Hoops hold the Jambos
Celtic emerged from Tynecastle with a point to keep their title ambitions intact and keep the gap to 6 points.
The teamsheet was a surprise with both January arrivals in the starting lineup, Reo dropped for Benji was less of a surprise. The bench was strange, no Kenny and two right backs.
The sides emerged into a red hot atmosphere with a real sense of occasion hanging heavy in the air and the crowds energy was matched by both sides delivering a frantic opening and both looking well up for it. But what happened next was not in the home sides script. A quick Celtic thrust upfield saw Benji find space and be hauled down for only a free kick with the obvious yellow card ignored. The Swede dusted himself off to do what no Celtic player had done for 5 years and actually scored direct from a freekick.
Its a funny old game for whereas I thought the early goal would really spark the game into life it basically had the opposite effect by slowing things down and it lost its edge. Its frantic nature was replaced by an attempt to find composure, a very feeble attempt at that. Keeping possession was thrown out the window as both teams left their passing boots at home and continually passed the ball to the opposition, or just straight outta play. It became a shockingly bad game of ping-pong with nothing really to show for either side by the time the halftime whistle I was longing for blew.
I forlornly imagined the gaffer calming them down but incredibly within a minute we had shot ourselves in the foot as a result of our inability to find a team-mate with our passing. This time it was Daizen, a suicidal cross-field ball forced a foul, that freekick brought a corner which was converted at the back post and I said to myself we are losing this game.
But Hearts made the fatal mistake of not turning the screw, they just kept about their business instead of going through the gears. This allowed Celtic to find a bit of composure and around the hour mark we actually started stringing some attacking play together which then delivered our new strikers first real impact in the Hoops.
In the space of around 2 minutes he contrived to…
Guide a great header onto the bar,
Get an on target rebound shot away via great footwork while still grounded only to see Daizen block it,
Came deep to collect then drove at their defense at pace to deliver a perfect assist,
Got booked for a tussle,
And finally got subbed.
It was a hell of a couple of minutes for Big Tommy and the Bhoys were back in front, but we no longer had a target man or recognized striker on the field, instead Martin had shoved Tonetki through the middle.
This worked in Hearts favour, they grew in confidence and went chasing the equalizer. Their chase was enormously boosted by Trusty receiving a VAR referred Red Card from Yellow upgrade. I thought it was a Red and would screaming for it at the other end. A reshuffle in defense after KT went off injured wasnt going to help either and sure enough in the 86th minute Hearts found what they were looking for.
Celtic, once again, were undone by a setpiece. It was time to hold on and take the point, we managed it despite a whopping 8 minutes of injury time.
The stats might suggest a belter of a game with a bit of everything, 10 cards in total, 4 goals etc. But I thought the game didnt really live up to the occasion and the reality is two poor sides shared the points and move on. I would so far as to say Celtic have two people to particularly thank for the away point that keeps us in the hunt,,,Tommy and Kasper.
The Dane saved our bacon on numerous occasions and was clearly the MOTM. He was fantastic between the sticks.
A point wasnt enough to retain 2nd place though and we now slip to 3rd, 6 points from Hearts and 2 behind RIFC with a worse goal difference than both and now we shall be without Austin in the rearguard going to Pittodrie which was already looking difficult plus we now dont have a fit left back. We’re gonna need Tommy, Kels, Benji and Yang to score the goals needed to keep us in the chase.
By Mahe
sentinelcelts@gmail.com
Our charity drives over the last two years are a credit to you, our readers, and to CHALMERSBHOY who set each of them up.
So far we have raised an amazing £8000+ plus Gift Aid. Thank you to everyone who was a part of this, you are all wonderful and generous people. You should rightfully feel significant pride in that.
Our current charity campaign, as ever for a charity of your choice, will continue until July 31st 2026. Nominated via these pages, and chosen as the most worthy by our contributors, it is
Chidren’s Hospices Across Scotland (CHAS)
Nominated by BAWHEID, and overwhelmingly the landslide winner of the vote. We have surpassed our first two targets, with the total now well over £2000.
You can donate by following this link, as set up by CHALMERSBHOY (and grateful thanks once again for doing so!)
https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinel-celts-2?utm_medium=FA&utm_source=EM
There is a default payment method by ApplePay, which I don’t use. Just click ”change” above the payment bar to view other options.
POTY competition sencelpoty@gmail.com
Hi Bhoys just a thought after yesterday’s game could we play Araujo as the holding midfielder, seems to be hard and can play fitba couldn’t be any worse than the current lot, also give Bernardo a decent run
Morning all,
Can I say well done to McCaff, 16 Roads and Chalmersbhoy for donating to CHAS.
Brilliant from you all 👋👋👋👋👋👋👋👋
💚 💚 💚 💚 💚
Very disappointed with the performance and with the result especially from our captain, in games like that we need real leadership, it wasn’t there yesterday. Nygren despite what some say has a great scoring record and I thought that Tomas added a bit of what we need, unsurprisingly he will need some time to adapt to the nuances of Scottish football. Irrespective of the debate regarding the red card, you could see the big difference in the way that our team were refereed, constantly throughout many games but especially yesterday I thought that there was far too many decisions going to the other side, so cannot help but feel cheated once again, be interested in what Collum’s report says. Two draws in a row one in Italy and one in bedlam both from a leading position tells it own story.
No doubt but that we miss the missing players especially CCV who is rock solid, I stick by my feelings on Trusty. I look back at the centre half’s of the past the confidence that they instilled and that was missing yesterday once again. But the biggest mistake by far and might lose us Five IAR was the appointment of Tisdale and Nancy two completely unforgivable appointments.
Thank goodness for MON he offers hope and confidence.
Lastly – thank you for the wonderful contributions to CHAS it is brilliant to witness all those donations will go a long, long way to helping the children and their families, respect to all of you.
The one ray of sun in a dismal day.
This isn’t easy to write but we are playing chaos football just now. We rarely control a game under MON and our passing has become non existent. I wasn’t quite longing for the horseshoe yesterday but I was getting there.
And no sign of changing things in game. Since hearts knew they could get free kicks on demand they sent them all into our 6 yard box fully expecting them to be headed out ….to the three unmarked men on edge of their box. Everytime. And we did nothing about it.
Now we must have been tired after Thursday yet only used 3 subs. We kept a totally dysfunctional midfield on for the full 90 minutes. Some players seem to have regressed but Nygren who clearly has a knack of scoring is actually an awful footballer. Can’t tackle. Can’t hold the ball up. Can’t pass. He is good at popping up in the box but in terms of building play he in one of the worse I have seen. We badly need reinforcements obviously but we also badly need to control games again. Falkirk coulda been out of sight against us in the first half. How we got out of Bologna with a draw after we retreated to our 18 yard box was amazing and Schmeichel of all people saved us from a doing yesterday. So we are 3rd in the table going into February. That sounds bad. But I think Motherwell and Falkirk are actually better footballing teams than us just now. So being the 5th best footballing team in Scotland is a disgrace. We seriously need to get a grip.
H3
So much to agree on in your post-especially the bit about them getting then recycling free kicks. And Nygren, who has about as much fight in him as the cowardly lion. Definitely not one you’d pick to be in the trenches alongside you.
But there was an issue not entirely of our own making re the subs. We replaced Cvancara after our second, presumably as he was nowhere near match fit. We then had to take Tierney off due to injury, and shortly afterwards Trusty got sent off, necessitating a reshuffled replacement in defence. We are allowed five subs but only three “substitution events.” The last two were out of MON’s control.
LEGGY
A great achievement so far, with hopefully more to come. As you point out, grateful thanks to MCCAFF, CHALMERSBHOY and 16 ROADS. But also to PERTH OZ BHOY, whose donation was Lucky 67!
Yes, Nygren is Pussy Nancy ( but top goal scorer with 11 goals) and McGregor and Engles were tough as mince.
BMCUW
Yep I agree with that. When the reshuffle happened when trusty was sent off was the last chance to put on fresh legs rather than one sub
Hi Bobby lucky 67 alright, I was there in Lisbon and 4 months later moved to Australia
You forgot their star MiB, and I suggest you go watch the ‘red’ again, in no way is it an obvious goal scoring opportunity, for a number of reasons.
Never a red
Does nobody find it quite a coincidence that our last 2 red cards domestically have been at Tynecastle. It was pointed out on Friday by someone in the media that we had gone 68 games without a red since Yang was wrongly sent off . And low n behold another wrong red appears. The rat McInnes also mentions it sarcastically in post match interview.
He needs to remember his last clubs ( Killie)red card record was the worst in Scotland due to the same thuggery he has called for his whole managerial career.
He calls it aggression.
PERTHOZBHOY
Ya lucky bugger! Dead jealous here, at least of the first bit.
I remember in early June 21, I’d arranged a wee post-covid hoot for the troops as I was back home for a couple of weeks. Unfortunately, Glasgow was put into a localised lockdown a few days before. My mate Garry, so sadly gone now, lived in Dalmuir and suggested a mini-hoot in Clydebank, as it isn’t classed as Glasgow. So my Aussie b-i-l and my nephew, neither of whom have any interest in football, joined me, my Dad, Garry and three other guys for a few beers and some convivial chat.
Of the three, two were nearer my Dad’s age while the other was slightly older than me and Garry. Turned out that the three older fellas had been at the 7-1 game, the Real v Eintracht final, and the Coronation Cup. Unfortunately, my Dad let the side down as he couldn’t make Lisbon.
But the other guy could-his Dad had been the fella organising the flights!
That was some wee day, that. Sad to think that both Garry and Macjay died within a few months of it.
by the laws of the game it was not ared card. he was not running in on goal and there was a covering player. someone posted that if it happened at the other end of the pitch he would be screaming for a red card but you can scream all you want a red card would not have been shown.
would a red card have been shown if that had been a sevco payer? of course not.
now that sevco are well and truly in the title race hearts will get nothing. a draw yesterday was the result sevco wanted and the officials duly obliged.
AULDBHOY 67
We were also the Tynecastle victims of the first wrong VAR call, the handball ignored when Forrest tried to play it past a Hearts defender.
The red card would only have been applied in two instances by the whistling cheats in Scotland.
1- if foul commited by a Celtic player
2-if foul commited on a rangers player
In no other circumstances would a ref comfortably ignore the written rules and give red.
Beaton is consistent in application of VAR when it disadvantages Celtic , helps our opponents or advantages rangers even in circumstances VAR is not allowed to intervene.!
He has numerous outcomes of this that would see him removed in an honest country.
The fact that we’re still in a title race after being 8 behind hearts in late October is in itself an achievement.
MON now fully aware of the fact that this is the worst squad he’s ever encountered at Celtic and that nothing in Scotland has changed with regards officiating – indeed VAR has made it worse for Celtic.
However, he is the first Celtic manager this season not to lose to Hearts and that’s important. This was a game Hearts had to win to cement their title credentials. They failed to do so and they know now that their cousins at Ibrox will be the ones who gain the most.
All Celtic can do is look after themselves. A tough as teak midfielder and CB would help. But will the parasites in the boardroom?
Fighting on three fronts will hinder us. Hearts a don’t have that ” luxury”.
interesting post by bored by the board yesterday. you would think that the brazen, barefaced and shameless cheating would motivate the board to do everything in their power to make sure we win everything and to keep sevco in their place. instead, they appear to be going out of their way to help the biggest cheats in world football.
this doesn’t make any kind of sense.
Hi Bobby I was at both of those games I don’t remember anything as I was just a wee boy, I have been to every ground in what was the then Scottish first division even went to Cathkin
Westcraigs
Imagine sending Michael Nicholson in to fight your corner. He’s a wee wimp.
SFA would just laugh at his puny attempt.
Yesterday’s red card will be subjected to Collum’s monthly VAR Review. As I said a couple of weeks ago, the language used to describe events has changed. Mark my words, Collum will explain this away as a “subjective” call by VAR. It’s not a decision based on what’s written It’s based on how VAR saw it and interpreted it to the ref. It’s cheating, pure and simple, but they are smart enough to cover each other and still get away with it.
We need brave men with Celtic’s best interests to challenge this shit but we know where we stand with that!
westcraigs
January 26, 2026 9:47 am
‘by the laws of the game it was not ared card. he was not running in on goal and there was a covering player. someone posted that if it happened at the other end of the pitch he would be screaming for a red card but you can scream all you want a red card would not have been shown.’
####
Whether it should have been yellow or red isn’t really the question.
The question to be asked is whether awarding a yellow in those circumstances was a clear and obvious error.
If it wasn’t VAR shouldn’t have been involved.
.
I hope that those poor deluded fools among the support who initially thought that VAR would help address the bias have seen the error of their ways and have learned their lesson.
westcraigs
January 26, 2026 9:58 am
‘this doesn’t make any kind of sense.’
###
If the agenda is to ensure a robust and viable Old Firm business model then it makes perfect sense.
It is though a risky strategy. You don’t want to piss off the support so much that they stop financing the whole operation.
Fortunately an awful lot of the support are faithful through and through and will renew no matter what.
Ching ching.
Surprised some enterprising gamer hasn’t invented a game called Grand Theft Scottish Football.
It would be a rule free cheat fest where everyone would be dishonest and one team would be totally subverted and another exempt from rules and given every advantage.
The officials would also constantly change the rules to suit their desired outcome!
Hi Ernie I thought the original intention of var was for off side and disputed goals, in my opinion it’s ruined the game as we know it
Perth oz bhoy
January 26, 2026 10:15 am
No doubt it’s ruined the game. Any time there’s a goal now you’re just waiting for a five minute VAR review. The immediacy and finality is gone. Completely changes the experience of watching football.
Good for the broadcasters and, possibly, the bookies, and that’s probably why it was brought in.
Ernie Lynch
Not all VAR reviews last 5 minutes in Scotland.
Pretty sure if there was stats on length of reviews in Scotland Celtic would have most minutes.
One gets the feeling they go back to kick off in their efforts to rule out the rare goals we score.
Huns first goal against Dundee was a decisive and quick VAR decision to award penalty.
And yes I agree it has ruined football.
I’m an advocate of VAR. The problem isn’t the technology it’s the competence/integrity of the officials using it.
VAR has highlighted how poor/corrupt officialdom actually is. It’s the same the world over.
It is not just the match officials within football that are corrupt and incompetent.
If we actually had officials who had played the game at a decent level instead of middle class professionals (who are more easily corrupted) decisions would be more equivocal and quicker BUT it’s deliberately not for a reason. See corruption.
We have this discussion every time we are cheated.
Can we not just give it a reference number or sumat ?
Zzzzzzzzzz…….
Don’t normally listen to this guy but he gives clear analysis of the red card issue.
Awe Naw
January 26, 2026 11:10 am
So if the problem is the competence of the officials how is adding another layer of the same incompetent officials supposed to help?
It’s just going to compound the problem isn’t it?
So what is the point of it?
ETims spot on:
you have to hand it to Hearts for utilising the transfer window and bringing in Steven MacLean and John Beaton to replace their injured talismen.
Scottish Premiership clubs either run at a loss or break even unless they compete in Europe. It’s the only place where a profit can be made. To consistently compete in Europe at the stages where money can be made. The UEFA coefficient has to be high enough. For that to happen more than one Scottish club has to perform consistently well in Europe. Oh how we laughed at Sevco being our coefficient monkeys@CQN
We just didn’t envisage our board banking the money and doing the durty on us in the meantime. This decision made by one man was so much easier as he had no personal axe to grind with this Sevco board unlike the last one. Who threw away 10m year upon year. Attempting to keep that up again would destroy the SF 49 owners which he certainly doesn’t want to do. Why would we attempt to hinder our major coefficient monkey? And with direct entry into the CL next season highly likely. It’s a UEFA coefficient booster
Ernie Lynch
To be seen to be doing something. A bit like LNS inquiry only on an ongoing basis. Sorry to sound like a Tory but the prices they charge they need to pretend that the product is of a high quality.
VAR is routinely ridiculed by managers and supporters in every league in Europe, some leagues have binned it.
Scotland won’t, because it gives part time officials extra hours work and helps keep Rangers relevant.
It serves little other purpose than to level the playing field with Celtic.
Celtic lost out again yesterday, but every other club loses out 3 or 4 times a season and not once do they complain. You have to ask why?
The only club to complain is the one that gains most from it’s ‘ subjective ‘ interpretation.
So, why haven’t the other clubs lodged complaints or why have Celtic not continually highlighted the discrepancy on show in our games?
My only explanation is because we accept it as part of the charade we’re involved in.
San Luis
See above
Didn’t Brendan take his own lawyer to SFA proceedings after the Yang Beaton incident?
He’s gone now
I’ve just sat and watched Sportscene. The more I look at the red card the more scandalous it is.
Apart from the “clear and obvious error” aspect of it if you look at it closely:
He doesn’t trip him.
He doesn’t grab his shirt.
It looks like he touches him and then immediately draws his hand back.
Minimal contact and not enough for the player to go down.
In reality the yellow card would have been harsh enough imo.
I’ve just watched the Keith Hackett video above.
It will be interesting to hear what wee Collum says.
HHH
Great summary of yesterday and where we are under MON.
Some posters saying we have improved, i think we have got worse.
Another poor display from our bhoys yesterday , we really don’t have the quality now to win this league . If big jock could be brought back he wouldn’t be able to make a team out of our playing pool . Unfortunately it seems we have been allowed to deteriorate. I can’t remember a softer team than present , hearts were more up for it than us , it was shooty in for big parts of the game . I was going to add my thoughts on what I thought we needed to improve the team , but no use as no one of any quality will be bought at this late juncture . I also admit to feeling sorry for MON a club legend being brought down to look an ordinary coach , he should have finished his coffee instead of taking Desmond’s call . I’m not going to mention the lodge members who get to officiate and decide if Celtic are going to win a game , as I stated many times with this lot and there bosses at SFA we will win games , cups when they let us win games /cups . It’s there to be seen presently .
HHH
We’re getting points that we didn’t get earlier this season or under Wilf. That’s all that matters at this very moment.
MON will know what’s needed, especially in that disaster of a midfield, it’s really is honking to see such ordinary players in Celtic shirts.
If we don’t sign anyone else this week, then I’m afraid it’s not going to improve too much until we get a free midweek and time on the training field…mid February.
Hi Bobby where are you situated
We have dropped 8 points, and lost 7 goals, under 3 managers, in 3 games, to McInnes, including goals from set pieces in all 3 games. What a fiasco!
We have dropped 5 points, and lost 3 goals, in 2 games, under 2 managers, to the Huns.
We are unable to protect a lead. We haven’t beaten our rivals once in the league, in 5 attempts. Anyone who thinks we will win at the Bigotdome is dreaming. The MIB now have the bit between their teeth, are increasingly blatant, have Hun penalties on an upward trajectory again, and their top stars of Beaton, McLean, Robertson, Aitken and Dallas are being assigned the critical games.
Meanwhile, weakling Nicholson flounders in ineptitude, and MON is being hung out to dry. The insipid incompetent mute will resign at the end of the season, leaving behind the detritus of an utter shambles, a facade of a professional club with no technical support structure.
What a way to run a business!
PERTH OZ BHOY
“Hi Bobby where are you situated”
Me-Swindon. Family-Kilwinning. Aussie b-i-l is from Brisbane.
INIQUITOUS IV
January 26, 2026 1:45 pm
What a way to run a business!
———
It’ll never catch on.
Saved for a rainy day, then fired on the sprinklers.
The boardroom Nancy duo inflicted more damage in 33 days than Sevco did in five years, we can only hope Dermot really did get caught out by Paul Tisdale now also gone, the lack of due diligence and research helped get us, where we are, unforgivable? By next Monday we’ll have a better view of how it’s shaping up for this season, it won’t be the same next year even if we win it, it’s been a hoot so far. By the time the window closes we’ll see amongst other things, if the board really care about Sevco’s CL threat, and whether they have considered the potential disturbance in equilibrium caused, in seasons to come.
If we don’t win it, then it’s because we threw it away in a story that we all know started in summer. Some supporters might reckon, ‘losing’ was already factored in. The bank balance £77M and third in a two horse race, sounds about right, for this group of custodians. They’ll likely bring in a few loans we’ll lap it up, like Cvancara and Araujo funnily enough loans but better than we’ve been watching . It won’t affect the budget, and will keep the wage bill in check, by loaning out this years Louis Palma / Michel – Ange Balikwisha? Inamura already away, Yamada invisible.
That blessed wage bill covered by the only investors in town i.e. the Celtic supporters, that buy tickets and merchandise. What happens in the run in with some distracted players like Hatate, Maeda, Yang, Engels all linked with moves, is anybody’s guess, ironic we can’t afford to sell anybody. MON back down on the Kings Rd today, muttering about Kings Park seen this movie before cavalry too late, no plan all done on the hoof.Besides nobody sells good players in January Celtic supporters are often told,
MON 1 telling us to prepare for life in slow lane.
WGS the battle of Willo Flood and having to be talked into another year.
MOGGA having to be talked out of resigning after a couple of weeks.
Neil Lennon walking the first time having “ taken us as far as he could “
Ronny Deila walking because of having “ taken us as far as he could “
Brendan Rodgers 1 we shouldn’t be scraping about at the end of the window.
Ange complaining about how slow moving transfers were, then bailing out.
Brendan Rodgers 2 we shouldn’t be scraping about at the end of the window.
MON 2 now telling us “ we’ve still got this week of the window “
Shrugs Shoulders CSC
Good afternoon, friends.
Just over 60 emails in the ole inbox so a wee bit of work still to do to get the charity donation barrier of 80, given that we drew the game. Still 6½ hours left to vote and first time voters are always welcome!
sencelpoty@gmail.com
1 point from 9 verse Hearts
1 point from 6 verse Sevco
£77M in the bank 👌
BOURNESOUPRECIPE
Strange thing, the Tisdale appointment. We were told that BR doesn’t like working with Directors of Football, etc, but then that he insisted an equivalent be appointed to take the strain.
Then, as it becomes clear that the Tisdale appointment is not working, that BR has consistently overruled his recommendations. Swiftly followed by the allegation that Tisdale was a BR recommendation in the first place.
This obviously flew in the face of the first point about BR not being keen on such appointments, yet another narrative arose regardless. That BR wanted such an appointment, to ease the burden of management. And that he had recommended Tisdale, despite two others “interviewing better”
Now, I’m sure you’re seeing the many contradictions in this, same as i am. BR didn’t want a DoF, he’d spent long enough getting rid of Lawwell, Jr. He was TOLD there would be one in place regardless.
This is the weird bit. We are now told that he had final say from a board-approved shortlist of three. And repeatedly told that the other two interviewed better. And I do mean repeatedly, it’s the talk ae the wash-hoose doon Board Lackey Way.
We’ve never had a hint of who those two might have been though…
I don’t just smell shite à la Karen Dunbar, this was an orchestrated campaign to wreck a man’s career out of sheer spite and personal animosity. The fact that the institution which paid them handsomely, and for which they all profess a lifelong love, was the ultimate victim, is just by the by.
They got rid of Rodgers. They trashed his rep. Job done, for that was all that was important to them.
Meantime, their empire crumbles. And Rodgers looks on from his palatial villa, contemplating his c£20m pa contact. And getting full use of that costly smile.
Cheated, betrayed, swindled, exploited, historic deceit and treason.
We need to keep the huns relevant.
Get me my Season Ticket!