the club.
San Luis…if the players are a combination of not good enough, badly coached and poorly set up who then takes the blame?
Nancy, in my opinion, has been put in an impossible situation but instead of trying to understand where he was at he doubled down and has compromised his own position.
If the players aren’t good enough it’s not on Brendan, MON or Nancy, its on the recruitment policy.
No matter what way you look at this, Nancy does not have the tools to do the job. And that is down to the man in charge of the football department. So, Dr Football, the self titled grandee, takes all responsibility. But, as always there’s a but, all of this charade, every last bit of it, sits with the Board and Desmond.
This is not a bad run of games. This is a mismanaged company. A fortune in the bank for no discernible reason. All of our best players sold every year. Players sourced on the cheap and just not at the standard required. The Company actively disengaging from its customer base. A main shareholder’s son calling out a section of the support for questioning the policies of the company, worse actually, they asked for dialogue but were vilified and banned. Police Scotland deciding who gets to support Celtic, enabled by the Board.
Aye, blame the players!
San Luis,
We are actually in agreement about needing better players, but my point is that a half decent manager would make sure we weren’t getting embarrassed by a team as bad as St Mirren.
I don’t expect everyone to agree with what I believe, I just want to be able to say what I believe as long as I’m respectful of others, and I certainly try hard.
I’m also on record saying we won’t get rid of the Desmond’s because we want them gone, I believe we won’t see the back of them before they decide they no longer want to be here
It’s some position we are in.
As ever, good to shoot the breeze with you.
Edward Sweeney will be getting a chap at the door……
McCaff,
I will put my hand up and say he should get more time. No club can sack a manager after three games and expect to get anyone else worth the position to take the job. I am on record as saying I didn’t think Nancy had the experience but maybe it’s a bit like players. We have to get them earlier because once they have a certain amount of games they’re out our reach.
I put a lot of the blame at the feet of the players. San Luis has said a lot of what I would be saying. We wanted change, we’ve got it now and it’s not working. But any change can be painful. If he goes back on his principles as some seem to want him to do then I would say he’d be taking a backward step. He is wedded to his system the way AP was to his and BR to his. He needs to keep playing this way to see who can step up and who he needs to discard before he goes into the window. If he goes to what we were playing under O’Neill more a 4-2-3-1 he might get results but he won’t know anything for the future. This league was always in jeopardy. As SL points out again, this team has won maybe 25% of big games and been beaten by Aberdeen, Huns, hearts, Almaty and that’s before you get to the games we’d expect to lose like Mytjiitland.
Anyone pining for the return of martin O’Neill can forget it after he talked out of school today. He’ll be the next one getting a DD statement. Nancy spoke to O’Neill for 15 minutes. He said he told him he needed to win and to get the senior players on side. Nancy he felt the best way to do this was to use his system. It’s not working but it won’t work if we don’t keep playing it. He is not getting sacked and all the blogging, tweeting, booing and leaving on 70 minutes is not changing that. This board just digs in further.
The last manager that came in mid season was Neil Lennon. He didn’t change much, maybe made us a bit more solid but he lost a cup semi final to Ross county and still got the job permanently. He was three down at Killie and in danger of slipping double figures behind the Huns when the SUPPORT decided to get behind the team and drag them out of the malaise they were in. We are not supporting Nancy. To my mind he is a the lightening rod for our disgust at our board and we need to give him time.
Martin O’Neill was asked when he was leaving what his final words were for the fans. He said “they need to remember they’re the best fans in the world.” The way we are treating Nancy tells me we’re not even the best supporters in Glasgow. One league out of 14 for the Huns and they still have 50k buying season tickets. Three defeats in a row and we have written off the new manager. I’m shocked by the vitriol towards him. It’s not how I see Celtic supporters and if we lose this league our season tickets will drop off a cliff. That would be two losses in 15 and we’d have less season ticket holders than at ibrox. Hmm 🤔
Kettlewell binned by Killie.