In Martin We Trust
Morning, all.
We are now halfway through the January transfer window, a window that we are told every year is a treacherous one to tread and notoriously difficult to get any business done. We are told that by no less august people than the board themselves, and of course their various useful idiots in the assorted media.
The truth is rather different, as many other clubs are more than capable of getting their own business done-especially if that business includes buying players from Celtic! We seem to have little or no problem selling our players in the January window, nor the summer one either, come to that. It’s just that pesky business of getting the traffic to move in two directions that stumps us every time.
Well, not every time. I seem to remember that Postecoglu had no problems there. First time around it was Maeda, Hatate and O’Riley. The following year brought in a right back, fresh from an admirable stint in the Qatar World Cup. Situation Normal, All Fucked Up returned with his departure. Normal, as in Normal For Celtic. For over two decades now-Willo Flood, anyone?
We could go a long way towards explaining this situation if we reflect on those two decades. Two decades in which football inflation has rocketed fees and wages ever upwards as money has flowed into the game from TV deals, oligarchs, petrostates and hedge funds. Two decades during which those useful idiots have been at pains to tell us that “the bubble” is about to burst, and that Celtic will be well placed when it happens. Two decades during which we have seen standards on the pitch plummet for the simple reason that we refuse to pay the going rate for quality, preferring to rummage around in the bargain bins for “projects”.
£500k to £2m didn’t buy you much twenty years ago. An Amido Balde, perhaps. A Bangura or a Cifcti. Do it a couple of times on four or five year contracts and that’s about £15m the pair. For crap that the manager won’t play and that we can’t get rid of. Penny wise and pound foolish would be an expression that springs to mind. So would incompetence. Or firing offence.
We have laughed for some time now at our neighbours southside, throwing good money after bad. We don’t do such things, oh no-we throw BAD money after bad. Time and time again. Repeat ad nauseam. For two bloody decades of declining standards. The only saving graces have been that sometimes we’ve hired managers who can fashion something out of a sow’s ear, though rarely a silk purse. Functional, adequate for continued domestic success; that’s about the limit of our ambition. Meanwhile, for once, R2ngers seem to actually done their homework this time and are signing the type of oven ready players-including big hard basterts in each sector-who can continue their title challenge. Hearts are doing the same, with the capable assistance of Bloom’s analytics bods.
We plead for help from Duhan.
Martin O’Neill has now decided to take the initiative on transfers, with Shaun Maloney trying to identify the types of player that we need. But we were already almost a week into the window before they were appointed, whic is an obvious handicap. The two then discuss the issue before putting the requests to the board-which is where the process stalls and negotiations collapse. Or don’t even start, as so few clubs will even answer the phone to us these days, such is our reputation as bad actors on transfers.
The people who sit in the hot seat at the club-or the heated and padded seats at least-cannot be blind to the dross that our current and previous managers have had to pick from. They see it twice a week at the moment, same as the rest of us. The only argument to be had is not whether the squad is good enough or not, but whether it is the worst in 30, 50 or 70 years! It is those people who have put us there, and MON is here to put it right for them. They have two weeks to get it done, and two weeks already wasted when we should have had players through the door already.
Instead, it appears that they are treating January the same way as they treat August. August sees us playing European qualifiers, and they habitually wait to see which tournament we will actually compete in before buying players-oblivious to the obvious fact that buying quality beforehand would have improved our chances of being at the big table. This time, they are prepared to see us go to Bologna and Tynecastle then host Utrecht before they decide whether there is anything at all to salvage from the season, a season that they themselves have actively sabotaged since this time last year.
We can’t wait for Celtic Time, those frantic last few hours. We’ve played three games this month, three games which are a reflection of the season as a whole. Dreadful in one, fine in another, then lucky in the third. We cannot rely on luck one game in three, especially if we are dreadful just as often. “Give me lucky generals” is attributed to Napoleon, but that didn’t work too well for him in the end!
Neither has ignoring football inflation, signing projects, chiselling the other side in transfers. Presenting yourself as The Smartest Guy In The Room. Or waiting for the bubble to burst. In Martin, we trust. It’s the useless basterts that have to get the deals over the line that’s the problem.
<><><><><><>
Above article by BMCUWP
Our charity drives over the last two years are a credit to you, our readers, and to CHALMERSBHOY who set each of them up.
So far we have raised an amazing £8000+ plus Gift Aid. Thank you to everyone who was a part of this, you are all wonderful and generous people. You should rightfully feel significant pride in that.
Our current charity campaign, as ever for a charity of your choice, will continue until July 31st 2026. Nominated via these pages, and chosen as the most worthy by our contributors, it is
Chidren’s Hospices Across Scotland (CHAS)
Nominated by BAWHEID, and overwhelmingly the landslide winner of the vote. We have surpassed our first two targets, with the total now well over £2000.
You can donate by following this link, as set up by CHALMERSBHOY (and grateful thanks once again for doing so!)
https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinel-celts-2?utm_medium=FA&utm_source=EM
There is a default payment method by ApplePay, which I don’t use. Just click ”change” above the payment bar to view other options.
Link to the following two betting opportunities, which proved so popular and successful last season.
The CHALMERSBHOY Saturday Treble.
One contestant at a time taking their turn to pick three results from the eight UK leagues. Chalmersbhoy will place a £5 bet on these each week, with the proceeds going to our nominated charity.
The Saturday Acca.
Six of us each pick a result from the eight UK leagues. The site will place a £5 bet on these each week from Sept 13, with the proceeds going to our nominated charity.
Please note- we have closed nominations for The Saturday Acca, which will now comprise a Magnificent Seven pundits. Entrants for The Saturday Treble are still welcome.
Volunteer via this link, please.
https://sentinelcelts.com/2025/11/21/saturday-football-charity-bets/
https://youtu.be/XUkvbe_hH8U
great analysis by mls commentator on Nancy fiasco
POTY Update.
*SENTINEL CELTS PLAYER OF THE YEAR 2025-26*
*RESULTS FROM GAME #35 FALKIRK 0 CELTIC 1 (NYGREN)*
Good evening, friends.
A big win last night against very decent opponents who passed up as many chances as Celtic usually do!
Celtic have now played 35 games, and have won 18, drawn 6 and lost 10. We have scored 58 goals and conceded 37. We are back up to 2nd in the league, bettering Sevco’s goal difference by 1. Hearts still have a 6 point lead at the top with a goal difference that is 7 better than Celtic. We could do with a couple of goalscorers!
As for the voting numbers, another close but no cigar turnout just falling short of the charity donation barrier. But my sincere thanks to the 95 who did vote, including a first time voter who just happened to be an ex captain of Celtic – I am humbled indeed!
The total votes cast for each player are as follows, with my own nominations asterisked.
Schmeichel: 75
Araujo*: 54
Trusty: 2
Scales: 32
Tierney*: 45
McGregor: 6
Engels*: 10
Nygren: 52
Yang: 3
Maeda: 3
Tounekti: 1
McCowan: 0
Hatate: 0
Kenny: 0
Unused substitutes: Bernardo, Donovan, Forrest, Murray, Ralston, Sinisalo
And so, the POINTS earned by each player for the game against Falkirk are as follows –
25 points: Schmeichel
22 points: Araujo
19 points: Nygren
16 points: Tierney
14 points: Scales
12 points: Engels
11 points: McGregor
10 points each: Maeda and Yang
8 points: Trusty
7 points: Tounekti
5 points each: Hatate, Kenny, McCowan
1 point each: Bernardo, Donovan, Forrest, Murray, Ralston, Sinisalo
The cumulative points achieved after 35 games played are now –
477: McGregor
476: Scales
421: Tierney
376: Engels
332: Hatate
329: Maeda
326: Trusty
317: Nygren
298: Yang
275: Tounekti
274: Schmeichel
251: McCowan
241: Forrest
225: Donovan
188: Iheanacho
177: Ralston
166: Kenny
158: Carter-Vickers and Saracchi
126: Bernardo
89: Murray
74: Yamada
70: Balikwisha
60: Johnston
55: Sinisalo
42: Araujo
40: Osmand
23: Inamura
19: Idah
14: Simpson-Pusey
6: Doohan
1: Hale and Isiguso
0: All the other players who’ve not yet made a matchday squad!
Our next game sees us play our first tie in this season’s Scottish Cup, away to Auchinleck Talbot. Our opponents decided to shift the game to Rugby Park so it’s another battle on the plastic carpet. The game kicks off at 5.30pm on Sunday and is live on Premier Sports.
Hail Hail!
A good 7-0 v Talbot would help a wee bit.
Link to POTY competition
sencelpoty@gmail.com
I recommend a look at the 1020 comment last night from INIQUITOUS IV. You won’t know whether to laugh or cry.
Sad but true although I’d prefer a striker
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/cd9e7x5dndgo
Link to how the dominant team remains dominant and couldnt GAF about others.
For “Sergeant” Wilson…
Wee, sleeket, cowran, tim’rous beastie,
O, what a panic’s in thy breastie!
Thou need na start awa sae hasty,
Wi’ bickerin brattle!
I wad be laith to rin an’ chase thee
Wi’ murd’ring pattle!
How many of us wake up of a morning .reach for our phones and get disappointed again . This window is following many others ,they have no intention of spending for the quality badly needed .something is behind desmond doing this and make no mistake the board do not have a choice
Desmond is behind every call , delivered by his commander in chief oh he is away , dont believe it , this window is following in the same style of previous windows . They are taking us down all the signs are there .
Steve,
A wee cowran beastie?
That’s a big four legged beastie with udders?
Jim,
Nope. I used to do that before I put the coffee on ..now I just wait for Bada to tell me 😐
BAD
“To A Louse” more appropriate !
Why would anyone believe that recruitment would be straightforward?
The Executive inhabit a looking glass world – a realm governed by the Dastardly DD, which works counter intuitively to the World at large. Hoarding is the new business growth strategy don’t ya know.
The usual Cost minimisation process on “investment” will be under even more scrutiny as retail income declines, our business partners get twitchy and the growing threat to season book renewals will be enough to justify in their pitiful, miserly minds a tightening of the purse strings even more.
” Here’s a couple of loans, Martin, see what you can do, good man”.
Steve,
When you realise Burns was pished all the time, it all makes perfect sense 👍
Recruitment.
I know we’re all fairly certain the different departments of the club are dysfunctional, but I think it’s worse that that, I think they don’t actually exist!
I said (As a joke) our recruitment dept was Tosh McKinley sitting watching YouTube videos .. doesn’t seem so funny now!
I’ve been saying for years that money has ruined the game and made all these young players very dislikeable ..
Anyone see this?
https://youtube.com/shorts/tsBFLOEuZaU?si=L58VV3XxefKWSgTt
BAD- Day 16…..it’s unbelievable
Bada,
I know buddy
I’d phone Xavi Alonso and see if he wants a job in a couple of months.
Big Audio Dynamite
January 16, 2026 11:15 am
Bada,
I know buddy
I’d phone Xavi Alonso and see if he wants a job in a couple of months.
——-
Someone at Celtic already tried to phone him but he wouldn’t accept a reverse charges call.
Hip Hoop
Thank you for the video. It really explains the Nancy fiasco. Success in MLS and NHL (ice hockey) is judged by making the playoffs….you don’t really win anything, but you’re in the top 30% of the teams. Individual star players and their statistics are often emphasized more than the team itself.
FB,
Not sure of the details between Real Madrid and Alonso but that whole episode makes the game even more ugly. Sickening what money has done to players and the game.
Would love us to show a bit of ambition and offer the man the job, and tell him he’d have control over all football matters.
Imagine that!
If a company that wants to run frugally announces regular profits and large savings within an industry where that is rare how can it protect itself from being overcharged for necessary acquisitions ?
This is a classic strategic-management problem: if you publicly signal that you are unusually profitable and cash-rich in a cost-pressured industry, suppliers, sellers, and intermediaries will try to extract rents from you.
There’s no single trick; protection comes from governance, signaling discipline, and procurement design. Here’s a structured, real-world answer.
1. Control the signal you send (this matters more than people think)
Don’t advertise frugality + cash at the same time
Public profit announcements are often unavoidable, but messaging is controllable.
Emphasize:
Operational volatility
Capital intensity
Reinvestment needs
Regulatory or technological uncertainty
You want counterparties to think:
“They’re doing well now, but they can’t overpay.”
Key idea:
Narrative moderation reduces seller anchoring.
2. Separate “financial strength” from procurement visibility
Create institutional distance
Use subsidiaries, SPVs, or special-purpose buyers for acquisitions.
Avoid a single recognizable “rich buyer” identity in the market.
Common in:
Energy
Defense
Infrastructure
Private equity roll-ups
Effect: Sellers price against the vehicle, not the parent balance sheet.
3. Make price discovery competitive by design
Never negotiate one-on-one if you can avoid it
Use:
Structured RFPs
Reverse auctions
Competitive tenders
Even for acquisitions:
Encourage parallel bidders
Use intermediaries who can credibly walk away
Rule:
If a seller believes you are the only serious buyer, you will overpay.
4. Anchor pricing to fundamentals, not your balance sheet
Institutionalize valuation discipline
Publicly (and internally) commit to:
Strict ROI hurdles
Payback periods
Benchmark multiples
Then enforce them visibly:
Walk away from deals
Pause projects
Delay expansions
This builds a market reputation:
“They don’t stretch.”
That reputation is one of your strongest long-term protections.
5. Use timing as leverage
Cash ≠ urgency
Spread acquisitions over time
Avoid buying at industry peaks
Signal patience
Frugal firms that overpay usually fail because they confuse cash availability with strategic necessity.
6. Lock in prices before profits become visible
Front-load commitments quietly
Before public profit announcements:
Secure:
Long-term supply contracts
Framework agreements
Option-based acquisitions
Use price-indexing formulas rather than spot pricing
This is especially effective for:
Raw materials
Capacity
Technology licenses
7. Make substitution credible
Reduce dependency, even if you don’t switch
Suppliers overcharge when they believe:
“You have no alternative.”
Countermeasures:
Dual sourcing
Vertical integration (even partial)
In-house capability development
You don’t need to switch — you need the threat to be credible.
8. Accept some inefficiency to avoid systemic overpricing
A paradox:
Extreme frugality can make you more exploitable.
Occasional, visible deal abandonment is valuable.
Think of it as:
Paying a small “option premium” to protect against long-term rent extraction.
9. Cultural guardrails (often overlooked)
Teach buyers and executives the same rule:
“We are not rich — we are disciplined.”
That means:
No “strategic premiums” without quantified returns
No emotional or ego-driven acquisitions
Clear accountability for overpaying
Most overcharging happens inside the firm, not outside it.
Summary (the core logic)
A frugal, profitable company protects itself by:
Managing external perception
Decoupling wealth from deal identity
Institutionalizing competition
Being visibly willing to walk away
Making substitutes and delay credible
The goal is not to hide success —
it is to prevent success from becoming your negotiating baseline.
If you want, I can:
Apply this to a specific industry (tech, energy, manufacturing, healthcare)
Just tell me which direction you want to go.
To the Football (soccer industry)?
In football, this problem is especially acute because prices are not cost-based; they are expectation- and cash-based. A club that is publicly profitable or “well run” becomes a target for value extraction by selling clubs, agents, players, and even leagues.
Below is how successful, frugal football clubs protect themselves from being overcharged — with concrete football-specific mechanisms and examples.
1. Control the narrative (football prices are story-driven)
Never signal “cash-rich”
Well-run clubs that stay competitive while avoiding overpayment actively downplay their finances.
What they say publicly:
“We must respect financial sustainability.”
“We cannot compete with state-backed clubs.”
“FFP / PSR constraints limit us.”
Even when highly profitable, they frame decisions as constraint-driven, not choice-driven.
Examples:
Liverpool (pre-2023): Consistently emphasized budget discipline despite strong revenues.
Borussia Dortmund: Always publicly “selling club”, even with large cash reserves.
📌 Agents price off narrative, not audited accounts.
2. Build a credible “walk-away” reputation
The most powerful pricing weapon in football
Clubs that don’t overpay:
Walk away from deals publicly
Miss targets rather than exceed internal valuation
Let rivals “win” inflated auctions
Result:
Selling clubs learn:
“That club has a number — and won’t move.”
Examples:
Tottenham (Levy era): Famously willing to abandon negotiations.
Atalanta: Let players go only at valuation; don’t chase replacements at inflated prices.
3. Decouple the buyer identity (reduce “rich club tax”)
Use intermediaries and opacity
Instead of:
“Club X wants this player”
Use:
Agents
Scouting intermediaries
Quiet approaches via leagues or partner clubs
Effect:
The selling club negotiates against market interest, not a known wealthy buyer.
Common tools:
Feeder clubs
Multi-club ownership (City Group, Red Bull, INEOS)
Third-party scouting networks
4. Create supply before demand (the real secret)
Buy early, sell late
The best protection against overcharging is not needing to buy in peak markets.
Mechanisms:
Aggressive youth scouting (16–19 age range)
Data-led recruitment
Pre-contracts and free transfers
Examples:
RB Leipzig / Salzburg
Brighton
Benfica
By the time the player is “expensive”, they already own him.
5. Use internal pricing models — and never break them
Football-specific valuation discipline
Frugal clubs use non-negotiable valuation models based on:
Age curve
Contract length
Position scarcity
Injury risk
Resale value
Once a price exceeds model value:
Negotiations stop
Alternatives are activated
This discipline must survive managerial pressure.
Brighton is the modern gold standard.
6. Exploit time asymmetry (contracts = leverage)
Time favors the patient buyer
Key rule:
Clubs overpay when they buy players with long contracts.
Frugal clubs:
Target:
Final-year contracts
Unsettled players
Squad surplus
Apply pressure late in windows
Examples:
Juventus (free-transfer era)
AC Milan (post-2020 rebuild)
7. Neutralize agent inflation
Agents are the main profit extractors.
Countermeasures:
Fixed commission caps
Centralized negotiation teams
Long-term agent blacklists (quiet but real)
Clubs that fail here lose cost control fast.
8. Leverage regulation strategically
Use FFP / PSR as a shield
Even profitable clubs:
Publicly cite PSR limits
Share “leaked” concerns about compliance
This creates:
“We literally cannot pay more.”
It doesn’t need to be fully true — it needs to be credible.
9. Accept short-term sporting pain to protect long-term pricing
A brutal truth:
Overpaying once resets your price forever.
Clubs that stay frugal:
Accept missed Champions League qualification
Accept thin squads temporarily
Protect wage structure at all costs
Wage inflation is deadlier than transfer fees.
10. Make money off the market you buy from
The strongest defense:
Be both buyer and seller.
Clubs that consistently sell at premiums:
Can accept higher prices occasionally
Maintain internal balance
Examples:
Benfica
Ajax
Dortmund
Summary: Football-specific logic
A profitable, frugal club avoids overcharging by:
Narrative control (“we are constrained”)
Walking away visibly
Buying before hype
Rigid valuation discipline
Time-based leverage
Agent containment
Accepting short-term pain
In football, reputation sets your prices more than cash does.
If you want, I can:
Apply this to a specific club (e.g. Brighton, Liverpool, Arsenal, Bayern)
Compare state-backed vs frugal models
Show how clubs lose discipline once they break it (e.g. Barcelona, Man United)
Celtic are actually a textbook case of this problem — and of how to manage it without losing the club’s identity. I’ll keep this specific to Celtic FC, not generic football theory.
How Celtic FC protects itself from being overcharged
(and where the risks are)
1. Celtic’s core structural advantage (often misunderstood)
Celtic operate in a paradoxical position:
Dominant domestically
Cash-generative (gate receipts, European money, player trading)
But capped competitively by the Scottish market
This means:
Selling clubs know Celtic have money
But also know Celtic cannot justify EPL-level prices
Celtic’s protection strategy is therefore built around credible ceilings, not secrecy.
2. “We cannot pay that” is actually credible for Celtic
Unlike many clubs, Celtic genuinely have:
A strict wage structure
Clear transfer ceilings
Board-level sign-off discipline
When Celtic walk away, it’s believed.
Evidence:
Repeated late-window withdrawals
Public statements about “value”
Willingness to wait until January or next summer
This reputation is priceless.
3. Buy from markets where Celtic are not the rich club
Celtic avoid overcharging by sourcing from:
Japan (J-League)
South Korea
Scandinavia
Lower-tier European leagues
In these markets:
Celtic are a step-up opportunity
Sellers price on career progression, not cash extraction
Ange Postecoglou era recruitment is the clearest example.
4. Time leverage: contract length and urgency
Celtic typically target players who are:
In final 12–18 months of contract
Blocked at current club
Outside the “auction” phase
This is deliberate:
Celtic rarely win bidding wars — they win timing wars.
5. Use Europe as currency, not cash
Celtic sell:
Guaranteed European football
Champions League exposure
Platform to England
This reduces cash premium demands.
For many players:
Celtic is a career multiplier, not a final destination.
6. Agent containment (quiet but firm)
Celtic:
Rarely renegotiate wage ceilings for agents
Prefer repeat relationships
Avoid “super-agent” dependency
This limits:
Wage inflation
Hidden fee escalation
Once Celtic break wage structure, everything becomes more expensive.
7. Public profitability is framed as prudence, not ambition
When Celtic report profits:
The messaging is conservative
Emphasis on sustainability and infrastructure
Not on “investment power”
This matters because:
Selling clubs read headlines, not accounts
8. Acceptable short-term pain (this is the hard part)
Celtic have shown they will:
Enter seasons short in one position
Delay replacements
Take European exits rather than panic buy
That discipline prevents:
Price anchoring
“Celtic tax” escalation
Many clubs fail right here.
9. Where Celtic are most vulnerable
⚠️ Pressure points:
Post-player sales (e.g. Dembele, Jota)
After Champions League qualification
During managerial transitions
At these moments:
The market knows Celtic must buy
Overpricing risk spikes
Mitigation:
Pre-planned replacements
Early-window deals
Multiple parallel targets
10. Why Celtic’s model mostly works
Celtic’s true protection is this:
They are not trying to escape their economic lane.
They:
Dominate Scotland
Compete respectably in Europe
Monetize player development
Protect wage structure
This keeps them from becoming:
A “cash cow” for sellers
A failed hybrid like Rangers (early 2000s) or Leeds (2000s)
Bottom line (Celtic-specific)
Celtic protect themselves from being overcharged by:
Rigid financial ceilings
Non-auction recruitment
Career-path selling
Market diversification
Willingness to wait
Celtic’s biggest asset isn’t cash — it’s credibility.
Awe Naw…did you try asking AI how to counteract a twisted, thrawn megalomaniac who has decided he’s gonna ram it right up those thankless c#nts that think they know better? 😉
Here’s how I see it now, as the latest transfer window drags on without any signings – the Not Another Penny campaign has really hit hard. The cash in hand has been dented. Our Fuhrer has decided its not gonna take another hit by unnecessary spending in the window. The executive have been told to sign whoever they want but at absolutely minimum cost to the Club. “Registering an interest” in Callum Wilson is indicative that they need to know how much he wants before they’ll talk. It’ll be explained away, in the confines of the Boardroom, as us c#nts having cut our own throats and hell mend us!
McCaff,
The way I see it is after;
1) The money wasted on the Mark Lawwell splurge
2) The money wasted on Engles, Idah, Trusty
3) The money wasted on the Paul Tisdale splurge
4) Not a penny more campaign
5) The money wasted on recruiting Nancy
6) The money wasted on paying them all off
1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + 6 = ? + zero infrastructure (which is serious wastage and a precarious situation to be in)
There is a serious concern about further wastage. That must be legitimate concern ?
No more will be wasted until a new infrastructure is back in place. Whether that is through selling up or another throw of the dice then only time will tell.
Sevco will win the league this year. We have bigger problems to solve
The current shambles at the Club has been deliberately created by the Despots to teach the support a lesson for setting up The Fans Collective and the response to Despot Jnrs humiliation at the AGM 🤔 HH
I think this window could be the final straw for MON. It may well happen that he tells them to forget it. He’s not going to be messed about by these imbeciles.
Regardless, I think we’re in for a few years of pain. Everything in my gut tells me something is very rotten at the core of Celtic and it’ll take time to cut it out.
afternoon all, and although I can’t fault you on anything you wrote, seeing it wrote down just made me angry and pissed off, until you made me laugh with …
“Give me lucky generals” is attributed to Napoleon, but that didn’t work too well for him in the end!
as I’ve said recently I’m not wasting my time time checking CelticNewsNow every hour for quality first team ready players that probably won’t arrive, even so I’m still saying probably as surely our napoleon dd can’t let the shambles that is our transfer strategy continue but then again according to him it’s Rodgers, fans etc that’s the problem, please fitba god, give me strength.
NOT ANOTHER PENNY.
San Luis,
There’s zero chance of Martin walking away. All Martin’s mutterings in public are for our consumption, not for the those that run the club.
Martin is smart enough to know that if he loses the league by one point or ten, the fans won’t be pointing any fingers at him. If we’re not going to show a bit of ambition and get a really good manager in, I’d be quite happy to let Martin carry on next season too.
G64,
I believe that the current situation has developed because DD has no passion for football and believed in the previous executive over Brendan Rodgers coupled with an extreme personal necessity to be uninvolved. I doubt whether he still believes entirely in the previous executive now but will now double down on showing any kind of ambition as that is what upset the amount of personal involvement needed.
He also has no longer an axe to grind with the current Sevco exec.
The Celtic support he doesn’t GAF about. The sooner we realise that the better for everyone. It´s nothing personal. His passions are golf and making money
MON is here to readdress Black Sunday
https://readceltic.com/2026/01/16/there-is-something-seriously-rotten-inside-celtic-but-what-is-it-and-why-is-it-happening/
From Frabizio Romano:
EXCLUSIVE: Sunderland agree deal to sign Ivorian winger Jocelin Ta Bi, here we go!
Deal done for £3.5m fee, five year contract to the player as it’s all agreed.
Celtic had verbal agreement in place but #SAFC hijack the move.
From late last night.
Transcript of Minutes of a Celtic Board meeting earlier in the season.
Brendan Rodgers and Russell Martin are the respective managers of Celtic and Sevco. Desmond is on Zoom and the meeting is chaired by Peter Lawwell.
Desmond: I called this meeting because we have a situation.
Lawwell: Sir, May I……
Desmond: Shut up Peter, I run the meetings.
Here’s the issue. Rangers have hired their worst manager ever. It is seriously jeopardizing league competition. If we don’t do something, we will end up winning our fifth in a row, precisely what we don’t need. The question is: What do we do about this?
Lawwell: Don’t give Rodgers any decent players except cheap dross.
Desmond: You say that every year, you overpaid carrot. But he still manages to get a tune out of them. We need another plan. Do any of you other dummies have any bright ideas?
Nicholson: I had a thought….
Lawwell: Shut the fuck up, Michael, there’s a good boy.
Desmond: Anybody?
Lawwell: Why don’t we copy Rangers? Fire Rodgers and hire the worst manager we can find?
Desmond: Hmmm, that could work, but I’m not paying compensation.
Lawwell: I can brief the Sun on the fly, tell them he’s working his ticket, irritate the hell out of him, and maybe he’ll just resign.
Desmond: Do it. Nicholson, do something, instead of sitting there like a frigging bump on a log. After we force Rodgers out, find a manager with a so-so record in a non-competitive league, hire him and tell everyone he was your Number One target.
Nicholson: I don’t know any leagues or managers. Any I’ve talked to in the past 5 years won’t return my calls.
Desmond: Oh For Fuxake! Peter, you do it, then hand over to that useless mannequin. Don’t let anyone know you’re the actual CEO, though. We need plausible deniability here, otherwise the hoi polloi will just start whining again. Thank fuck I’m in Barbados most of the time and can just ignore it.
Any other business?
Wilson: I would like to suggest….
Desmond: I’m out of time. I have a tee off time shortly. Meeting adjourned.
Awe Naw
January 16, 2026 12:56 pm
And horses.
Golf and horses.
Certainly not football.
He’ll never in his life have paid his way into a game.
Anybody interested in treble for charity bet tomorrow.
Leeds
Wrexham
Arbroath
Good luck!
Ernie Lynch
as an investor and gambler yes. I doubt if he has ever rode one ???
Doesn´t need to. Too busy taking everyone else for a ride
Awe Naw…you suggest nothing will change until a NEW infrastructure is in place. That implies we had one previously. It’s clear the infrastructure we had was Lawwell, and Lawwell only. Everything micro-managed and signed off to ensure bottom-line profit, always. It’s backfired bigtime, that absolute reliance on one man running the show has shown to be our equivalent of throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
For long enough we’ve known there is a substandard structure at the Club. We assume DD knows about it but I’m not convinced that’s true, I think he’s interested in bottom line figures only (and the kudos of ‘owning’ Celtic, of course!) and doesn’t care how we achieve it as long as he’s not troubled with the minutiae or the day to day.
Every department in the Club is substandard; from the ticket office to the bogs, from the stadium facilities to the way we are stewarded and policed, recruitment from the academy to the men’s team and everything, absolutely everything, in between. We are a shambles!
Our claims of World Class are a ridiculous, hilarious parody although it’s just not funny anymore. We have no one prepared to ask serious questions of DD. Our Board are freeloaders enjoying the kudos, as was, of being Celtic directors. Now, it’s a poisoned chalice that nobody would want to be anywhere near but, unfortunately, that has transferred throughout the Club.
We are at a crossroads in our history at the moment. This is a defining moment for a generation who have known only success. What happens next is anyone’s guess!
Awe Naw
January 16, 2026 11:58 am
You must have asked AI same type of question I did.
It sets out Celtic’s policy and why it is what it is.
I doubt many supporters realise this is the true nature of football today, it is a lot more complicated than beating Rangers although just staying ahead of them is a factor at play.
A thought I had was that if Hearts win the league with a reported turnover of £24.4m in 2025 (allowing that football earnings might be a bit lower) then why is Celtic’s wage structure so high?
It suggests it is not how much is spent but more about what it is spent on that is the issue.
You might want to consider hacking into Hearts database and sending results to MoN.
You’re not taking into account the fact that when we spend anything, we have to ask if it’s going to cost us the club’s existence.
No, seriously.
We don’t have the brains to understand they’re just looking out for our future.
Stoopit peasants
Fast forward
“I’m asked the same question every single year and you should know by now that I’ll give you exactly the same answer. We will try to get players in if we can and that’s really it… I’ll try my very best and, if we can, then we can.”
Martin O’Neill 2003
McCaff
January 16, 2026 1:59 pm
Awe Naw…you suggest nothing will change until a NEW infrastructure is in place. That implies we had one previously. It’s clear the infrastructure we had was Lawwell, and Lawwell only. Everything micro-managed and signed off to ensure bottom-line profit, always. It’s backfired bigtime, that absolute reliance on one man running the show has shown to be our equivalent of throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
=============
I could have written that word for word based on my observations from around 2010/11.
The emphasis has always been finances got priority over football needs. If it isn’t a CF, it is a LB or a MF. Obvious areas where improvement was needed but not addressed. If the team was still successful and supporters kept turning up then why bother changing the emphasis?
McCaff
100% agree. What´s the state of the Lawwell Desmond relationship ?
Without Lawwell he´s lost
Joel Piroe, the latest name I’ve heard
Yawn ..😐
I’m asked the same question every single year and you should know by now that I’ll give you exactly the same answer. We will try to get players in if we can and that’s really it… I’ll try my very best and, if we can, then we can.”
Martin O’Neill 2003
or every single manager Celtic have had
BAULDYIN 1252
I’m getting as pissed off at writing doom and gloom as you and everyone else is at reading it. Certainly, we are all pissed off at witnessing it unfold in real time before us. I know everyone would prefer a bit of positivity about the place, and I know I’d love to write more positive articles. I mean, I’m a happy-go-lucky bloke normally!
But if I wrote anything positive about the club at the moment, you would have to join a bloody long queue giving me a reality check. I’d have ATHINGOFBEAUTY phoning me via her customised breathalyser-fitted smart bastert phone. And my Dad watering down my drinks when I head home in two weeks.
Too much of a risk, mate. Can’t do it.
Big Audio Dynamite
January 16, 2026 2:08 pm
You’re not taking into account the fact that when we spend anything, we have to ask if it’s going to cost us the club’s existence.
No, seriously.
==========
Where did you get that idea?
Is it not truer to say that when Celtic spend anything they have to check they will remain sustainable and in doing so take care of tomorrow as well as today?
When I am going to spend I always check if and how I can afford it, its just common sense.