Systems, subs, and selections

Google info and the time change defeated me which saw myself arise in time for the second half on Sunday. To say it was bad is a drastic understatement, it was dire and further highlights the early kickoff on a Sunday doesn’t deliver a good game.

 

Still, we got the job done and if you had offered me three wins over Hibs, Hearts, Motherwell I would have snapped your hand off. I pointed out on Saturday that just winning doesn’t seem to be enough now, there was more than three points at stake, and this was bore out both during and since. Given we have been taking the points obviously other aspects of his management come in for scrutiny and as the title says it’s one or all of his system, subs, and selections taking major heat from Tims.

 

I’ll be the first to admit he does leave himself wide open to critism on the above. On Sunday he was guilty when taking off Hogh while bringing on the two wide men he needed for supply. On the other hand he got slammed over the AJ injury which I certainly don’t see as his fault as the medical team surely cleared him to play. He is flawed, and there’s unlikely to be a proper system implemented, but I would accept his final ever fingers crossed title being won in this fashion over the alternative.

 

It seems I’m in the minority though if the vibe across Celtic Cybersphere represents the majority. We’ve experienced unpopular title winning managers, in a football sense that is, such as Ronnie, Lenny, possibly WGS,,,I just never imagined Martin being added to the list. I just cannot see him walking away either especially if in the title hunt. That leaves us with an uneasy middle ground as either he keeps delivering ugly and gets flack, or he stops delivering and the floodgates open upon him. Let us not forget he is (and always will be) afforded protection by the executives so if he does decide to lash out at the support there will be zero employment consequences,,he won’t be a silent punching bag forever and I fear if the results stop doing his talking then he will take the task upon himself.

 

Clubs and managers who are genuinely watching the roof cave in must be gobsmacked when style of play etc is under heavy scrutiny as we sit reigning Champions and top of the league, but standards and all that.
And isn’t there a tragic hint of irony in that the man who basically introduced the modern standard for a good Celtic team is now being found guilty of failing the standard.

 

By Mahe
sentinelcelts@gmail.com

Subscribe
Notify of
70 Comments
Mahe
October 27, 2026 4:06 am

We now have a new JustGiving page set up to enable donations to be made for our latest charity appeal. 

We wanted to focus again on a local charity, and this time one which is dedicated to helping those suffering from homelessness, addiction or poverty. 

The one we have gone for is

GLASGOW CITY MISSION

You can find our dedicated page at

https://www.justgiving.com/page/sentinelcelts67

Mahe
October 27, 2026 4:07 am

Goals so far…

Høgh……… 3
Nygren …….8
Durán…..….10
Osmand……2
Yang………..2
Tierney…….1
McCowan …1
Baur………..4
Tounekti……1
Trusty………1
McGregor….1
Scales….….1
og…………..1

******

Assists so far…

Nygren …. 7
Tierney…. 5
Høgh……..3
Scales..….1
Engels …..1
Murray……1
Duran ……5
Hassan…..3
Yang…..…1
Tounekti …1

Stats as given on BBC match report

Mahe
October 27, 2026 4:09 am

*SENTINEL CELTS PLAYER OF THE YEAR 2026-27*
*RESULTS FROM GAME #17 HIBS 1 CELTIC 2 (OWN GOAL, DURAN)*

Good evening, friends.
Most of my Sunday morning was spent searching for confirmation that our game was to be postponed but it was not to be. And whilst the strong winds reduced the chance of any decent football breaking out it was ultimately a good weekend for those of a green hooped persuasion.
Hibs kicked off and won a corner with just 16 seconds on the clock. And whilst nothing came from that particular set piece, their next one just 2 minutes later saw the whole Celtic back 5 asleep to a quickly taken free kick and a well curled finish into the bottom corner. 0-1.
Celtic progressed well from the restart and a couple of minutes later, good work from McGregor saw his decent effort turned round the post for a corner. The inswinging ball was met by 2 Hibs defenders who combined to gift Celtic an early equaliser. 1-1.
On 13 minutes a fine move saw Nygren slip in Osmand on the left. Callum cut it back to Duran who slipped it right to Høgh who’s effort was well saved.
The game ebbed and flowed and on 36 minutes Hibs cut straight though the middle. Donovan showed brilliant anticipation to slide across our D with a brilliant shot-saving tackle.
A couple of minutes before half time proved to be crucial. A loose ball on the edge of Hibs’ box was spotted by right sided Duran who drifted in, controlled the loose ball and then stroked a fine shot into his far corner. Celtic were to lead 2-1 at half time.
The second half started well and on 47 minutes a terrific effort from Baur from 22 yards was turned round the post. But the following 46 minutes produced little of note with both keepers rarely troubled. Celtic eventually settling for the 3 points having won 9 of the first 10 league games of this season.
Celtic have now played 17 games, winning 11 and losing 6. We have scored 36 and conceded 23. We remain 4 points clear at the top of the SPL.
Voting numbers were high but not quite enough to generate a further benefit to our nominated charity. But thanks, as always, to the 87 who sent their nominations for this one.

The total votes cast for each player (with my own nominations asterisked) are as follows –

Johnstone: 2
Donovan: 18
Murray: 27
Scales: 11
Tierney*: 42
McGregor*: 7
Baur*: 60
Nygren: 0
Duran: 66
Høgh: 0
Osmand: 25
Johnston: 0
Jota: 2
Hassan: 0
Carter Vickers: 1
Mheuka: 0
Unused subs: Forrest, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Sinisalo, Sørensen

And so, the POINTS earned by each player for the game against Hibs are as follows:

25 – Duran
22 – Baur
19 – Tierney
16 – Murray
14 – Osmand
12 – Donovan
11 – Scales
10 – McGregor
9 each – Johnstone and Jota
7 – Carter-Vickers
4 each – Hassan, Høgh, Johnston, Mheuka and Nygren
1 each – Forrest, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Sinisalo, Sørensen

And the CUMULATIVE POINTS after 17 games played are as follows –
280 – Duran
268 – Donovan
258 – Baur
241 – Tierney
188 – McGregor
170 – Nygren
162 – Hassan
161 – Scales
138 – Carter-Vickers
121 – Sinisalo
114 – Forrest
108 – Yang
107 – Høgh
105 – Tounekti
88 – Murray
86 – Trusty
84 – Osmand
81 – Oxlade-Chamberlain
49 – Johnstone
40 – McCowan
36 – Mheuka
34 – Sørensen
30 – Engels
27 – Jota
21 – Johnston
18 – Hatate
17 – Lotomba
15 – Ralston
7 – Doohan
5 – Emenalo
3 – Kennedy and Kenny
2 – Balikwisha and Van den Berg
1 – Clearie, Haney and McArdle

There’s a full midweek card in the SPL this Wednesday and Celtic have a home game against Dundee Utd, kick off 7.45pm.
Hail Hail!

Westcraigs
October 27, 2026 8:10 am

Was Strachan unpopular? Not with me. Won 3 in a row. Reached the last 16 of the champions league twice. Achieved this despite the best efforts of Lawwell.
Going for 4 in a row. He wanted Fletcher from Hibs. Got flood instead. Lawwell won in the end and Gordon left.
Gordon is a Celtic hero in my mind.

October 27, 2026 9:48 am

I liked wee Gordon although his football at times was very dull, but no arguing that he got some big results.

INIQUITOUS IV
October 27, 2026 10:03 am

Cosy Corner Bhoy

 October 26, 2026 5:30 pm
INQ 1V 434ish: Are you trying to cheer us all up with your info re Besiktas? Might be those named might have an ‘off-night’, ’ it happens.

Celtic’s progression this year is virtually now non-existent , but I will still be in Portugal for the game on 26th November “ We are Celtic supporters, faithful through and through”. It’s not always about winning for some supporters… it’s being there supporting. The Huns have had more experience of the scenario so why not ask one “ Why are you still going to watch that mince?” You’ll be surprised at the answer.
———————————-
Hi Pat:
Hope yer in the pink.
I’m neither trying to cheer people up nor depress them. I just have an interest in details of any upcoming opposition, and it’s a bit of a curiosity that we are familiar with 3 members of the Besiktas team.

I applaud you for still making the effort to travel abroad to see the Hoops. I was deported in 1984, but can still remember traveling in the early 80’s and suffering disappointment at Real Madrid, Juve, Real Sociedad, and worst of all, Timisoara! 😅

I didn’t understand the reference to the Huns. They are mince in Europe, but so are we.
HH
INIQUITOUS IV😊

INIQUITOUS IV
October 27, 2026 10:07 am

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED UP WINKLEPICKERS

 October 26, 2026 11:56 pm
INIQUITOUS IV
No problem mate. Hope the trip is going well.
——————
Hi Bobby:
Struggling to leave Stornoway. All flights cancelled this morning. Still blowing a hooley.
HH
INIQUITOUS IV😊

SteveNaive
October 27, 2026 10:24 am

SL,

Not Strachan’s football which was dull, more the capabilities of his players.
Same as now.
Great teams can have bad results ( 0-4 Thistle) and lesser teams can have great results ( 0-4 Thistle )
Consistency is the thing.
Planning and all that.

Fan
October 27, 2026 11:40 am

Westcraigs
Never really liked Strachan’s style of football but he was pragmatic and could set up a team properly with the tools the bastard Lawwell gave him.
I actually think Gordon’s tenure gave Lawwell reason to think he was great at his job rather than the useless bastard he was.
It cemented the disastrous path we have tread since!

October 27, 2026 11:58 am

SN

Yeah, any team that lost the likes of Larsson, Lubo and Petrov was always going to struggle in comparison to reach such heights. Some great nights in Europe it has to be said.

Cosy Corner Bhoy
October 27, 2026 12:09 pm

Fan 1140: I’m in agreement with you re Lawwell’s sense of his own importance re titles being won etc we’re all down to his genius!
The problem, now that he is gone, is that he’s left a clutch of like minded nonentities behind.
We are hoist by our own petard😫
The more we keep winning in Scotland the more genius they tell themselves they are!
As for Europe…. Young Master Desmond told us their stance, which was/is it’s a waste of time if you can’t win it. Competing well never comes into it.
All we want for Christmas is a new owner or a Damascene moment for the one we have.

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 27, 2026 1:10 pm

FAN

While you’re bang on about Lawwell thinking he’d cracked this Football Manager lark due to Strachan winning three in a row, his decision to hire Mowbray should have set him right. And if not, then Smith winning three in a row should have put it beyond doubt.

Sadly, by then his ego and bonus-driven greed were out of control. We as fans have been paying for it ever since by way of a declining product and dearth of ambition.

Fan
October 27, 2026 2:05 pm

BMCUWP
And Lawwell should always be remembered as an INSTRUMENT OF TERMINAL DECLINE if not the INSTRUMENT OF DEATH aided by Despot Dermot of a once renowned World famous football club.

Bada Bing
October 27, 2026 2:10 pm

AJ out for next 4 games at least

Fan
October 27, 2026 2:17 pm

Bada Bing
Of course nothing to do with fitness coaches or World class medical professionals!
There is not one coach at Celtic fc who is qualified in their present capacity to be there!

Bada Bing
October 27, 2026 2:23 pm

Could do worse than giving Seamus Coleman a deal till end of the season, great experience

Bada Bing
October 27, 2026 2:35 pm

BRRB around….?

101768
October 27, 2026 2:40 pm

Fan

October 27, 2026 2:17 pm
Bada Bing
Of course nothing to do with fitness coaches or World class medical professionals!
There is not one coach at Celtic fc who is qualified in their present capacity to be there!

———————

Do you think none of the coaches have got any qualifications ?

Seriously ?

October 27, 2026 2:55 pm

meanwhile,

The Celtic annual report has not yet been published, I think that now makes it late.

And so there is not yet a date set for the AGM.

Fan
October 27, 2026 3:04 pm

Saint Stivs
Football is results based.
Our performances on field at every level , youth , women and first team, our simple lack of basics, and a ridiculous injury record then I seriously think not one coach is fulfilling their purpose.

Bluegrass Celt
October 27, 2026 3:08 pm

Fan, Saint Stivs,
No doubt out coaches have qualifications, but it doesn’t look like any of them are 18th Edition, more like 16th (1991-92)

big packy
October 27, 2026 3:09 pm

AFTERNOON ALL AND JIM AND MAGUA talking about the late great bobby murdoch last night,reminded me of my first scottish cup final celtic v rangers,1969 anybody else from sentinel celts there??? rangers were the hot favourites having beaten aberdeen 6-1 in the semi final ,but it was not to be, bobby murdoch didnt give the rangers player alex ferguson a sniff of the ball and at one point seemed to head butt bobby murdoch,,but goals from billy McNeil bobby lennox george Connelly and stevie chalmers saw us become scottish champions once again.ACH memories.another true story👍👍

October 27, 2026 3:12 pm

As much as I love my fellow Canuck, Aj, a football player is of no use sitting getting constant treatment.

A real shame, his situation, as he’s definitely one of our better players.

I think we’re at the stage of making plans to find a replacement.

HH 🍀

October 27, 2026 3:12 pm

St.Stivs

How ye doin mate?

Stephen McManus could have a Level 8 Doctrate on Fitba but he’s no convincing me he’s a football coach..

October 27, 2026 3:17 pm

aye, I am good.

Does my head in though, that anyone thinks our coaches, medical staff even our analytics people are not qualified to do the jobs.

I suppose if the management thought they were performing badly then they would be moved on.

For many years we heard John Kennedy was useless as a coach, but I repeatedly heard people in the game saying he was a fantstic operator. Where is he now ?

In an up to date example, how did Coldy get to where he is now ? Pure luck ? raw talent ? or 10 years in the academy system ?

October 27, 2026 3:24 pm

BMCUWP
And Lawwell should always be remembered as an INSTRUMENT OF TERMINAL DECLINE if not the INSTRUMENT OF DEATH aided by Despot Dermot of a once renowned World famous football club.

Fan.2.05

We are still a world renowned club.
I think that always

we have not been to a European final since 2003 some 24 year before today.

Prior to MoN.1 our previous best was 1980 ¼s v.Real Madrid 20 years

Before that is Jocks time where I am sure youll agree when Celtics success went global.

I would use our historic euro record as a measure of decline,the majority is poor fayre.

This myth punted that this renowned club is in decline i dissent,we are going thro change.i am sure man u fans after Como and AC Milan falling to new towering euro giants of Bournemouth

I was been active in our club 92-4.
We were in decline then and minutes away from folding that would have been the death of our club.it did not happen.

We are nowhere near that today thank god

Game on wed,3 pts please and onwards

We have a lot to be gettin on with

HH

.

October 27, 2026 3:25 pm

Correection

I would NOT use europe as a gauge

October 27, 2026 3:34 pm

St Stivs

Def mate.they’l be qualified alright.have to be probably but think of some of the duffers that have passed through Scottish football and offered nothing to the game in a coaching sense.How McManus got a job with 1st team after the regularly poor performances of B team to me is a mystery.

SteveNaive
October 27, 2026 3:46 pm

Highest paid ex Celtic player in world football ?

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 27, 2026 3:55 pm

STEVENAIVE

Jack Hendry?

Cosy Corner Bhoy
October 27, 2026 4:09 pm

INQ1V 1004: Wouldn’t go as far as in the pink but still going to watch the Bhoys, mostly in CSC Linwood, great club btw, and golf on Mondays.All in can’t complain .
Good point re the connection with the names Besiktas players… which I missed… but a bit more cup half full and less bloody nearly empty helps the spirit to perk up.Im in one you’re in the other😅

October 27, 2026 4:11 pm

Stevie,

On top of his universal credit, big Virgil must be close

Ex Machina
October 27, 2026 4:18 pm

Nabbla

Surely the point is Celtic are the major player taking part in a decline( terminal has yet to be reached) infecting the entire Scottish football structure. It is sinking at an alarming rate. Down among the Euro also rans.
We are a substandard product, that much is clearly obvious. This is certainly what you could call undergoing change but in a downward spiral towards rock bottom.

We do not stand alone now as we did facing extinction 30 years ago. At that time the Huns were in the ascendancy and had a European reputation. Scotland had a measure of credibility in club European terms.
.
The financial landscape was only beginning to change for the better for the top leagues, taking them into a different category in fairly short order.
We were not quite third/fourth rate neighbours then.

Now the collective quality of Scottish football is currently a laughing stock, soon to be an irrelevance.

We were being left behind then, but still had the opportunity to build on our strengths. Clubs comparable in status have shown this possibility.

Fast forward and it seems we have decided to aid the process of decline by embracing functional obsolescence.

With no accountability our leadership/ ownership group dictate this process for god knows what reasons.

The change we are undergoing could already be irreversible.

jimbo67
October 27, 2026 5:03 pm

Steve Naive @ 3.46

Moussa Dembele?

Jimbo

jimbo67
October 27, 2026 5:24 pm

Afternoon all

Re earlier discussion re WGS.

Funny one. He inherited a team that was ageing and had just sustained its blackest day in 35 years with nothing coming close to that debacle since. He faced a Hun club that was in full cheat mode. 6 major trophies in 4 seasons and with the only Celtic team in my adulthood that exceeded European expectations his teams reached the Champions League last 16 in consecutive seasons- and was genuinely unlucky not to progress to the last 8 one of those times after some very suspect refereeing in San Siro versus AC Milan who went on to win the whole thing. The football was sometimes a bit on the dull side but if Lubo and Henrik were not there so was Martin O’Neill’s team too. He often treated the local media with the contempt it deserved. A former colleague who had been in the youth teams from 2005 to 2008 said he was an absolutely top bloke too. And yet…

WGS should be a hero in all our eyes but he is not – and I have very fixed feelings towards him. Maybe it was starting off with that five-goal loss in Bratislava and the loss to Clyde (the only one to them in my lifetime) and the anti-climax of his last season- the one I was in back in the country and did not mostly watch in Perth or Sydney- that go against him for me even though not only was he up against cheating opponents he was being hindered by his own chief executive whose strategy seemed to be that Celtic’s vehicle always drove with the hand brake still on (sorry for the cliche) .

I’d still give Strachan a passmark and would not swear that Celtic has had a better manager since but he remains someone I admire rather than really like.

Jimbo

October 27, 2026 5:30 pm

rumor today is that Man U are talking to Unai Emery.

October 27, 2026 5:57 pm

hhmm.

all about perspective i suppose but losing the league in the final minutes were bad days yes

but dont compare to trully awful seasons

Jimbo67
October 27, 2026 6:12 pm

St Stivs

I was not comparing one day in May 2005 with truly awful seasons because they are not the same thing.

Jimbo

October 27, 2026 6:15 pm

I know lots of lawyers who are “qualified to do the job’, i.e., the passed the Bar exam, but are still very poor lawyers.

big packy
October 27, 2026 6:19 pm

noticed no one replied to my post at 3-09, looks like I was the only one from sentinelcelts that was at the 1969 scottish cup final,,actually im proud of that🙏❤ another true story👍

October 27, 2026 6:38 pm

Saint Stivs on 27th October 2026 6:37 pm

the hertz, fecking cheek oh them, serial losers.
 
 
———————-
 
 
“The final week was difficult on a number of fronts. Amongst other things, we were disappointed by the unprecedented decision that, as the team leading the league at the time of the split, we had to play our final game away from home. The circumstances at the end of that game were, from our perspective, completely unacceptable.
 
 
 
 
“We took advice and we made our concerns very clear to the football authorities. Standing back from it all, I think we’d like to see greater transparency and consistency around key decisions in Scottish football, because standards and processes matter, particularly at important points in the season, and I think there’s room for improvement.
 
 
 
 
“I understand the frustration about how little supporters heard from us afterwards. There was, and remains, a live police investigation into actions against our players, and that obviously limited what we could say publicly, but I think even with those constraints, I think we could have communicated more clearly. In the end, we had to think about what was best for Hearts. With a new management team coming in, a new season to prepare for, we felt the right thing for us was to draw a line and look forward.
 
 
 
 
“But our supporters should know that we did everything we could to stand up for Hearts. We will always do that, and we certainly haven’t forgotten what happened last season. But our focus now has to be on putting the club in the strongest possible position for this season and beyond and of course communicating better along the way.”

October 27, 2026 6:50 pm

https://www.andymuirhead.com/p/mcinnes-can-cry-injustice-all-he
McInnes can cry injustice all he wants; Hearts choked when it mattered most

Rebus67
October 27, 2026 6:54 pm

Ex Machina,

I agree that the club is in a downward spiral. It seems most areas of the business are either poorly structured and/or populated by second rate personnel.

In spite of this, the club can succeed domestically because of the resource gap that it has.

Where we might disagree is in terms of whether we have passed the point of no return.

The Ange appointment illustrates that a quick turnaround is possible even if only by chance

Expectation and motivation are the levers
Whether they will be pulled is another matter

Rebus

Cosy Corner Bhoy
October 27, 2026 7:28 pm

BP Sorry I didn’t follow up on your query as I thought you’d know I would be at that game being as I’m a few years older than you😅
Will do better next time!
Did I tell you about the Vodvodinja game? It’s that long ago I can’t even remember how to spell it.
Good health to yourself and Joan👍

Ex Machina
October 27, 2026 7:30 pm

Rebus67

I don’t doubt we could turn it round ( improved performances on the pitch) with a quality appointment but maintaining domestic dominance isn’t going to appeal to any/ many decent candidates. Particularly in a league environment that is third rate at best.

Once mediocrity becomes the norm, and this league is a standard bearer in that respect, instead of preparing for defeats to the EL might of Ferencvaros, Celta Vigo etc we could well be steeling ourselves to build up some enthusiasm for regular games against ECL makeweights.

In turn our appeal diminishes significantly. Not only will we struggle to fulfill home grown quotas with good players( are there any in Scotland?) , If I was a young internationalist like Baur, Duran I’d be carefully weighing up whether my career trajectory is best served staying with a club lacking any ambition.
We can only live off our name for so long.

Our custodians show little interest in changing the direction of travel.

Craig 76
October 27, 2026 7:33 pm

big packy
October 27, 2026 7:41 pm

HI cosy corner bhoy, just knew you would be at that game,,thanks for your kind comments about myself and wee joan,.hope you and yours are well.big shout out to,ATOB,sadly missed on here 👍 👍 ❤

BOBBY MURDOCH’S CURLED UP WINKLEPICKERS
October 27, 2026 7:58 pm

Arsenal playing at Highbury tonight for the first time in over two decades.

October 27, 2026 8:07 pm

Sometimes you need to take a few steps back to move forward

Often progress requires stepping back, reassessing where you are, and letting go of the idea that you must keep moving in the same direction.

A step backwards isn’t necessarily a failure. It can be a strategic retreat that gives you the perspective, stability, or room you need to move forward more effectively.

The important distinction is whether you’re retreating out of fear or stepping back with a purpose. One keeps you stuck; the other can change everything.

In professional sport, stepping backwards can be a deliberate tactical decision rather than a sign of weakness.

Examples include:

Football tactics: A team recycles possession through its centre-backs or goalkeeper rather than forcing a forward pass. Drawing the opposition forward can create space behind their midfield.

Rebuilding a squad: A club may sell established players, reduce its wage bill and accept a short-term decline to build a younger, more balanced team for the future.

Player development: A footballer may drop to a lower division to secure regular first-team football rather than remain a substitute at a bigger club.

In-game management: A team may retreat into a compact defensive shape to regain control before launching another attack.

The distinction is between a purposeful step backwards and simply going backwards. The former has a defined objective, a plan and a reasonable prospect of improvement. The latter may just be decline dressed up as strategy.

In football, particularly, the real test is whether the temporary sacrifice creates a credible route to future success. A club cannot justify years of declining performance merely by calling it a rebuild.

How does a professional football club do this when the plc is hell bent on maintaining profits and cutting costs and ignoring the signs that they and the environment they operate in is stagnant.

A professional football club in that position faces a fundamental governance problem: the interests of the PLC and the interests of the football club can diverge.

The PLC may regard financial stability, annual profits, cash reserves and cost control as evidence of competent management. Supporters, meanwhile, judge the club by its ability to compete, improve its squad, develop a coherent football strategy and respond to changes in the game.

But if a board’s overriding objective is to preserve its existing financial model, rather than continually test whether that model is delivering the best possible sporting outcome, the club can become a victim of its own past success.

Those objectives are not necessarily incompatible. The problem arises when financial prudence becomes the overriding objective, regardless of the sporting consequences.

1. The trap of managing for financial preservation
Consider a club that has reached a competitive plateau.
Its income is relatively stable.
Its costs are tightly controlled.
It generates a surplus or accumulates cash.
Its competitors improve their recruitment, coaching, analytics and squad depth.

The club continues operating according to the model that previously made it successful.
Initially, the financial results may look perfectly respectable. But the club’s relative competitive position deteriorates.

This is particularly dangerous in football because success is relative. A club can improve its own operations and still fall behind if its competitors improve faster.

The consequences can compound:
Underinvestment leads to a weaker squad.
A weaker squad produces poorer European results or loses domestic dominance.
Poorer results threaten prize money, ticket demand, commercial income and the club’s reputation.

Management responds by cutting costs further rather than addressing the original strategic failure.

The cycle reinforces itself.

The club may be financially healthy in the short term while steadily damaging its long-term earning capacity.

A board that measures success predominantly through profit, cash accumulation and cost control can convince itself that its strategy is working long after the sporting evidence suggests otherwise.

A serious football board should measure at least four things:

Area What the board should ask
Financial Is the club financially sustainable?

Sporting Is the team becoming more competitive against its real rivals?

Strategic Are recruitment, coaching and infrastructure improving?

Long-term value Are we protecting or eroding future revenues and the club’s competitive position?

This isn’t an argument for reckless spending. UEFA itself emphasises financial stability and cost control alongside the long-term interests of clubs and competition.

The problem is treating financial sustainability as the entire strategy, rather than the foundation on which a sporting strategy is built.

What happens when the board refuses to change?

If the board is convinced that its existing model is correct, it may interpret every demand for change as financial irresponsibility. It can point to cash reserves, profitability over previous years and the danger of overspending by other clubs.

That argument can be reasonable in isolation and still be strategically wrong.

There is also an accountability problem. A PLC board can be judged by financial results, while the sporting consequences of its decisions emerge over several seasons. By then, the people responsible may have moved on, and the cost of correcting the problem may be considerably higher.

A club needs a sporting leadership structure with sufficient authority to challenge the board’s assumptions, present a credible investment case and explain what the club is sacrificing by not investing

Without that authority, the football operation is effectively being asked to deliver better results without necessarily being given the resources to do so.

Applying this to Celtic is an interesting example because the club has historically operated with substantial cash reserves and a self-sustaining financial model.

The published results for the year ended 30 June 2026 show a significant change from the previous year:

Profit after tax of £33.9 million became a loss of £4.8 million.

Year-end cash fell from £77.3 million to £66.4 million.

Player acquisition spending fell from £38.6 million to £15.6 million during the financial year.

The club attributed the revenue decline principally to playing in the Europa League rather than the Champions League, lower player-trading gains and increased operating expenses.

Its statement also described a deliberate shift towards loan signings with purchase options in January 2026.

Those figures alone do not prove that the board is deliberately pursuing managed decline. They do, however, illustrate the strategic dilemma: how should Celtic deploy its financial capacity to improve its chances of competing at a higher level, while protecting itself against volatile European income?

Celtic’s own statement in September 2025 defended its self-sustaining model and explained that cash reserves do not exempt the club from UEFA’s squad-cost rules. It also said that the model should support recruitment, infrastructure and long-term development.

The important question is therefore not simply whether Celtic should spend more. It is whether its board is making the best possible use of its resources, given the competitive environment in which the club operates.

So how does the club actually break the cycle?

If the board will not voluntarily reconsider its approach, the realistic mechanisms are structural:

Shareholder pressure. Investors challenge the board’s strategy, voting decisions and accountability.

Supporter pressure. Organised supporters make it clear that sporting ambition and competent governance are essential to the club’s long-term interests.

Board renewal. Directors with stronger football-industry experience and a different strategic perspective are introduced.

Independent performance review. The club examines recruitment, wage investment, squad planning and European competitiveness against measurable objectives.

Leadership change. If the board repeatedly fails to respond to evidence, shareholders may eventually seek different directors or executives.

None guarantees success. In particular, supporters may have considerable influence but limited formal power, depending on the shareholding structure.

The fundamental issue
I would frame it this way: a football club can be financially conservative without being strategically conservative.
It can spend carefully while still recognising that the competitive environment has changed, that yesterday’s operating model may no longer be sufficient, and that investment today may be necessary to protect tomorrow’s revenues.

But if a board’s overriding objective is to preserve its existing financial model, rather than continually test whether that model is delivering the best possible sporting outcome, the club can become a victim of its own past success.

The most dangerous position is not necessarily financial crisis. It is a board that remains convinced it is doing everything correctly while the evidence of relative decline accumulates.

And that leads to the uncomfortable question: if the board controls the money, the appointments and the strategy, but is unwilling to acknowledge that the strategy needs to change, what mechanism remains to make it change?

At that point, the issue is no longer merely football management. It is corporate governance and accountability.

Prestonpans bhoys
October 27, 2026 8:08 pm

Game delayed because of a drone