Bhoys beat Buddies & Var
Saturday night, the two league leaders meeting under the floodlights, it had entertainment written all over it and so it proved.
The teamsheet was to be expected but the bench had the feeling of proper strength, so much so that three mainstays of the bench were pushed off it (Doohan, Luke, Tony) and into the stands.
The best away crowd and atmosphere greeted the Hoops as they emerged from the tunnel but the first ten minutes was very scrappy with the notables being Colby committing a stupid yellow card challenge and Hassan having his man on toast everytine. Things changed in the next ten minutes as we found some rhythm and started playing with intent and purpose. However around the 20 minute mark Liam gave away a clear penalty, a stupid penalty and with about 50% of the half played the onus was on Celtic to react. We did keep our heads, got a good grip on the game and it did look like we equalized via Duran but it was ruled out.
Hassan’s crosses dont suit Duran, we weren’t attempting long range shots, and the closer it got to half time the more I wanted the whistle and a tactical tweak or subs.
I got neither, apparently they got the old fashioned rocket because the same group absolutely stormed out of the blocks and before you know it had tied the game.
The setpiece coach once again takes credit as does Liam Scales, but I still want more from that department. Nevertheless the goal got us truly on the hunt for the winner and the game delivered a truly bizarre sequence of events.
About the hour mark, Yang missed a good chance, scored a good chance, then got injured and went off,,,all in the space of 10 minutes maybe less.
Okay so we are 2-1 ahead and bring on the subs. I was looking forward to this part, and sure enough two of them combined to create a beautiful goal. Which then went to VAR.
Who denied us two goals on the night.
When the first was chalked off I awaited the visual evidence, it never arrived, there was nothing clear and obvious in the goal.
For the second, the lines shown were not upon the release of the ball but rather our strikers initial burst to get into the danger zone, he then later came onside and scored. VAR again wasn’t conclusive so it can’t be clear and obvious. Maybe its just me but with this VAR lite they can pick whatever angle they like knowing theres none better.
Anyway, I took a ton of positives away from the game. Our attitude was spot on, I didn’t think we were losing that game at any stage. The 2nd half was exciting yes but I thought I saw signs of improvement. Donovan and Yang look totally at ease in the starting 11 now, and I wondsr was this injury to Yang an “ahem” sorry must stay/wanna stay type of injury?
Baur was pointing and talking like hes right at home and his positional awareness is excellent as is his stamina. Sorenson played the pass of the season to Shim, Duran laid it on a plate for Yang.
I walked away thinking the team is getting better, that I can see Martins imprint in that we spring forward quickly usually via a good ball into space, and from there hit one of the options. Its working so far, Europe will be tricky when they do the same to us.
Another pleasing aspect of this result is that we bested a team of giants via our football. They were huge, yet we got the better of them and one brainfart aside would have kept a clean sheet.
Martin said we need to take of ourselves domestically and threw away the European ambitions did he? Gimme a break, I recall his Rangers are the benchmark comment, and trust me he’s at the same malarkey. Tempering our expectations then hoping everyone rides on the crest of the wave all the way home.
There is a good team in there, and we haven’t seen all the players yet..
Write us off at your peril.
By Mahe
sentinelcelts@gmail.com
We now have a new JustGiving page set up to enable donations to be made for our latest charity appeal.
We wanted to focus again on a local charity, and this time one which is dedicated to helping those suffering from homelessness, addiction or poverty.
The one we have gone for is
GLASGOW CITY MISSION
You can find our dedicated page at
https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinelcelts67
It is coming up to that time of year when the betting aficionados amongst us have to get our thinking caps on again.
As usual, our site will run a NAPS COMPETITION with some healthy prize money, and once again it will start on St Leger Day in September and run through till the last day of Royal Ascot in June. There will be a short break from the end of November till the end of January.
https://sentinelcelts.com/2026/08/31/saturday-naps-competition-2/
And for those whose betting interests are mainly centred on the football, we will also run our MAGNIFICENT SEVEN accumulator, starting on the same day and finishing when we no longer have eight leagues to pick from. Usually the end of April. Let’s hope that it gives us a more magnificent return than the litany of near-misses and total failures we got last term!
https://sentinelcelts.com/2026/08/31/saturday-football-accumulator/
We will be looking for volunteers for this year’s ACCA , so please join up!
Both these initiatives are FREE TO ENTER, so please click on the links provided.
D R M has also very kindly volunteered to operate a competition over the three days of the AYR GOLD CUP meeting. September 17-19th
Usual rules, with a selection from each race.
There is £100 of prize money, and as alway is FREE TO ENTER!
More details are available on the dedicated page, so click on the link.
https://sentinelcelts.com/2026/08/31/d-r-m-ayr-gold-cup-meeting-competition/
*SENTINEL CELTS PLAYER OF THE YEAR 2025-26*
*RESULTS FROM GAME #8 ST MIRREN 1 CELTIC 2 (SCALES, YANG)*
Good evening, friends.
Our first real test of the domestic season saw a 2nd v 1st clash in Paisley. A pity that only around 6,500 fans were in the ground to see it.
It turned out to be a game of very fine margins with 3 big decision – a penalty and 2 disallowed goals – being decided on centimetres rather than being of the clear cut varieties. All 3 decisions went St Mirren’s way and we learned that, in Scotland, the VAR can encourage the referee to have a guess at what the correct outcome should be! Grrrrr…
Celtic started very brightly and completely dominated the opening stages, despite Donovan picking up another very early yellow card. Our front line were very positive and Camillo isn’t just a fine footballer, but a male model in the making, displaying the whitest teeth ever seen on a Celtic player!
The first goal came in the 19th minute. St Mirren’s corner was cleared to the edge of our box but the volleyed strike towards goal hit Scales’ outstretched hand right on the edge of the box and a penalty was awarded. Sinisalo guessed right but the shot had enough power to hit the net and Celtic were behind in a domestic game for the first time this season. Consequently, St Mirren now had it in their own hands to secure the 2027-28 Champions League qualifying spot.
After half an hour it looked like Celtic had equalised. Good work from Baur released Yang on the left and his ball into the box was put home by the outstretched boot of Duran. I wasn’t totally convinced by the VAR angles but anyway the goal was disallowed for offside and Celtic went into the break one down.
Celtic came flying out of the traps for the second half and had a couple of decent chances right after half time. The best had come from good work from Hassan on the right when his whipped inswinging cross wasn’t rewarded with a goal from Yang at the back post.
But in the 50th minute we did draw level and there was a degree of satisfaction involved here. St Mirren’s opener came from a corner unnecessarily conceded due to Sinisalo’s poor decision making. Celic’s equaliser also came from a corner that the St Mirren keeper could have easily avoided. But when the ball was crossed in we shouldn’t fail to appreciate the brilliant run to the near post by Scales and the excellent glancing looping header across to the far corner. Liam concedes a penalty, then gets the equaliser and so sits at level par with 40 to play!
The next 15 minutes saw play shift repeatedly from end to end but a moment of magic from Duran was to prove significant. Camilo did very well to steal the ball inside Celtic’s half and he then progressed into the opposition half before releasing Yang in the inside left position to calmly slot the ball home. Wait a minute, didn’t I just type more or less the same for our 3rd goal against Aberdeen? It’s déjà vu all over again! And 2-1 Celtic meant that another Saturday night tin of beer could be poured!
The game remained in the balance for the remainder, not least when in the 85th minute the limping Donovan was left for dead in a St Mirren counter attack. The ball across Celtic’s 6 yard box looked a certain goal but the attacker ballooned it over the bar. I cheered loudly and poured another!
Right after that, Donovan was replaced by Murray which meant that Celtic’s back line consisted of 4 centre backs – The right footed Murray and CCV along with the left footed Trusty and Scales. Total football?
The final talking point came in stoppage time. A ball through to Mheuta, playing on the shoulder of the last defender, saw our loanee striker in on goal and a composed, well struck finish seemed to seal the points. Admittedly, whether he was onside or offside was a matter of inches but neither the linesman nor the referee thought he was offside. The automatic VAR lines couldn’t be drawn and so, surely, the onfield decision stands? But, no, the VAR calls the referee to the monitor to have a look. Now, I accept that it does look as if Mheuta was just offside. But that’s not the point here. As there was no definitive proof of offside (i.e. the ‘lines’ couldn’t be drawn) then surely the onfield decision must stand? But not in Scotland – goal disallowed!! If I were paranoid (which I am!) I’d say that many folk in Scotland are still not able to accept how the final week of the 2025-26 league season played out!
Fortunately that incredible sequence of events didn’t affect the outcome of the game and Celtic continue with a 100% win rate in the league.
Celtic have now played 8 games, winning 7 and losing 1. We have scored 21 and conceded 8. We sit 3 points clear of last season’s runners up, and 5 clear of the mob who finished third.
Another excellent turnout of voters, so thank you for that. For this latest game, 104 provided their nominations, meaning we have again hit the 100+ target, for the 7th time in 8 games. £15 was sent to the Glasgow City Mission last weekend and that’s now another £6 sitting in the pot.
The total votes cast for each player (with my own nominations asterisked) are as follows –
Sinisalo*: 3
Donovan: 11
Carter Vickers: 7
Trusty: 0
Scales: 34
McGregor: 18
Baur: 31
Nygren: 3
Hassan*: 38
Duran: 69
Yang*: 98
Forrest: 0
Sørensen: 0
Tounekti: 0
Mheuka: 0
Murray: 0
Unused subs: Johnstone, Lotombo, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Van den Berg
And so, the POINTS earned by each player for the game against St Mirren are as follows –
25 – Yang
22 – Duran
19 – Hassan
16 – Scales
14 – Baur
12 – McGregor
11 – Donovan
10 – Carter-Vickers
9 each – Nygren and Sinisalo
5 each – Forrest, Mheuka, Murray, Sørensen, Tounekti, Trusty
1 each – Johnstone, Lotombo, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Van den Berg
And the CUMULATIVE POINTS after 8 games played are as follows –
151 – Duran
109 – Donovan
108 – Yang
106 – McGregor and Nygren
89 – Carter-Vickers
83 – Tierney
73 – Sinisalo
71 – Baur
60 – Høgh, Scales and Trusty
59 – Hassan
53 – Oxlade-Chamberlain
51 – Tounekti
38 – Forrest
30 – Engels
26 – McCowan
21 – Murray
18 – Hatate
17 – Johnston
13 – Osmand
10 each – Mheuka and Sørensen
9 – Ralston
6 – Doohan
3 – Kenny
2 – Balikwisha and Johnstone
1 – Kennedy, Lotomba and Van den Berg
We only have to wait 3 more sleeps until our next league game, an away trip to St Johnstone on Wednesday evening, kick off 8.00pm.
Hail Hail!
Happy Monday troops.
Two more sleeps till Celtic!
Mahe
Great start to the week on SC. If Celtic don’t challenge these VAR decisions we can assume that the Lackeys will never stand up for the club.
The still eventually shown for Duran’s goal is suspicious given that you can’t even see the ball. In the original the ball has just been played and he’s onside. The second decision is completely unacceptable and appears to have broken IFAB rules!
Jobo
Thanks again for continuing with the POTY. Inspired by your generosity I will donate £1 every time my 3 picks match what the collective choose. I started this half way through last season and donated £20 which was my guesstimation of what it would have been. Of course, it would have been more if you lot
weren’t all a buncha dumplings! (When did you last hear that phrase?)
😉
Mahe,
Worth mentioning we have AJ, KT, Van Den Berg, Hogh, Jota, Osmand and the other loan players we’ve yet to see. I really like the look of this team
If we get to a point where all are fit and contributing, we will streak away to 6 in a row!
SFA have announced ref , officials and VAR team for Wednesdays StJohnstone fixture
Ref-Hun
Linesman-Hun
Linesman-Hun
4th official-Hun
VAR- gang of Huns
Willie Collum-Hun apologist
Billy Bhoy
Whilst VAR in Scotland is a poorer version at 30 frames per second, as opposed to the better 50fps elsewhere, it is still a very useful tool. The problem in Scotland is that Officials are misusing it to the detriment of Celtic and it needs called out.
The technology isn’t the problem. The officials are.
Considering the hun media frenzy over correct Penalty award at Motherwell last season I expected the StMirren VAR decision’s would generate a flurry of scribbling.
But the same media have decided there was nothing to see!
Quelle surprise.
All that Celtic need to look for is clarity. Is VAR for clear and obvious errors or is for re refereeing the game. It’s a simple question which would go a long way to resolving the issue.
San Luis
September 7, 2026 9:48 am
Billy Bhoy
Whilst VAR in Scotland is a poorer version at 30 frames per second, as opposed to the better 50fps elsewhere, it is still a very useful tool. The problem in Scotland is that Officials are misusing it to the detriment of Celtic and it needs called out.
The technology isn’t the problem. The officials are.
##
Sort out the officials and ditch VAR.
Ernie
No, VAR works, without it we don’t win a title last season ” honest mistakes” normalised again.
The Huns hate VAR because it works well in the big games, they recieve no clear advantage, other than being permitted to foul continuously. By and large it levels the playing field and they and their laptop loyal want it gone for that very reason. Parity.
Officials are still very poor. I’ll agree with you on that.
If VAR is used honestly it can only benefit Scottish football. But for VAR we would not have won the league last season.
There were 3 contentious decisions in the St Mirren game and they all went against us. Likewise, there were a couple of decisions in sevco’s game Aberdeen and they went in sevco’s favour as did a decision in their game against Motherwell.
We are only 5 games into the season and the decisions are racking up.
These decisions will make the league very tight once again.
Ask yourself the question
Which support, to a man, wishes VAR gone?
Keep/ Upgrade VAR, dump the corrupt officials in charge of it.
San Luis
There’s no doubt that our FisherPrice version of VAR is simply not fit for purpose. I assumed the Jota incident at Motherwell was early teething problems but here we are still.
Last Sunday at Pittodrie the camera behind the goal was used to cancel Nisbets header for a push yet the same camera angle wasn’t shown for the Nisbet penalty claim. I don’t understand why Aberdeen didn’t challenge this. It was even omitted on Refwatch on Sky on Monday.
Unfathomable.
I meant to add: the view shown was utterly inconclusive and we were denied the view that would surely have clarified the position?
San Luis
September 7, 2026 10:50 am
VAR removes the immediacy and finality of decisions. Football is a sport, not a science. It doesn’t and shouldn’t require precision and exactitude from referees. That way leads to sterility and boredom.
Mistakes are fine if they are honest and even handed. They’ve always been a feature of the game.
So far as I know VAR wasn’t introduced because of demands by supporters or players. It was commercial interests who pushed for it.
We were told it would sort out the hun bias we are subjected to in Scotland. It hasn’t. So what’s the solution that’s being suggested? More VAR, but a newer and shinier version.
There are only 4 UEFA nations who do not use VAR
Finland
Ireland
Sweden
Montenegro
Even the lesser nations Litchtenstein, San Marino and others have it
Sweden is the only one not to consider the introduction of it. This is due to the supporters association of the clubs voting against it. Swedish supporters who are not members of the clubs polled 58% in favour when canvassed.
Ditching VAR having adopted it would sum up perfectly where Scottish football is at the moment
The most revealing decision on Saturday night was the throw in that we lost. I’d be interested in the statistics around this throughout all SPFL games and with this referee in particular. I posit it would be highly revealing
Cheating in the women’s game as well, never a penalty.
https://x.com/BBCSportScot/status/2096900990712598611
Awe Naw,
Was watching the game in the pub on Saturday night and missed the throw in incidence with Scales but my mates were saying Scales was looking for a ball to take the shy when the Ref then awarded it to St Mirren.
Did Scales have a fitba in his hands?
Also, mate just sent me a photo, dated yesterday, of an SFA Apology to Celtic for VAR not available at our disallowed goal and that it should have stood.
Now, an SFA Apology to Celtic will never, ever happen so I’ve told him it’s fake.
HH
From my calculations the huns are very close to being non FSR compliant. My calculations are naturally only estimates
Maybe somebody with more ken than me can tell me that if the huns sell a player in January 27 whether it can help their FSR assessment for their UEFA 27/28 season ?
The FSR accounting period ends on the 31st December 2026 so maybe they can’t fix it.
If it does and they need to sell in January then it would mean having to sell a player who wasn’t bought this summer. Basically Raskin, Curtis, Gassama, Fernandez as they will bring in “pure profit” but amortisized profit
These players will be starting 11 choices as they need to be showcased. As there is no European platform to showcase them it will need to be done in the SPFL.
So not only punishment for winning the double last year when we had no right to having made a pigs ear of it. The huns cannot be languishing in third place this season come January.
It’s going to be a hun saving mibbery extravaganza like we’ve never seen before. Craig levein could be the next Scottish manager by Christmas along with John Rowbottom becoming head of refereeing.
Ernie
We were told it would sort out the hun bias we are subjected to in Scotland. It hasn’t
_-_-_+_-_-_-“-_-_-_+”-
Ernie
You’re wrong , technology is a machine, it has no in built bias, the people working it do though.
Nonetheless, in a number of games involving Celtic v Rangers VAR has intervened to over rule an incorrect flag for an offide, resulting in a goal to Celtic, awarded a Celtic penalty at Ibrox for hand ball, disallowed a Huns goal at Ibrox for a foul in the lead up. Chopped of a Cup Final goal for the Huns for a two handed shove on keeper.
These are the “honest mistakes” we’ve dealt with for years, now being levelled out by technology.
Long live VAR
Billy Bhoy at 9:38 – that’s a really fine gesture. But hopefully it doesn’t directly interfere with your nomination choices. Sometimes there’s something about a particular player’s performance that earns him one of my votes, even though I recognise that he might a not be a popular choice. For example, I plumped for Sinisalo on Saturday night as I felt he held everything fired at him and had a few goal saving saves too. Perhaps your pledge could be more of the Meat Loaf approach – nominating 2 of the overall top 3? 😉
I suppose one benefit of VAR is that it saves people having to confront the real problem.
OK it has it downsides, but that’s a price worth paying to avoid having to deal with an issue we’d rather not confront
Maybe another is that it makes the game more attractive for those with extreme OCD.
Ernie
VAR is not perfect, how could it be in the hands of Scottish officials, but give me an alternative that’s better? Because we cannot go backwards to how it once was.
Fair play, if you liked being cheated, or you liked being treated as the lesser team. You’re a better man than me.
I prefer my sport fair, so anything that increases fair play and eliminates the certain unconscious bias prevalent amongst the Scottish refereeing fraternity, is all good by me.
San Luis
September 7, 2026 1:34 pm
Can you see any ways in which VAR has adversely affected the game?
Ernie
I don’t disagree about the spontaneity and rush of excitement of a goal being lost…. but then I remember all the wrong offside flags, imagined balls going over the bye line in a dangerous attack, the stonewall penalties denied and I make my peace with the technology.
VAR is designed to overcome obvious referee mistakes but its only as good as the integrity of the people paying for it and implementing it. Its as vulnerable to cheating as everything else. VAR is how Argentina cheated (due to World Cup inherent corruption) their way to the last two World Cup finals.
What i don’t understand is why we don’t speak out especially after we won. The third goal decision was against the rules say something ffs.
VARiety is the spice of life or in Scottish officialdoms case a tool to cheat.
We can’t get rid of it as the establishment would increase cheating tenfold due to lack of scrutiny.
The MSSM would be in lock step to further that agenda.
But Celtic should demand a clear explanation of why 3rd goal was ruled out with conversation between officials demanded.
There is precedent for such I believe as the Huns demanded such last year over a VAR incident and were acquiesced.
Jobo
I have always simply picked my top 3 and am pleasantly surprised when it matches the collective view. I won’t be modifying it to guess what others might think. I’m not that smart. 😉
I’m pretty sure that there are several on here who still want to include Greg Taylor and Arne Engels in their top three!
😂
The Sad Case of Jadon Sancho.
Jadon has been released by MU after his 21/22 transfer from Dortmund. The reported fee was 100 million(euros or pounds?). He is 26 years old. According to Transfermkt his market value is now 18 million euros.
Jadon stands out as an exception amongst the high valued free agents currently available. Most of the others have recent records of absences due to physical injuries such as knee knack, hamstrings, and muscle injuries. Bissouma and Zinchenko are examples in point.
In Jadon’s case his absences are frequently explained by the term “Ill”. After arrived at MU in season 22/23, he missed 10 games due to what Transfermkt classifies as “Depression”. His MU career cannot be described as a roaring success as he was loaned out to Dortmund and Chelsea. Neither of these clubs rushed to pay a transfer fee for him.
At 26 years of age there is still time for Jadon to have a successful career but which club will take a chance on him? Would Celtic?
Salary would be an issue but Jadon will probably have to settle for less wherever he goes. If he is wise, money will not be the top priority, at least initially. A nurturing environment should be high on the list.
Rebus
Away from Celtic I have another issue with VAR and score updates.
I check scores a lot during matches and get hacked off when I see a 1-0, 1-1 or whatever then check in later to see the latest score is now 0-1 or 2-0 or whatever in these games.
I don’t know why they don’t put goals just scored in red until VAR has confirmed or cancelled it.
And you think our officials cause problems with their decision making?
https://youtu.be/VFWa_Oh7hiY?si=K6s9v-he1qcOPdKO
Damn, I came on here to get away from Merchant Bankers like that.
Ah well.
Ave Ave
Jobo
Decent shout for Sinisalo but quickly forgotten
that he was catching bees at the Dons corner
that was headed onto the bar.
I think he’s improving but a bit to go yet.
Keep up the POTY, thanks
SteveNaive
Oh, he didn’t get nominated for his Aberdeen performance. But I felt he played very well on Saturday. Yes, he gave away 1 needless corner but better to be safe than sorry. He will hopefully improve, now that there appears to be some competition for the jersey.
Hello there, ya auld bams.
Shankland out for 3 months
MIT
On probation?
BIGRAILROADBLUES
You gorra laff, apparently he’s done his hamstring. Possibly the least unlikely injury ever.
Awe Naw
September 7, 2026 12:51 pm
From my calculations the huns are very close to being non FSR compliant. My calculations are naturally only estimates
Maybe somebody with more ken than me can tell me that if the huns sell a player in January 27 whether it can help their FSR assessment for their UEFA 27/28 season ?
The FSR accounting period ends on the 31st December 2026 so maybe they can’t fix it.
===========
One of the reasons I backed off was explaining how FSR works has been seen as defending last seasons transfer window rather trying to explain its relevance to how The Board operates under FSR each year not jus current. The other thing about FSR is it has what I call “wrinkles” in it as in there is something not understood within the complex array of regulations. However I think I have ironed them out to improve my understanding with help of AI so I will try and set them out.
First the UEFA FSR Three Year Rules.
There are actually two different “three-year” concepts in the UEFA Club Licensing and Financial Sustainability Regulations, and it’s easy to confuse them.
The Three-Year Rule (Club Eligibility) – Article 14
This has nothing to do with financial monitoring.
Article 14.02 requires that, by the start of the licence season, a club must have:
been a member (or in a contractual relationship with a member) for at least three consecutive seasons, and participated in official national competitions for at least three consecutive seasons. (The old Article 12 in FFP that made The Rangers a new club to UEFA)
The Three-Year Financial Assessment (Football Earnings Rule)
This is the one most people mean when discussing FSR.
The Football Earnings Rule (FER) is assessed over three reporting periods (T, T-1 and T-2). UEFA aggregates the football earnings result across those three financial years to determine compliance. This is set out in the Football Earnings Rule provisions and the calculation methodology in the relevant annexes.
By contrast:
Football Earnings Rule (FER): rolling three-year assessment.
Squad Cost Rule (SCR): single-year assessment.
The rolling assessment for the Football Earnings Rule (FER) effectively began with the introduction of the new Financial Sustainability Regulations in 2022, but the first full three-year assessment took place in the 2025/26 UEFA club competition season.
Here’s the timeline:
Article 86 defines the monitoring period as three consecutive reporting periods, namely:
UEFA confirmed that the 2025/26 season was the first time the Football Earnings Rule was assessed on a three-year aggregate basis, using the financial years ending in 2023, 2024 and 2025.
For Celtic assuming a 30 June year-end, the rolling FER assessments are:
This is quite separate from the Squad Cost Rule, which is assessed one reporting period at a time rather than on a rolling three-year basis.
The purpose of the rolling three-year assessment is to judge a club’s financial sustainability over time, rather than on the basis of a single exceptional year.
UEFA recognises that football finances are volatile. A club might have:
Looking at just one year could produce a misleading picture. By assessing three consecutive reporting periods, UEFA can see whether the club’s financial model is sustainable rather than whether it happened to have one good or bad year.
In Summary
The three-year rolling assessment applies to the Football Earnings Rule, not the Squad Cost Rule. UEFA uses the rolling assessment to judge whether a club’s financial model is sustainable over time, smoothing out one-off events such as a major player sale or missing out on the Champions League. The Squad Cost Rule is different: it is assessed for each reporting period and measures whether a club’s current squad costs are within the permitted percentage of its adjusted football revenue.
I will cover SCR which uses a clubs annual audited accounts. To be SCR compliant for 2027/2028 Rangers latest audited accounts for 25/26 will be used from Jan 2027 by SFA applying SCR and reporting results to UEFA who can then apply the 3 year FER rules.
Ernie Lynch 10.20
Sort out the officials and ditch VAR.
Dont be silly Ernie technology is only going to get more involved,for e.g I would like to see a running clock that stops when play does
it was Var that was inconclusive.if we paid for uefa/epl standard the technology var would have worked.Our current system is a failure as Sat proved.a technology failure..
HH
For the Squad Cost Rule itself, the calculation is based on the current reporting period’s adjusted football revenue and squad costs. It is not directly based on forecasts.
However, when a club decides what wages it can safely offer today, it cannot sensibly look only at current income. It must also consider its future expected income, because:
So, in practice, clubs use financial forecasts when recruiting, even though the SCR itself is assessed against actual reported figures.
For example:
That’s why prudent clubs model different scenarios before committing to contracts.
(The underling and bold is the point I have been trying to get across since 6th Sept statement that was read as an excuse for poor recruitmnet last window)
In summary: Current recruitment decisions should not be based solely on current income. Because player contracts extend into future reporting periods, clubs need realistic forecasts of future income—including the possibility of not qualifying for the Champions League—to avoid committing to wage levels that may become unaffordable and breach the Squad Cost Rule in later years.
With regard to the 6th Sept statement this might help what I have been driving at in terms of raising questions at the AGM:
I think there are two separate questions that are worth keeping distinct.
A club can be fully compliant today and still decide not to increase its long-term wage commitments because it is planning for future reporting periods. That isn’t because UEFA is assessing future forecasts directly; it’s because the club’s board has to manage the risk of future revenues falling while player contracts remain fixed.
So the statement:
is only partly true.
A more accurate statement would be:
Whether that forecasting was too cautious, about right, or overly conservative is a legitimate matter for debate.
Reasonable people can disagree on that because it involves management judgement rather than a straightforward interpretation of the regulations.
What I have been trying to do has been encouraging supporters to distinguish between:
Those are not the same thing. FSR sets the boundaries. The board decides how close to those boundaries it is prepared to operate.
That distinction helps avoid blaming UEFA for decisions that are, in reality, business judgements made by the club.
The key principles identified are consistent with UEFA’s framework:
What I want to know next is how much is it costing Celtic to fund a team where CL participation over 3 or 4 years guaranteed and what the cost of any failure amounts to.
I’m working on it.
Anyone who thinks FSR in football is anything meaningful is deluded. It will only make the corrupt more corrupt
Anyone who thinks VAR is a technology failure and not about more corruption is deluded. I give you the Champions league and the World Cup as the most glaring examples. Then it’s all downhill from there ending in Scottish corruption with a bigot ingredient which makes it all the more pitiful
Upgrading VAR
Is it Time to Act:
Should Celtic, Rangers, and Hearts Unite to End Our Shambolic VAR Crisis
Scottish football is stuck in a self-inflicted time warp. Week after week, we endure embarrassing delays, baffling line-drawing exercises, and outright technological blind spots—like Celtic’s disallowed goals against St Mirren where the camera angles failed entirely and officials were left guessing. It is actively damaging the credibility of our game.
The solution is staring us in the face: Semi-Automated Offside Technology (SAOT). It cuts decision times to seconds and brings total accuracy. So why haven’t we implemented it? Because of a total financial deadlock.
A league-wide SAOT upgrade costs roughly £1.2 million a year. Expecting smaller clubs to vote for this is a fantasy. For sides like Ross County or St Mirren, that means cannibalising their €766,666 (£639,000) UEFA Sustainability Payments—money legally ring-fenced to keep their youth academies and community programmes alive. They cannot, and will not, vote to bankrupt their futures just to upgrade refereeing tech.
The responsibility lies squarely with the clubs who actually have European aspirations. It is time for a “Coalition of the Willing.” Celtic, Rangers, and an ambitious Hearts must step forward and directly bankroll SAOT.
If the Glasgow giants absorb 40% each (£480k) and Hearts picks up 20% (£240k) as a statement of their intent as Scotland’s permanent “third force,” the financial gridlock vanishes. By providing a private commercial guarantee to the SPFL, the “Big Three” can bypass the voting drama completely. No smaller club will block a multi-million-pound infrastructure gift that costs them nothing.
For Celtic and Rangers, this expense is a rounding error compared to European prize money. For all three, it protects their multi-million-pound player assets and ensures their squads aren’t tactically shocked when playing under elite UEFA tech on the continent.
Stop waiting for a broken SPFL system to fix itself. Our top clubs need to stop complaining about refereeing standards, put their hands in their pockets, and buy the technology the Scottish game desperately needs.
Auldheid
Egypt were disallowed on of the greatest goals in World cup history against Argentina a few months back as it was deemed to be a dubious toe stamp foul on their own byline about 10 touches and a minute earlier. VAR deficiencies have got nothing to do with technology. Its all about cheating for money.